Standing Sausage Modes Research Articles

The Propagation of Coherent Waves Across Multiple Solar Magnetic Pores

Solar pores are efficient magnetic conduits for propagating magnetohydrodynamic wave energy into the outer regions of the solar atmosphere. Pore observations often contain isolated and/or unconnected structures, preventing the statistical examination of wave activity as a function of the atmospheric height. Here, using high-resolution observations acquired by the Dunn Solar Telescope, we examine photospheric and chromospheric wave signatures from a unique collection of magnetic pores originating from the same decaying sunspot. Wavelet analysis of high-cadence photospheric imaging reveals the ubiquitous presence of slow sausage-mode oscillations, coherent across all photospheric pores through comparisons of intensity and area fluctuations, producing statistically significant in-phase relationships. The universal nature of these waves allowed an investigation of whether the wave activity remained coherent as they propagate. Utilizing bisector Doppler velocity analysis of the Ca ii 8542 Å line, alongside comparisons of the modeled spectral response function, we find fine-scale 5 mHz power amplification as the waves propagate into the chromosphere. Phase angles approaching zero degrees between co-spatial line depths spanning different line depths indicate standing sausage modes following reflection against the transition region boundary. Fourier analysis of chromospheric velocities between neighboring pores reveals the annihilation of the wave coherency observed in the photosphere, with examination of the intensity and velocity signals from individual pores indicating they behave as fractured waveguides, rather than monolithic structures. Importantly, this work highlights that wave morphology with atmospheric height is highly complex, with vast differences observed at chromospheric layers, despite equivalent wave modes being introduced into similar pores in the photosphere.

Non-equilibrium Ionization Effects on Extreme-ultraviolet Emissions Modulated by Standing Sausage Modes in Coronal Loops

Abstract Forward-modeling the emission properties in various passbands is important for confidently identifying magnetohydrodynamic waves in the structured solar corona. We examine how non-equilibrium ionization (NEI) affects the extreme-ultraviolet (EUV) emissions modulated by standing fast sausage modes (FSMs) in coronal loops, taking the Fe ix 171 Å and Fe xii 193 Å emission lines as examples. Starting with the expressions for linear FSMs in straight cylinders, we synthesize the specific intensities and spectral profiles for the two spectral lines by incorporating the self-consistently derived ionic fractions in the relevant contribution functions. We find that relative to the case where equilibrium ionization (EI) is assumed, NEI considerably impacts the intensity modulations, but shows essentially no effect on the Doppler velocities or widths. Furthermore, NEI may affect the phase difference between intensity variations and those in Doppler widths for Fe xii 193 Å when the line of sight is oblique to the loop axis. While this difference is 180° when EI is assumed, it is ∼90° when NEI is incorporated for the parameters we choose. We conclude that in addition to viewing angles and instrumental resolutions, NEI further complicates the detection of FSMs in spectroscopic measurements of coronal loops in the EUV passband.

Standing sausage modes in curved coronal slabs

Context. Magnetohydrodynamic waveguides such as dense coronal loops can support standing modes. The ratios of the periods of oscillations for different longitudinal harmonics depend on the dispersive nature of the waveguide and so may be used as a seismological tool to determine coronal parameters.Aims. We extend models of standing sausage modes in low β coronal loops to include the effects of loop curvature. The behaviour of standing sausage modes in this geometry is used to explain the properties of observed oscillations that cannot be accounted for using straight loop models.Methods. We perform 2D numerical simulations of an oscillating coronal loop, modelled as a dense slab embedded in a potential magnetic field. The loop is field-aligned and so experiences expansion with height in addition to being curved. Standing sausage modes are excited by compressive perturbations of the loop and their properties are studied.Results. The spatial profiles of standing sausage modes are found to be modified by the expanding loop geometry typical for flaring loops and modelled by a potential magnetic field in our simulations. Longitudinal harmonics of order n > 1 have anti-nodes that are shifted towards the loop apex and the amplitude of anti-nodes near the loop apex is smaller than those near the loop footpoints.Conclusions. We find that the observation of standing sausage modes by the Nobeyama Radioheliograph in a flaring coronal loop on 12 January 2000 is consistent with interpretation in terms of the global mode (n = 1) and third harmonic (n = 3). This interpretation accounts for the period ratio and spatial structure of the observed oscillations.

Inferring Flare Loop Parameters with Measurements of Standing Sausage Modes

Standing fast sausage modes in flare loops were suggested to account for a considerable number of quasi-periodic pulsations (QPPs) in the light curves of solar flares. This study continues our investigation into the possibility to invert the measured periods $P$ and damping times $\tau$ of sausage modes to deduce the transverse Alfv\'en time $R/v_{\rm Ai}$, density contrast $\rho_{\rm i}/\rho_{\rm e}$, and the steepness of the density distribution transverse to flare loops. A generic dispersion relation (DR) governing linear sausage modes is derived for pressureless cylinders where density inhomogeneity of arbitrary form takes place within the cylinder. We show that in general the inversion problem is under-determined for QPP events where only a single sausage mode exists, be the measurements spatially resolved or unresolved. While $R/v_{\rm Ai}$ can be inferred to some extent, the range of possible steepness parameters may be too broad to be useful. However, for spatially resolved measurements where an additional mode is present, it is possible to deduce self-consistently $\rho_{\rm i}/\rho_{\rm e}$, the profile steepness, and the internal Alfv\'en speed $v_{\rm Ai}$. We show that at least for a recent QPP event that involves a fundamental kink mode in addition to a sausage one, flare loop parameters are well constrained, even if the specific form of the transverse density distribution remains unknown. We conclude that spatially resolved, multi-mode QPP measurements need to be pursued for inferring flare loop parameters.

STANDING SAUSAGE MODES IN NONUNIFORM MAGNETIC TUBES: AN INVERSION SCHEME FOR INFERRING FLARE LOOP PARAMETERS

Standing sausage modes in flare loops are important for interpreting quasi-periodic pulsations (QPPs) in solar flare lightcurves. We propose an inversion scheme that consistently uses their periods $P$ and damping times $\tau$ to diagnose flare loop parameters. We derive a generic dispersion relation governing linear sausage waves in pressure-less straight tubes, for which the transverse density inhomogeneity takes place in a layer of arbitrary width $l$ and is of arbitrary form. We find that $P$ and $\tau$ depend on the combination of $[R/v_{\rm Ai}, L/R, l/R, \rho_{\rm i}/\rho_{\rm e}]$, where $R$ is the loop radius, $L$ is the looplength, $v_{\rm Ai}$ is the internal Alfv\'en speed, and $\rho_{\rm i}/\rho_{\rm e}$ is the density contrast. For all the density profiles examined, $P$ and $\tau$ experience saturation when $L/R \gg 1$, yielding an inversion curve in the $[R/v_{\rm Ai}, l/R, \rho_{\rm i}/\rho_{\rm e}]$ space with a specific density profile when $L/R$ is sufficiently large. When applied to a spatially unresolved QPP event, the scheme yields that $R/v_{\rm Ai}$ is the best constrained, whereas $l/R$ corresponds to the other extreme. For spatially resolved QPPs, while $L/R \gg 1$ cannot be assumed beforehand, an inversion curve remains possible due to additional geometrical constraints. When a spatially resolved QPP event involves another mode, as is the case for a recent event, the full set of $[v_{\rm Ai}, l, \rho_{\rm i}/\rho_{\rm e}]$ can be inferred. We conclude that the proposed scheme provides a useful tool for magneto-seismologically exploiting QPPs.

Periods and Damping Rates of Fast Sausage Oscillations in Multishelled Coronal Loops

Standing sausage modes are important in interpreting quasi-periodic pulsations in the lightcurves of solar flares. Their periods and damping times play an important role in seismologically diagnosing key parameters like the magnetic field strength in regions where flare energy is released. Usually such applications are based on theoretical results neglecting unresolved fine structures in magnetized loops. However, the existence of fine structuring is suggested on both theoretical and observational grounds. Adopting the framework of cold magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), we model coronal loops as magnetized cylinders with a transverse equilibrium density profile comprising a monolithic part and a modulation due to fine structuring in the form of concentric shells. The equation governing the transverse velocity perturbation is solved with an initial-value-problem approach, and the effects of fine structuring on the periods $P$ and damping times $\tau$ of global, leaky, standing sausage modes are examined. A parameter study shows that fine structuring, be it periodically or randomly distributed, brings changes of only a few percent to $P$ and $\tau$ when there are more than about ten shells. The monolithic part, its steepness in particular, plays a far more important role in determining $P$ and $\tau$. We conclude that when measured values of $P$ and $\tau$ of sausage modes are used for seismological purposes, it is justified to use theoretical results where the effects due to fine structuring are neglected.

Standing sausage modes in coronal loops with plasma flow

Magnetohydrodynamic waves are important for diagnosing the physical parameters of coronal plasmas. Field-aligned flows appear frequently in coronal loops.We examine the effects of transverse density and plasma flow structuring on standing sausage modes trapped in coronal loops, and examine their observational implications. We model coronal loops as straight cold cylinders with plasma flow embedded in a static corona. An eigen-value problem governing propagating sausage waves is formulated, its solutions used to construct standing modes. Two transverse profiles are distinguished, one being the generalized Epstein distribution (profile E) and the other (N) proposed recently in Nakariakov et al.(2012). A parameter study is performed on the dependence of the maximum period $P_\mathrm{max}$ and cutoff length-to-radius ratio $(L/a)_{\mathrm{cutoff}}$ in the trapped regime on the density parameters ($\rho_0/\rho_\infty$ and profile steepness $p$) and flow parameters (magnitude $U_0$ and profile steepness $u$). For either profile, introducing a flow reduces $P_\mathrm{max}$ relative to the static case. $P_\mathrm{max}$ depends sensitively on $p$ for profile N but is insensitive to $p$ for profile E. By far the most important effect a flow introduces is to reduce the capability for loops to trap standing sausage modes: $(L/a)_{\mathrm{cutoff}}$ may be substantially reduced in the case with flow relative to the static one. If the density distribution can be described by profile N, then measuring the sausage mode period can help deduce the density profile steepness. However, this practice is not feasible if profile E better describes the density distribution. Furthermore, even field-aligned flows with magnitudes substantially smaller than the ambient Alfv\'en speed can make coronal loops considerably less likely to support trapped standing sausage modes.

Effects of Field-Aligned Flows on Standing Kink and Sausage Modes Supported by Coronal Loops

Fundamental standing modes and their overtones play an important role in coronal seismology. We examine the effects of a significant field-aligned flow on standing modes that are supported by coronal loops, which are modeled here as cold magnetic slabs. Of particular interest are the period ratios of the fundamental to its (n−1)th overtone [P 1/nP n ] for kink and sausage modes, and the threshold half-width-to-length ratio for sausage modes. For standing kink modes, the flow significantly reduces P 1/nP n in general, the effect being particularly strong for higher n and weaker density contrast [ $\rho_{0}/\rho_{\rm e}$ ] between loops and their surroundings. That said, even when $\rho_{0}/\rho_{\rm e}$ approaches infinity, this effect is still substantial, reducing the minimal P 1/nP n by up to 13.7 % (24.5 %) for n=2 (n=4) relative to the static case, when the Alfvén Mach number [M A] reaches 0.8, where M A measures the loop flow speed in units of the internal Alfvén speed. Although it is not negligible for standing sausage modes, the flow effect in reducing P 1/nP n is not as strong. However, the threshold half-width-to-length ratio is considerably higher in the flowing case than in its static counterpart. For $\rho_{0}/\rho_{\rm e}$ in the range [9,1024] and M A in the range [0,0.5], an exhaustive parameter study yields that this threshold is well fitted by $(d/L)_{\rm cutoff, fit} = \frac{1}{2}\sqrt{\frac{1}{\rho_{0}/\rho_{\rm e}-1}} \exp (3.7 M_{\mathrm{A}}^{2} )$ , which involves the two parameters in a simple way. This allows one to analytically constrain the combination $(\rho_{0}/\rho_{\rm e}, M_{\mathrm {A}})$ for a loop with a known width-to-length ratio when a standing sausage oscillation is identified. It also allows one to examine the idea of partial sausage modes in more detail, and the flow is found to significantly reduce the spatial extent where partial modes are allowed.

THE PERIOD RATIO FOR STANDING KINK AND SAUSAGE MODES IN SOLAR STRUCTURES WITH SIPHON FLOW. I. MAGNETIZED SLABS

In the applications of solar magneto-seismology(SMS), employing the ratio of the period of the fundamental mode to twice the one of its first overtone, $P_1/2P_2$, plays an important role. We examine how field-aligned flows affect the dispersion properties, and hence the period ratios, of standing modes supported by magnetic slabs in the solar atmosphere. We numerically solve the dispersion relations and devise a graphic means to construct standing modes. For coronal slabs, we find that the flow effects are significant, for the fast kink and sausage modes alike. For the kink ones, they may reduce $P_1/2P_2$ by up to 23% compared with the static case, and the minimum allowed $P_1/2P_2$ can fall below the lower limit analytically derived for static slabs. For the sausage modes, while introducing the flow reduces $P_1/2P_2$ by typically $\lesssim 5$ % relative to the static case, it significantly increases the threshold aspect ratio only above which standing sausage modes can be supported, meaning that their detectability is restricted to even wider slabs. In the case of photospheric slabs, the flow effect is not as strong. However, standing modes are distinct from the coronal case in that standing kink modes show a $P_1/2P_2$ that deviates from unity even for a zero-width slab, while standing sausage modes no longer suffer from a threshold aspect ratio. We conclude that transverse structuring in plasma density and flow speed should be considered in seismological applications of multiple periodicities to solar atmospheric structures.

Sausage oscillations in loops with a non-uniform cross-section

Context. Flaring coronal loops are often observed in microwave and sometimes in soft X-rays, as extended structures of variable cross-section or width. The quasi-periodic pulsations associated with flaring coronal loops have been interpreted in terms of standing, fast sausage magnetoacoustic modes and suggested for the diagnostics of the magnetic field outside the oscillating loop. Aims. We investigate the effects of a non-uniform cross-section on a coronal loop with respect to the standing sausage modes it supports. Methods. Numerical simulations of standing sausage modes are performed for a straight, zero-β coronal loop with a varying crosssection. The global sausage mode and higher harmonics are considered, and simulations were performed for a range of density contrast ratios and loop divergence parameter. We consider modifications of the period of oscillation and the spatial profile of the standing modes. Results. As the loop divergence parameter increases, the period of the standing modes decreases. The fractional change period is independent of the density contrast ratio. The spatial profiles of the standing modes are modified by the cross-section inhomogeneity,but this effect is too weak to be observable by modern instruments. For the global sausage mode, the cross-section radius divergence by a factor of 2 is found to cause the decrease in the period of about 5%.