Spindle Self-organization Research Articles

Microtubule choreography: spindle self-organization during cell division

AbstractDuring cell division, the network of microtubules undergoes massive rearrangement to self-organize into the spindle, a bipolar structure essential for accurate chromosome segregation. This structure ensures the stable transmission of the genome from the mother cell to two daughter cells, yet the process by which the ordered architecture emerges from a collection of protein “parts” remains a mystery. In this review, we focus on several key spindle proteins, describing how they move, crosslink, and grow microtubules in vitro and contribute to the spindle’s structural organization. We categorize these proteins into groups, such as transporters, bundlers, and nucleators, to highlight their functional roles. We also present an advanced perspective on the spindle’s complex polymer architecture and its temporal assembly order in cellular contexts. This in situ level information should guide the minimal reconstitution of the spindle, helping to elucidate the biophysical principles underlying essential cytoskeletal self-organization.

Morphological growth dynamics, mechanical stability, and active microtubule mechanics underlying spindle self-organization

The spindle is a dynamic intracellular structure self-organized from microtubules and microtubule-associated proteins. The spindle's bipolar morphology is essential for the faithful segregation of chromosomes during cell division, and it is robustly maintained by multifaceted mechanisms. However, abnormally shaped spindles, such as multipolar spindles, can stochastically arise in a cell population and cause chromosome segregation errors. The physical basis of how microtubules fail in bipolarization and occasionally favor nonbipolar assembly is poorly understood. Here, using live fluorescence imaging and quantitative shape analysis in Xenopus egg extracts, we find that spindles of varied shape morphologies emerge through nonrandom, bistable self-organization paths, one leading to a bipolar and the other leading to a multipolar phenotype. The bistability defines the spindle's unique morphological growth dynamics linked to each shape phenotype and can be promoted by a locally distorted microtubule flow that arises within premature structures. We also find that bipolar and multipolar spindles are stable at the steady-state in bulk but can infrequently switch between the two phenotypes. Our microneedle-based physical manipulation further demonstrates that a transient force perturbation applied near the assembled pole can trigger the phenotypic switching, revealing the mechanical plasticity of the spindle. Together with molecular perturbation of kinesin-5 and augmin, our data propose the physical and molecular bases underlying the emergence of spindle-shape variation, which influences chromosome segregation fidelity during cell division.

A gelation transition enables the self-organization of bipolar metaphase spindles

The mitotic spindle is a highly dynamic bipolar structure that emerges from the self-organization of microtubules, molecular motors and other proteins. Sustained motor-driven poleward flows of dynamic microtubules play a key role in the bipolar organization of spindles. However, it is not understood how the local activity of motor proteins generates these large-scale coherent poleward flows. Here we show that a gelation transition enables long-range microtubule transport causing the spindles to self-organize into two oppositely polarized microtubule gels. Laser ablation experiments reveal that local active stresses generated at the spindle midplane propagate through the structure, thereby driving global coherent microtubule flows. Simulations show that microtubule gels undergoing rapid turnover can exhibit long stress relaxation times, in agreement with the long-range flows observed in experiments. Finally, our model predicts that in the presence of branching microtubule nucleation, either disrupting such flows or decreasing the network connectivity can lead to a microtubule polarity reversal in spindles. We experimentally confirm this inversion of polarity by abolishing the microtubule transport in spindles. Overall, we uncover a connection between spindle rheology and architecture in spindle self-organization.

The Xenopus spindle is as dense as the surrounding cytoplasm.

The mitotic spindle is a self-organizing molecular machine, where hundreds of different molecules continuously interact to maintain a dynamic steady state. While our understanding of key molecular players in spindle assembly is significant, it is still largely unknown how the spindle's material properties emerge from molecular interactions. Here, we use correlative fluorescence imaging and label-free three-dimensional optical diffraction tomography (ODT) to measure the Xenopus spindle's mass density distribution. While the spindle has been commonly referred to as a denser phase of the cytoplasm, we find that it has the same density as its surrounding, which makes it neutrally buoyant. Molecular perturbations suggest that spindle mass density can be modulated by tuning microtubule nucleation and dynamics. Together, ODT provides direct, unbiased, and quantitative information of the spindle's emergent physical properties-essential to advance predictive frameworks of spindle assembly and function.

Self-Organization and Forces in the Mitotic Spindle.

At the onset of division, the cell forms a spindle, a precise self-constructed micromachine composed of microtubules and the associated proteins, which divides the chromosomes between the two nascent daughter cells. The spindle arises from self-organization of microtubules and chromosomes, whose different types of motion help them explore the space and eventually approach and interact with each other. Once the interactions between the chromosomes and the microtubules have been established, the chromosomes are moved to the equatorial plane of the spindle and ultimately toward the opposite spindle poles. These transport processes rely on directed forces that are precisely regulated in space and time. In this review, we discuss how microtubule dynamics and their rotational movement drive spindle self-organization, as well as how the forces acting in the spindle are generated, balanced, and regulated.

Central Spindle Self-Organization and Cytokinesis in Artificially Activated Sea Urchin Eggs.

The ability of microtubules of the mitotic apparatus to control the positioning and initiation of the cleavage furrow during cytokinesis was first established from studies on early echinoderm embryos. However, the identity of the microtubule population that imparts cytokinetic signaling is unclear. The two main--and not necessarily mutually exclusive--candidates are the central spindle and the astral rays. In the present study, we examined cytokinesis in ammonia-activated sea urchin eggs, which lack paternally derived centrosomes and undergo mitosis mediated by unusual anastral, bipolar mini-spindles. Live cell imaging and immunolabeling for microtubules and the centralspindlin constituent and kinesin-related protein, MKLP1, demonstrated that furrowing in ammonia-activated eggs was associated with aligned arrays of centralspindlin-linked, opposed bundles of antiparallel microtubules. These autonomous, zipper-like arrays were not associated with a mitotic apparatus, but did possess characteristics similar to the central spindle region of control, fertilized embryos. Our results highlight the self-organizing nature of the central spindle region and its ability to induce cytokinesis-like furrowing, even in the absence of a complete mitotic apparatus.

Kinesin-5: A Team Is Just the Sum of Its Parts

How the cell builds a spindle remains an open question. In this issue of Developmental Cell, Shimamoto, Forth, and Kapoor (2015) show that kinesin-5 motor ensembles can exert sliding forces that scale with microtubule overlap length. This behavior could allow microtubule architecture-dependent modulation of force and contribute to spindle self-organization.

The Ran-GTP Gradient Spatially Regulates XCTK2 in the Spindle

Ran is a small GTP binding protein that was originally identified as a regulator of nucleocytoplasmic transport [1] and subsequently found to be important for spindle formation [2-5]. In mitosis, a gradient of Ran-GTP emanates from chromatin and diminishes toward spindle poles [6]. Ran-GTP promotes spindle self-organization through the release of importin-bound spindle assembly factors (SAFs), which stimulate microtubule (MT) nucleation and organization and regulate MT dynamics [7-9]. Although many SAFs are non-motile MT-associated proteins, such as NuMA, TPX2, and HURP [7, 10-12], Ran also controls motor proteins, including Kid and HSET/XCTK2 [13, 14]. The Kinesin-14 XCKT2 is important for spindle assembly and pole organization [15-20], and Ran-GTP is proposed to promote XCKT2 MT crosslinking activity by releasing importin α/β from a bipartite nuclear localization signal (NLS) located in the tail domain [14]. Here, we show that the Ran-GTP gradient spatially regulates XCTK2 within the spindle. A flattened Ran-GTP gradient blocked the ability of excess XCTK2 to stimulate bipolar spindle assembly and resulted in XCTK2-mediated bundling of free MTs. These effects required the XCTK2 tail, which promoted the motility of XCTK2 within the spindle independent of the Ran-GTP gradient. In addition, the turnover kinetics of XCTK2 were spatially controlled: they were faster near the poles relative to the chromatin, but not with a mutant XCTK2 that cannot bind to importin α/β. Our results support a model in which the Ran-GTP gradient spatially coordinates motor localization with motility to ensure efficient spindle formation.

Physical basis of spindle self-organization.

The cytoskeleton forms a variety of steady-state, subcellular structures that are maintained by continuous fluxes of molecules and energy. Understanding such self-organizing structures is not only crucial for cell biology but also poses a fundamental challenge for physics, since these systems are active materials that behave drastically differently from matter at or near equilibrium. Active liquid crystal theories have been developed to study the self-organization of cytoskeletal filaments in in vitro systems of purified components. However, it has been unclear how relevant these simplified approaches are for understanding biological structures, which can be composed of hundreds of distinct proteins. Here we show that a suitably constructed active liquid crystal theory produces remarkably accurate predictions of the behaviors of metaphase spindles-the cytoskeletal structure, composed largely of microtubules and associated proteins, that segregates chromosomes during cell division.

Prime movers: the mechanochemistry of mitotic kinesins

Mitotic spindles are self-organizing protein machines that harness teams of multiple force generators to drive chromosome segregation. Kinesins are key members of these force-generating teams. Different kinesins walk directionally along dynamic microtubules, anchor, crosslink, align and sort microtubules into polarized bundles, and influence microtubule dynamics by interacting with microtubule tips. The mechanochemical mechanisms of these kinesins are specialized to enable each type to make a specific contribution to spindle self-organization and chromosome segregation.

Asymmetric Force Response Reveals Mechanical Role in Spindle Protein Localization

The mitotic spindle is the self-organized, microtubule based structure which mechanically segregates chromosomes during cell division. The spindle ‘parts-list' includes microtubules, motor proteins, and non-motor microtubule-associated proteins (or MAPs), and the biochemical properties of many of these components have been well studied. By comparison, our understanding of the force-dependent behavior of many key interactions remains limited. In particular, we do not understand the role that cross-linking MAPs play in providing mechanical stability within the highly dynamic spindle, or how force regulates the function and localization of these proteins. To address this shortcoming, we examine the force-dependent response of NuMA, the major cross-linking MAP of minus-end focused parallel microtubules at the spindle pole. Combining data taken with single molecule TIRF-based imaging and optical trapping methods, we show that NuMA/microtubule interactions generate resistive, friction-like forces which approach ∼1pN when dragged at velocities in the micron/sec range. Unexpectedly, the mechanical response is asymmetric, with NuMA sliding more easily towards the minus ends of microtubules than the plus ends. For comparison, we show that PRC1, a dimeric protein which cross-links antiparallel microtubules at the spindle midzone in anaphase, does not possess such an asymmetric behavior under force. We further perform computer simulations on parallel microtubules cross-linked by ‘dimerized' NuMA (effectively a minimal structural unit of the spindle pole), and show that in the presence of small oscillatory perturbations, NuMA will migrate to the minus ends. These combined results suggests a mechanism for autonomous localization to the spindle poles, and may reveal a possible mechanical principle underlying spindle self-organization.

Mechanisms of plant spindle formation

In eukaryotes, the formation of a bipolar spindle is necessary for the equal segregation of chromosomes to daughter cells. Chromosomes, microtubules and kinetochores all contribute to spindle morphogenesis and have important roles during mitosis. A unique property of flowering plant cells is that they entirely lack centrosomes, which in animals have a major role in spindle formation. The absence of these important structures suggests that plants have evolved novel mechanisms to assure chromosome segregation. In this review, we highlight some of the recent studies on plant mitosis and argue that plants utilize a variation of "spindle self-organization" that takes advantage of the early polarity of plant cells and accentuates the role of kinetochores in stabilizing the spindle midzone in prometaphase.

Examining Mechanical Properties of Vertebrate Meiotic Spindles

Accurate chromosome segregation during cell division relies on the self-organization of a dynamic multi-component apparatus, the microtubule-based bipolar spindle. Through genetic, biochemical, and cell biological approaches, the complete ‘parts list’ of the components, including microtubule-based motor proteins, which are responsible for the assembly and maintenance of the meiotic spindle are now available. However, how spindle self-organization is controlled through integration of forces generated by multiple biomolecular processes remains mysterious. Here we report a calibrated microneedle-based system that allows application of sub-nanoNewton forces at specific sites within the metaphase spindle assembled in Xenopus egg extracts. Our set-up allows direct force measurements and can be combined with multi-mode high resolution microscopy along with chemical perturbations of specific spindle components. Using this system we applied sinusoidal strain to the metaphase spindle, keeping the range <5% to minimize nonlinearities of the response. The stress response was measured over the frequency ranged between 0.01 Hz and 2 Hz. Based on the resultant stress-strain relationship we determined the frequency-dependent mechanical properties of the spindle. The spindle response showed a typical characteristic time-scale of ∼50 s, at which the mechanical property changed from solid-like to liquid-like. Additional experiments examining stress relaxation, which may reflect the dynamics of structural reorganization, revealed a similar time-scale. This transition disappeared when the spindles were treated with AMPPNP, a slow-hydrolyzing ATP analog, suggesting that the characteristic time-scale is determined by an ATP-dependent processes within the spindle. The contribution of key mitotic motors such as dynein and kinesin is being examined by pharmacological or immunological perturbations. Together, these analyses will allow us discuss models for how forces in the self-organizing meiotic spindle are integrated.

Meiotic Spindle Self-Organization: One Plus One Equals Only One

Like other cellular organelles, the bipolar spindle is a structure of well-defined size and shape. Now, spindle fusion experiments using micro-manipulation have allowed current models for spindle morphogenesis and size control to be tested.

Centrosome Dysfunction in Drosophila Neural Stem Cells Causes Tumors that Are Not Due to Genome Instability

Genome instability (GI) and centrosomal alterations are common traits in human cancer [1, 2]. It is suspected that centrosome dysfunction may cause tumors by bringing about GI, but direct experimental proof is still lacking [3]. To explore the possible functional link between centrosome function and overgrowth, we have assayed the tumorigenic potential of a series of mutants that affect different centrosomal proteins in Drosophila. We have found that a significant number of such mutant conditions are tumorigenic in larval brain tissue, where self-renewing asymmetric division of neural stem cells is frequent, but not in symmetrically dividing epithelial cells. We have also found that mutations that increase GI without causing centrosome dysfunction are not tumorigenic in our assay. From these observations, we conclude that the tumors caused by centrosome dysfunction cannot be explained solely by the resulting genome instability. We propose that such tumors might be caused by impaired asymmetric division of neural stem cells [4]. These results show that centrosome loss, far from being innocuous, is a potentially dangerous condition in flies.

Minus-End-Directed Motor Ncd Exhibits Processive Movement that Is Enhanced by Microtubule Bundling In Vitro

Drosophila Ncd, a kinesin-14A family member, is essential for meiosis and mitosis. Ncd is a minus-end-directed motor protein that has an ATP-independent microtubule binding site in the tail region, which enables it to act as a dynamic crosslinker of microtubules to assemble and maintain the spindle. Although a tailless Ncd has been shown to be nonprocessive, the role of the Ncd tail in single-molecule motility is unknown. Here, we show that individual Ncd dimers containing the tail region can move processively along microtubules at very low ionic strength, which provides the first evidence of processivity for minus-end-directed kinesins. The movement of GFP-Ncd consists of both a unidirectional and a diffusive element, and it was sensitive to ionic strength. Motility of a truncation series of Ncd and removal of the tubulin tail suggested that the Ncd tail serves as an electrostatic tether to microtubules. Under higher ionic conditions, Ncd showed only a small bias in diffusion along "single" microtubules, whereas it exhibited processive movement along "bundled" microtubules. This property may allow Ncd to accumulate preferentially in the vicinity of focused microtubules and then to crosslink and slide microtubules, possibly contributing to dynamic spindle self-organization.

A Role for NuSAP in Linking Microtubules to Mitotic Chromosomes

The spindle apparatus is a microtubule (MT)-based machinery that attaches to and segregates the chromosomes during mitosis and meiosis. Self-organization of the spindle around chromatin involves the assembly of MTs, their attachment to the chromosomes, and their organization into a bipolar array. One regulator of spindle self-organization is RanGTP. RanGTP is generated at chromatin and activates a set of soluble, Ran-regulated spindle factors such as TPX2, NuMA, and NuSAP . How the spindle factors direct and attach MTs to the chromosomes are key open questions. Nucleolar and Spindle-Associated Protein (NuSAP) was recently identified as an essential MT-stabilizing and bundling protein that is enriched at the central part of the spindle . Here, we show by biochemical reconstitution that NuSAP efficiently adsorbs to isolated chromatin and DNA and that it can directly produce and retain high concentrations of MTs in the immediate vicinity of chromatin or DNA. Moreover, our data reveal that NuSAP-chromatin interaction is subject to Ran regulation and can be suppressed by Importin alpha (Impalpha) and Imp7. We propose that the presence of MT binding agents such as NuSAP, which can be directly immobilized on chromatin, are critical for targeting MT production to vertebrate chromosomes during spindle self-organization.

Monastral bipolar spindles in meiosis II of male Trichosia pubescens (Sciaridae): early stages of spindle formation and chromosome orientation.

The metaphase spindle of male meiosis II in fungus gnats (Sciaridae) is one example of naturally occurring monastral bipolar spindles. To gain further insights into how the bipolar spindle is formed in the presence of only one polar center, prometaphase of male meiosis II was investigated in the sciarid Trichosia pubescens by means of anti-tubulin immunofluorescence, DAPI chromosome staining, and electron microscopy of ultrathin serial sections. The first step in spindle formation after interkinesis seems to be the organization of an astral half-spindle, probably by MTOC activity of the astral region. With the exception of the non-disjunctional X chromosome, which always lies close to the aster, the chromosomes are found to occupy various positions with respect to the astral region, revealing different orientations of their chromatid kinetochores. It was observed that some of the mal-oriented kinetochores are associated with microtubules that, due to their orientation perpendicular to the spindle axis, are unlikely to originate from the astral region. Therefore, these mal-oriented microtubules are taken as an indication of a dispersed MTOC activity near the chromosomes or at kinetochores. According to recent models of chromosome-induced spindle self-organization [e.g., Merdes et al., 1997: J. Cell Biol. 138:953-956], they could be responsible for the formation of the other (anastral) half-spindle and for amphitelic (bipolar) orientation of the chromosomes.

Spindle self-organization and cytokinesis during male meiosis in asterless mutants of Drosophila melanogaster.

While Drosophila female meiosis is anastral, both meiotic divisions in Drosophila males exhibit prominent asters. We have identified a gene we call asterless (asl) that is required for aster formation during male meiosis. Ultrastructural analysis showed that asl mutants have morphologically normal centrioles. However, immunostaining with antibodies directed either to gamma tubulin or centrosomin revealed that these proteins do not accumulate in the centrosomes, as occurs in wild-type. Thus, asl appears to specify a function required for the assembly of centrosomal material around the centrioles. Despite the absence of asters, meiotic cells of asl mutants manage to develop an anastral spindle. Microtubules grow from multiple sites around the chromosomes, and then focus into a peculiar bipolar spindle that mediates chromosome segregation, although in a highly irregular way. Surprisingly, asl spermatocytes eventually form a morphologically normal ana-telophase central spindle that has full ability to stimulate cytokinesis. These findings challenge the classical view on central spindle assembly, arguing for a self-organization of this structure from either preexisting or newly formed microtubules. In addition, these findings strongly suggest that the asters are not required for signaling cytokinesis.