Speed In Cartilage Research Articles

Articular Cartilage Thickness Measured with US is Not as Easy as It Appears: A Systematic Review of Measurement Techniques and Image Interpretation

Theoretically, the high spatial resolution of US makes it well suited to monitor the decrease in articular cartilage thickness in osteoarthritis. A requirement is, however, that the borders of the cartilage are correctly identified and that the cartilage is measured under orthogonal insonation. If US measurements are compared to measurements with other techniques, they should be corrected for the higher sound speed in cartilage. To study whether investigators correctly identify the articular cartilage, whether they insonate orthogonally, and whether they correct for sound speed. A literature search limited to the last 10 years of studies applying US to measure cartilage thickness. 15 studies were identified and they referred to another 8 studies describing methods of thickness measurement. 11 of the 15 studies identified the superficial cartilage border incorrectly, and 6 applied oblique insonation. 2 of the 15 studies corrected for sound speed. Of the further 8 studies, one might correctly identify the superficial cartilage border, 4 applied oblique insonation, and none corrected for sound speed. We found that the majority of studies over the last 10 years, evaluating articular cartilage thickness with US, underestimated the cartilage thickness by not including the leading interface as part of the cartilage. Since the cartilage is relatively thin, this error is substantial. Some investigators also overestimated cartilage thickness by using oblique insonation of the cartilage. By not correcting for the high sound speed in cartilage, most investigators underestimated the cartilage thickness.

Differences in Acoustic Properties of Intact and Degenerated Human Patellar Cartilage During Compression

Ultrasound indentation measurements have been shown to provide means to assess cartilage integrity and mechanical properties. To determine cartilage stiffness in the ultrasound indentation geometry, cartilage is compressed with an ultrasound transducer to determine the induced strain from the ultrasound signal using the time-of-flight principle. As the ultrasound speed in cartilage has been shown to vary during compression, the assumption of constant speed generates significant errors in the values of mechanical parameters. This variation in ultrasound speed has been investigated in intact cartilage, however, its existence and significance in degenerated tissue is unknown. In the present study, we investigate this issue with both intact and spontaneously degenerated human tissue. To accomplish this aim, we determined ultrasound speed and attenuation in human patellar cartilage ( n = 68) during mechanical loading. For reference, cartilage mechanical properties and proteoglycan, collagen and water contents were determined. The acoustic properties were related to the composition and mechanical properties of the samples. Ultrasound speed showed significant, site-dependent variation and it was significantly associated ( r = 0.79–0.81, p < 0.01) with the mechanical properties of cartilage. The compression related decrease in ultrasound speed showed statistically significant variation between different stages of degeneration. Error simulations revealed that changes in ultrasound speed during 2% compression could generate errors up to 15% in the values of elastic moduli of samples with early degeneration, if determined with the ultrasound indentation technique. In samples with advanced degeneration, the error was significantly ( p < 0.05) smaller being 2% on average. As the compression related variation in ultrasound speed was lower in more degenerated samples, the mechanical parameters could be diagnosed more reliably in tissue showing advanced degeneration. The present results address the need to consider possible uncertainties in mechano-acoustic measurements of articular cartilage and call for methods to correct the effect of variable sound speed during compression. (E-mail: panu.kiviranta@uku.fi)

EFFECT OF ULTRASOUND BEAM ANGLE ON EQUINE ARTICULAR CARTILAGE THICKNESS MEASUREMENT

The purpose of this study was to determine if variation in the ultrasound beam angle would affect cartilage thickness measurement performed with B-mode ultrasonography. Transverse sections of six fresh equine middle phalanges were obtained from necropsy. Ultrasonographic images of the proximal articular cartilage were obtained in a water bath, in a plane parallel and adjacent to the section plane using a 5-10 MHz linear transducer. Static images were acquired for all six bone specimens with an ultrasound beam angle of 0 degree, 30 degrees, 45 degrees, and 60 degrees. Proximal articular cartilage thickness was measured on ultrasonographic images and on the bone specimen at the same level. A linear mixed-effects model was used to compare articular cartilage thickness measured on specimen and on ultrasonographic images using different ultrasound beam angle. Mean +/- SD cartilage thickness was 1.82 +/- 0.35 mm on bone specimens, 1.72 +/- 0.29 with a 0 degrees angle, 1.99 +/- 0.34 with 30 degrees, 2.06 +/- 0.34 with 45 degrees, and 2.3 +/- 0.38 with 60 degrees. There was a significant difference between macroscopic measurements and ultrasonographic measurements performed with ultrasound angles at 30 degrees, 45 degrees, and 60 degrees. There was a significant increase in cartilage thickness when the ultrasound beam angle decreased (P = 0.0157; R2 = 0.969). Cartilage thickeness measured on ultrasonographic images varies with the ultrasound beam angle and may not be accurate because ultrasound speed in cartilage may be different than the speed used by the ultrasonographic unit for distance calculation.

Non‐Contact Evaluation of Osmosis‐Induced Shrinkage and Swelling Behavior of Articular Cartilage In‐Situ Using High‐Frequency Ultrasound

The aim of the present study was to use high‐frequency ultrasound for the investigation of the transient osmosis‐induced free shrinkage‐swelling behaviors of normal articular cartilage in situ. Full‐thickness cartilage‐bone specimens were prepared from normal bovine patellae. The transient shrinkage and swelling strains of the cartilage induced by changing the bathing solution between physiological saline (0.15 M) and hypertonic saline (2 M) were monitored using a 50 MHz focused ultrasound beam. Both shrinkage and swelling strains showed temporary overshoots, followed by relaxation phases. The absolute peak value of the shrinkage strain (1.01%±0.62%) was significantly larger (p<0.05) than that of the swelling strain (0.40%±0.33%). It was found that the change of the mean ultrasound speed in cartilage could be approximately represented by an exponential function of time after the change of saline concentration. This study successfully demonstrated that a high‐frequency focused ultrasound beam could be used to monitor the transient osmosis‐induced deformation of articular cartilage in a non‐contact way. Since the osmosis‐swelling behavior of cartilage relates to its compositional and structural characteristics and degeneration status, the reported ultrasound method may have potential for the characterization of cartilage degeneration, such as osteoarthritis.