Spectral Library Search Research Articles

Critical evaluation of the NIST retention index database reliability with specific examples.

The NIST gas chromatographic retention index database is widely used in gas chromatography-mass spectrometry analysis. For many compounds, the NIST database contains many entries that are presumably obtained independently of each other. We showed with specific examples that there are cases in the NIST database where several entries exist for the same compound, and all of them are equally erroneous (an error of more than 100 units). In particular, we demonstrated that all retention index values for such an important compound as imidazole for non-polar stationary phases in theNISTdatabase are erroneous. In addition to imidazole, a similar situation is observed for four more nitrogen-containing heterocyclic compounds. For certainty, measurements were performed under several conditions, using various temperature programs, and using two specimens of columns. The structures were confirmed using nuclear magnetic resonance and mass spectrometry. It was shown with specific examples that many values are not reliable: either data were obtained using standard samples of undescribed origin without confirmation (without even using mass spectrometry) or, in some cases, standard samples were not used at all, and the retention index was obtained for a mixture component identified using a mass spectral library search. Some "independent" values are not such but are repeated publications of the same data (secondary sources), or simply several values taken from the same source. In the work, an analysis was carried out and assumptions were made about how several equally incorrect retention index values could appear in the NIST database.

STAVER: a standardized benchmark dataset-based algorithm for effective variation reduction in large-scale DIA-MS data.

Mass spectrometry (MS)-based proteomics has become instrumental in comprehensively investigating complex biological systems. Data-independent acquisition (DIA)-MS, utilizing hybrid spectral library search strategies, allows for the simultaneous quantification of thousands of proteins, showing promise in enhancing protein identification and quantification precision. However, low-quality profiles can considerably undermine quantitative precision, resulting in inaccurate protein quantification. To tackle this challenge, we introduced STAVER, a novel algorithm that leverages standardized benchmark datasets to reduce non-biological variation in large-scale DIA-MS analyses. By eliminating unwanted noise in MS signals, STAVER significantly improved protein quantification precision, especially in hybrid spectral library searches. Moreover, we validated STAVER's robustness and applicability across multiple large-scale DIA datasets, demonstrating significantly enhanced precision and reproducibility of protein quantification. STAVER offers an innovative and effective approach for enhancing the quality of large-scale DIA proteomic data, facilitating cross-platform and cross-laboratory comparative analyses. This advancement significantly enhances the consistency and reliability of findings in clinical research. The complete package is available at https://github.com/Ran485/STAVER.

Pesticide residues and polyphenols in urine – A combined LC-HRMS screening to reveal intake patterns

Human exposure to pesticides in the general population occurs mainly through food consumption. However, specific dietary habits or food products that contribute to pesticide exposure are often unknown. In this study, we propose a combined screening for polyphenols and pesticide residues by liquid chromatography coupled to high-resolution mass spectrometry (LC-HRMS) to assess the diet and the associated pesticide exposure. We measured 587 urine samples from women around the 34th week of pregnancy of a prospective mother–child cohort. A non-targeted screening for flavonoid-like compounds related to fruit and vegetable consumption was performed, prioritizing 164 features and identifying a total of 46 features by spectral library search. Based on a subset of markers, k-means clustering was performed, leading to four clusters with presumably similar dietary habits. The clusters were compared against food questionnaire data collected within the period of sample collection. Suspect screening of more than 500 pesticide residues including metabolites was performed, with a total of 40 residues being reported for 27 different pesticides. The detection of pesticide residues was compared across the different clusters of dietary habits. Indications were found that pyrimethanil metabolites might be associated with the consumption of citrus fruits or derivate products. We demonstrate that the method used has the potential to reveal patterns of pesticide intake from specific food commodities.

SpecEncoder: deep metric learning for accurate peptide identification in proteomics.

Tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) is a crucial technology for large-scale proteomic analysis. The protein database search or the spectral library search are commonly used for peptide identification from MS/MS spectra, which, however, may face challenges due to experimental variations between replicated spectra and similar fragmentation patterns among distinct peptides. To address this challenge, we present SpecEncoder, a deep metric learning approach to address these challenges by transforming MS/MS spectra into robust and sensitive embedding vectors in a latent space. The SpecEncoder model can also embed predicted MS/MS spectra of peptides, enabling a hybrid search approach that combines spectral library and protein database searches for peptide identification. We evaluated SpecEncoder on three large human proteomics datasets, and the results showed a consistent improvement in peptide identification. For spectral library search, SpecEncoder identifies 1%-2% more unique peptides (and PSMs) than SpectraST. For protein database search, it identifies 6%-15% more unique peptides than MSGF+ enhanced by Percolator, Furthermore, SpecEncoder identified 6%-12% additional unique peptides when utilizing a combined library of experimental and predicted spectra. SpecEncoder can also identify more peptides when compared to deep-learning enhanced methods (MSFragger boosted by MSBooster). These results demonstrate SpecEncoder's potential to enhance peptide identification for proteomic data analyses. The source code and scripts for SpecEncoder and peptide identification are available on GitHub at https://github.com/lkytal/SpecEncoder. Contact: hatang@iu.edu.

TransExION: a transformer based explainable similarity metric for comparing IONS in tandem mass spectrometry

Small molecule identification is a crucial task in analytical chemistry and life sciences. One of the most commonly used technologies to elucidate small molecule structures is mass spectrometry. Spectral library search of product ion spectra (MS/MS) is a popular strategy to identify or find structural analogues. This approach relies on the assumption that spectral similarity and structural similarity are correlated. However, popular spectral similarity measures, usually calculated based on identical fragment matches between the MS/MS spectra, do not always accurately reflect the structural similarity. In this study, we propose TransExION, a Transformer based Explainable similarity metric for IONS. TransExION detects related fragments between MS/MS spectra through their mass difference and uses these to estimate spectral similarity. These related fragments can be nearly identical, but can also share a substructure. TransExION also provides a post-hoc explanation of its estimation, which can be used to support scientists in evaluating the spectral library search results and thus in structure elucidation of unknown molecules. Our model has a Transformer based architecture and it is trained on the data derived from GNPS MS/MS libraries. The experimental results show that it improves existing spectral similarity measures in searching and interpreting structural analogues as well as in molecular networking.Scientific ContributionWe propose a transformer-based spectral similarity metrics that improves the comparison of small molecule tandem mass spectra. We provide a post hoc explanation that can serve as a good starting point for unknown spectra annotation based on database spectra.

3D-MPEA: A Graph Attention Model-Guided Computational Approach for Annotating Unknown Metabolites in Interactomics via Mass Spectrometry-Focused Multilayer Molecular Networking.

The spectral matching strategy of MS2 fragment spectrograms serves as a ubiquitous method for compound characterization within the matrix. Nevertheless, challenges arise due to the deficiency of distinctions in spectra across instruments caused by coelution peak-derived fragments and incompleteness of the current spectral reference database, leading to dilemma of multidimensional omics annotation. The graph attention model embedded with long short-term memory was proposed as an optimized approach involving integrating similar MS2 spectra into molecular networks according to the isotopic ion peak cluster spacing features to collapse diverse ion species and expand the spectral reference library, which efficiently evaluated the substance capture capacity to 123.1% than classic substance perception tactics. The versatility and utility of the established annotation procedure were showcased in a study on the stimulation of pork mediated by 2,2-bis(4-hydroxyphenyl)propane and enabled the global metabolite annotation from knowns to unknowns at metabolite-lipid-protein level. On the spectra for which in silico extended spectral library search provided a group truth, 83.5-117.1% accuracy surpassed 1.2-14.3% precision after manual validation. β-Ala-His dipeptidase was first evidenced as the critical node related to the transformation of α-helical (36.57 to 35.74%) to random coil (41.53 to 42.36%) mediated by 2,2-bis(4-hydroxyphenyl)propane, ultimately triggering an augment of catalytic performance, inducing a series of oxidative stress, and further intervening in the availability of animal-derived substrates. The integration of ionic fragment feature networks and long short-term memory models allows the effective annotation of recurrent unknowns in organisms and the deciphering of unacquainted matter in multiomics.

On the use of tandem mass spectra acquired from samples of evolutionarily distant organisms to validate methods for false discovery rate estimation.

Estimating the false discovery rate (FDR) of peptide identifications is a key step in proteomics data analysis, and many methods have been proposed for this purpose. Recently, an entrapment-inspired protocol to validate methods for FDR estimation appeared in articles showcasing new spectral library search tools. That validation approach involves generating incorrect spectral matches by searching spectra from evolutionarily distant organisms (entrapment queries) against the original target search space. Although this approach may appear similar to the solutions using entrapment databases, it represents a distinct conceptual framework whose correctness has not been verified yet. In this viewpoint, we first discussed the background of the entrapment-based validation protocols and then conducted a few simple computational experiments to verify the assumptions behind them. The results reveal that entrapment databases may, in some implementations, be a reasonable choice for validation, while the assumptions underpinning validation protocols based on entrapment queries are likely to be violated in practice. This article also highlights the need for well-designed frameworks for validating FDR estimation methods in proteomics.

Weighting Low-Intensity MS/MS Ions and m/z Frequency for Spectral Library Annotation.

Calculating spectral similarity is a fundamental step in MS/MS data analysis in untargeted metabolomics experiments, as it facilitates the identification of related spectra and the annotation of compounds. To improve matching accuracy when querying an experimental mass spectrum against a spectral library, previous approaches have proposed increasing peak intensities for high m/z ranges. These high m/z values tend to be smaller in magnitude, yet they offer more crucial information for identifying the chemical structure. Here, we evaluate the impact of using these weights for identifying structurally related compounds and mass spectral library searches. Additionally, we propose a weighting approach that (i) takes into account the frequency of the m/z values within a spectral library in order to assign higher importance to the most common peaks and (ii) increases the intensity of lower peaks, similar to previous approaches. To demonstrate our approach, we applied weighting preprocessing to modified cosine, entropy, and fidelity distance metrics and benchmarked it against previously reported weights. Our results demonstrate how weighting-based preprocessing can assist in annotating the structure of unknown spectra as well as identifying structurally similar compounds. Finally, we examined scenarios in which the utilization of weights resulted in diminished performance, pinpointing spectral features where the application of weights might be detrimental.

Mass spectra prediction with structural motif-based graph neural networks.

Mass spectra, which are agglomerations of ionized fragments from targeted molecules, play a crucial role across various fields for the identification of molecular structures. A prevalent analysis method involves spectral library searches, where unknown spectra are cross-referenced with a database. The effectiveness of such search-based approaches, however, is restricted by the scope of the existing mass spectra database, underscoring the need to expand the database via mass spectra prediction. In this research, we propose the Motif-based Mass Spectrum prediction Network (MoMS-Net), a GNN-based architecture to predict the mass spectra pattern utilizing the structural motif information of the molecule. MoMS-Net considers both a molecule and its substructures as a graph form, which facilitates the incorporation of long-range dependencies while using less memory compared to the graph transformer model. We evaluated our model over various types of mass spectra and showed the validity and superiority over the conventional models.

Spectral library search for improved TMTpro labelled peptide assignment in human plasma proteomics.

Clinical biomarker discovery is often based on the analysis of human plasma samples. However, the high dynamic range and complexity of plasma pose significant challenges to mass spectrometry-based proteomics. Current methods for improving protein identifications require laborious pre-analytical sample preparation. In this study, we developed and evaluated a TMTpro-specific spectral library for improved protein identification in human plasma proteomics. The library was constructed by LC-MS/MS analysis of highly fractionated TMTpro-tagged human plasma, human cell lysates, and relevant arterial tissues. The library was curated using several quality filters to ensure reliable peptide identifications. Our results show that spectral library searching using the TMTpro spectral library improves the identification of proteins in plasma samples compared to conventional sequence database searching. Protein identifications made by the spectral library search engine demonstrated a high degree of complementarity with the sequence database search engine, indicating the feasibility of increasing the number of protein identifications without additional pre-analytical sample preparation. The TMTpro-specific spectral library provides a resource for future plasma proteomics research and optimization of search algorithms for greater accuracy and speed in protein identifications in human plasma proteomics, and is made publicly available to the research community via ProteomeXchange with identifier PXD042546.

Spectral Library Searching Algorithms in Metabolomics

Spectral Library Searching Algorithms in Metabolomics

Mistle: bringing spectral library predictions to metaproteomics with an efficient search index.

Deep learning has moved to the forefront of tandem mass spectrometry-driven proteomics and authentic prediction for peptide fragmentation is more feasible than ever. Still, at this point spectral prediction is mainly used to validate database search results or for confined search spaces. Fully predicted spectral libraries have not yet been efficiently adapted to large search space problems that often occur in metaproteomics or proteogenomics. In this study, we showcase a workflow that uses Prosit for spectral library predictions on two common metaproteomes and implement an indexing and search algorithm, Mistle, to efficiently identify experimental mass spectra within the library. Hence, the workflow emulates a classic protein sequence database search with protein digestion but builds a searchable index from spectral predictions as an in-between step. We compare Mistle to popular search engines, both on a spectral and database search level, and provide evidence that this approach is more accurate than a database search using MSFragger. Mistle outperforms other spectral library search engines in terms of run time and proves to be extremely memory efficient with a 4- to 22-fold decrease in RAM usage. This makes Mistle universally applicable to large search spaces, e.g. covering comprehensive sequence databases of diverse microbiomes. Mistle is freely available on GitHub at https://github.com/BAMeScience/Mistle.

MeRgeION: a Multifunctional R Pipeline for Small Molecule LC-MS/MS Data Processing, Searching, and Organizing.

Small molecule structure elucidation using tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) plays a crucial role in life science, bioanalytical, and pharmaceutical research. There is a pressing need for increased throughput of compound identification and transformation of historical data into information-rich spectral databases. Meanwhile, molecular networking, a recent bioinformatic framework, provides global displays and system-level understanding of complex LC-MS/MS data sets. Herein we present meRgeION, a multifunctional, modular, and flexible R-based toolbox to streamline spectral database building, automated structural elucidation, and molecular networking. The toolbox offers diverse tuning parameters and the possibility to combine various algorithms in the same pipeline. As an open-source R package, meRgeION is ideally suited for building spectral databases and molecular networks from privacy-sensitive and preliminary data. Using meRgeION, we have created an integrated spectral database covering diverse pharmaceutical compounds that was successfully applied to annotate drug-related metabolites from a published nontargeted metabolomics data set as well as reveal the chemical space behind this complex data set through molecular networking. Moreover, the meRgeION-based processing workflow has demonstrated the usefulness of a spectral library search and molecular networking for pharmaceutical forced degradation studies. meRgeION is freely available at: https://github.com/daniellyz/meRgeION2.

Isolation of the active ingredients of antimalarial activity of the stem bark of Pseudocedrela kotschyi (Dry zone cedar)

Natural products, either as pure compounds or as standardized extracts provide unlimited opportunities for new drug discoveries because of the unmatched availability of chemical diversity. This study was carried out to isolate the active ingredients and determine the antimalarial activity of fractions of Pseudocedrela kotschyi stem bark following a scientific report of the antimalarial activity of crude extract of the plant material. Atotal of seven different fractions were obtained from 12g of the ethyl acetate crude extract using the flash chromatography method. GC-MS analysis of each of the seven ethyl acetate fractions was done and the identification of components present was based on a direct a comparison of the similarity index, retention times and mass spectral data with those for standard compounds. The compound prediction is based on NIST 05 Spectral library search programme. LD50 of 5 out of 7 fractions obtained was carried out using 45 mice of both sexes weighing 17-34g. The antimalarial (suppressive and curative) properties were evaluated in 40 mice in 3 different groups using NK 65 Plasmodium berghei berghei for each fraction. The plant treatments were compared against chloroquine and dimethyl sulfoxide. Results of GC-MS analysis of the seven ethyl acetate fractions of the plant extract showed the presence of forty-four different compounds, of which 3, 5-di-tert-butylphenol have been previously reported to have antimalarial properties. Acute toxicity (LD50 ) of fractions F1-4, F8, F9, F10-11, and F12-19 were 450mg/kg, 200mg/kg, 450mg/kg, 200mg/kg, and 450mg/kg respectively. All 7 fractions exhibited antimalarial activity. Remarkably, fractions F8 and F6-7 showed significant antimalarial activities for both suppressive and curative tests. These findings may benefit the antimalarial drug search in the current public health concerns of malaria disease.

Supramolecular solvent extraction and ambient mass spectrometry for the determination of organic contaminants in food packaging material

A rapid method based on a fast sample treatment with supramolecular solvents (SUPRASs) and ambient mass spectrometry (AMS) analysis was developed for the screening and quantification of organic contaminants in food packaging materials (FCMs). The suitability of SUPRASs made up of medium chain alcohols in ethanol:water mixtures was investigated, given their low toxicity, proven capacity for multi-residue analysis (since they provide a wide variety of interactions and multiple binding sites) and restricted access properties for simultaneous sample extraction and clean-up. Two families of emerging organic pollutants, bisphenols and organophosphate flame retardants, were targeted as representative compounds. The methodology was applied to 40 FCMs. Target compounds were quantitated using ASAP (atmospheric solids analysis probe)-low resolution MS and a broad-spectrum screening of contaminants was performed through spectral library search using direct injection probe (DIP) and high resolution MS (HRMS). The results showed the ubiquity of bisphenols and of some flame retardants, as well as the presence of other additives and unknown compounds in about half of the analyzed samples, which highlight the complex composition of FCMs and the possible associated health risks.

GlycoSLASH: Concurrent Glycopeptide Identification from Multiple Related LC-MS/MS Data Sets by Using Spectral Clustering and Library Searching.

Liquid chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry is commonly adopted in large-scale glycoproteomic studies involving hundreds of disease and control samples. The software for glycopeptide identification in such data (e.g., the commercial software Byonic) analyzes the individual data set and does not exploit the redundant spectra of glycopeptides presented in the related data sets. Herein, we present a novel concurrent approach for glycopeptide identification in multiple related glycoproteomic data sets by using spectral clustering and spectral library searching. The evaluation on two large-scale glycoproteomic data sets showed that the concurrent approach can identify 105%-224% more spectra as glycopeptides compared to the glycopeptide identification on individual data sets using Byonic alone. The improvement of glycopeptide identification also enabled the discovery of several potential biomarkers of protein glycosylations in hepatocellular carcinoma patients.

MAD HATTER Correctly Annotates 98% of Small Molecule Tandem Mass Spectra Searching in PubChem.

Metabolites provide a direct functional signature of cellular state. Untargeted metabolomics usually relies on mass spectrometry, a technology capable of detecting thousands of compounds in a biological sample. Metabolite annotation is executed using tandem mass spectrometry. Spectral library search is far from comprehensive, and numerous compounds remain unannotated. So-called in silico methods allow us to overcome the restrictions of spectral libraries, by searching in much larger molecular structure databases. Yet, after more than a decade of method development, in silico methods still do not reach the correct annotation rates that users would wish for. Here, we present a novel computational method called Mad Hatter for this task. Mad Hatter combines CSI:FingerID results with information from the searched structure database via a metascore. Compound information includes the melting point, and the number of words in the compound description starting with the letter 'u'. We then show that Mad Hatter reaches a stunning 97.6% correct annotations when searching PubChem, one of the largest and most comprehensive molecular structure databases. Unfortunately, Mad Hatter is not a real method. Rather, we developed Mad Hatter solely for the purpose of demonstrating common issues in computational method development and evaluation. We explain what evaluation glitches were necessary for Mad Hatter to reach this annotation level, what is wrong with similar metascores in general, and why metascores may screw up not only method evaluations but also the analysis of biological experiments. This paper may serve as an example of problems in the development and evaluation of machine learning models for metabolite annotation.

Four-dimensional proteomics analysis of human cerebrospinal fluid with trapped ion mobility spectrometry using PASEF.

A quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometer coupled with a trapped ion mobility spectrometry (timsTOF) operated in parallel accumulation-serial fragmentation (PASEF) mode has recently emerged as a platform capable of providing four-dimensional (4D) features comprising of elution time, collision cross section (CCS), mass-to-charge ratio, and intensity of peptides. The PASEF mode provides ∼100% ion sampling efficiency both in data-dependent acquisition (DDA) and data-independent acquisition (DIA) modes without sacrificing sensitivity. In addition, targeted measurements using PASEF integrated parallel reaction monitoring (PRM) mode have also been described. However, only limited number of studies have used timsTOF for analysis of clinical samples. Although Orbitrap mass spectrometers have been used for biomarker discovery from cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) in a variety of neurological diseases, these Orbitrap-derived datasets cannot readily be applied for driving experiments on timsTOF mass spectrometers. We generated a catalog of peptides and proteins in human CSF in DDA mode on a timsTOF mass spectrometer and used these data to build a spectral library. This strategy allowed us to use elution times and ion mobility values from the spectral library to design PRM experiments for quantifying previously discovered biomarkers from CSF samples in Alzheimer's disease. When the same samples were analyzed using a DIA approach combined with a spectral library search, a higher number of proteins were identified than in a library-free approach. Overall, we have established a spectral library of CSF as a resource and demonstrated its utility for PRM and DIA studies, which should facilitate studies of neurological disorders.

Automated identification of unknown doping agents in confiscation samples by flow-injection mass spectrometry and mass spectral library searches.

Rapid and accurate identification of unknown compounds within suspicious samples confiscated for sports doping control and law enforcement drug testing is critical, but such analyses are often conducted manually and can be time-consuming. Here, we report a methodology for automated identification of unknown substances in confiscation samples by rapid automatic flow-injection analysis on a liquid chromatography coupled to high-resolution mass spectrometry system and identifying unknown compounds with Compound Discoverer software. The developed methodology was validated by comparing the automated identification results with those obtained from manual syringe-infusion experiments and manual tandem mass spectral library searches. The automated methodology resulted in far higher throughput and remarkably shorter turnaround time for analysis when compared with manual procedures and, in most cases, yielded more compounds. As this is the first such report to the authors' knowledge, this methodology may potentially transform analysis of confiscated samples in sports doping control and law enforcement drug testing.

MS Ana: Improving Sensitivity in Peptide Identification with Spectral Library Search

Spectral library search can enable more sensitive peptide identification in tandem mass spectrometry experiments. However, its drawbacks are the limited availability of high-quality libraries and the added difficulty of creating decoy spectra for result validation. We describe MS Ana, a new spectral library search engine that enables high sensitivity peptide identification using either curated or predicted spectral libraries as well as robust false discovery control through its own decoy library generation algorithm. MS Ana identifies on average 36% more spectrum matches and 4% more proteins than database search in a benchmark test on single-shot human cell-line data. Further, we demonstrate the quality of the result validation with tests on synthetic peptide pools and show the importance of library selection through a comparison of library search performance with different configurations of publicly available human spectral libraries.