SpCas9 Variants Research Articles

Why Does the E1219V Mutation Expand T-Rich PAM Recognition in Cas9 from Streptococcus pyogenes?

Popular RNA-guided DNA endonuclease Cas9 from Streptococcus pyogenes (SpCas9) recognizes the canonical 5'-NGG-3' protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) and triggers double-stranded DNA cleavage activity. Mutations in SpCas9 were demonstrated to expand the PAM readability and hold promise for therapeutic and genome editing applications. However, the energetics of the PAM recognition and its relation to the atomic structure remain unknown. Using the X-ray structure (precatalytic SpCas9:sgRNA:dsDNA) as a template, we calculated the change in the PAM binding affinity in response to SpCas9 mutations using computer simulations. The E1219V mutation in SpCas9 fine-tunes the water accessibility in the PAM binding pocket and promotes new interactions in the SpCas9:noncanonical T-rich PAM, thus weakening the PAM stringency. The nucleotide-specific interaction of two arginine residues (i.e., R1333 and R1335 of SpCas9) ensured stringent 5'-NGG-3' PAM recognition. R1335A substitution (SpCas9R1335A) completely disrupts the direct interaction between SpCas9 and PAM sequences (canonical or noncanonical), accounting for the loss of editing activity. Interestingly, the double mutant (SpCas9R1335A,E1219V) boosts DNA binding affinity by favoring protein:PAM electrostatic contact in a desolvated pocket. The underlying thermodynamics explain the varied DNA cleavage activity of SpCas9 variants. A direct link between the energetics, structures, and activity is highlighted, which can aid in the rational design of improved SpCas9-based genome editing tools.

The SpRY Cas9 variant release the PAM sequence constraint for genome editing in the model plant Physcomitrium patens

Genome editing via CRISPR/Cas has enabled targeted genetic modifications in various species, including plants. The requirement for specific protospacer-adjacent motifs (PAMs) near the target gene, as seen with Cas nucleases like SpCas9, limits its application. PAMless SpCas9 variants, designed with a relaxed PAM requirement, have widened targeting options. However, these so-call PAMless SpCas9 still show variation of editing efficiency depending on the PAM and their efficiency lags behind the native SpCas9. Here we assess the potential of a PAMless SpCas9 variant for genome editing in the model plant Physcomitrium patens. For this purpose, we developed a SpRYCas9i variant, where expression was optimized, and tested its editing efficiency using the APT as a reporter gene. We show that the near PAMless SpRYCas9i effectively recognizes specific PAMs in P. patens that are not or poorly recognized by the native SpCas9. Pattern of mutations found using the SpRYCas9i are similar to the ones found with the SpCas9 and we could not detect off-target activity for the sgRNAs tested in this study. These findings contribute to advancing versatile genome editing techniques in plants.

The development of SpCas9 variants with high specificity and efficiency based on the HH Theory

Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 (SpCas9) is the most popular tool in gene editing; however, off-target mutagenesis is one of the biggest impediments in its application. In our previous study, we proposed the HH theory, which states that sgRNA/DNA hybrid (hybrid) extrusion-induced enhancement of hydrophobic interactions between the hybrid and REC3/HNH is a key factor in cleavage initiation. Based on the HH theory, we analyzed the interactions between the REC3 domain and hybrid and obtained 8 mutant sites. We designed 8 SpCas9 variants (V1–V8), used digital droplet PCR to assess SpCas9-induced DNA indels in human cells, and developed high-fidelity variants. Thus, the HH theory may be employed to further optimize SpCas9-mediated genome editing systems, and the resultant V3, V6, V7, and V8 SpCas9 variants may be valuable for applications requiring high-precision genome editing.

The Development of SpCas9 Variants with High Specificity and Efficiency Based on the HH Theory

Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 (SpCas9) is the most popular tool in gene editing; however, off-target mutagenesis is one of the biggest impediments in its application. In our previous study, we proposed the HH theory, which states that sgRNA/DNA hybrid (hybrid) extrusion-induced enhancement of hydrophobic interactions between the hybrid and REC3/HNH is a key factor in cleavage initiation. Based on the HH theory, we analyzed the interactions between the REC3 domain and hybrid and obtained 8 mutant sites. We designed 8 SpCas9 variants (V1-V8), used digital droplet PCR to assess SpCas9-induced DNA indels in human cells, and developed high-fidelity variants. Thus, the HH theory may be employed to further optimize SpCas9-mediated genome editing systems, and the resultant V3, V6, V7, and V8 SpCas9 variants may be valuable for applications requiring high-precision genome editing.

SpCas9-HF1 enhances accuracy of cell cycle-dependent genome editing by increasing HDR efficiency, and by reducing off-target effects and indel rates

In genome editing, it is important to avoid off-target mutations so as to reduce unexpected side effects, especially for therapeutic applications. Recently, several high-fidelity versions of SpCas9 have been developed to reduce off-target mutations. In addition to reducing off-target effects, highly efficient intended target gene correction is also essential to rescue protein functions that have been disrupted by single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). Homology directed repair (HDR) corrects genes precisely using a DNA template. Our recent development of cell cycle-dependent genome editing has shown that regulation of Cas9 activation with an anti-CRISPR-Cdt1 fusion protein increases HDR efficiency and reduces off-target effects. In this study, to apply high-fidelity SpCas9 variants to cell cycle-dependent genome editing, we evaluated anti-CRISPR inhibition of high-fidelity SpCas9s. In addition, HDR efficiency of high-fidelity SpCas9s was addressed, identifying eSpCas9, SpCas9-HF1, and LZ3 Cas9 as promising candidates. Although eSpCas9 and LZ3 Cas9 showed decreased HDR efficiency in cell cycle-dependent genome editing, SpCas9-HF1 successfully achieved increased HDR efficiency and few off-target effects when co-expressed as an AcrIIA4-Cdt1 fusion.

The Development of SpCas9 Variants with High Specificity and Efficiency Based on the HH Theory

The Development of SpCas9 Variants with High Specificity and Efficiency Based on the HH Theory

Continuous directed evolution of a compact CjCas9 variant with broad PAM compatibility.

CRISPR-Cas9 genome engineering is a powerful technology for correcting genetic diseases. However, the targeting range of Cas9 proteins is limited by their requirement for a protospacer adjacent motif (PAM), and in vivo delivery is challenging due to their large size. Here, we use phage-assisted continuous directed evolution to broaden the PAM compatibility of Campylobacter jejuni Cas9 (CjCas9), the smallest Cas9 ortholog characterized to date. The identified variant, termed evoCjCas9, primarily recognizes N4AH and N5HA PAM sequences, which occur tenfold more frequently in the genome than the canonical N3VRYAC PAM site. Moreover, evoCjCas9 exhibits higher nuclease activity than wild-type CjCas9 on canonical PAMs, with editing rates comparable to commonly used PAM-relaxed SpCas9 variants. Combined with deaminases or reverse transcriptases, evoCjCas9 enables robust base and prime editing, with the small size of evoCjCas9 base editors allowing for tissue-specific installation of A-to-G or C-to-T transition mutations from single adeno-associated virus vector systems.

A cleavage rule for selection of increased-fidelity SpCas9 variants with high efficiency and no detectable off-targets

Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 (SpCas9) has been employed as a genome engineering tool with a promising potential within therapeutics. However, its off-target effects present major safety concerns for applications requiring high specificity. Approaches developed to date to mitigate this effect, including any of the increased-fidelity (i.e., high-fidelity) SpCas9 variants, only provide efficient editing on a relatively small fraction of targets without detectable off-targets. Upon addressing this problem, we reveal a rather unexpected cleavability ranking of target sequences, and a cleavage rule that governs the on-target and off-target cleavage of increased-fidelity SpCas9 variants but not that of SpCas9-NG or xCas9. According to this rule, for each target, an optimal variant with matching fidelity must be identified for efficient cleavage without detectable off-target effects. Based on this insight, we develop here an extended set of variants, the CRISPRecise set, with increased fidelity spanning across a wide range, with differences in fidelity small enough to comprise an optimal variant for each target, regardless of its cleavability ranking. We demonstrate efficient editing with maximum specificity even on those targets that have not been possible in previous studies.

CRISPincette, and detection of low frequency cancer mutations in ctDNA.

61 Background: Liquid biopsy has emerged as a non-invasive and widely applicable approach in clinical practice for cancer detection and monitoring. Detecting low-frequency mutations in circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) is crucial for the success of liquid biopsy; however, technical limitations have hindered the detection of low variant allele frequency (VAF) mutations. To address this issue, we developed CRISPincette, a novel method which combines next-generation sequencing with an advanced CRISPR system, GeneCker-Cas9. Methods: CRISPincette was designed to efficiently detect mutant alleles by eliminating abundant wild-type alleles from normal cell-induced cell-free DNA (cfDNA) using CRISPR/Cas9. An engineered CRISPR/Cas9 variant, GeneCker-Cas9, was developed to maintain single-base precision outside the PAM region, enabling efficient discrimination of single-base mutations at all 20 positions within a single guide RNA target sequence. This advanced fidelity significantly improved the accuracy compared to high-specificity SpCas9 variants (SpCas9-HF and eSpCas9). To validate the sensitivity and accuracy of ctDNA detection using CRISPincette, we employed NGS standard materials (Horizon HD776, 778, 779) and assessed the improvement in ctDNA detection sensitivity for EGFR gene mutations (EGFR 19del, EGFR L858R, EGFR T790M). Subsequently, we analyzed the clinical applicability of CRISPincette using plasma samples from 7 non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients (6 patients with EGFR mutations and 1 patient without EGFR mutations). Results: Our analysis showed an approximately 10 to 30-fold enhancement in the detection sensitivity of EGFR gene mutations. Concordant detection of EGFR mutations was observed in the 6 patients with EGFR mutations using real-time PCR tests in each tissue biopsy, and no EGFR mutation was detected in the patient without the EGFR mutation. This confirmed CRISPincette's high accuracy and sensitivity in detecting low-frequency mutations in ctDNA. Conclusions: The implementation of CRISPincette has significantly improved the accuracy and sensitivity of liquid biopsy, making it a reliable and non-invasive alternative for confirming molecular pathological information in cancer patients. Furthermore, the high accuracy of CRISPincette will be a powerful tool for monitoring treatment and prognosis through the timing of anticancer drug administration. Overall, CRISPincette represents a substantial advancement in liquid biopsy technology, with potential implications for cancer diagnosis, treatment allocation, and monitoring the emergence of resistance.

Deleting specific residues from the HNH linkers creates a CRISPR-SpCas9 variant with high fidelity and efficiency.

Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats (CRISPR) and CRISPR-associated (Cas) systems are immunological defenses used in archaea and bacteria to recognize and destroy DNA from external invaders. The CRISPR-SpCas9 system harnessed from Streptococcus pyogenes (SpCas9) has become the most widely utilized genome editing tool and shows promise for clinical application. However, the off-target effect is still the major challenge for the genome editing of CRISPR-SpCas9. Based on analysis of the structure and cleavage procedures, we proposed two strategies to modify the SpCas9 structure and reduce off-target effects. Shortening the HNH or REC3 linkers (Strategy #1) aimed to move the primary position of HNH or REC3 far away from the single-guide RNA (sgRNA)/DNA hybrid (hybrid), while elongating the helix around the sgRNA (Strategy #2) aimed to strengthen the contacts between SpCas9 and the sgRNA/DNA. We designed 11 SpCas9 variants (variant No.1- variant No.11) and verified their efficiencies on the classic genome site EMX1-1, EMX1-1-OT1, and EMX1-1-OT2. The top three effective SpCas9 variants, variant No.1, variant No.2, and variant No.5, were additionally validated on other genome sites. The further selected variant No.1 was compared with two previous SpCas9 variants, HypaCas9 (a hyper-accurate Cas9 variant released in 2017) and eSpCas9 (1.1) (an "enhanced specificity" SpCas9 variant released in 2016), on two genome sites, EMX1-1 and FANCF-1. The results revealed that the deletion of Thr769 and Gly906 could substantially decrease off-target effects, while maintaining robust on-target efficiency in most of the selected genome sites.

Identification of the EH CRISPR-Cas9 system on a metagenome and its application to genome engineering.

Non-coding RNAs (crRNAs) produced from clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) loci and CRISPR-associated (Cas) proteins of the prokaryotic CRISPR-Cas systems form complexes that interfere with the spread of transmissible genetic elements through Cas-catalysed cleavage of foreign genetic material matching the guide crRNA sequences. The easily programmable targeting of nucleic acids enabled by these ribonucleoproteins has facilitated the implementation of CRISPR-based molecular biology tools for in vivo and in vitro modification of DNA and RNA targets. Despite the diversity of DNA-targeting Cas nucleases so far identified, native and engineered derivatives of the Streptococcus pyogenes SpCas9 are the most widely used for genome engineering, at least in part due to their catalytic robustness and the requirement of an exceptionally short motif (5'-NGG-3' PAM) flanking the target sequence. However, the large size of the SpCas9 variants impairs the delivery of the tool to eukaryotic cells and smaller alternatives are desirable. Here, we identify in a metagenome a new CRISPR-Cas9 system associated with a smaller Cas9 protein (EHCas9) that targets DNA sequences flanked by 5'-NGG-3' PAMs. We develop a simplified EHCas9 tool that specifically cleaves DNA targets and is functional for genome editing applications in prokaryotes and eukaryotic cells.

Prime editing with genuine Cas9 nickases minimizes unwanted indels

Unlike CRISPR-Cas9 nucleases, which yield DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs), Cas9 nickases (nCas9s), which are created by replacing key catalytic amino-acid residues in one of the two nuclease domains of S. pyogenesis Cas9 (SpCas9), produce nicks or single-strand breaks. Two SpCas9 variants, namely, nCas9 (D10A) and nCas9 (H840A), which cleave target (guide RNA-pairing) and non-target DNA strands, respectively, are widely used for various purposes, including paired nicking, homology-directed repair, base editing, and prime editing. In an effort to define the off-target nicks caused by these nickases, we perform Digenome-seq, a method based on whole genome sequencing of genomic DNA treated with a nuclease or nickase of interest, and find that nCas9 (H840A) but not nCas9 (D10A) can cleave both strands, producing unwanted DSBs, albeit less efficiently than wild-type Cas9. To inactivate the HNH nuclease domain further, we incorporate additional mutations into nCas9 (H840A). Double-mutant nCas9 (H840A + N863A) does not exhibit the DSB-inducing behavior in vitro and, either alone or in fusion with the M-MLV reverse transcriptase (prime editor, PE2 or PE3), induces a lower frequency of unwanted indels, compared to nCas9 (H840A), caused by error-prone repair of DSBs. When incorporated into prime editor and used with engineered pegRNAs (ePE3), we find that the nCas9 variant (H840A + N854A) dramatically increases the frequency of correct edits, but not unwanted indels, yielding the highest purity of editing outcomes compared to nCas9 (H840A).

Vision rescue via unconstrained in vivo prime editing in degenerating neural retinas.

Retinitis pigmentosa (RP) is an inherited retinal dystrophy causing progressive and irreversible loss of retinal photoreceptors. Here, we developed a genome-editing tool characterized by the versatility of prime editors (PEs) and unconstrained PAM requirement of a SpCas9 variant (SpRY), referred to as PESpRY. The diseased retinas of Pde6b-associated RP mouse model were transduced via a dual AAV system packaging PESpRY for the in vivo genome editing through a non-NGG PAM (GTG). The progressing cell loss was reversed once the mutation was corrected, leading to substantial rescue of photoreceptors and production of functional PDE6β. The treated mice exhibited significant responses in electroretinogram and displayed good performance in both passive and active avoidance tests. Moreover, they presented an apparent improvement in visual stimuli-driven optomotor responses and efficiently completed visually guided water-maze tasks. Together, our study provides convincing evidence for the prevention of vision loss caused by RP-associated gene mutations via unconstrained in vivo prime editing in the degenerating retinas.

An optimized SpCas9 high-fidelity variant for direct protein delivery

Electroporation of the Cas9 ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complex offers the advantage of preventing off-target cleavages and potential immune responses produced by long-term expression of the nuclease. Nevertheless, the majority of engineered high-fidelity Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 (SpCas9) variants are less active than the wild-type enzyme and are not compatible with RNP delivery. Building on our previous studies on evoCas9, we developed a high-fidelity SpCas9 variant suitable for RNP delivery. The editing efficacy and precision of the recombinant high-fidelity Cas9 (rCas9HF), characterized by the K526D substitution, was compared with the R691A mutant (HiFi Cas9), which is currently the only available high-fidelity Cas9 that can be used as an RNP. The comparative analysis was extended to gene substitution experiments where the two high fidelities were used in combination with a DNA donor template, generating different ratios of non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) versus homology-directed repair (HDR) for precise editing. The analyses revealed a heterogeneous efficacy and precision indicating different targeting capabilities between the two variants throughout the genome. The development of rCas9HF, characterized by an editing profile diverse from the currently used HiFi Cas9 in RNP electroporation, increases the genome editing solutions for the highest precision and efficient applications.

Sniper2L is a high-fidelity Cas9 variant with high activity.

Although several high-fidelity SpCas9 variants have been reported, it has been observed that this increased specificity is associated with reduced on-target activity, limiting the applications of the high-fidelity variants when efficient genome editing is required. Here, we developed an improved version of Sniper-Cas9, Sniper2L, which represents an exception to this trade-off trend as it showed higher specificity with retained high activity. We evaluated Sniper2L activities at a large number of target sequences and developed DeepSniper, a deep learning model that can predict the activity of Sniper2L. We also confirmed that Sniper2L can induce highly efficient and specific editing at a large number of target sequences when it is delivered as a ribonucleoprotein complex. Mechanically, the high specificity of Sniper2L originates from its superior ability to avoid unwinding a target DNA containing even a single mismatch. We envision that Sniper2L will be useful when efficient and specific genome editing is required.

Efficient PAM-Less Base Editing for Zebrafish Modeling of Human Genetic Disease with zSpRY-ABE8e.

CRISPR/Cas9 technology has increased the value of zebrafish for modeling human genetic diseases, studying disease pathogenesis, and drug screening, but protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) limitations are a major obstacle to creating accurate animal models of human genetic disorders caused by single-nucleotide variants (SNVs). Until now, some SpCas9 variants with broad PAM compatibility have shown efficiency in zebrafish. The application of the optimized SpRY-mediated adenine base editor (ABE), zSpRY-ABE8e, and synthetically modified gRNA in zebrafish has enabled efficient adenine-guanine base conversion without PAM restriction. Described here is a protocol for efficient adenine base editing without PAM limitation in zebrafish using zSpRY-ABE8e. By injecting a mixture of zSpRY-ABE8e mRNA and synthetically modified gRNA into zebrafish embryos, a zebrafish disease model was constructed with a precise mutation that simulated a pathogenic site of the TSR2 ribosome maturation factor (tsr2). This method provides a valuable tool for the establishment of accurate disease models for studying disease mechanisms and treatments.

Overexpression and cell-penetrating peptide-mediated delivery of Cas9 and its variant(s) for targeted genome editing.

The clustered, regularly interspaced, short palindromic repeat (CRISPR)-associated (Cas) system is a powerful tool that has been used for genome editing. Cas9 is a bacterial RNA-guided endonuclease that cleaves target DNA and modifies a cell's genome. Despite the advantages and promising results of the use of CRISPR-Cas9 as a molecular tool and potential therapeutic protein, the production and purification of the recombinant Cas9 protein remain a challenge. Following protein expression and purification, delivering the Cas9 protein into the cells is a key concern for many researchers. Typically, Cas9 and gRNA are delivered by using either plasmid or viral vectors. However, the plasmid or viral-mediated delivery triggers an undesirable immune response and leads to uncontrolled integration of the plasmid into the host genome. We envision that direct delivery i.e. conjugating the protein with cell-penetrating peptide (CPP) will lead to endogenous gene editing with reduced off-target effects when compared to the other delivery methods that require a transfection reagent. Our study aims to determine if the vector strains or culture conditions need to be optimized based on different Cas9 variants. Additionally, this study intends at delivering Cas9 derived from Streptococcus pyogenes (SpCas9) and other Cas9 variants into the mouse fibroblasts (NIH3T3 cell line) by conjugating the protein with CPP through thiol chemistry. Therefore, here, we methodically evaluate the expression of recombinant SpCas9 and other Cas9 variants in four different E. coli strains (Rosetta, BL21 (regular), BL21 PlysS, and BL21 star). After optimization of the conditions (temperature and post-induction time), BL21 (DE3) PlysS strain efficiently expressed the SpCas9 protein. Overall, the results of this study will inform optimized methods for CPP-mediated delivery of Cas9.

SuperFi-Cas9 exhibits remarkable fidelity but severely reduced activity yet works effectively with ABE8e

Several advancements have been made to SpCas9, the most widely used CRISPR/Cas genome editing tool, to reduce its unwanted off-target effects. The most promising approach is the development of increased-fidelity nuclease (IFN) variants of SpCas9, however, their fidelity has increased at the cost of reduced activity. SuperFi-Cas9 has been developed recently, and it has been described as a next-generation high-fidelity SpCas9 variant, free from the drawbacks of first-generation IFNs. In this study, we characterize the on-target activity and the off-target propensity of SuperFi-Cas9 in mammalian cells, comparing it to first-generation IFNs. SuperFi-Cas9 demonstrates strongly reduced activity but high fidelity features that are in many aspects similar to those of some first-generation variants, such as evo- and HeFSpCas9. SuperFi-cytosine (CBE3) and -adenine (ABE7.10) base editors, as well as SuperFi-prime editor show no meaningful activity. When combined with ABE8e, SuperFi-Cas9, similarly to HeFSpCas9, executes DNA editing with high activity as well as high specificity reducing both bystander and SpCas9-dependent off-target base editing.

Precise DNA cleavage using CRISPR-SpRYgests.

Methods for in vitro DNA cleavage and molecular cloning remain unable to precisely cleave DNA directly adjacent to bases of interest. Restriction enzymes (REs) must bind specific motifs, whereas wild-type CRISPR-Cas9 or CRISPR-Cas12 nucleases require protospacer adjacent motifs (PAMs). Here we explore the utility of our previously reported near-PAMless SpCas9 variant, named SpRY, to serve as a universal DNA cleavage tool for various cloning applications. By performing SpRY DNA digests (SpRYgests) using more than 130 guide RNAs (gRNAs) sampling a wide diversity of PAMs, we discovered that SpRY is PAMless in vitro and can cleave DNA at practically any sequence, including sites refractory to cleavage with wild-type SpCas9. We illustrate the versatility and effectiveness of SpRYgests to improve the precision of several cloning workflows, including those not possible with REs or canonical CRISPR nucleases. We also optimize a rapid and simple one-pot gRNA synthesis protocol to streamline SpRYgest implementation. Together, SpRYgests can improve various DNA engineering applications that benefit from precise DNA breaks.

Optimized prime editing efficiently generates glyphosate-resistant rice plants carrying homozygous TAP-IVS mutation in EPSPS

Optimized prime editing efficiently generates glyphosate-resistant rice plants carrying homozygous TAP-IVS mutation in EPSPS