Heterogeneous element doping in amorphous carbon films can reduce residual stresses and improve plastic deformation. Nevertheless, the effects of dopant content and size on the metastable transition mechanism between sp2-C and sp3-C atoms during the deformation process are unclear and difficult to be in situ observed and researched, experimentally. In this work, the mechanical properties and the structural evolution during the nanoindentation of amorphous CoCrFeNi sphere-doped carbon heterostructured films with different radii were simulated. The results indicate that the hardness H and elastic modulus E of the films decreased with the increase of the dopant addition. H decreases from 50.69 to 28.94 GPa, and E decreases from 664.39 to 448.62 GPa. The decrease in the elastic recovery and the enlargement of the shear transition zones indicate that the presence of the amorphous CoCrFeNi dopant can significantly improve the plastic deformation capacity of the films. During the nanoindentation process, the spherical dopants reduce the stress and shear strain of the regions under the indenter in a-C films. The reduction of compressive and shear stresses in the film can inhibit the C atom metastable transition from sp2-C to sp3-C. This can provide a theoretical basis for the development and design of heavy-load and high-deformation-rate a-C films.