Metasomatism of the sub-continental lithospheric mantle (SCLM) can result in enrichment in volatile elements introduced via subduction of seawater-altered oceanic lithosphere. Subduction-related metasomatism can introduce chlorine isotope heterogeneity to the SCLM inherited from the subducted source, which can be used to characterize the source of metasomatism. This study presents Cl isotope compositions (δ37Cl) of variably metasomatized continental lithospheric mantle xenoliths from the Colorado Plateau and southern Rio Grande Rift (southwestern United States). Fertile mantle xenoliths that represent asthenosphere that has recently been emplaced at the base of the North American lithosphere have δ37Cl values of 0.0 ‰ to +0.1 ‰, suggesting that the convecting mantle has an average δ37Cl value similar to seawater and chondrites. In contrast, metasomatized xenoliths span a range of δ37Cl values from +0.1 ‰ to +1.9 ‰, extending above the average convecting mantle value. The range in δ37Cl values can be explained by mixing between a subduction-related fluid with δ37Cl values between +1.0 ‰ and +1.9 ‰ and a shallow crustal fluid with a δ37Cl value less than +0.3 ‰. The most likely source of the high δ37Cl subduction-related signature is the lower crust in the subducted Farallon plate. Lower crustal Cl likely entered the SCLM either through direct dehydration of lawsonite ± phengite in the deeply subducted Farallon plate or from a mixed serpentinite-oceanic crust source in the subducted Farallon. Regardless of the mechanism, this study provides evidence for subduction of crustal Cl into the mantle, which can introduce isotopic heterogeneity into the SCLM and has implications for the volatile cycling in the HIMU mantle and SCLM.