South African University Research Articles

Governance and Leadership in Advancing Entrepreneurial Universities: Exploring Awareness and Change Dynamics in South Africa

This research explores the role of awareness, as framed by the ADKAR (Awareness, Desire, Knowledge, Ability, and Reinforcement) change management model, in driving the transformation of South African higher education institutions (HEIs) into Entrepreneurial Universities (EnU). The study focuses on the critical question of whether raising awareness of entrepreneurship among academics can catalyse transformative changes within universities, fostering an entrepreneurial mindset and practices across the institution. In the context of South Africa’s socio-economic challenges, such as high unemployment and inequality, entrepreneurial universities are seen as key drivers of innovation and economic development. The research findings underscore that awareness, the foundational step of the ADKAR model, is essential for initiating the entrepreneurial shift within HEIs. Academics who are aware of the importance of entrepreneurship are more likely to engage in activities that promote innovation, student entrepreneurship, and industry collaboration. However, the study also highlights that awareness alone is insufficient for a full institutional transformation. Leadership commitment and active involvement are critical in moving beyond awareness to implement sustainable entrepreneurial initiatives. Without strong leadership that aligns institutional governance structures and policies with entrepreneurial objectives, the entrepreneurial agenda may struggle to gain traction. The research concludes that while raising awareness among academics is a necessary first step, leadership at universities must also be equipped with the skills and understanding to champion entrepreneurship at an institutional level. Comprehensive leadership training, continuous evaluation of entrepreneurial initiatives, and fostering cross-departmental and external collaborations are essential for sustaining momentum towards the full realisation of Entrepreneurial Universities in South Africa. This study contributes to the broader discourse on entrepreneurship in higher education by providing insights into the specific challenges and opportunities facing South African universities as they navigate the path towards becoming entrepreneurial institutions.

Leveraging Information Technologies for Organisational Learning and Knowledge Management: Enhancing Access and Educational Outcomes for Rural Students

PurposeThis study investigates the role of information technologies in enhancing organisational learning and knowledge management in South African rural universities, with the goal of improving access and educational outcomes for rural students. The research focuses on how digital tools can create more equitable learning environments and address the unique challenges faced by rural institutions. Study design/methodology/approachA scoping review of literature from 2000 to 2024 was conducted, employing the Diffusion of Innovation theory and Social Pedagogy Justice framework to analyse the impact of digital platforms on organisational learning and knowledge management in rural universities. The study examines how these tools can help bridge the gap between rural and urban students and address the challenges of limited resources and digital divides. FindingsThe study finds that information technologies can significantly improve organisational learning processes and knowledge management in rural universities by providing tools that promote inclusion and participation. Digital technologies, when thoughtfully implemented, can help reduce educational disparities by enhancing access to resources and supporting collaboration between students in urban and rural areas. The research suggests that a strategic approach to technology adoption, tailored to the local context, is key to achieving more equitable educational outcomes. Originality/valueThis research provides valuable insights for policymakers and educational leaders on how to leverage information technologies to advance social justice in education. By focusing on rural universities in South Africa, the study highlights the importance of addressing infrastructural and resource challenges while using digital tools to foster inclusion and equity. The findings offer practical strategies for enhancing the effectiveness of digital platforms in improving educational outcomes for traditionally underserved communities.

Idea generation and planning time in second language academic writing: An empirical investigation at Howard College Campus, University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban, South Africa

Idea generation is a cognitive process which underlies the production of coherent writing. However, little is known about the nature of this process and how it is affected by different preparatory conditions. The current study examines the effects of three planning time conditions: ‘planning time’ (10 minutes), ‘extended planning time’ (20 minutes) and ‘no planning time’ and two task conditions, namely ‘topic given’ and ‘topic and ideas given’, and their effect on the quality and the quantity of idea units produced in the planning notes and essays of 30 English Second Language (ESL) learners at a South African university. The study aims to replicate an earlier study by Ong, and tests four hypotheses: hypotheses 1 and 2 state that an extended planning time has a positive effect on both the quantity and the quality of ideas generated in planning notes (hypothesis 1) and essays (hypothesis 2). Hypotheses 3 and 4 state that additional ideas alongside a topic enhance the idea generation process in both planning notes (hypothesis 3) and essays (hypothesis 4). Our findings do not verify hypothesis (1) as neither in the planning notes nor the essays was the quantity of ideas affected by the planning time conditions. Hypothesis 2 was partially verified as the quality of ideas in the essays — but not in the planning notes — improved as an effect of an extended planning time. These results differ from Ong whose data fully support both hypotheses 1 and 2. Our data falsify hypotheses 3 and 4 as the topic-given condition consistently produced both a better quality and a larger quantity of ideas in the planning notes and in the essays of the participants. This finding concurs with Ong. In conclusion, the attempt at a replication of Ong only partially yielded the same results. Interestingly, the data indicate that the idea-generation process differed between the production of the planning notes and the production of the essays.

Comparing the South African and Brazilian student uprisings (2015–2016): Similarities, Circulations, and Distance

ABSTRACT South Africa and Brazil are notorious for having some of the highest levels of (racialised) inequality on the planet, and dysfunctional education systems failing millions in their aspirations for a better life. Over 2015-16, student protests erupted across Brazilian and South African schools and universities, challenging these conditions through strikes, occupations, on-campus and street protests, and intellectual production. This paper builds on a World-Systems theoretical framework to understand the similarities, circulation, and distance between the two contemporaneous movements. In Brazil, the ‘Primavera Secundarista' high school occupations dealt primarily with local political dynamics, such as school closures, and intersectional forms of oppression. In South Africa, the ‘Fallist' university mobilisations demanded free, decolonised education, alongside addressing issues of outsourcing and institutional racism. In the first section, I give a comparative overview of these student movements’ similarities, situating them in their context and highlighting the key concerns and political and pedagogical practices of student activists in each. While these movements did not generally engage with each other, there were some important points of interaction, discussed in the second section. While highlighting these points of connection, I also advance an argument in the third section for why there was nevertheless relatively little direct engagement between these contemporaneous movements that otherwise had so much in common. The points of connection and disconnection between these similar movements offers insights about the functioning of the contemporary World-System and the modes of transnational circulation between movements therein, with lessons for transnational understandings of social movements, especially South-South movements.

Going Nowhere Fast? A Review of Literature on Barriers to Queer Inclusion in South African Universities

Going Nowhere Fast? A Review of Literature on Barriers to Queer Inclusion in South African Universities

Synchronous online learning and career readiness in higher education: student perceptions, challenges, and solutions

Synchronous Online Learning (SOL) environments have rapidly transformed the educational landscape. However, there is limited research on their efficacy in equipping students with the necessary skills to succeed in the workforce, particularly in developing essential professional skills like digital literacy, interpersonal communication, and practical experience. This study explores how SOL impacts students’ readiness for the workforce and the development of these critical skills. The research employed a qualitative methodology involving in-depth interviews with 27 third- and fourth-year students from a South African university. Purposive sampling was used to capture diverse experiences regarding SOL and its influence on professional skill development. Thematic analysis was performed to identify critical patterns and insights from the interviews. Findings reveal that SOL environments effectively enhance students’ technical skills and digital adaptability, essential for navigating a digital workforce. However, SOL is inadequate in developing interpersonal skills and providing practical, hands-on experiences. Students reported a lack of networking opportunities and expressed concerns about their preparedness for the demands of real-world employment, particularly in fields requiring strong interpersonal skills and practical experience. The study highlights the need for educational innovations that combine the benefits of digital learning with comprehensive skill development strategies, particularly in soft skills and experiential learning.

Towards effective web-based learning: An investigation of the management of learning management system at a university of technology

The effectiveness of web-based learning has garnered significant attention in the global educational landscape, with numerous studies providing invaluable insights to transform education through technology. These research endeavors have generated theoretical frameworks that underpin the implementation and utilization of technology for educational enhancement. However, despite the remarkable contributions of these studies, concerns persist regarding the adept management of web-based Learning Management Systems (LMS). Hence, this paper addresses this critical concern by conducting an analysis of LMS management at a South African University of Technology. Utilising a mixed-methods approach, this study combines qualitative interviews with lecturers and quantitative analysis involving students to comprehensively assess the management of web-based LMS. By triangulating these diverse data sources, this research offers a holistic perspective on LMS management, thereby enriching the understanding of this multifaceted field. The findings of this study indicate that the University of Technology has made significant strides in adopting and implementing web-based learning technologies via Think Learn Zone (TLZ) Moodle platform. However, certain challenges were identified. Notably, inconsistencies in lecturer training, concerns about accessibility, and the demand for enhanced technical support for students. Moreover, the study highlights that while the LMS serves as a pivotal tool for disseminating educational content, its effectiveness hinges on the synergy between administrative decisions and faculty practices.

Young People’s voices on social justice: a participatory storytelling and action learning approach

ABSTRACT South Africa is home to a large youth population, defined in South Africa as aged between 18 and 34 years. In working to transform our unequal society, we need to take diverse youth voices, including young people at university, into account regarding what matters to them. To enable their voices, the paper recounts a participatory storytelling research project with students in the educational space of one South African university. Using individual and collective digital storytelling, participants produced an archive of everyday stories, which then comprised a data base for them to analyse social in/justice issues and themes and co-create knowledge from the ground-up, with their emergent ideas categorised in a social injustice map. Through the iterative action learning and reflective process, participants developed their critical awareness of injustices and enhanced their sense of their own epistemic agency to contribute to change. Both the project process and the formation of intersecting capabilities for the co-creation of substantive reparative knowledge about social injustices and fairness were advanced through the project. Finally, it is suggested that these two capabilities might be applied to young people globally as crucial for contributions to epistemic agency and for making more just future societies.

Collaging together-apart: building trust and hope in social innovation and design pedagogies

ABSTRACT This article explores how relationships of care, trust and hope might be fostered in a social innovation design course at a South African university of technology. Rather than shy away from the challenges of our uncertain world, the paper proposes feminist pedagogical strategies that seek to nurture students’ capacity for trust and hope, rather than overwhelm and despair, through carefully curated collaborative-collage-making processes. By interweaving Bracha Ettinger’s theory of matrixial trans-subjectivity and Karen Barad’s agential realism, the generative role that arts-based practices offer social innovation design pedagogies is made explicit. The paper will show how collaborative artworking activated a co-affective encounter in which students and myself, rather than drowning in overwhelm, discovered new educational imaginaries and Hope-full renewals.

Exploring preservice teachers’ pedagogical content knowledge for teaching analytical geometry in multilingual classrooms

The narrative permeating higher education institutions globally is the intention to advance the quality of preservice mathematics teachers to gain better performance than mathematics school learners. In this article we report on a qualitative case study which explored the pedagogical content knowledge (PCK) of preservice teachers (PST) (n = 20) at a South African university of technology. These preservice teachers were provided with activity sheets with past examination questions in analytical geometry. Their written responses were analysed, and verification interviews were conducted. This was followed by an analysis of the preservice teachers’ lesson plans for teaching the topic to Grade 11 learners. The domains and subdomains of the Shulman’s PCK derived Mathematics Teacher’s Specialised Knowledge (MTSK) model were used as the theoretical framework. The study established that the PSTs had limited content knowledge, and knowledge for teaching analytical geometry at Grade 11 as their responses to the activities confirmed that they mostly had procedural understanding. The study was conducted in a context with multilingual PSTs who are training in multilingual classrooms.Contribution: The study will highlight the misconceptions and existing gaps in the PSTs’ knowledge for teaching analytical geometry in multilingual classrooms.

Perceived social support and sense of belonging: The mediating role of academic anxiety among first-generation students at a South African university

This study investigated the role of academic anxiety in the relationship between perceived social support and a sense of belonging of first-generation university students. The sample consisted of 240 undergraduate first-generation students (FGS) at a South African university (female = 72.5%; mean age = 28.14 years, SD = 5.10 years). They completed surveys on perceived social (friendship and family) support, academic anxiety, and sense of belonging. Simple linear regression analysis results showed perceived family support to significantly predict sense of belonging. Additionally, simple mediation analysis results showed that academic anxiety significantly mediated the relationship between perceived friendship support and sense of belonging, for higher sense of belonging. Moreover, academic anxiety significantly mediated the relationship between perceived family support and sense of belonging, to be stronger. These findings suggest that friendship and family support resources foster a sense of belonging among FGS, which may reduce their academic anxiety. Developing FGS’s sense of belonging is essential for positive mental health and academic success.

Science communication across cultures: design and delivery of a graduate science communication program in South Africa

ABSTRACT Over two years, a graduate diploma program in science communication was designed and delivered by a university in the Republic of South Africa with assistance from a university in Australia. Building on the Australian program, the design incorporated cross-cultural and Indigenous Knowledge elements in keeping with the ethos of the South African university and broader inclusive movements within science communication. The overall design corresponded to many essential learning objectives later identified by Lewenstein and Baram-Tsabari (2022, How should we organize science communication trainings to achieve competencies? International Journal of Science Education, Part B, 12(4), 289–308. https://doi.org/10.1080/21548455.2022.2136985), but there were also many modifications that had to be made over the course of the design and delivery to accommodate cultural considerations. In this paper, we consider how closely the design matched the threshold concepts and the learning objectives suggested by Lewenstein and Baram-Tsabari, and what modifications might be made to them to include cultural considerations.

Renewing Systems Analysis: The Impact of Game-Based Learning on Repeating Students

Systems Analysis and Design, a second-year subject offered over two semesters, is experienced as challenging. The subject is offered at a South African university and form part of several baccalaureus courses, of which the BSc. Information Technology course is the most prominent. Several reasons contribute to the situation where a substantial percentage of students struggle to pass the first of two modules; the extensive theoretical concepts covered, the necessity to understand their implementation, and the ability to apply the theory in real-life scenarios simulated in a learning context. To address this issue, the class was split, to afford repeating students inverted learning with a gaming focus. The selection of games was aiming to suit the type of learning that were expected to take place. In support, students competed in their project groups. Students new to the module were taught as per the status quo. The mixed method enquiry of this changed setting focused on the group of repeating students. Quantitative data extracted focused on the success of students as repeaters, and their evaluation of the module compared to newcomer students. Qualitative data was gathered using interviews with purposively selected participants who passed the first semester as a repeating student and improved much based on the difference in participation marks, before and after the intervention. Qualitative data analysis focused on identifying codes to allow the categorization of responses into categories to elucidate the value of this endeavour. The participants on which reporting of this paper focuses, formed part of a larger study with a wider perspective. In this paper the focus is on the impressions of the individual regarding this experience. The intervention reported on occurred over a four-year period and was concluded six years ago. This allowed participants to complete their studies and start a career. Results show that the intervention did have a substantial impact on the progress of these students’ studies and helped them to overcome study and work-related obstacles. The approach to this game-based may guide future lecturers experiencing similar challenges.

Accessibility Challenges of Using Podcasts and Vodcasts in a South African Distance Learning University

Academic writing presents a range of challenges for students, particularly those enrolled in distance university institutions. These challenges encompass various facets such as understanding citation and referencing, developing a distinctive writer’s voice, mastering academic discourse, paraphrasing, summarising, and adhering to academic conventions. Notably, deficiencies in academic writing skills often trace back to inadequate preparation during high school education, potentially leading to qualification deferment and high dropout rates. To tackle these challenges, podcasts and vodcasts emerged as essential tools to bridge academic gaps, catering to diverse learning styles and offering flexibility beyond traditional teaching methods. However, the efficacy of supplemental multimedia tools warrants exploration, considering uncertainties regarding student acceptance. Thus, this study aimed to identify accessibility challenges, to reduce existing barriers and enhance accessibility in open distant institutions. Utilising qualitative research methodologies, including focus group discussions and literature analysis, data collection was conducted. The study drew upon Moore’s theory of transactional distance and Garrison et al.’s community of inquiry framework to create collaborative online interactions and meaningful lecturer-student engagement, culminating in the construction of new knowledge. Findings revealed that students did not encounter accessibility challenges and expressed preference for shorter podcasts and vodcasts. These multimedia formats alleviated boredom, clarified complex concepts, prevented monotony, enhanced attention and comprehension, stimulated interest, facilitated active learning, and accommodated various learning styles. Podcasts and vodcasts reduced transactional distance and created a sense of community. Contrary to prevailing literature, students did not encounter accessibility challenges, shifting the focus towards shorter, high-quality multimedia content rather than accessibility concerns.

Prospects and Challenges to ICT Adoption in Teaching and Learning at Rural South African Universities: A Systematic Review

This study aimed to systematically review the prospects and challenges associated with adopting Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in teaching and learning at rural universities in South Africa. To achieve this aim, a systematic review methodology was employed. The systematic review findings revealed a multifaceted landscape wherein opportunities for enhancing education through ICT exist alongside significant challenges. Prospects include the potential for technology to bridge educational gaps, increase accessibility, and provide innovative learning experiences. However, challenges such as inadequate infrastructure, limited connectivity, and varying levels of digital literacy pose significant impediments. The study emphasizes the need for targeted interventions to address these challenges, including infrastructure development, capacity building, and localized content creation. Additionally, recommendations for flexible learning models and collaborative partnerships are outlined to facilitate effective ICT adoption in the unique context of rural South African universities. Continuous research and evaluation are advocated to inform future strategies and ensure sustainable improvements in rural education through ICT integration.

Experiences of Students with Online Learning at a South African University

Experiences of Students with Online Learning at a South African University

Engagement and learning approaches among medical students in an online surgical teaching programme: A cross-sectional study

BackgroundThe COVID-19 pandemic prompted the transition of all teaching and learning of final-year General Surgery students to an online platform. Despite the utility of online methods, challenges exist such as a sense of impersonal learning, and poor student engagement. Student engagement with course content is important for deep learning. An Online Student Engagement Scale (OSE) and a revised Biggs Two-Factor Study Process Questionnaire (R-SPQ-2F) were used to evaluate student engagement and learning approaches respectively. MethodsA cross-sectional study was conducted in 2021 at a South African university. The OSE and R-SPQ-2F online survey tools were administered to all final-year students (n = 325) enrolled in the surgical online module. Quantitative data was collected, and the data was analysed statistically using R-Statistical computing software. Results are presented in the form of descriptive and inferential statistics. The reliability of the tools was evaluated by Cronbach's alpha. ResultsThe survey response rate was 35.4 % (115/325). Students were engaged at a high level, and the median (IQR) scores of the OSE tool were 71.0 (63.0–78.0). Overall, students adopted a deep approach (DA) to learning, with median (IQR) scores of 34.0 (30.0–39.0) on the R-SPQ-2F tool. There was a moderate positive correlation between the total OSE score and DA (0.53, p < 0.001). Both the OSE and R-SPQ-2F tools showed an acceptable level of internal consistency of 0.893 and 0.806 respectively. ConclusionsStudent engagement was associated with deep learning approaches. The OSE and R-SPQ-2F tools were reliable tools to measure student engagement and learning approaches among medical students.

Colonial methodologies: a discourse analysis of medical students’ talk about psychology

The historical tension between the natural and social sciences, and the associated discourses of superiority and inferiority, remains prevalent today in academia and practice. This study analyses the discourses that medical students at a South African university employ in their talk about psychology. The analysis demonstrates the function of these discourses and locates them within historical debates surrounding the social and natural sciences. More importantly, it identifies how psychology is locked into Eurocentric assumptions of rigour and empiricism. We use discursive psychology to examine five online discussion board entries detailing medical students’ understanding of psychology. The findings suggest that definitions of psychology subvert the discipline under the guise of bolstering its value in ways that are comparable to colonial methodologies, thereby reconstituting and reinforcing historical notions of othering in social scientific discourses. This research therefore contributes to debates on the current role and position of psychology in South Africa and helps to destabilise dominant scientific discourses within and against which psychology is enacted in the academy. Through a critical interrogation of such hegemony, this study aims to forge new ways of doing and thinking psychology in South Africa.

Teacher Education Lecturers' Views of Open Educational Resources: A Case of South African Universities

Literature reflects that universities freely share their teaching materials as Open Educational Resources (OER). The major objective of this study was to investigate lecturers at faculties of education views of the usefulness of OER for academic purposes at selected South African universities. This study is grounded in the Technology Acceptance Model, TAM (Davis, 1989); and the Unified Theory of Technology Acceptance and Use, UTTAU (Bagozzi, 2007) and Theory of Diffusion of Innovations, TDI (Rogers, 2003). These theories justified this investigation explores lecturers at faculties of education views of the usefulness of OER for academic purposes at selected South African universities. The study was informed by the qualitative research approach, which employed semi-structured interviews. Four lecturers were sampled purposively from each university to participate in the study and the data were analysed thematically. The findings of this study are that although the lecturers had an inadequate understanding and knowledge of OER, they were able to display their disposition toward in the usefulness of OER in applying in their pedagogical practices. What is now needed is for South African universities to ensure greater OER awareness and assist lecturers to acquire knowledge of OER so that they can infuse and utilise it effectively in their daily teaching-and-learning environments.

A blended teaching and learning model for family-medicine registrar training at a South African university.

Effective primary healthcare is essential in developing countries but faces several challenges, including the lack of standardised training across decentralised sites. In response to unsatisfactory registrar examination outcomes in 2013, the Department of Family Medicine at the University of the Witwatersrand in South Africa introduced a blended teaching and learning programme. The aim of the new programme was to level the playing field by providing uniform online resources on a course site on the university's learning management system. The uniform online resources would be integrated into the teaching programme. A team consisting of the registrar-training-programme coordinator, an educationalist and five family-medicine consultants from different districts began reviewing the curriculum, selecting appropriate resources and developing the course site. The blended programme was developed and implemented using a phased, participatory research action approach, including phases of evaluation and redesign. Since the implementation of the blended-learning programme in 2017, registrar outcomes have improved, but this has not been the only success attributed to the programme. The programme also resulted in an enhanced focus on teaching and learning, especially among those involved in its development. We share the lessons gleaned from our experiences, emphasising the need for adequate training and teamwork if we are to use technology appropriately and effectively to address the difficulties associated with decentralised training in developing countries.