We present the case of a patient who presented with one day of sudden abdominal distension and two episodes of projectile nonbilious vomiting. A solitary liver abscess was diagnosed using ultrasonography and contrast-enhanced computed tomography findings, and the patient was treated conservatively with parenteral broad-spectrum antibiotics. Following the completion of the antibiotic dose, an ultrasound of the abdomen reveals that the size of the liver abscess has decreased. Neonatal liver abscess is a rare clinical condition that causes significant morbidity and mortality in premature and term babies. In a neonate with potential risk factors, a high index of suspicion is required to make the diagnosis. Baseline tests, as well as computed tomography with or without contrast, aid in the definitive diagnosis of a hepatic abscess. For management, a multidisciplinary approach should be considered, including correction of the predisposing factor as well as appropriate medical and/or surgical intervention. Neonatal liver abscess is frequently overlooked due to its rarity. Thus, whenever a neonate exhibits the aforementioned clinical spectrum, it should be considered in the differential diagnosis, and a diagnostic workup and treatment should be initiated as soon as possible to avoid debilitating complications.