Large deflections and accumulation of permanent track geometry defects at railway soft spots cause significant operational issues including increased maintenance costs, decreased train speed, and, at an extreme, derailments and track failures. Reinforcing inclusions placed between the ties are a promising rehabilitation scheme to locally stabilize the embankment and transfer the loads to deeper, more suitable soils. In this paper we report the results of a long-term monitoring program to assess the performance of ductile inclusions, known commercially as “GeoSpike® elements”, to stabilize a rapidly deteriorating railway soft spot. Observations of track bed behavior are presented for 8 months prior to installation and 15 months after installation using a combination of LIDAR, Digital Image Correlation (DIC), and ShapeAccelArrays (SAA). Through the monitoring program, it was determined that the ductile inclusions decreased the average rate of deterioration by a factor of approximately 3, which allowed the frequency of site maintenance to be decreased from three times a year to once a year.