In this issue, Diekelmann, Wilhelm and Born1 provide an extensive and critical review of the rapidly growing literature on sleep-dependent memory consolidation. But rather than simply reviewing this literature, they have taken this opportunity to ask several important questions concerning off-line memory processing. Most gratifying is their decision not to simply look ever more deeply into frequently discussed questions, but rather to raise several new ones. They ask what kinds of memories are consolidated by sleep, what kinds of consolidation are accomplished, and what kinds of sleep are required. For the reader looking for a quick set of answer, they won't find them here or in the Diekelmann article. But the authors have done a superb job of organize the literature to support a series of proposed answers, and I will offer a few more, all of which will hopefully serve as a basis for further investigations. The task of sorting out the interactions between sleep and memory is a daunting one. We summarized some of these issues in an earlier review.2 At the very least (Fig 1), one has to address the question of how five stages of sleep3 interact with at least six types of memories4 and six stages of post-encoding memory processing,2 for a combined total of 144 distinct sub-questions (e.g., how does REM sleep affect the stabilization of classical conditioning; Fig 1). But Diekelmann and colleagues have now added another layer of more subtle questions – how do the strength of initial encoding and the perceived value of the memory interact with these sleep-dependent processes, how do the amount of sleep and the timing of the sleep affect them, and how do these processes change with age and in the presence of psychiatric disorders? Open in a separate window Figure 1 The sleep cycle, memory systems, and memory stages (A) The human sleep cycle—across the night, NREM and REM sleep cycle every 90 min in an ultradian manner, while the ratio of NREM to REM sleep shifts. During the first half of the night, stages 3 and 4 NREM (SWS) dominate, while stage 2 NREM and REM sleep prevail in the latter half of the night. EEG patterns also differ significantly between sleep stages, with electrical oscillations such as K complexes and sleep spindles occurring during stage 2 NREM, slow (0.5–4Hz) delta waves developing in SWS, and theta waves seen during REM. (B) Memory systems—human memory is most commonly divided into declarative forms, with further subdivisions into episodic and semantic; and nondeclarative forms, subdivided into an array of different types including procedural skill memory (C) Developing stages of memory—following the initial encoding of a memory, several ensuing stages are proposed, beginning with consolidation, as well as integration of the memory representation, translocation of the representation, or erasure of the memory. Also, following later recall, the memory representation is believed to become unstable once again, requiring periods of reconsolidation. Reproduced from 2.
Read full abstract