Singlet Fission Research Articles

Inverse Design of Singlet‐Fission Materials with Uncertainty‐Controlled Genetic Optimization

AbstractSinglet fission has shown potential for boosting the efficiency of solar cells, but the scarcity of suitable molecular materials hinders its implementation. We introduce an uncertainty‐controlled genetic algorithm (ucGA) based on ensemble machine learning predictions from different molecular representations that concurrently optimizes excited state energies, synthesizability, and exciton size for the discovery of singlet fission materials. The ucGA allows us to efficiently explore the chemical space spanned by the reFORMED fragment database, which consists of 45,000 cores and 5,000 substituents derived from crystallographic structures assembled in the FORMED repository. Running the ucGA in an exploitative setup performs local optimization on variations of known singlet fission scaffolds, such as acenes. In an explorative mode, hitherto unknown candidates displaying excellent excited state properties for singlet fission are generated. We suggest a class of heteroatom‐rich mesoionic compounds as acceptors for charge‐transfer mediated singlet fission. When included in larger donor‐acceptor systems, these units exhibit localization of the triplet state, favorable diradicaloid character and suitable triplet energies for exciton injection into semiconductor solar cells.

Spin Mixing in Intramolecular Singlet Fission: A First-Principles-Based Quantum Dynamical Study.

We investigate the dynamical interplay between the different triplet-pair spin states that are formed in the intramolecular singlet fission process in a series of pentacene-based dimers covalently bonded to a phenylene linker in ortho, meta, and para positions. Using first-principles calculations and a density matrix quantum dynamical approach we show that the spin dipole-dipole interaction leads to significant population of the quintet spin manifold in these regioisomers when the singlet, triplet and quintet triplet-pair states are quasidegenerate. Furthermore, we also show that the relative arrangement of the pentacene-like moieties has a profound impact on the dynamics of the spin-mixing process, affecting both the relative population of the different spin-states involved in the dynamics and the time scale of the process.

Molecular design of furanoacene-based singlet fission sensitizers combining diradical character and cross-substitution

Singlet fission (SF) suffers from the scarcity of available SF chromophores and sensitizers. Tetracene, pentacene and their derivatives, are two typical model systems for the study of SF photophysical phenomena. Herein, the analogues of polyacenes, furanoacenes and their derivatives, were evaluated as potential SF chromophores and sensitizers through a theoretical study. The primary photostability were evaluated by the frontier molecular orbital energy levels, diradical characters and SF relevant excited state energies according to the type-I and −II photodegradation mechanisms. The cross-substitutions by combining central substitutions with triple bonds and terminal substituents enhance photostability, tune the SF relevant excited states efficiently, and give more appropriate E(T1) to be SF sensitizers. This work helps to give better understanding of the electronic structures and SF capability of furanoacenes.

Ultrafast Time-Domain Spectroscopy Reveals Coherent Vibronic Couplings upon Electronic Excitation in Crystalline Organic Thin Films.

The coherent coupling between electronic excitations and vibrational modes of molecules largely affects the optical and charge transport properties of organic semiconductors and molecular solids. To analyze these couplings by means of ultrafast spectroscopy, highly ordered crystalline films with large domains are particularly suitable because the domains can be addressed individually, hence allowing azimuthal polarization-resolved measurements. Impressive examples of this are highly ordered crystalline thin films of perfluoropentacene (PFP) molecules, which adopt different molecular orientations on different alkali halide substrates. Here, we report polarization-resolved time-domain vibrational spectroscopy with 10 fs time resolution and Raman spectroscopy of crystalline PFP thin films grown on NaF(100) and KCl(100) substrates. Coherent oscillations in the time-resolved spectra reveal vibronic coupling to a high-frequency, 25 fs, in-plane deformation mode that is insensitive to the optical polarization, while the coupling to a lower-frequency, 85 fs, out-of-plane ring bending mode depends significantly on the crystalline and molecular orientation. Comparison with calculated Raman spectra of isolated PFP molecules in vacuo supports this interpretation and indicates a dominant role of solid-state effects in the vibronic properties of these materials. Our results represent a first step toward uncovering the role of anisotropic vibronic couplings for singlet fission processes in crystalline molecular thin films.

Optimization of Ultrafast Singlet Fission in One-Dimensional Rings Towards Unit Efficiency

Singlet fission (SF) is an electronic transition that in the last decade has been under the spotlight for its applications in optoelectronics, from photovoltaics to spintronics. Despite considerable experimental and theoretical advancements, optimizing SF in materials like multichromophoric systems and molecular crystals remains a challenge, due to the complexity of its analysis beyond perturbative methods. Here, we tackle the case of one-dimensional rings, aiming to promote singlet fission and prevent its backreaction. We study ultrafast SF nonperturbatively, by numerically solving a spin-boson model, via exact propagation and tensor network methods. By optimizing over a parameter space relevant to organic molecular materials, we identify two classes of solutions that can take SF efficiency beyond 85% in the nondissipative (coherent) regime, and to 99% when exciton-phonon interactions can be tuned. After discussing the experimental feasibility of the optimized solutions, we conclude by proposing that this approach can be extended to a wider class of optoelectronic optimization problems. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Slowed Singlet Exciton Fission Enhances Triplet Exciton Transport in Select Perylenediimide Crystals.

Singlet fission (SF) materials used in light-harvesting devices must not only efficiently produce spin-triplet excitons but also transport them to an energy acceptor. N,N'-Bis(2-phenylethyl)-3,4,9,10-perylenedicarboximide (EP-PDI) is a promising SF chromophore due to its photostability, large extinction coefficient, and high triplet yield, but the energy transport mechanisms in EP-PDI solids are minimally understood. Herein, we use transient absorption microscopy to directly characterize exciton transport in EP-PDI crystals. We find evidence for singlet-mediated transport in which pairs of triplet excitons undergo triplet fusion (TF), producing spin-singlet excitons that rapidly diffuse. This interchange of singlet and triplet excitons shuttles triplets as far as 205 nm within the first 500 ps after photoexcitation. This enhanced transport comes at a cost, however, as it necessitates favoring triplet recombination and thus requires fine-tuning of SF dynamics to balance triplet yields with triplet transport lengths. Through numerical modeling, we predict tuning the ratio of SF and TF rate constants, kSF/kTF, to between 1.9 and 3.8 allows for an optimized triplet transport length (425-563 nm) with minimal loss (7-10%) in triplet yield. Interestingly, by adjusting the size of EP-PDI crystals, we find that we can subtly tune their crystal structure and thereby alter their SF and TF rates. By slowing SF within small EP-PDI crystals, we are able to boost their triplet transport length by ∼20%. Although counterintuitive, our work suggests slowing SF by introducing moderate structural distortions can be preferential when optimizing triplet exciton transport, provided singlet exciton transport is not significantly hindered.

The Interplay of Strongly and Weakly Exchange-Coupled Triplet Pairs in Intramolecular Singlet Fission.

Singlet fission (SF) and triplet-triplet annihilation upconversion (TTA-UC) nominally enable the interconversion of higher-energy singlet states with two lower-energy triplet states and vice versa, with both processes having envisaged application for enhanced solar power devices. The mechanism of SF/TTA-UC involves a complex array of different multiexcitonic triplet-pair states that are coupled by the exchange interaction to varying extents. In this work a family of bounded intramolecular SF materials, based upon the chromophore 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene, were designed and synthesized. Their SF behavior was characterized using fluorescence lifetime, transient absorption, and magnetic field dependence studies. The capacity for the formation of weakly exchange-coupled triplet pairs, and subsequent spin-evolution, is shown to be strongly dependent upon the combined factors of oligomer size and geometry. By contextualizing these results with the wider SF literature, we present a general schematic model for SF/TTA-UC of greater completeness than portrayed elsewhere.

The Acetylene Bridge in Intramolecular Singlet Fission: A Boon or A Nuisance?

Various analogues of the alkylsilylacetylene group are frequently used as auxiliary groups to enhance the solubility and stability of the acene dimer core, widely used as platforms to investigate intramolecular singlet fission (iSF) mechanisms. However, while in the 2,2'-linked dimers they are primarily auxiliary groups, these are essential fragments of the bridging units in 6,6'/5,5'-linked dimers, the two preferred choices for dimerization. The starkly different iSF dynamics observed in the two variants raise the question of what role the acetylene bridges play. Here, we systematically designed a set of (oligo-)para-phenylene bridged 2,2'-linked pentacene dimers with an additional acetylene fragment in the bridging unit to mimic the structure of 6,6'-linked dimers. Contrasting the results with previously reported analogous 2,2'-linked and 6,6'-linked pentacene dimers reveals that the acetylene bridges contribute to significant conformational freedom. This effect provides a mechanism to promote spin evolution within the triplet pair to achieve free triplets but also offers new parasitic pathways for triplet-pair recombination, revealing that this structural motif can be both a boon and a nuisance. Additionally, our analysis reveals that these bridges directly modify the electronic states, highlighting significant pitfalls of the standard chromophore-bridge-chromophore framework used to design and interpret photophysics of iSF materials.

The Acetylene Bridge in Intramolecular Singlet Fission: A Boon or A Nuisance?

Various analogues of the alkylsilylacetylene group are frequently used as auxiliary groups to enhance the solubility and stability of the acene dimer core, widely used as platforms to investigate intramolecular singlet fission (iSF) mechanisms. However, while in the 2,2’‐linked dimers they are primarily auxiliary groups, these are essential fragments of the bridging units in 6,6’/5,5’‐linked dimers, the two preferred choices for dimerization. The starkly different iSF dynamics observed in the two variants raise the question of what role the acetylene bridges play. Here, we systematically designed a set of (oligo‐)para‐phenylene bridged 2,2’‐linked pentacene dimers with an additional acetylene fragment in the bridging unit to mimic the structure of 6,6’‐linked dimers. Contrasting the results with previously reported analogous 2,2’‐linked and 6,6’‐linked pentacene dimers reveals that the acetylene bridges contribute to significant conformational freedom. This effect provides a mechanism to promote spin evolution within the triplet pair to achieve free triplets but also offers new parasitic pathways for triplet‐pair recombination, revealing that this structural motif can be both a boon and a nuisance. Additionally, our analysis reveals that these bridges directly modify the electronic states, highlighting significant pitfalls of the standard chromophore‐bridge‐chromophore framework used to design and interpret photophysics of iSF materials.

Long-Lived Triplets from Singlet Fission in Pentacene-Decorated Helical Supramolecular Polymers.

Singlet fission (SF), which involves the conversion of a singlet excited state into two triplet excitons, holds great potential to boost the efficiency of photovoltaics. However, losses due to triplet-triplet annihilation hamper the efficient harvesting of SF-generated triplet excitons, which limits an effective implementation in solar energy conversion schemes. A fundamental understanding of the underlying structure-property relationships is thus crucial to define design principles for cutting-edge SF materials, yet it remains elusive. Herein, we harness helical supramolecular polymers decorated with pentacene side groups to elucidate intermolecular SF dynamics in solution and promote the formation of long-lived mobile triplets. By leveraging the hydrogen bonding-driven assembly of benzene-1,3,5-tricarboxamide (BTA) cores into one-dimensional scaffolds, we direct the organization of appended pentacene motifs into long-range ordered helical frameworks. Dynamic interactions between weakly coupled SF pendants mediate singlet conversion within hundreds of picoseconds, affording triplet quantum yields well above 100%. Moreover, analysis of triplet dynamics with a Monte Carlo simulation model reveals that triplet diffusion along the supramolecular fibers is favored over annihilation, resulting in independent triplets exhibiting considerably slow decay on the time scale of tens of microseconds. The molecular packing within the assembly is tuned by subtle changes in monomer design to increase the rate and efficiency of SF while ensuring exceptionally long-lived mobile triplets, allowing to maintain triplet quantum yields exceeding 100% for at least 100 ns. This work opens new opportunities to exploit self-assembled supramolecular polymers as functional templates to achieve long-lived SF-generated triplets.

Strong-Coupling Modification of Singlet-Fission Dynamical Pathways.

We investigate theoretically the influence of strong light-matter coupling on the initial steps of the phototriggered singlet-fission process. In particular we focus on intramolecular singlet fission in a TIPS-pentacene dimer derivative described by a vibronic Hamiltonian including the optically active singlet excited states, doubly excited and charge transfer states, as well as the final triplet-triplet pair state. Quantum dynamics simulations of up to four dimers in the cavity indicate that the modified resonance condition imposed by the cavity strongly quenches the passage through the intermediate charge transfer and double-excitation states, thus largely reducing the triplet-triplet yield in the bare system. Subsequently, we modify the system parameters and construct a model Hamiltonian where the optically active singlet excitation lies below the final triplet-triplet state such that the yield of the bare system becomes insignificant. In this case we find that using the upper polariton as the doorway state for photoexcitation can lead to a much enhanced yield. This pathway is operative provided that the system is sufficiently rigid to prevent vibronic losses from the upper polariton to the dark-states manifold.

Efficient simulation of open quantum systems coupled to a reservoir through multiple channels.

It is challenging to simulate open quantum systems that are connected to a reservoir through multiple channels. For example, vibrations may induce fluctuations in both energy gaps and electronic couplings, which represent two independent channels of system-bath couplings. Systems of this kind are ubiquitous in the processes of excited state radiationless decay. Combined with density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) and matrix product states (MPS) methods, we develop an interaction-picture chain mapping strategy for vibrational reservoirs to simulate the dynamics of these open systems, resulting in time-dependent spatially local system-bath couplings in the chain-mapped Hamiltonian. This transformation causes the entanglement generated by the system-bath interactions to be restricted within a narrow frequency window of vibrational modes, enabling efficient DMRG/MPS dynamical simulations. We demonstrate the utility of this approach by simulating singlet fission dynamics using a generalized spin-boson Hamiltonian with both diagonal and off-diagonal system-bath couplings. This approach generalizes an earlier interaction-picture chain mapping scheme, allowing for efficient and exact simulation of systems with multi-channel system-bath couplings using matrix product states, which may further our understanding of nonlocal exciton-phonon couplings in exciton transport and the non-Condon effect in energy and electron transfer.

Ultrafast Intramolecular Singlet Fission in Homoconjugated Oligomers of Azapentacene with Rigid Connecting Unit

Ultrafast Intramolecular Singlet Fission in Homoconjugated Oligomers of Azapentacene with Rigid Connecting Unit

Monosilicon Derivatives of Phenanthrene and Pyrene as Potential Singlet Fission Materials for High-Performance Solar Cells.

Singlet fission (SF) is a process in which the energy of a singlet-excited molecule is divided into two triplet excitations. This is a special case of an internal conversion that is spin-allowed and extremely fast. Ideally, this process utilizes one photon to produce two electron-hole pairs. In tandem with a layer of singlet fission material, conventional solar cells can achieve improved efficiency by utilizing higher-energy photons. This density functional theory study provides information about additional efficient SF chromophores that were theoretically modeled by functionalizing phenanthrene and pyrene via site-specific monosilicon substitutions. The SF capabilities of the derivatives were evaluated by calculating the SF thermodynamic driving force (ΔESF) and the excited state's molecular planarity. The most promising monosilicon derivatives with SF capabilities are 3-silaphenanthrene and 1-silapyrene for each family, respectively. All phenanthrene and pyrene monosilicon derivatives are strong closed-shell species, because their multiple diradical characteristics are close to zero. Based on these results, 3-silaphenanthrene and 1-silapyrene were selected for electron excitation analysis, which further demonstrated that the monosilicon functionalization of phenanthrene and pyrene led to a transfer from local excitation characters to hybridized local and charge-transfer characters of the excited states, resulting in a significant change from endoergic to exoergic in the SF chromophores.

Inverse Design of Singlet-Fission Materials with Uncertainty-Controlled Genetic Optimization.

Singlet fission has shown potential for boosting the efficiency of solar cells, but the scarcity of suitable molecular materials hinders its implementation. We introduce an uncertainty-controlled genetic algorithm (ucGA) based on ensemble machine learning predictions from different molecular representations that concurrently optimizes excited state energies, synthesizability, and exciton size for the discovery of singlet fission materials. The ucGA allows us to efficiently explore the chemical space spanned by the reFORMED fragment database, which consists of 45,000 cores and 5,000 substituents derived from crystallographic structures assembled in the FORMED repository. Running the ucGA in an exploitative setup performs local optimization on variations of known singlet fission scaffolds, such as acenes. In an explorative mode, hitherto unknown candidates displaying excellent excited state properties for singlet fission are generated. We suggest a class of heteroatom-rich mesoionic compounds as acceptors for charge-transfer mediated singlet fission. When included in larger donor-acceptor systems, these units exhibit localization of the triplet state, favorable diradicaloid character and suitable triplet energies for exciton injection into semiconductor solar cells.

Ultrafast and Coherent Dynamics in a Solvent Switchable "Pink Box" Perylene Diimide Dimer.

Perylene diimide (PDI) dimers and higher aggregates are key components in organic molecular photonics and photovoltaic devices, supporting singlet fission and symmetry breaking charge separation. Detailed understanding of their excited states is thus important. This has proven challenging because interchromophoric coupling is a strong function of dimer architecture. Recently, a macrocyclic PDI dimer was reported in which excitonic coupling could be turned on and off simply by changing the solvent. This presents a useful case where coupling is modified without synthetic changes to tune supramolecular structure. Here we present a detailed study of solvent dependent excited state dynamics in this dimer by means of coherent multidimensional spectroscopy. Spectral analysis resolves the different coupling strengths, which are consistent with solvent dependent changes in dimer conformation. The strongly coupled conformer forms an excimer within 300 fs. The low-frequency Raman active modes recovered from two-dimensional electronic spectra reveal frequencies characteristic of exciton coupling. These are assigned to modes modulating the coupling from the corresponding DFT calculations. Further analysis reveals a time dependent frequency during excimer formation. Analysis of two-dimensional "beatmaps" reveals features in the coupled dimer which are not predicted by the displaced harmonic oscillator model and are assigned to vibronic coupling.

Configuration Interaction in Frontier Molecular Orbital Basis for Screening the Spin-Correlated, Spatially Separated Triplet Pair State 1(T···T) Formation.

In the theoretical screening of Singlet Fission rates in molecular aggregates, often the frontier molecular orbital model for dimers is employed. However, the dimer approach fails to account for recent experimental findings that suggest singlet fission progresses through a further intermediate state featuring two spatially separated, spin-correlated triplets, specifically a 1(T···T) state. We address this limitation by generalizing the often used frontier molecular orbital model for singlet fission by incorporation of both separated Charge Transfer (C···T) and 1(T···T) states as well as mixed triplet-charge transfer states, delivering analytic expressions for the diabatic matrix elements. Applying the methodology to the perylene diimide trimer, we examine the packing dependence of competing formation pathways of the 1(T···T) state by evaluation of diabatic matrix elements.

High Efficiency Non‐Doped Organic Light Emitting Diodes Based on Pure Organic Room Temperature Phosphorescence by High‐Lying Singlet Exciton Fission

AbstractHeavy‐metal‐free pure organic room temperature phosphorescence (ORTP) holds great potential in the field of organic optoelectronic devices owing to low economic cost, simple preparation techniques, and high exciton utilization. However, it is still filled with challenges in realizing high efficiency organic light‐emitting diodes (OLEDs) and exploring the internal physical mechanism based on these ORTP molecules. Here, a high‐performance OLED induced by an unexpected interfacial spin‐mixing process between the ORTP molecule and interlayers is demonstrated, and the high efficiency electroluminescence (EL) mechanism is studied through magneto–electroluminescence (MEL) and magneto–photoluminescence (MPL) measurements. The steady‐state and transient PL properties imply that the interfacial effect is related to a high‐lying singlet fission (HLSF) process in the ORTP molecule itself. Further, the HLSF process and the corresponding energy level position are confirmed by the incident wavelength‐ and temperature‐dependent PL spectra and the magnetic‐field‐dependent transient PL. Finally, by optimizing the interfacial material adjacent to the emissive layer to utilize this interfacial spin mixing effect, a high‐efficiency non‐doped ORTP‐OLED with external quantum efficiency of 16% and CIE coordinates of (0.27, 0.49) is developed. The proposed mechanism during the EL process will give insight to produce more efficient OLEDs based on ORTP materials in the future.

Excitonic Approach for Nonadiabatic Dynamics: Extending Beyond the Frenkel Exciton Model.

We report the formulation and implementation of an extended Frenkel exciton model (EFEM) designed for simulating the dynamics of multichromophoric systems, taking into account the possible presence of interchromophore charge transfer states, as well as other states in which two chromophores are simultaneously excited. Our approach involves constructing a Hamiltonian based on calculations performed on monomers and selected dimers within the multichromophoric aggregate. Nonadiabatic molecular dynamics is addressed using a surface hopping approach, while the electronic wave functions and energies required for constructing the EFEM are computed utilizing the semiempirical floating occupation molecular orbitals-configuration interaction (FOMO-CI) electronic structure method. To validate our approach, we simulate the singlet fission process in a trimer of 2,5-bis(fluorene-9-ylidene)-2,5-dihydrothiophene (ThBF) molecules, embedded in their crystal environment, comparing the results of the EFEM to the standard "supermolecule" approach.

Pressure-Promoted Triplet-Pair Separation in Singlet-Fission TIPS-Pentacene Nanofilms Revealed by Ultrafast Spectroscopy.

Singlet fission (SF), as an effective way to break through the Shockley-Queisser limit, can dramatically improve energy conversion efficiency in solar cell areas. The formation, separation, and relaxation of triplet-pair excitons directly affect the triplet yield, especially triplet-pair separation; thus, how to enhance the triplet-pair separation rate becomes one of the key points to improve SF efficiency; the decay mechanism where the singlet state is converted into two triplet states is significant for the study of the SF mechanism. Herein, we employ ultrafast transient absorption spectroscopy to study the singlet-fission process of nano-amorphous 6, 13-bis(triisopropylsilylethynyl)-Pentacene (TIPS-pentacene) films in a diamond anvil cell (DAC). A kinetics model related to the structural geometric details, as well as an evaluation of the pressure manipulation impacts, is demonstrated based on the experimental results. The results indicate that pressure manipulation enhanced the triplet-pair separation rates of SF-based materials according to their structural micro-environmental improvement when compressed in DAC, while the triplet-exciton transportation lifetime is prolonged. This work shows that pressure may effectively optimize the structural disorder of SF materials, which were found to improve triplet-pair separation efficiency and potentially offer an effective way to further improve SF efficiency.