Single Virus Fusion Research Articles

Adaptation of single virus fusion assay to study fusion of dengue virus-like particles with model lipid membranes

Adaptation of single virus fusion assay to study fusion of dengue virus-like particles with model lipid membranes

Single-Virus Fusion Measurements Reveal Multiple Mechanistically Equivalent Pathways for SARS-CoV-2 Entry.

Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) binds to cell surface receptors and is activated for membrane fusion and cell entry via proteolytic cleavage. Phenomenological data have shown that SARS-CoV-2 can be activated for entry at either the cell surface or in endosomes, but the relative roles in different cell types and mechanisms of entry have been debated. Here, we used single-virus fusion experiments and exogenously controlled proteases to probe activation directly. We found that plasma membrane and an appropriate protease are sufficient to support SARS-CoV-2 pseudovirus fusion. Furthermore, fusion kinetics of SARS-CoV-2 pseudoviruses are indistinguishable no matter which of a broad range of proteases is used to activate the virus. This suggests that the fusion mechanism is insensitive to protease identity or even whether activation occurs before or after receptor binding. These data support a model for opportunistic fusion by SARS-CoV-2 in which the subcellular location of entry likely depends on the differential activity of airway, cellsurface, and endosomal proteases, but all support infection. Inhibition of any single host protease may thus reduce infection in some cells but may be less clinically robust. IMPORTANCE SARS-CoV-2 can use multiple pathways to infect cells, as demonstrated recently when new viral variants switched dominant infection pathways. Here, we used single-virus fusion experiments together with biochemical reconstitution to show that these multiple pathways coexist simultaneously and specifically that the virus can be activated by different proteases in different cellular compartments with mechanistically identical effects. The consequences of this are that the virus is evolutionarily plastic and that therapies targeting viral entry should address multiple pathways at once to achieve optimal clinical effects.

Influenza Virus Membrane Fusion Is Promoted by the Endosome-Resident Phospholipid Bis(monoacylglycero)phosphate.

The phospholipid bis(monoacylglycero)phosphate (BMP) is enriched in late endosomal and endolysosomal membranes and is believed to be involved in membrane deformation and generation of intralumenal vesicles within late endosomes. Previous studies have demonstrated that BMP promotes membrane fusion of several enveloped viruses, but a limited effect has been found on influenza virus. Here, we report the use of single-virus fusion assays to dissect BMP's effect on influenza virus fusion in greater depth. In agreement with prior reports, we found that hemifusion kinetics and efficiency were unaffected by the addition of 10-20 mol % BMP to the target membrane. However, using an assay for fusion pore formation and genome exposure, we found full fusion efficiency to be substantially enhanced by the addition of 10-20 mol % BMP to the target membrane, while the kinetics remained unaffected. By comparing BMP to other negatively charged phospholipids, we found the effect on fusion efficiency mainly attributable to headgroup charge, although we also hypothesize a role for BMP's unusual chemical structure. Our results suggest that BMP function as a permissive factor for a wider range of viruses than previously reported. We hypothesize that BMP may be a general cofactor for endosomal entry of enveloped viruses.

Recent Developments in Single-Virus Fusion Assay.

Viral infection is a global health hazard. A crucial step in the infection cycle of enveloped viruses is the fusion of viral and host cellular membranes, which permits the transfer of the viral genome to the host cells. Membrane fusion is a ubiquitous process involved in sperm-egg fusion, exocytosis, vesicular trafficking, and viral entry to host cells. While different protein machineries catalyze the diverse fusion processes, the essential step, i.e., merging of two lipid bilayers against a kinetic energy barrier, is the same. Therefore, viral fusion machineries/pathways are not only the sites for antiviral drug development but also serve as model fusogens. Ensemble-based spectroscopic approaches or bulk fusion assays have yielded valuable insights regarding the fusion processes. However, due to the stochastic nature of the fusion events, ensemble-based assays do not permit synchronization of all the fusion events, and the molecular steps leading to fusion pore opening cannot be resolved entirely and correlated with the structural changes in viral fusion proteins. Several single-virus fusion assays have been developed to circumvent these issues. The review describes the recent advancements in single-virus/particle fusion assays using the Influenza virus as a paradigm.

Single-virus content-mixing assay reveals cholesterol-enhanced influenza membrane fusion efficiency

To infect a cell, enveloped viruses must first undergo membrane fusion, which proceeds through a hemifusion intermediate, followed by the formation of a fusion pore through which the viral genome is transferred to a target cell. Single-virus fusion studies to elucidate the dynamics of content mixing typically require extensive fluorescent labeling of viral contents. The labeling process must be optimized depending on the virus identity and strain and can potentially be perturbative to viral fusion behavior. Here, we introduce a single-virus assay in which content-labeled vesicles are bound to unlabeled influenza A virus (IAV) to eliminate the problematic step of content-labeling virions. We use fluorescence microscopy to observe individual, pH-triggered content mixing and content-loss events between IAV and target vesicles of varying cholesterol compositions. We show that target membrane cholesterol increases the efficiency of IAV content mixing and decreases the fraction of content-mixing events that result in content loss. These results are consistent with previous findings that cholesterol stabilizes pore formation in IAV entry and limits leakage after pore formation. We also show that content loss due to hemagglutinin fusion peptide engagement with the target membrane is independent of composition. This approach is a promising strategy for studying the single-virus content-mixing kinetics of other enveloped viruses.

Precise Triggering and Chemical Control of Single-Virus Fusion within Endosomes.

Many enveloped viruses infect cells within endocytic compartments. The pH drop that accompanies endosomal maturation, often in conjunction with proteolysis, triggers viral proteins to insert into the endosomal membrane and drive fusion. Fusion dynamics have been studied by tracking viruses within living cells, which limits the precision with which fusion can be synchronized and controlled, and reconstituting viral fusion to synthetic membranes, which introduces nonphysiological membrane curvature and composition. To overcome these limitations, we report chemically controllable triggering of single-virus fusion within endosomes. We isolated influenza (A/Aichi/68; H3N2) virus:endosome conjugates from cells, immobilized them in a microfluidic flow cell, and rapidly and controllably triggered fusion. Observed lipid-mixing kinetics were surprisingly similar to those of influenza virus fusion with model membranes of opposite curvature: 80% of single-virus events had indistinguishable kinetics. This result suggests that endosomal membrane curvature is not a key permissive feature for viral entry, at least lipid mixing. The assay preserved endosomal membrane asymmetry and protein composition, providing a platform to test how cellular restriction factors and altered endosomal trafficking affect viral membrane fusion.IMPORTANCE Many enveloped viruses infect cells via fusion to endosomes, but controlling this process within living cells has been challenging. We studied the fusion of influenza virus virions to endosomes in a chemically controllable manner. Extracting virus:endosome conjugates from cells and exogenously triggering fusion permits precise study of virus:endosome fusion kinetics. Surprisingly, endosomal curvature does not grossly alter fusion kinetics, although membrane deformability does. This supports a model for influenza virus entry where cells restrict or permit membrane fusion by changing deformability, for instance, using interferon-induced proteins.

Influenza hemagglutinin drives viral entry via two sequential intramembrane mechanisms

Enveloped viruses enter cells via a process of membrane fusion between the viral envelope and a cellular membrane. For influenza virus, mutational data have shown that the membrane-inserted portions of the hemagglutinin protein play a critical role in achieving fusion. In contrast to the relatively well-understood ectodomain, a predictive mechanistic understanding of the intramembrane mechanisms by which influenza hemagglutinin drives fusion has been elusive. We used molecular dynamics simulations of fusion between a full-length hemagglutinin proteoliposome and a lipid bilayer to analyze these mechanisms. In our simulations, hemagglutinin first acts within the membrane to increase lipid tail protrusion and promote stalk formation and then acts to engage the distal leaflets of each membrane and promote stalk widening, curvature, and eventual fusion. These two sequential mechanisms, one occurring before stalk formation and one after, are consistent with our experimental measurements of single-virus fusion kinetics to liposomes of different sizes. The resulting model also helps explain and integrate previous mutational and biophysical data, particularly the mutational sensitivity of the fusion peptide N terminus and the length sensitivity of the transmembrane domain. We hypothesize that entry by other enveloped viruses may also use sequential processes of acyl tail exposure, followed by membrane curvature and distal leaflet engagement.

Single-cell glycolytic activity regulates membrane tension and HIV-1 fusion.

There has been resurgence in determining the role of host metabolism in viral infection yet deciphering how the metabolic state of single cells affects viral entry and fusion remains unknown. Here, we have developed a novel assay multiplexing genetically-encoded biosensors with single virus tracking (SVT) to evaluate the influence of global metabolic processes on the success rate of virus entry in single cells. We found that cells with a lower ATP:ADP ratio prior to virus addition were less permissive to virus fusion and infection. These results indicated a relationship between host metabolic state and the likelihood for virus-cell fusion to occur. SVT revealed that HIV-1 virions were arrested at hemifusion in glycolytically-inactive cells. Interestingly, cells acutely treated with glycolysis inhibitor 2-deoxyglucose (2-DG) become resistant to virus infection and also display less surface membrane cholesterol. Addition of cholesterol in these in glycolytically-inactive cells rescued the virus entry block at hemifusion and enabled completion of HIV-1 fusion. Further investigation with FRET-based membrane tension and membrane order reporters revealed a link between host cell glycolytic activity and host membrane order and tension. Indeed, cells treated with 2-DG possessed lower plasma membrane lipid order and higher tension values, respectively. Our novel imaging approach that combines lifetime imaging (FLIM) and SVT revealed not only changes in plasma membrane tension at the point of viral fusion, but also that HIV is less likely to enter cells at areas of higher membrane tension. We therefore have identified a connection between host cell glycolytic activity and membrane tension that influences HIV-1 fusion in real-time at the single-virus fusion level in live cells.

Differentiating Antibody Neutralisation Mechanisms using a Single Virus-Assay

Neutralizing antibodies to influenza mostly target the viral envelope glycoprotein hemagglutinin, critical for viral entry and fusion. Antigens recognizing the globular head of hemagglutinin are thought to inhibit virus attachment and antigens against the stalk region are thought to inhibit fusion. We report the development of a microfluidic single-virus fusion assay that utilizes both reconstituted receptors and DNA-lipid tethering to clearly differentiate the antibody inhibition of virus attachment versus fusion. As expected, antibodies to the receptor-binding domain inhibited attachment, but, antibodies against the fusion stalk could inhibit attachment and fusion. The relative potencies of neutralizing attachment versus fusion are trivially predictable from the antibody binding site and, combined with analysis of fusion kinetics under antibody inhibition, reveals further insight into the mechanism of neutralization by different antibodies. The information gained from this assay can be used to help guide antibody and vaccine optimization strategies.

Membranes with Decreased Deformability to Study the Kinetics of Fusion Intermediates

While the initial protein activation steps involved in influenza membrane fusion have been relatively well resolved, the subsequent lipid rearrangements are much more challenging to study. This is because the formation of lipid intermediates is faster than protein activation and thus masked in kinetic measurements of intact virus. To unmask these intermediates, we have developed methods that utilize target membranes with decreased deformability. By using supported lipid bilayers on silica nanoparticles of a defined diameter we are able to alter the deformability of the target membrane without changing its lipid composition. In conjunction with single-virus fusion kinetics, this allows us to examine the effect of membrane deformability on the kinetics of influenza membrane fusion. Our results show that decreasing target membrane deformability does indeed slow lipid mixing between virus and target. Further extensions to this platform then allow stepwise dissection of how membrane mechanical properties affect influenza membrane fusion.

Detecting and Controlling Dye Effects in Single-Virus Fusion Experiments

Fluorescent dye-dequenching assays provide a powerful and versatile means to monitor membrane fusion events. They have been used in bulk assays, for measuring single events in live cells, and for detailed analysis of fusion kinetics for liposomal, viral, and cellular fusion processes; however, the dyes used also have the potential to perturb membrane fusion. Here, using single-virus measurements of influenza membrane fusion, we show that fluorescent membrane probes can alter both the efficiency and the kinetics of lipid mixing in a dye- and illumination-dependent manner. R18, a dye that is commonly used to monitor lipid mixing between membranes, is particularly prone to these effects, whereas Texas Red is somewhat less sensitive. R18 further undergoes photoconjugation to viral proteins in an illumination-dependent manner that correlates with its inactivation of viral fusion. These results demonstrate how fluorescent probes can perturb measurements of biological activity and provide both data and a method for determining minimally perturbative measurement conditions.

Detecting and Controlling Dye and Illumination Effects in Single-Virus Fusion Experiments

Fluorescent dyes are widely used to visualize biological targets, as well as to monitor biological activity, such as viral entry. While powerful tools for insight, such probes also have the potential to perturb the process under study in non-obvious ways. Here, we show how dyes used to membrane fusion in viral entry can alter both the kinetics and the efficiency of viral membrane fusion in a fashion that depends on illumination intensity and dye concentration. We demonstrate this using single-virus fusion measurements. R18, a dye that is commonly used to monitor lipid mixing between membranes, is particularly prone to these effects, while Texas Red is somewhat less sensitive. These results demonstrate how fluorescent probes can perturb measurements of biological activity and provide both data and a method for assessing determining minimally perturbative measurement conditions.

PH Dependence of Zika Membrane Fusion Kinetics Reveals an Off-Pathway State

The recent spread of Zika virus stimulated extensive research on its structure, pathogenesis, and immunology, but mechanistic study of entry has lagged behind, in part due to the lack of a defined reconstituted system. Here, we report Zika membrane fusion measured using a platform that bypasses these barriers, enabling observation of single-virus fusion kinetics without receptor reconstitution. Surprisingly, target membrane binding and low pH are sufficient to trigger viral hemifusion to liposomes containing only neutral lipids. Second, although the extent of hemifusion strongly depends on pH, hemifusion rates are relatively insensitive to pH. Kinetic analysis shows that an off-pathway state is required to capture this pH-dependence and suggests this may be related to viral inactivation. Our surrogate-receptor approach thus yields new understanding of flaviviral entry mechanisms and should be applicable to many emerging viruses.

Live-Cell Imaging of Early Steps of Single HIV-1 Infection.

Live-cell imaging of single HIV-1 entry offers a unique opportunity to delineate the spatio-temporal regulation of infection. Novel virus labeling and imaging approaches enable the visualization of key steps of HIV-1 entry leading to nuclear import, integration into the host genome, and viral protein expression. Here, we discuss single virus imaging strategies, focusing on live-cell imaging of single virus fusion and productive uncoating that culminates in HIV-1 infection.

Novel Labeling Strategy for Automated Detection of Single Virus Fusion and Assessment of HIV-1 Protease Activity in Single Virions

A common approach to visualizing single-virus fusion utilizes a fluorescently labeled Gag that, upon processing by HIV-1 viral protease, yields fluid-phase fluorescent proteins trapped within the virus particle. Upon loss of viral membrane integrity this content marker rapidly diffuses out of the particle, and, in combination with a viral core fiducial, such as a fluorescently tagged Vpr, can be used to reliably report single-particle fusion. But, this labeling approach is limited by an uncontrolled incorporation of the two markers, resulting in an excess of single-labeled particles and lack of correlation between intensities of the content and core markers. Here, we introduce a novel bi-functional mCherry-2xCL-YFP-Vpr label that encodes both the content (fluid-phase mCherry) and fiducial (core-associated YFP-Vpr) markers on a single construct separated by a 2xCL linker that contains a tandem of cleavage sites targeted by the viral protease. We show that the bi-functional label is efficiently incorporated and processed in single-virus particles and can be used to reliably report single-virus fusion in imaging assays. Further, by taking advantage of the nearly perfect colocalization and correlated intensities of content and fiducial markers in single-particles we are able to automate fusion event detection in both fixed and live cells, significantly increasing assay throughput. Finally, we show that the loss of Forster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) signal between YFP and mCherry is a good predictor of viral protease activity, and that the maturation status of single virions can be inferred by both FRET efficiency and YFP/mCherry signal ratio. Together, these results demonstrate that the new labeling strategy offers a number of advantages compared to the previous approaches, including reading out single-virus maturation status and increasing reliability and throughput of single-virus fusion imaging assays.

An improved labeling strategy enables automated detection of single-virus fusion and assessment of HIV-1 protease activity in single virions

Enveloped viruses transfer their genomes into host cells by fusing their membrane to that of the cell. To visualize single-virus fusion in living cells, researchers take advantage of the proteolytic maturation of HIV, type 1 (HIV-1), which can generate free fluorescent proteins within the viral particle. Co-labeling viruses with a content marker and a fluorescently tagged Vpr (a viral core protein) enables detection of single-virus fusions, but a major limitation of this approach is that not all viral particles incorporate both markers. Here we designed a labeling strategy based on the bifunctional mCherry-2xCL-YFP-Vpr construct, in which 2xCL denotes a tandem cleavage site for the viral protease. This bifunctional marker was efficiently cleaved during virus maturation, producing free mCherry and the core-associated YFP-Vpr. A nearly perfect colocalization of these two markers in virions and their fixed 1:1 ratio enabled automated detection of single-particle fusion in both fixed and live cells based on loss of the mCherry signal. Furthermore, a drop in FRET efficiency between YFP and mCherry because of cleavage of the bifunctional marker, which manifested as a marked shift in the normalized YFP/mCherry fluorescence ratio, reliably predicted viral protease activity in single virions. This feature could discriminate between the particles containing free mCherry, and therefore likely representing mature viruses, and immature particles whose fusion cannot be detected. In summary, our new labeling strategy offers several advantages compared with previous approaches, including increased reliability and throughput of detection of viral fusion. We anticipate that our method will have significant utility for studying viral fusion and maturation.

Disentangling Viral Membrane Fusion from Receptor Binding Using Synthetic DNA-Lipid Conjugates

Enveloped viruses must bind to a receptor on the host membrane to initiate infection. Membrane fusion is subsequently initiated by a conformational change in the viral fusion protein, triggered by receptor binding, an environmental change, or both. Here, we present a strategy to disentangle the two processes of receptor binding and fusion using synthetic DNA-lipid conjugates to bind enveloped viruses to target membranes in the absence of receptor. This permits direct testing of whether receptor engagement affects the fusion mechanism as well as a comparison of fusion behavior across viruses with different receptor binding specificities. We demonstrate this approach by binding X-31 influenza virus to target vesicles and measuring the rates of individual pH-triggered lipid mixing events using fluorescence microscopy. Influenza lipid mixing kinetics are found to be independent of receptor binding, supporting the common yet previously unproven assumption that receptor binding does not produce any clustering or spatial rearrangement of viral hemagglutinin, which affects the rate-limiting step of pH-triggered fusion. This DNA-lipid tethering strategy should also allow the study of viruses where challenging receptor reconstitution has previously prevented single-virus fusion experiments.

Click labeling of unnatural sugars metabolically incorporated into viral envelope glycoproteins enables visualization of single particle fusion

Enveloped viruses infect target cells by fusing their membrane with cellular membrane through a process that is mediated by specialized viral glycoproteins. The inefficient and highly asynchronous nature of viral fusion complicates studies of virus entry on a population level. Single virus imaging in living cells has become an important tool for delineating the entry pathways and for mechanistic studies of viral fusion. We have previously demonstrated that incorporation of fluorescent labels into the viral membrane and trapping fluorescent proteins in the virus interior enables the visualization of single virus fusion in living cells. Here, we implement a new approach to non-invasively label the viral membrane glycoproteins through metabolic incorporation of unnatural sugars followed by click-reaction with organic fluorescent dyes. This approach allows for efficient labeling of diverse viral fusion glycoproteins on the surface of HIV pseudoviruses. Incorporation of a content marker into surface-labeled viral particles enables sensitive detection of single virus fusion with live cells.

Visualization of Content Release from Cell Surface-Attached Single HIV-1 Particles Carrying an Extra-Viral Fluorescent pH-Sensor.

HIV-1 fusion leading to productive entry has long been thought to occur at the plasma membrane. However, our previous single virus imaging data imply that, after Env engagement of CD4 and coreceptors at the cell surface, the virus enters into and fuses with intracellular compartments. We were unable to reliably detect viral fusion at the plasma membrane. Here, we implement a novel virus labeling strategy that biases towards detection of virus fusion that occurs in a pH-neutral environment—at the plasma membrane or, possibly, in early pH-neutral vesicles. Virus particles are co-labeled with an intra-viral content marker, which is released upon fusion, and an extra-viral pH sensor consisting of ecliptic pHluorin fused to the transmembrane domain of ICAM-1. This sensor fully quenches upon virus trafficking to a mildly acidic compartment, thus precluding subsequent detection of viral content release. As an interesting secondary observation, the incorporation of the pH-sensor revealed that HIV-1 particles occasionally shuttle between neutral and acidic compartments in target cells expressing CD4, suggesting a small fraction of viral particles is recycled to the plasma membrane and re-internalized. By imaging viruses bound to living cells, we found that HIV-1 content release in neutral-pH environment was a rare event (~0.4% particles). Surprisingly, viral content release was not significantly reduced by fusion inhibitors, implying that content release was due to spontaneous formation of viral membrane defects occurring at the cell surface. We did not measure a significant occurrence of HIV-1 fusion at neutral pH above this defect-mediated background loss of content, suggesting that the pH sensor may destabilize the membrane of the HIV-1 pseudovirus and, thus, preclude reliable detection of single virus fusion events at neutral pH.

Fusion of Mature HIV-1 Particles Leads to Complete Release of a Gag-GFP-Based Content Marker and Raises the Intraviral pH

By imaging the release of a GFP-based viral content marker produced upon virus maturation, we have previously found that HIV-1 fuses with endosomes. In contrast, fusion at the cell surface did not progress beyond a lipid mixing stage (hemifusion). However, recent evidence suggesting that free GFP can be trapped within the mature HIV-1 capsid raises concerns that this content marker may not be released immediately after the formation of a fusion pore. To determine whether a significant portion of GFP is trapped in the mature capsid, we first permeabilized the viral membrane with saponin. The overwhelming majority of pseudoviruses fully released GFP while the remaining particles exhibited partial loss or no loss of content. The extent of GFP release correlated with HIV-1 maturation, implying that incomplete Gag processing, but not GFP entrapment by mature capsids, causes partial content release. Next, we designed a complementary assay for visualizing pore formation by monitoring the intraviral pH with an additional pH-sensitive fluorescent marker. The loss of GFP through saponin-mediated pores was associated with a concomitant increase in the intraviral pH due to equilibration with the pH of an external buffer. We next imaged single HIV-cell fusion and found that these events were manifested in a highly correlated loss of content and increase in the intraviral pH, as it equilibrated with the cytosolic pH. Fused or saponin-permeabilized pseudoviruses that partially lost GFP did not release the remaining content marker under conditions expected to promote the capsid dissociation. We were thus unable to detect significant entrapment of GFP by the mature HIV-1 capsid. Together, our results validate the use of the GFP-based content marker for imaging single virus fusion and inferring the sites of HIV-1 entry.