Single-antigen Flow Beads Assay Research Articles

Monoclonal secondary reagents do not outperform polyclonal secondary reagents for detection of anti-HLA IgG using single antigen flow beads assays.

Luminex single antigen flow beads (SAFB) assays are used to monitor anti-HLA antibodies, which are associated with allograft loss. The primary antibody binding level is evaluated by the mean fluorescence intensity (MFI) provided by the tracing secondary antibody. The aim of this study was to compare the MFI obtained with two secondary antibodies and to evaluate their sensitivity to detect newly developed de novo anti-HLA donor-specific antibodies (dnDSA). A total of 23 and 46 different sera from 20 HLA-sensitized kidney transplant recipients were tested with class I and II SAFB, respectively, as well as sera from 17 patients with dnDSA. The conventional secondary antibody (IgHPolyFab) was the phycoerythrin (PE)-conjugated goat anti-human IgG constant heavy chain (HC)-binding polyclonal-F(ab')2. The alternate secondary antibody was a PE-conjugated anti-human IgG Fc-specific monoclonal IgG (FcMonoIgG). MFI of negative control sera were drastically lower with the FcMonoIgG than with IgHPolyFab, requesting a unique positivity threshold to be defined for each secondary antibody. MFI obtained with positive control sera were also lower with FcMonoIgG. In kidney transplant recipient's sera, the number of antigenic specificities detected by each secondary antibody was comparable, for dnDSA as well as for nonDSA. In conclusion, decision thresholds must be refined when changing the secondary tracing reagent in SAFB assays. FcMonoIgG did not demonstrate any superiority over IgHPolyFab for monitoring HLA antibodies.

Prevalence, distribution and amplitude of the complement interference phenomenon in single antigen flow beads assays.

HLA antibody detection with single antigen flow beads (SAFB) assays is impaired by complement interference whose frequency, predictability and distribution among HLA antigens have not been analyzed in large cohorts. We compared in two patients' cohorts the routine follow-up SAFB profiles obtained in class I (n = 129) and class II (n = 85) with and without ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA)-treatment. The presence of complement interference was defined according to the reproducibility of the SAFB assays evaluated with our class I and II routine positive control sera. Interference occurred in 29.5% and 45.9% of patients in class I and II, respectively. In the untreated condition, at serum level, neither the number of positive beads, the highest bead mean fluorescence intensity (MFI) nor MFI at bead level, satisfactorily predicted interference. HLA-C were the least affected among class I beads. HLA-DQ beads were the most affected in class II. At least one antibody specificity was falsely negative without EDTA for about 3% of sera in class I and 9% in class II. EDTA-treatment did not significantly modify the low-MFI strengths (500-3000 range). This study emphasizes the high frequency of complement interference and the importance and advantages of systematically pretreating sera with EDTA before performing SAFB assays.

Reassessment of T Lymphocytes Crossmatches Results Prediction With Luminex Class I Single Antigen Flow Beads Assay.

In virtual crossmatch (XM) strategies, a correct anticipation of XM results is required for appropriately allocating organs. We reassessed the ability to predict T lymphocyte flow cytometry and complement dependent cytotoxicity XM results with the mean fluorescence intensity (MFI) in Luminex class I single antigen flow beads (SAFB) assay, after correction of complement interference and exclusion of antidenatured HLA antibodies. Among 432 XM with T lymphocytes (T-XM), 407 were analyzed after exclusion of antidenatured HLA antibodies. Only ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid-treated serum MFI was considered. Only 1 cellular target HLA antigen for the serum was expressed in 238 cases, 209 and 29 being heterozygous and homozygous for this antigen, respectively. For the remaining 169 cases, at least 2 antigens were recognized. Single antigen flow bead MFI thresholds allowing XM positivity to be predicted were calculated with receiver operating characteristic curves. T-XM results were tightly associated with SAFB MFI values. Anti-HLA-A and anti-HLA-B antibodies behaved similarly. Prediction and sensitivity SAFB MFI thresholds were determined, respectively, assessing the highest sensitivity/specificity ratio and at least 95% sensitivity for predicting T-XM positivity. Both were slightly lower for HLA-B than for HLA-A, whereas anti-HLA-Cw antibodies induced random XM results. Both thresholds were only slightly diminished for homozygous and for multiple HLA targets, considering the immunodominant, but not the sum, of antibodies MFI. Antibodies against HLA-A, -B, or -Cw behave differently. A homozygous HLA target does not trigger a twice higher XM positivity. Multiple antibodies are better evaluated through the immunodominant DSA MFI than through the sum of DSA MFI.

Evaluation of the iBeads assay as a tool for identifying class I HLA antibodies

In addition to antibodies targeting native class I human leukocyte antigens (HLA), the single antigen flow beads assay (SAFB) detects antibodies recognizing denatured forms (anti-dHLA). Acid treated SAFB and the modified SAFB reagent named iBeads are expected to distinguish anti-native (anti-nHLA) from anti-dHLA. Sera from 280 class I HLA-sensitized SAFB-positive kidney transplant candidates were retested with acid-treated SAFB and iBeads. Concordance between SAFB and iBeads, taking into account acid-treatment results, was described at global and locus levels. T-lymphocyte flow cytometry crossmatches (FCXM) were performed to identify an accurate iBeads MFI threshold allowing predicting FCXM results. Concordance between acid-treatment and iBeads assays was observed for 86.9% of alleles. The iBeads MFI were lower than for classical SAFB, especially for HLA-B and C alleles. Anti-dHLA identified with acid-treated SAFB were more frequently negative with iBeads for HLA-B and -C alleles. An iBeads MFI threshold of 1000 allowed predicting positive FCXM with 95.6% sensitivity, 91.6% negative predictive value and 0.08 negative likelihood ratio. The iBeads assay still has limitations, but might represent an invaluable alternative to SAFB for virtual crossmatch strategies in organ transplant allocation programs.

Clinical impact of preformed donor-specific denatured class I HLA antibodies after kidney transplantation.

Class I single-antigen flow beads (SAFB) carry native and denatured human leukocyte antigen (HLA) molecules. Using a cohort of 179 class I HLA-sensitized kidney recipients, we described incidence and clinical relevance of preformed denatured HLA donor-specific antibodies (DSA) using two different assays: an acid-treated SAFB assay (anti-dHLA DSA) and the iBeads assays (SAFB+/iBeads- DSA). Eighty-five class I DSA were found in 67 patients (median mean fluorescence intensity [MFI] of 1729 [range 520-13 882]). Anti-dHLA and SAFB+/iBeads- DSA represented 11% and 18% of class I DSA and were mainly low MFI DSA (500-1000 MFI). Concordance between these two assays was good (90%). None of the patients with only class I anti-dHLA DSA or only SAFB+/iBeads- DSA developed acute clinical antibody-mediated rejection in the first-year post-transplantation, and their five-yr death-censored graft survival was similar to that of patients without DSA. Moreover, all these patients displayed a negative current T-cell flow cytometry cross-match. Therefore, both anti-dHLA DSA and SAFB+/iBeads- DSA appear irrelevant, which could explain the good outcome observed in some patients with preformed class I DSA.

Denatured Class I Human Leukocyte Antigen Antibodies in Sensitized Kidney Recipients

Single antigen flow beads assays may overestimate sensitization because of the detection of supposedly irrelevant antibodies recognizing denatured class I human leukocyte antigens (HLAs). Sera of 323 HLA-sensitized kidney transplant candidates positive with a class I HLA single antigen flow beads assay were retested after acid treatment of the beads. Denatured HLA antibodies were identified according to ratio between the measured fluorescence intensity for treated and nontreated beads. T-lymphocyte flow cytometry crossmatches were performed to characterize the ability of these antibodies to recognize HLA on normal cells as a surrogate of their potential clinical relevance. Their impact on organ allocation was evaluated through a calculated panel reactive antibody. The utility of single antigen flow beads largely devoid of denatured HLA (iBeads) was also evaluated. Denatured HLA antibodies were detected in 39% of the patients. They provided much less positive flow cytometry crossmatches than anti-native HLA antibodies (16% vs. 83%, P<0.0001). Removing the HLA-A and HLA-B antigens targeted by denatured HLA antibodies from unacceptable antigens lowered the calculated panel reactive antibody for 90 patients, sometimes dramatically. The iBeads assay demonstrated nearly the same ability to predict crossmatch results than the acid treatment assay. Denatured class I HLA antibodies are common, but the antigens they target should not be considered as unacceptable in most cases, because they negatively impact access to a transplant while predominantly providing negative sensitive crossmatches. The iBeads assay seems to be a valuable alternative to better define unacceptable antigens.

Deciphering complement interference in anti-human leukocyte antigen antibody detection with flow beads assays.

Anti-human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibody detection in solid-phase flow beads assays can be quenched by complement activation, but the precise mechanism of this interference is not fully elucidated yet. Using the Luminex flow beads screening assay for detection of anti-HLA antibodies, we analyzed the binding of high concentrations of the pan class I anti-HLA monoclonal antibody W6/32 in neat normal, ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid-treated normal and complement factors C1q, C4/C3, C2, C3, factor B or C5-depleted human sera, using anti-mouse immunoglobulin G as the detection antibody. Complement activation and binding to beads were revealed using anti-human C1q, C4d, and C3d antibodies. To translate our findings to the human setting, we used the class I and class II HLA single-antigen flow beads assays and sera from four patients with high titers of antibodies. Detection of W6/32 did not suffer any interference with C1q and C4/C3-depleted sera. A partial quenching was observed with C2, C3, and factor B-depleted sera, but was more pronounced with the factor B-depleted serum. W6/32 was undetectable in presence of C5-depleted serum. The binding of activation products derived from C3 principally, and also from C4, impaired immunoglobulin G and C1q detection. Accordingly, C4d detection was hindered by deposition of activated C3. Similar findings were obtained with patients' sera. Binding of C4 and C3 activation products is the main responsible for complement interference in flow beads assays. A complete quenching requires complement activation through C3 cleavage and its amplification by the alternative pathway.

Pretransplant IgG Subclasses of Donor-Specific Human Leukocyte Antigen Antibodies and Development of Antibody-Mediated Rejection

The subclass of IgG antibodies contributes to their capability to activate complement. It is currently unknown whether the pretransplant IgG subclass composition allows distinguishing harmful from presumably irrelevant donor-specific human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies (HLA-DSA) detected by single-antigen flow beads (SAFB). Seventy-four patients transplanted in the presence of HLA-DSA were investigated. HLA-DSA characteristics were not different between patients experiencing antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) (n=40) and patients who did not (n=34) experience AMR. Sera were reanalyzed using SAFB with IgG subclass-specific reporter antibodies. The 74 patients had in total 141 HLA-DSA. IgG1 was the predominant subclass (78%), followed by IgG2 (49%), IgG3 (36%), and IgG4 (20%). When grouped according to the complement-activating capability, only 4 of 74 patients (5%) had exclusively weak/no complement-activating HLA-DSA (i.e., IgG2 and IgG4), 21 of 74 patients (28%) had isolated strong complement-activating HLA-DSA (i.e., IgG1 and IgG3), and 46 of 74 patients (62%) had a mixture of both. There was no difference between the strong complement-activating and the mixture group regarding incidence of AMR (57% vs. 54%; P=0.81), phenotypes of AMR (P=0.70), and death-censored allograft survival at 5 years (78% vs. 78%; P=0.74). Interestingly, patients with exclusively weak/no complement-activating HLA-DSA (n=4) had a numerically lower incidence of AMR (25%) and no allograft loss has occurred yet. In 90% of patients, pretransplant HLA-DSA are composed of isolated strong or a mixture of strong and weak/no complement-activating IgG subclasses. Because outcomes in these two groups were similar, pretransplant IgG subclass analysis is likely not providing substantial value beyond the standard IgG SAFB assay for pretransplant risk stratification.

C4d-Fixing Capability of Low-Level Donor-Specific HLA Antibodies Is Not Predictive for Early Antibody-Mediated Rejection

Recent studies indicate that not all low-level donor-specific human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies (HLA-DSA) (i.e., positive by solid-phase assays, negative by complement-dependent cytotoxic-crossmatch) have a detrimental clinical impact. The aim of this study was to investigate whether the pretransplant C4d-fixing capability allows distinguishing harmful from presumably clinically irrelevant HLA-DSA. We retrospectively investigated 64 patients with low-level HLA-DSA detected by single-antigen flow beads (SAFB). Thirty-four of 64 patients (53%) experienced early antibody-mediated rejection (AMR), whereas 30 patients (47%) did not. HLA-DSA characteristics (i.e., number, class, and strength), frequency of retransplants, and immunosuppressive regimens were not different in these two groups. Pretransplant sera were reanalyzed using a modified SAFB assay measuring C4d fixation induced by HLA antibodies. C4d-fixing HLA-DSA were observed in 11 of 64 patients (17%). AMR occurred in 6 of 11 patients (55%) with C4d-fixing HLA-DSA and in 28 of 53 patients (53%) without C4d-fixing HLA-DSA (P=1.0). Positive C4d staining in peritubular capillaries was detected in 6 of 11 patients (55%) with C4d-fixing HLA-DSA and in 21 of 53 patients (40%) without C4d-fixing HLA-DSA (P=0.50). The pretransplant capability of low-level HLA-DSA to trigger C4d fixation in vitro is not predictive for early AMR or C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries in vivo. This argues against pretransplant C4d SAFB testing to define the clinical relevance of low-level HLA-DSA.