Voltage-gated sodium and calcium channels are distinct, evolutionarily related ion channels that achieve remarkable ion selectivity despite sharing an overall similar structure. Classical studies have shown that ion selectivity is determined by specific binding of ions to the channel pore, enabled by signature amino acid sequences within the selectivity filter (SF). By studying ancestral channels in the pond snail (Lymnaea stagnalis), Guan etal. showed in a recent JBC article that this well-established mechanism can be tuned by alternative splicing, allowing a single CaV3 gene to encode both a Ca2+-permeable and an Na+-permeable channel depending on the cellular context. These findings shed light on mechanisms that tune ion selectivity in physiology and on the evolutionary basis of ion selectivity.