Shunt Registry Research Articles

Influence of distal insertion technique, valve selection, and patient demographics on shunt survival in ventriculoperitoneal shunt insertion: A retrospective analysis of an Australian case series

BackgroundVentriculoperitoneal (VP) shunt insertion is a means of diverting cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) for management of hydrocephalus. Revision rates, operating time, and length of stay (LOS) following laparoscopic insertion of the distal catheter have been mixed. There are limited data on the role of adhesiolysis during VP shunt insertion. Valve characteristics have also been shown to influence patient outcomes. There is a paucity of Australian data reporting on the effect of these variables on shunt outcomes. We aimed to study patient demographics, indications, and surgical and instrument variables in the Australian context. MethodsWe performed a retrospective, multi-surgeon, single-centre analysis of VP shunts inserted in adults via an open or laparoscopic technique. Data on patient demographics and surgery characteristics were collected from the hospital medical records and the Australasian Shunt Registry. The primary outcome was shunt revision rate and secondary outcomes were postoperative complications, operating time and LOS, and shunt survivability. ResultsFifty-six participants were eligible for analysis. The overall revision rate was 14.3 %, which was lower than the national average. The distal catheter revision rate was 0 %. Laparoscopic insertion of the distal catheter was shown to significantly reduce operating time (70.4 min in the open group and 50.7 min in the laparoscopic group, p < 0.001). This was demonstrated across different aetiologies, and when controlling for age and valve-type (p < 0.05). The revision rate of non-programmable was higher than programmable valves (42.9 % versus 2.9 %, respectively). There were no differences between previous abdominal surgery, LOS, complication, or revision rate between open and laparoscopic insertion. VP shunt survivability was greater in the laparoscopic group (90-day shunt survival of 96.7 % and 92 % in the laparoscopy and open groups, respectively; p > 0.05). We did not find any significant difference in operating time or length of stay for age, sex, or previous abdominal surgery, even when accounting for surgical technique. Indication and shunt survivability varied widely between age groups. The use of laparoscopic insertion increased over time, though surgeons did not crossover techniques. ConclusionsThe overall distal revision rate of VP shunts is low. Laparoscopic insertion of the distal catheter reduces operating time and may improve shunt survivability. Larger studies are needed to confirm differences in shunt survivability in open versus laparoscopic distal catheter insertion, between age groups, clinical indications, and valve type on patient outcomes.

Pediatric shunt revision analysis within the first year of shunt placement: A single center experience.

Background: Hydrocephalus is a common problem in neurosurgery with shunt placement remains the mainstay of the management. However, shunt placement generally requires following surgical procedures, including shunt revision. Despite the recent developments, the incidence of shunt failure remains high, approximately 30–51% in the 1st year following the shunt placement.Methods: An observational retrospective study of pediatric neurosurgery patients whom underwent CSF shunting procedure, both primary and repeated VPS, VAS, CPS, and subdural-peritoneal shunt procedures between January 2018 and May 2019. The patients were observed for 12 months for potential complication requiring shunt revision following the shunt placement.Results: A total of 142 patients underwent shunt placement. The shunt revision within 12 months was found in 26 patients (18.3%), 25 cases were VPS (96.2%) and one case was CPS (3.8%). The mean period of time between shunt placement to shunt revision was 3.96 months. Age of under 6 months old during the shunt placement showed significantly higher risk for shunt revision (RR 2.32 CI 1.13–4.74, P = 0.018). The most common diagnosis requiring shunt revision was congenital anomaly (16 cases, 61.5%). The most common cause of revision was shunt malfunction, with 21 cases (80.8%) followed by infected shunt with 5 cases (19.2%).Conclusion: The 1st year observation showed relatively high rate for shunt revision. The patient underwent shunt procedure should be regularly followed up in long period for better evaluation of the outcome. The application of shunt registry in some countries appears to be efficient and beneficial for sustainable follow-up in patients underwent shunt placement.

An adjustable gravitational valve for initial VP-shunt treatment in hydrocephalic preterm neonates and infants below 1 year of age

ObjectiveShunt treatment for hydrocephalus in children should aim for sustainable flexibility in regard to optional, perspective pressure level adjustment during advancing physical and mental development. Gravitation-assisted shunt valves are designed to prevent hydrostatic over-drainage frequently observed in the long course of shunt-treated hydrocephalus. We prospectively studied and analyzed the implication, safety, and feasibility for an adjustable gravitational unit combined with a fixed differential-pressure (DP) valve for neonates and infants primary shunted within the first 12 months of life.MethodsClinical course of hydrocephalic neonates and infants who received initial VP-shunt insertion in the early post-natal phase were monitored prospectively on the basis of our digital institutional Hydrocephalus & Shunt Registry. All patients were equipped with a fixed DP valve combined with a programmable gravitational unit activated in upright body position. Patients with a minimum shunt follow-up of 24 months were considered for further statistical analysis regarding hydrocephalus etiology, surgical setting, pre- and post-operative ventricular enlargement, head circumference, valve pressure setting, implication for the adjustment option of the gravitational unit, type and number of shunt complications, and revision-free shunt and valve survival.ResultsSeventy-eight pediatric patients received primary VP-shunt insertion at a mean age of 10 weeks with age gestationally corrected for preterm neonates. Hydrocephalus was related to perinatal IVH (64%), CNS malformation (11%), spina bifida (9%), congenital aqueductal stenosis (9%), and idiopathic (4%) or post-infectious etiology (3%). Fifty-two patients (70%) presented with history of prematurity (gestational age 23–36 weeks). Regular follow-up carried out for a mean period of 63 months demonstrated that ventricular enlargement decreased significantly after applied treatment and excessive head growth could be counteracted effectively. At least one pressure level adjustment was performed in 31% of all patients after 12 months, in 42% after 24 months, and in 64% at the time of last clinical follow-up since initial shunt insertion. Pressure level adjustments were successful in cases of clinical or radiographic signs of under- or over-drainage for individual patients of various ages during entire clinical course. Mean pressure setting for upright position was 24.1 cm H2O at the time of initial shunt insertion and increased to 26.4 cmH2O at the time of last clinical follow-up. Revision-free shunt-survival rates after 12 and 24 months were 79% and 70% and valve-survival rates 91% and 90%, respectively.ConclusionThe combination of a fixed DP valve with an adjustable gravitational unit utilized as first-line shunt regimen was feasible and safe in a highly vulnerable subgroup of hydrocephalic infants. The adjustment option for the gravitational unit showed frequent and increasing implication over time and was beneficial even during the very early developmental stage of limited autonomous mobility. To our knowledge this is the first ever reported long-term investigation of an age-consistent pediatric patient collective primary shunted with an adjustable gravitational valve system.

PND53 Budget IMPACT Analysis of the Antibiotic-Impregnated Ventriculoperitoneal Shunt VS Standard Silicone Shunt in Patients with Hydrocephalus in England, France, Germany and Italy

Hydrocephalus is the pathological accumulation of cerebrospinal fluid in the cerebral ventricles. If left untreated, progressive hydrocephalus leads to high mortality and severe neurological outcomes. The most common treatment method is the placement of the ventriculoperitoneal shunt (VPS). The objective of the study was to evaluate the budget impact of antibiotic-impregnated VPS vs. standard silicone VPS on healthcare systems in England, France, Germany, and Italy over a one-year time horizon. Decision-analytic modelling was used. The model considered the initial placement of the shunt and revision surgery due to catheter-related infections and other reasons. Clinical data were obtained from the BASICS RCT and the UK Shunt Registry. Cost data were obtained from the local sources. The analysis was performed for a cohort of 100 patients, including a mix of adult and pediatric patients. The use of the antibiotic-impregnated VPS led to a reduction of infection-related revisions by 3.87 for the cohort of 100 patients. When only infection-related revisions were considered, the budget impact of antibiotic-impregnated VPS was -£50,220 in England, -€23,076 in France, -€22,445 in Germany, and -€29,362 in Italy for the cohort of 100 patients. When all types of revisions were considered, antibiotic-impregnated VPS was still cost saving to the system, but the magnitude of saving was smaller. In summary, the use of antibiotic-impregnated shunt leads to better patient outcomes, reduced morbidity, and reduced cost to the health care system. The use of antibiotic-impregnated shunts should be prioritized over standard silicone shunts to achieve the best clinical and economic outcomes.

Current epidemiology of cerebrospinal fluid shunt surgery in the UK and Ireland (2004–2013)

ObjectivesTo determine current epidemiology and clinical characteristics of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) shunt surgery, including revisions.MethodsA retrospective, multicentre, registry-based study was conducted based on 10 years’ data from the UK Shunt...

Implementing a digital real-time Hydrocephalus and Shunt Registry to evaluate contemporary pattern of care and surgical outcome in pediatric hydrocephalus.

Treatment monitoring and outcome evaluation in pediatric hydrocephalus require gapless documentation regarding surgical and clinical follow-up data beginning from day 1 of treatment in order to apply high quality of care. Endoscopic procedures, shunt insertion and revision surgeries, and individual modifications of valve hardware or pressure settings during follow-up as well as established outcome measurements are highly relevant for complete illustration of the patient's hydrocephalus histories. A digital tool to capture, organize, and analyze comprehensive treatment-related data was estimated long overdue, consequentially developed, and implemented in daily pediatric neurosurgical routine. We established a self-contained, network-capable database application to supply and back up clinical information of complete surgical treatment history with implant status and follow up for all institutional pediatric hydrocephalus patients from 1995 to date. The application content has been prospectively complemented since 2012 during daily pediatric neurosurgical routine. Beside surgical data, neurological outcome and quality of life assessment were integrated according to validated scales to be recordable 2, 3, and 5years after initial surgical intervention for prospective administration. The application is in continuous and problem-free use since implementation offering homogeneous and structured real-time information of surgical and corresponding neurological hydrocephalus-related data. By using an automatized data extraction tool, an exemplary surgical outcome evaluation reviewing institutional ventriculo-peritoneal shunt (VPS) treatment in infants over a period of more than 20years was performed. To validate applicability, the Registry was successfully implemented in an external institution under identical conditions continuously serving for the same purpose until today. Upon completion of the developing process, the application was successfully implemented into routine clinical workflow of our institution. In total, 579 pediatric hydrocephalus patients entered into the Registry with collectively 1874 corresponding hydrocephalus-related surgeries (9% neuro-endoscopic procedures, 18% temporary CSF-diversions, 73% shunt surgeries) so far. For exemplary surgical outcome analysis, the total volume of complex data sets could easily be reduced stepwise in regard to requested inclusion criteria. The selection process generated conclusive data of 256 institutional pediatric VPS patients providing a median follow-up of 8.5years. Surgical outcome was evaluated in regard to hydrocephalus etiology, applied valve design, valve augmentation, cause of initial malfunction, time to initial shunt revision, and number of total revisions. The pediatric hydrocephalus registry application delivers easy access to contemporary and up-to-date clinical information during daily clinical routine and proves comprehensive value for various scientific purposes. Institutional hydrocephalus etiologies, treatment modalities, and surgical outcome could be reviewed for a selected pediatric patient collective during an interval of more than 20years and confirmed initial shunt treatment within the first year of age, communicating hydrocephalus and a history of prematurity as significant variables for unfavorable shunt survival and long-term revision rate. At our institution, the Registry emerged to an essential and sustainable tool to capture, organize, and analyze patterns of care in pediatric hydrocephalus patients of all etiologies and treatment modalities. Because of its adaptable and reliable predicate, a prospective multi-center utilization is currently in preparation.

Impact of antibiotic-impregnated catheters on the reduction in operations for cerebrospinal fluid shunt infection since 1995: evidence from the UK Shunt Registry

Various methods have been introduced to reduce CSF shunt infection including institutional protocols, antibiotic prophylaxis and antibiotic-impregnated catheters. Have such measures led to a sustainable reduction in CSF shunt infections?

Proposal for establishment of the UK Cranial Reconstruction Registry (UKCRR)

Background. The increasing utilisation of decompressive craniectomy for traumatic brain injury and stroke has led to an increase in the number of cranioplasties undertaken. Cranioplasty is also undertaken following excision of tumours originating from or invading the skull vault, removal of bone flaps due to post-operative infection, and decompressive craniectomy for the management of rarer causes of brain oedema and/or refractory intracranial hypertension. The existing literature which mainly consists of single-centre, retrospective studies, shows a significant variation in practice patterns and a wide range of morbidity. There also exists a need to measure the outcome as perceived by the patients themselves with patient reported outcome measures (PROMs; functional outcome, quality of life, satisfaction with cosmesis). In the UK, the concept of long-term surveillance of neurosurgical implants is well established with the UK shunt registry. Based on this background, we propose to establish the UK Cranial Reconstruction Registry (UKCRR). Aim. The overarching aim of the UKCRR is to collect high-quality data about cranioplasties undertaken across the UK and Ireland in order to improve outcomes for patients. Methods. Any patient undergoing reconstruction of the skull vault with autologous bone, titanium, or synthetic material in participating units will be eligible for inclusion. Data will be submitted directly by participating units to the Outcome Registry Intervention and Operation Network secure platform. A Steering Committee will be responsible for overseeing the strategic direction and running of the UKCRR. Outcome measures. These will include re-operation due to a cranioplasty-related issue, surgical site infection, re-admission due to a cranioplasty-related issue, unplanned post-operative escalation of care, adverse events, length of stay in admitting unit, destination at discharge from admitting unit, mortality at discharge from admitting unit, neurological status and PROMs during routine follow-up. Conclusion. The UKCRR will be an important pillar in the ongoing efforts to optimise the outcomes of patients undergoing cranioplasty.

Are adjustable valves effective in all ages of patient? Data from the UK Shunt Registry

Background Adjustable CSF valves have been developed by several manufacturers. These valves are more expensive, but have an advantage in that the operating pressure of the valve can be altered by the use of an external magnet. We have used data collected by the UK Shunt Registry to assess the effectiveness of these valves in reducing valve replacement for under and over-drainage using a case-control design.

A Multicenter Multinational Registry for Assessing Ventriculoperitoneal Shunt Infections for Hydrocephalus

Reported infection rates after ventriculoperitoneal shunt surgery vary from 1 to 25%. Antibiotic-impregnated (AI) catheters may reduce shunt infection rates, but this is uncertain. To establish a prospective shunt registry to evaluate short-term (3-month) infection rates associated with ventriculoperitoneal shunts and standard or AI catheters during surgical treatment of hydrocephalus. A prospective, multicenter, noncontrolled, open-label registry investigated patients with de novo catheter implantation or catheter replacement of an existing ventriculoperitoneal shunt. The primary outcome was shunt infection. A total of 440 patients were entered into the registry at 10 sites: 3 in North America, 2 in Singapore, 4 in China and 1 in India. Seven patients were excluded. Of the 433 remaining patients, 314 had new shunts and 119 were revisions. Shunt infections occurred in 14 of 433 patients (3.2%) overall and in 2 of 37 infants (5.2%) younger than 1 year. AI catheters were used in 46 of 433 patients at 7 centers. The shunt infection rate was 0 of 46 for shunts with AI catheters and 14 of 387 (3.6%) without AI catheters. Infection rates were similar with AI catheters, adjusting for age and catheter type. The overall shunt infection rate was lower than in previous multicentered studies. The low infection rate and low rate of AI catheter use precludes any meaningful statement regarding the value of AI catheters in reducing the infection rate. Consideration should be given to performing a well designed, adequately powered, prospective randomized controlled trial to determine whether AI catheters reduce shunt infection rates.

Efficacy of antibiotic-impregnated shunt catheters in reducing shunt infection: data from the United Kingdom Shunt Registry

In recent years CSF shunt catheters impregnated with rifampicin and clindamycin have been introduced to the United Kingdom (UK) market. These catheters have been shown to be effective in vitro against cultures of Staphylococcus epidermidis. The authors used data collected by the UK Shunt Registry to assess the efficacy of antibiotic-impregnated catheters (AICs) against shunt infection by using a matched-pair study design. The UK Shunt Registry contains data on nearly 33,000 CSF shunt-related procedures. The authors identified 1139 procedures in which impregnated catheters had been used, and accurate information was known about diagnosis, number of revisions, sex, and age in these cases. The database was ordered chronologically and searched forward and backward for cases with these same characteristics but involving conventional catheters. Matches were found for 994 procedures. Among the 994 procedures in which AICs had been used, 30 shunts were subsequently revised because of shunt infection. Among the 994 controls, 47 were subsequently revised for infection (p = 0.048, chi-square test). The UK Shunt Registry does not collect data on causative organisms, and the surgeon is relied on entirely for the diagnosis of infection. However, with the large number of matched pairs evaluated, the authors attempted to reduce bias to a minimum. Their data suggest that AICs have the potential to significantly reduce shunt infections.

Who should perform shunt surgery? Data from the UK Shunt Registry

Annual Meeting of the Society for Research into Hydrocephalus and Spina Bifida Meeting

Are adjustable valves effective? Data from the UK Shunt Registry

Background Adjustable (often-called programmable) CSF valves have been developed by several manufacturers. These valves are more expensive, but have an advantage in that the operating pressure of the valve can be altered by the use of an external magnet as a simple procedure. The proportion of these valves used in the UK and Ireland has increased from 4.9% in 2000 to 22.4% in 2006. We have used data collected by the UK Shunt Registry to assess the effectiveness of these valves in reducing valve replacement for under and over-drainage using a case-control design. Materials and methods The UK Shunt Registry contains data on nearly 30,000 CSF shunt-related procedures. Our data suggests that primary factors involved in shunt revision are patient age, diagnosis and the number of revisions a patient has had. Procedures were identified where either a Medtronic Strata Valve or Codman Hakim Programmable Valve was used. Of these 1,389 had an accurate diagnosis and age entered and we were able to determine the exact number of shunt revisions. A database search was performed for procedures matched for patient age, diagnosis and revision status but using Medtronic or Codman fixed-pressure valves. Matches were found for 943 procedures.

Do antibiotic-impregnated shunt catheters reduce shunt infection? Data from the UK Shunt Registry

Bifida Meeting abstracts - A single PDF containing all abstracts in this supplement is available here .

Reasons for shunting and reasons for revision: a survey based on data from the UK Shunt Registry

Data from the UK Shunt Registry for procedures carried out between May 1999 and April 2002 was examined for the given reason for shunting and the given reasons for subsequent revisions. Sixty-eight per cent of patients receiving shunts had 'secondary' hydrocephalus, with congenital and idiopathic hydrocephalus accounting for 18% and 14% respectively. Patients with Spina Bifida represented 5.1% of shunted patients.