Shellfish Farming Areas Research Articles

Toward an ecologically realistic experimental system to investigate the multigenerational effects of ocean warming and acidification on benthic invertebrates

AbstractHuman activities over the past 150 yr have led to significant carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions, causing global warming and ocean acidification. Surface ocean temperature has risen by 0.93°C since 1850, with projections of an additional +1.42°C to 3.47°C by 2080–2099. Ocean acidification, driven by CO2 absorption, has already lowered seawater pH by 0.1 units, affecting calcifying organisms, including shelled mollusks. Long‐term multigenerational studies on mollusk responses to both ocean acidification and warming, under realistic environmental conditions, are scarce. To address this knowledge gap, two mobile experimental units that can be deployed at the vicinity of shellfish farming areas were developed within the framework of the CocoriCO2 project. The experimental systems were designed to manipulate temperature and pH as offsets from ambient conditions. The experimental units have shown their effectiveness in terms of controlling and maintaining pH and temperature to assess the multigenerational effects of ocean warming and acidification on benthic invertebrates. Finally, the developed experimental systems can be modified easily to provide an educated assessment of the impact of other relevant environmental changes such as deoxygenation and changes in salinity.

Effects of mussel-phytoplankton interactions on the aquatic environment

A five-day in situ experiment was conducted in plastic enclosures to investigate the effects of different densities of the mussel Mytilus edulis, and sampling time on water variables, and phytoplankton community structure in Sanggou Bay (Shandong, China). The tested mussel densities were low (LD300: 300 g/m3), medium (MD600: 600 g/m3), high (HD900: 900 g/m3), and sampling times were at 6:00 and 17:00 h. The water variables analyzed as indicators were pH, dissolved oxygen, nutrients, carbonate system, pCO2, and chlorophyll-a (Chl-a). The results showed that density and sampling time had highly significant effects on all water parameters and phytoplankton abundance, except for dissolved oxygen (P<0.01). At the same sampling time, pH, c[CO32-] and Chl-a concentrations in the water column of LD300 treatment were much higher than those of MD600 and HD900 treatments, while c[HCO3-], c[CO2] and pCO2 were significantly lower than those of MD600 and HD900 treatments (P<0.01). Phosphate was the main limiting nutrient for phytoplankton growth. Chl-a concentrations increased and then decreased significantly in LD300 and MD600 treatments, while it diminished continuously in HD900 treatment. The higher M. edulis density showed higher correlation with picophytoplankton abundance and Chl-a concentrations. Not only the phytoplankton structure was affected, but also the condition index of the HD900 treatment was significantly reduced (P<0.05). The present study showed LD300 and MD600 treatments significantly promoted the growth of picophytoplankton. The selective filtration of M. edulis for microphytoplankton and nanophytoplankton were much higher than those for picophytoplankton. The combined decrease in competitors (micro- and nanophytoplankton) led to a substantial increase of picophytoplankton abundance in shellfish farming areas. The interactions between mussel and phytoplankton significantly affected the water environment. However, well designed integrated shellfish and algae aquaculture might mitigate the adverse impacts.

Mapping intertidal oyster farms using unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV) high-resolution multispectral data

In France, oyster aquaculture has been historically developed in intertidal zones, with shellfish farming areas covering much of the Atlantic coast. Monitoring these off-bottom cultures where oysters are grown in plastic mesh-bags set on trestle tables is mandatory for the maritime administration to check compliance with a Structural Plan Document (SPD), while also being important for stock assessment in relation to carrying capacity issues. However, traditional monitoring methods are time-consuming, labor-intensive, and inefficient in covering large intertidal areas. In this study, we used a new GIS-based analytical method to assess the potential of high-resolution Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) multispectral data to retrieve spatial information on oyster-farming structures using Bourgneuf Bay (France) as a case-study. A non-parametric machine learning algorithm was applied to four UAV flight orthomosaics collected at different altitudes (12, 30, 50, and 120 m) to identify oyster mesh-bags. These supervised classifications achieved overall accuracies above 95% for all tested altitudes. In addition, an accurate distinction of oyster-bag mesh sizes (4, 9 and 14 mm) was obtained for 12–50 m flights, but there was a lower accuracy at 120 m. Across all flights, the 4 mm mesh size was the least well detected (72.14% Producer Accuracy). This information can be used to identify bags with specific mesh-sizes used for spat or adult grow out. Finally, we accurately measured oyster table heights using a high-resolution Digital Surface Model (DSM) derived from Structure from Motion (SfM) photogrammetry. The 50 m flight was suggested as the best compromise to obtain precise measurements of the oyster table heights while covering larger areas than lower altitude flights. This demonstrates that UAV technology can provide a set of spatial variables relevant for shellfish farmers and coastal managers in an efficient, rapid, and non-destructive way to monitor the extent and characteristics of oyster-farming areas regularly.

Ecological risks assessment of sulfur and heavy metals in sediments in a historic mariculture environment, North Yellow Sea.

The environment behaviors of sulfur and heavy metals in sediments are closely related to sediment aging in mariculture area. In this study, the distributions and ecological risks of reduced inorganic sulfur (RIS) and heavy metals were investigated, along with the relationships between different occurrences of RIS and heavy metals. The results indicated that the adequate organic matter in mariculture sediments significantly enhanced the accumulation of acid volatile sulfur (AVS) compared to the control area. In shellfish farming area, biological sedimentation contributed to accumulation of AVS. The chromium (II)-reducible sulfur (CRS) was the main component of RIS in mariculture area. The environmental risks of heavy metals in mariculture area presented low levels. Principal component analysis (PCA) showed that distribution of Cu closely related to mariculture activities compared to other heavy metals. For ecological risks of heavy metals, the ratio of ∑(acid-soluble fraction (F1)+reducible fraction (F2)+oxidizable fraction (F3))/AVS was the appropriate index rather than conventional simultaneous extraction of heavy metals (SEM)/AVS, because SEM/AVS would overestimate the toxicity of heavy metals. AVS/RIS ratios significantly positively correlated with Pb (F2/(F1+F2+F3+residual fraction (F4)), F2/∑F), Pb (F3/∑F), and Zn (F3/∑F), while significantly negatively correlated with Pb (F4/∑F) and Cu (F1/∑F). These results indicated that the accumulation of AVS during the mariculture process was conducive to the formation of F2 and F3 of Pb, and F3 of Zn, conversely to the formation for F4 of Pb and F1 of Cu, because it was opposite to the accumulation of CRS.

Ecosystem modelling to assess the impact of rearing density, environment variability and mortality on oyster production

The natural productivity of ecosystems, farming practices and mortality events drive the rearing density and growth of oysters in shellfish farming areas. The variability of these drivers, which can be of natural or anthropic origin, is therefore an important source of variation in the growth performance and production of shellfish. Knowledge of these variabilities and their relative importance help producers to anticipate their effects and adapt aquaculture practices in order to limit negative impacts and guarantee a constant, or at least acceptable, level of production. In this paper, we implement a 3D model coupling hydrodynamics, primary production and individual growth to predict oyster growth and production in Bourgneuf Bay (French Atlantic coast). We set up numerous scenarios to compare and hierarchize the impacts of aquaculture practices, environmental variability and mortality events on shellfish production. Our results allowed us to propose a simplified management tool, in the form of response functions, to optimize shellfish farming practices interannually. This tool will help shellfish farmers quickly recover production levels in response to variations in mortality and/or environmental conditions.

Prevalence, virulence-gene profiles, antimicrobial resistance, and genetic diversity of human pathogenic Aeromonas spp. from shellfish and aquatic environments

Aeromonas are found in various habitats, particularly in aquatic environments. This study examined the presence of the most common human pathogenic Aeromonas species (Aeromonas caviae, A. hydrophila, and A. veronii) in surface water, sea water, and shellfish. The detection rates in fishing harbour seawater, shellfish farming seawater, and a river basin were 33.3%, 26.4%, and 29.4%, respectively, and high prevalence was observed in summer. The detection rates in shellfish procured from a fish market and shellfish farm were 34.9% and 13.3%, respectively. The most abundant species of human pathogenic Aeromonas detected via water sampling was A. caviae, whereas that obtained via shellfish sampling was A. veronii. The prevalence of human pathogenic Aeromonas in river water was lower in fishing harbours and in the estuary shellfish farming area. Here, 25 isolates of human pathogenic Aeromonas species were isolated from 257 samples and divided among 16 virulence profiles. The high virulence gene-carrying isolates (more than six genes) belonged to A. hydrophila. The shellfish-sourced isolates had the highest detection rates of act, aerA, and fla genes than of other virulence genes, and vice versa for seawater-sourced isolates. The Aeromonas isolates showed high levels of resistance to ampicillin-sulbactam; however, none were resistant to cefepime, ciprofloxacin, or gentamicin. The incidence of multiple drug resistance (MDR) in Aeromonas isolates was 20%. In this study, phylogenetic analysis with 16S rRNA sequencing, biochemical tests and enterobacterial repetitive intergenic consensus-polymerase chain reaction fingerprinting facilitated the distinct categorisation of three species of human pathogenic Aeromonas isolates. In addition, A. veronii isolates from the same geographical area were also concentrated in the same cluster. This study provides information on the risk of infection by Aeromonas with MDR and multiple virulence genes isolated from shellfish and aquatic environments.

In situ characterisation of pathogen dynamics during a Pacific oyster mortality syndrome episode

Significant mortality of Crassostrea gigas juveniles is observed systematically every year worldwide. Pacific Oyster Mortality Syndrome (POMS) is caused by Ostreid Herpesvirus 1 (OsHV-1) infection leading to immune suppression, followed by bacteraemia caused by a consortium of opportunistic bacteria. Using an in-situ approach and pelagic chambers, our aim in this study was to identify pathogen dynamics in oyster flesh and in the water column during the course of a mortality episode in the Mediterranean Thau lagoon (France). OsHV-1 concentrations in oyster flesh increased before the first clinical symptoms of the disease appeared, reached maximum concentrations during the moribund phase and the mortality peak. The structure of the bacterial community associated with oyster flesh changed in favour of bacterial genera previously associated with oyster mortality including Vibrio, Arcobacter, Psychrobium, and Psychrilyobacter. During the oyster mortality episode, releases of OsHV-1 and opportunistic bacteria were observed, in succession, in the water surrounding the oyster lanterns. These releases may favour the spread of disease within oyster farms and potentially impact other marine species, thereby reducing marine biodiversity in shellfish farming areas.

Carbonate chemistry dynamics in shellfish farming areas along the Chilean coast: natural ranges and biological implications

AbstractThe increasing shellfish aquaculture requires knowledge about nearshore environmental variability to manage sustainably and create climate change adaptation strategies. We used data from mooring time series and in situ sampling to characterize oceanographic and carbonate system variability in three bivalve aquaculture areas located along a latitudinal gradient off the Humboldt Current System. Our results showed pHT &amp;lt;8 in most coastal sites and occasionally below 7.5 during austral spring–summer in the lower (−30°S) and central (−37°S) latitudes, related to upwelling. Farmed mussels were exposed to undersaturated (Ωarag &amp;lt; 1) and hypoxic (&amp;lt;2 ml l−1) waters during warm seasons at −37°S, while in the higher latitude (43°S) undersaturated waters were only detected during colder seasons, associated with freshwater runoff. We suggest that both Argopecten purpuratus farmed at −30°S and Mytilus chilensis farmed at −43°S may enhance their growth during summer due to higher temperatures, lower pCO2, and oversaturated waters. In contrast, Mytilus galloprovincialis farmed at 37°S grows better during spring–summer, following higher temperatures and high pCO2. This knowledge is relevant for aquaculture, but it must be improved using high-resolution time series and in situ experimentation with farmed species to aid their adaptation to climate change and ocean acidification.

Purification, Toxicity and Functional Characterization of a New Proteinaceous Mussel Biotoxin from Bizerte Lagoon.

The marine environment is known to be occupied by microorganisms. The potential toxicity of some of these marine microorganisms, that are capable of producing unknown biotoxins, has always been underestimated. Indeed, these biotoxins may be a threat to human health through the consumption of contaminated seafood and fish. For more than ten years, recurrent but atypical toxicity has been detected in mussels from Bizerte lagoon (North of Tunisia) during routine tests. In this study, we have isolated and characterized a new proteinaceous marine biotoxin, named Mussel Toxic Peptide (MTP). Using HPLC, electrophoresis and LC/MS studies, we showed that MTP has a protein characteristic UV-spectrum, can be visualized by protein specific reagents such as Coomassie, and has a molecular mass of 6.4 kDa. Patch-clamp experiments performed on cultured N18 neuroblastoma cells revealed that MTP (0.9–18 µM) markedly inhibited voltage-gated Na current, but was about 23 times less active in blocking voltage-gated K current at equimolar concentrations. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that a proteinaceous marine biotoxin with relatively high molecular mass is isolated and involved in the contamination of mussels harvested from shellfish farming areas.

Pollution Status of Surface Sediment in Jinju Bay, a Spraying Shellfish Farming Area, Korea

Pollution Status of Surface Sediment in Jinju Bay, a Spraying Shellfish Farming Area, Korea

Assessing Average Residence Time as a Physical Descriptor for Shellfish Farming Areas in Jaran Bay, Korea

Assessing Average Residence Time as a Physical Descriptor for Shellfish Farming Areas in Jaran Bay, Korea

Shellfish culture: a complex driver of planktonic communities

AbstractThis review features recent updates on planktonic community alteration attributed to shellfish farming across three major drivers: predation, nutrient availability and the hydrodynamic environment. The grazing pressure generated by filter‐feeder communities (shellfish and epibionts) constitutes a ‘top‐down’ control of planktonic communities in aquaculture areas, inducing a significant depletion of planktonic organism concentration. By selecting larger cells during the filtration process, shellfish also favour smaller organisms in the water column, leading to the dominance of the latter. Direct excretion and the benthic alteration process tend to fertilise the water column and significantly stimulate primary production. The associated epibiont community particularly contributes to this regeneration process. The expected consequence of increasing nutrient availability is generally a planktonic shift in favour of small planktonic species. However, investigation on the relationship between planktonic structure and nutrient conditions has revealed a wide complexity and variability. Finally, all structures used in shellfish farming activities interact with water currents and tend to significantly increase the residence time of planktonic organisms inside shellfish farming areas. In grazing‐dominated systems, an increase in residence time tends to increase the exposure time of planktonic populations to detrimental conditions, reducing biomass and production. The general consequences of shellfish farming are a decrease in primary production in farming ecosystems, and a possible alteration of structure and functioning of planktonic communities. The implications of shellfish farming also appear to be quite different from other aquaculture activities such as fish farming, which tend to promote primary production leading to eutrophication process.

English

Shellfish aquaculture has become an increasingly important factor in Bulgarian economy in the recent years. Marine biotoxins, produced by some phytoplankton species, may accumulate in mussels and present an important challenge in commercialization of shellfish. The aim of this study was to determine the occurrence and variability of hydrophilic toxins – paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP) and amnesic shellfish poisoning (ASP) as well as lipophilic toxins – including diarrheic shellfish poisoning (DSP), pectenotoxins (PTXs) and yessotoxins (YTXs) in plankton, wild and farmed mussel samples from the Southern Black Sea coast, an important shellfish farming area in spring 2017. PSP toxins were determined by HPLC with postchromatographic oxidation and fluorescence detection and domoic acid and lipophilic toxins by liquid chromatograph coupled to tandem mass spectrometry. DA and pectenotoxin-2 were detected in plankton, wild and farmed mussel samples. Yessotoxins were detected only in cultivated mussels and no PSP toxins were detected. The occurrence of phycotoxins differed over both space and time. Toxin profile includes prevalent domoic acid, scarce presence of pectenotoxin-2 and yessotoxins in the samples.

Growth, chain formation, and toxin production by southern Brazilian Pseudo-nitzschia isolates under laboratory conditions.

Pseudo-nitzschia is a diatom genus capable of producing the neurotoxin domoic acid (DA), which has been related to mortalities of marine vertebrates, and the amnesic shellfish poisoning (ASP) in human consumers of contaminated bivalves. This study reports DA production among Pseudo-nitzschia strains isolated from shellfish farming areas in southern Brazil. Twenty-seven cultures of potentially toxigenic Pseudo-nitzschia species were established. Growth, stepped-chain formation, and DA production were evaluated in static, intermittently illuminated (12:12 photoperiod) batch cultures for 12 selected strains, and under continuous light and/or turbulence for a single Pseudo-nitzschia calliantha strain. Growth rate ranged from 0.16 to 0.39day-1 among the 12 strains. Only P. calliantha and P. cf. multiseries yielded detectable levels of intracellular DA, reaching up to 0.054fgcell-1 in late exponential and 0.15pgcell-1 in early stationary phase, respectively. Continuous light impaired cell growth, and turbulence enhanced step-chain formation by threefold during exponential growth phase, but no DA production was detected under both conditions. The effect of turbulence on chain formation should be further evaluated in the field, once particle size is expected to affect the ingestion of toxic cells and thus toxin accumulation by certain DA vectors. The low cell toxicity revealed herein under laboratory conditions is in accordance with the low frequency of DA contamination episodes in south Brazilian waters. Nevertheless, monitoring of Pseudo-nitzschia abundance and DA presence in farming areas is continuously required to assure the quality of local shellfish products.

Distribution and Pollution Status of Organic Matter and Heavy Metals in Surface Sediment Around Goseong Bay, a Shellfish Farming Area, Korea

Distribution and Pollution Status of Organic Matter and Heavy Metals in Surface Sediment Around Goseong Bay, a Shellfish Farming Area, Korea

Temporal Evolution of the Microbiological Conditions of a Sicilian Area Designed for Aquaculture (Castellammare Gulf, Southern Tyrrhenian Sea)

Microbiological controls of coastal seawaters are a common practice to verify their safety for human recreational and productive uses. The aim of the present study is to describe the microbiological conditions of the Castellammare Gulf (Trapani, Sicily), an area traditionally used for aquaculture purposes. Particularly, the results obtained from three surveys (1993-1995, 2000-2001 and 2007) are compared in order to depict how the hygienic-sanitary conditions of this marine ecosystem have evolved over time. Attention has been given to the abundance and distribution of the bacterial indicators of faecal pollution (faecal coliforms, enterococci and Salmonella spp.) as well as halophilic vibrios, using the culture methods conventionally indicated by current legislation in force for the sanitary control of waters designed for aquaculture productions. The obtained results shows that the sanitary conditions of seawater samples met the criteria recommended by current legislations for shellfish farming approved areas. The low concentrations of faecal pollution indicators and of halophilic vibrios confirm the general suitability of the Gulf of Castellammare for seafood production. Nevertheless, the detection of low percentages of potentially pathogenic species of halophilic vibrios stresses the importance of extending microbiological controls also to these emerging pathogens.

Investigation of diarrhetic shellfish toxins in Lingshan Bay, Yellow Sea, China, using solid-phase adsorption toxin tracking (SPATT)

ABSTRACTEarly detection of toxin contamination in shellfish (i.e., prior to harvest) would be of considerable advantage to fish farmers, researchers and food safety administrators. In 2004, a solid-phase adsorption toxin tracking (SPATT) technique was developed to study algal toxins in New Zealand shellfish harvesting areas. In subsequent years, the basic idea have been further developed. Using a SPATT method, an investigation into diarrhetic shellfish toxins (DSTs) was conducted over a 10.5-month period in 2012 in shellfish farming areas in Lingshan Bay (Yellow Sea, China). This paper discusses the relationship among DSTs in toxic algae, seawater and contaminated shellfish. OA, DTX1 and PTX2 toxins were found in this shellfish farming area from summer to autumn. In shellfish the maximum concentrations of OA and DTX1 were 81 and 41 ng g–1 respectively. PTX2 was very low. The maximum levels of OA and DTX1 in seawater were 165 and 56 ng g–1 respectively, and were detected on June, separated by a 14-day period. Shellfish had accumulated the highest levels of OA and DTX1 recorded in this study. Comparison of the variations in DST levels in seawater showed there to be about 2 weeks for administrators to warn of the potential for toxin contamination in shellfish. Further research to explore the relationship between the variables of seawater temperature, sunlight and salinity, and DSTs in shellfish may help to establish a more suitable model for forecasting DST contamination in shellfish.

Seasonal distribution, sources and sink of dissolved organic carbon in integrated aquaculture system in coastal waters

Dissolved organic carbon (DOC) concentrations were measured in the Sanggou Bay (SGB) in northern China, in order to investigate the seasonal distribution, sources and sink of DOC in an integrated multi-trophic aquaculture (IMTA) system of fish, shellfish and seaweed. The sampling was conducted during April (spring), August (summer), October (autumn) and January (winter) of 2011–2012. Salinity, Chlorophyll a (Chl a) and DOC showed large spatial and seasonal variation during sampling period. DOC increased with increasing Chl a in spring, summer and autumn and decreased with increasing salinity in summer compared to other seasons. Maximum surface concentration of DOC ranged from 108.0 to 875.2 µM and minimum from 134.4 to 184.7 µM was found during summer and spring, respectively. Terrestrial input, phytoplankton and seaweed were the main sources of DOC in SGB. Shellfish farming area was enriched in organic matter as well as served to reduce DOC levels in the bay. As it was indicated that average annual removal of 42 % DOC occurred in the shellfish, the lowest occurred at an average 32 % in combined shellfish and seaweed culture area. Additionally, controlled experiment results showed that seaweed produced approximately 64.81 ± 40.86 µM day−1 and shellfish generated approximately 13.36 ± 6.07 µM day−1 and assimilated 17.07 ± 13.12 µM day−1 DOC in SGB. Accumulation of DOC at the bottom could be a result of long-term aquaculture activities in the bay. Integration of sea cucumber into IMTA system could be useful to mitigate the stockpile of organic matter at the bottom.

Bloom of Dinophysis spp. dominated by D. sacculus and its related diarrhetic shellfish poisoning (DSP) outbreak in Alfacs Bay (Catalonia, NW Mediterranean Sea): Identification of DSP toxins in phytoplankton, shellfish and passive samplers

We report a comprehensive study of a diarrhetic shellfish poisoning (DSP) outbreak in a Mediterranean coastal embayment, integrating phytoplankton identification and quantification data, with toxin analysis by LC–MS/MS of shellfish samples (mussels and oysters), phytoplankton concentrates, and solid phase adsorbing toxin tracking (SPATT) devices. Alfacs Bay was proposed as a model for the study of semi-enclosed coastal embayments and it is the most important shellfish farming area in Catalonia (Spain, NW Mediterranean Sea). The bay suffered a ban for bivalve harvesting that lasted 78 days, from late winter to the end of the spring of 2012, due to a harmful algae bloom of the toxic dinoflagellate Dinophysis sacculusthat fluctuated in three abundance peaks, reaching maximum abundance of 2200 cell/L. Mussels sampled during the bloom contained okadaic acid (OA, maximum 592 μg/kg, 3.7 times the maximum permitted level (MPL) set by the European Commission), and pectenotoxin-2 (PTX2, maximum 61 μg/kg). Oysters also contained OA and PTX2, but always below the MPL. Toxin content per cell measured from phytoplankton concentrates in filters was most likely overestimated (up to 461 pg OA/cell and 668 pg PTX2/cell), but showed an increase of cell toxicity towards the end of the bloom. OA-diol esters were not detected in phytoplankton aggregates. Concentration of DSP toxins in SPATT devices were up to 94 ng OA/g resin⋅day, 42 ng PTX2/g resin⋅day and 7 ng PTX2-sa/g resin⋅day. The applied monitoring strategy, based on the measurement of Dinophysis cell abundance in the water column, was effective to protect public health and did not extended the regulatory closure unnecessarily. Concentration of DSP in SPATT bags followed Dinophysis abundance dynamics, thus SPATTs were confirmed as a valuable research tool for Dinophysis blooms.

Metal bioaccumulation and physiological condition of the Pacific oyster (Crassostrea gigas) reared in two shellfish basins and a marina in Normandy (northwest France)

A 5-month experiment combining a geochemical survey of metals with a bioaccumulation study in batches of Crassostrea gigas was conducted in two shellfish farming areas and a marina in Normandy (France). Various endpoints at different levels of biological organization were studied. ROCCH data showed differences in biota contamination between the two shellfish areas but the present study revealed only slight differences in metallic contamination and biomarkers. By contrast, significantly different values were recorded in the marina in comparison with the two other sites. Indeed, higher levels of Cd, Cu and Zn were measured in the oysters from the marina, and these oysters also showed a poorer physiological condition (e.g., condition index, histopathological alterations and neutral lipid content). For coastal monitoring, the multi-biomarker approach coupled with an assessment of metallic contamination in biota appeared to be suitable for discriminating spatial differences in environmental quality after only a few months of exposure.