Sexual traits, such as visual adornments, sound‐based cues and courtship dances, are frequently displayed in combination as multimodal signals. Some hypotheses propose that different signals trade‐off with each other, potentially due to resource limitations (‘trade‐off’ or transfer hypothesis) or that these develop simultaneously to enhance communication effectiveness (‘joint evolution’ hypothesis). Alternatively, multiple cues may evolve independently to serve distinct functions or convey different information (‘multiple messages’ hypothesis). Here, we explored the interdependence between different signal modalities in manakins (Pipridae), which are known for great interspecific diversity in the degree of elaboration in courtship dance, song and plumage coloration. We also used comparative methods to explore the mode of evolution and the degree of conservatism of these signals. We found that song, plumage coloration and courtship dance evolved independently as there was no correlation between these traits. Song evolution in manakins was attracted to a single optimum and exhibited a weak phylogenetic signal in comparison with those of colour and behavioural diversity. The high support found for the speciational and κ models when analysing the multivariate estimates of trait variability suggests that these signals (especially colour and behaviour attributes) may have evolved in a punctuated manner, with large evolutionary changes at speciation events and minimal subsequent changes along the branches. Our results show that song, colour and dance diversity are each associated (or marginally associated) with different ecological factors, indicating that sexual signals in manakins might convey different information and/or respond to different selection pressures. Larger species and those with lower dispersal capacity tend to exhibit higher colour richness, which in turn differed among lek categories, being higher in species with ‘classic’ leks and lower in non‐lekking species. Overall, the present study supports the idea that correlation between signal modalities does not constitute a widespread pattern in songbirds.
Read full abstract