Frequencies of sex-linked recessive lethals (in the X C2 chromosome) and of translocations between the second and third chromosomes in Drosophila melanogaster were determined after irradiation of mature spermatozoa and late spermatids with 15-MeV neutrons and 250-kV X-irradiation. The doses employed ranged from 1200–4000 rad. The results show that, at all dose levels, neutrons are more effective than X-rays in producing genetic damage in late spermatids than in mature spermatozoa. The effect is more pronounced for translocations than for recessive lethals; at translocation frequencies of 2–4%, neutrons are about twice as effective in spermatids as in sperm. These observations are consistent with the finding that the lower sensitivity of late spermatids to X-irradiation originates from their lower degree of oxygenation than sperm. The greater effectiveness of neutrons in producing chromosomal damage in these relatively anoxic cells, is therefore another indication of the potential advantage of neutrons over X-rays in the treatment of tumours. The relatively low RBE values obtained for 15-MeV neutron irradiation in this study are discussed in the context of what has been recorded in the literature. The apparent discrepancies between the present and the earlier results seem to arise both from a possible mixing of stages with different X-ray sensitivity and from using neutrons of different LET spectra in the earlier work.
Read full abstract