Severe Ankle Sprain Research Articles

Injury severity at the time of sport-related ankle sprain is associated with symptoms and quality of life in young adults after 3–15 years

Background Ankle sprains are the most common sports-related injuries. Individuals with time-loss ankle sprains often experience residual symptoms and chronic ankle instability years after injury. Up to 90% of post-traumatic ankle osteoarthritis cases are associated with severe ankle sprain. This study aimed to examine whether ankle injury severity sustained during youth sports participation is associated with ankle symptoms and function. Materials and Methods Cohort study included 50 young adults (mean age, 23 years) with a 3-to 15-year history of a youth-sport related ‘significant ankle sprain’ (SAS). The primary independent variable was injury severity, which was captured in the index SAS injury details through interviews. SAS was defined as ligament and other intra/extra-articular structure injuries that disrupted youth sport participation, at least 3 days of time loss, and required medical consultation. Severe SAS was defined as SAS involving >28 days of time loss, and non-severe SAS only involved ankle ligaments and/or with ≤28 days of time loss. The Foot and Ankle Outcome Score questionnaire was used to assess ankle symptoms and function. Descriptive statistics and multivariable linear regression models were used to examine the association between SAS severity and outcomes, with sex and time since injury as covariates. Results Compared to participants with non-severe SAS, participants with a history of severe SAS demonstrated significantly poorer outcomes in symptoms [-18.4 (99% CI: −32.2 to −4.6)], pain [-10.1 (99% CI: −19.2 to −1.1)] and QoL [-17.1 (99% CI: −33.1 to −1.1)] in multivariable linear regression models. Conclusions Severe ankle sprain with a loss of > 4 weeks from sports participation at the time of injury is independently associated with poorer ankle symptoms, pain, and ankle-related quality of life after 3–15 years. Secondary prevention measures are needed in individuals with a history of severe ankle sprains to mitigate the potential health consequences.

Cortical Activation During Single-Legged Stance in Patients With Chronic Ankle Instability.

Chronic ankle instability (CAI) has been considered a neurophysiological condition, with dysfunctional somatosensory and motor system excitability. However, few researchers have explored the changes in cortical activation during balance tasks of patients with CAI. To compare the cortical activity during single-legged stance among CAI, copers, and uninjured control participants and to compare dynamic balance across groups. Cross-sectional study. Biomechanics laboratory. A total of 22 participants with CAI (median [interquartile range]; age = 34.5 [11.0] years, height = 170.0 [15.8] cm, mass = 67.0 [16.2] kg), 17 copers (age = 27.0 [14.0] years, height = 170.0 [9.5] cm, mass = 66.5 [16.5] kg), and 21 uninjured control participants (age = 25.0 [10.5] years, height = 170.0 [11.0] cm, mass = 64.0 [16.5] kg). Participants performed single-legged stance while cortical activation was tested with functional near-infrared spectroscopy. The peak oxyhemoglobin response of the activated cortex was calculated and compared across groups. The Y-Balance test outcomes and patient-reported outcomes were assessed and compared across groups. The CAI group had worse Y-balance test and patient-reported outcomes than the coper and uninjured control groups. Differences in the peak oxyhemoglobin response were observed for the primary somatosensory cortex (S1; F2,57 = 4.347, P = .017, ηp2 = 0.132) and superior temporal gyrus (STG; F2,57 = 4.548, P = .015, ηp2 = 0.138). Specifically, copers demonstrated greater activation in S1 and STG than the CAI (d = 0.73, P = .034, and d = 0.69, P = .043, respectively) and uninjured control (d = 0.77, P = .036, and d = 0.88, P = .022, respectively) groups. No differences were found in the cortical activation between CAI and uninjured control participants. Copers displayed greater cortical activation in S1 and STG than CAI and uninjured control participants. Greater activation in S1 and STG suggested a better ability to perceive somatosensory stimuli and may represent a compensatory mechanism that allows copers to maintain good functional ability after the initial severe ankle sprain.

Arthroscopic Assisted, Lateral Ligament Reconstruction with Suture Tape Augmentation and Knotless All Suture Anchors: A Technique Guide

More than 30,000 ankle sprains occur each day in the United States, and the majority of ankle sprains involve the anterior talofibular ligament. Up to 30% of patients develop functional ankle instability and chronic pain after a severe ankle sprain. When nonoperative measures are unsuccessful, operative reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligaments is recommended. To further strengthen the repair, accelerate rehabilitation, and allow for a quicker return to sport, augmentation with suture tape has recently become an alternative among surgeons in the reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligaments. Moreover, the advent of knotless all-suture anchors decreases the number of knots required in the procedure and, in theory, reduces lateral soft tissue irritation and accentuates recovery after surgery. Here we present our technique for arthroscopic assisted, lateral ligament reconstruction with suture tape augmentation and knotless all suture anchors.

The hamstrings are more impacted than the quadriceps after severe ankle sprain.

Ankle sprains (AS) are common in the military population, with a prevalence 5 to 8 times higher than that for civilians. The aim of this study was to evaluate in patients with severe AS the impact of disuse on thigh muscle induced by unloading and immobilization due to care. This study focused on muscle trophicity and dynamometric strength. In this observational prospective study, assessments were repeated at 3 visits: close to injury, 15 and 30 days following the sprain. The injured limb was compared to the contralateral limb. A dynamometer assessment was used to monitor changes in strength and fatigue of the thigh muscles of both limbs. Isometric and isokinetic concentric evaluation of peak torque (PTiso and PTdyn), total work (Wt), and peak torque time integral (IPT) of thigh muscles. Full follow-up was obtained in 30 subjects. The injured limbs showed significant deficits in the mean (SD). The quadriceps PTiso and IPT deficits were −12.6% ± 1.9% (P < .0001) and −13.27% ± 1.8% (P < .0001), respectively. The quadriceps PTdyn showed a significant deficit since V2 (−12.2.5% ± 2.0). The quadriceps Wt presented a significant deficit of −4.2% ± 2.4 (P < .0007) at 1 month. The hamstring PTdyn deficit presented a mean loss of −16.5% ± 2.4% (P < .0001). The hamstring Wt deficit was −13.7% ± 2.3% (P < .001). The analysis of variance showed that the grade of the sprain had a significant effect on the quadriceps PTq deficit (P < .016) but not the type of discharge. Our study showed that disuse leads to a significant deficit in the strength of knee muscles within 1 month. It is noteworthy that the hamstrings are more affected than the quadriceps. The rehabilitation protocol to prevent the risk of iterative ankle injuries and secondary knee injuries should incorporate early training of both quadriceps and hamstrings.

Spraino: A novel low-friction device for prevention of lateral ankle sprain injuries in indoor sports

A heightened risk for lateral ankle sprain injuries has been associated with excessive shoe-surface friction. ‘Spraino’ is a novel product specifically designed towards preventing friction-related lateral ankle sprains. In a recent 510-athlete randomized controlled trial, allocation to this “low-friction” shoe-patch resulted in a 53% reduction of severe ankle sprain injuries. Until now, however, a theoretical explanation linking shoe-surface friction and lateral ankle sprain injury mechanism is missing, and the extent to which Spraino reduces shoe-surface friction remains unknown. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to present a theoretical link between lateral edge shoe-surface friction and the mechanism of lateral ankle sprain injuries, and ultimately establish the ability of Spraino to reduce lateral edge shoe-surface friction. In this paper, we present a theory on how ankle sprain mechanics are directly affected by the friction between shoe and surface, and why friction modifications might be a viable preventive strategy. When testing slip resistance in a modified mechanical test-setup, we detected a 63% reduction (0.83–0.31) in friction coefficient between the lateral edge of the outsole and the indoor sports floor when adding Spraino to the side of the shoe. Justified in our theory, and the previously established clinical effectiveness, this reduction in friction can mitigate both the risk and severity of lateral ankle sprain injuries. This suggests that reducing friction on the lateral edge of footwear can be an effective ankle sprain injury prevention strategy.

Simultaneous Treatment of Osteochondral Lesion Does Not Affect the Mid- to Long-Term Outcomes of Ligament Repair for Acute Ankle Sprain: A Retrospective Comparative Study with a 3-11-Year Follow-up.

PurposeThis study aims to evaluate the mid- to long-term outcome of concurrent arthroscopic treatment of osteochondral lesion (OCL) and open anatomical repair of lateral ankle ligaments for severe acute ankle sprain patients and compare them to the outcome of those without OCL.MethodsA total of 166 patients with grade III acute lateral ankle ligament injuries underwent concurrent ankle arthroscopy and open anatomic ligament repair. Forty-three patients (group A) with OCL underwent arthroscopic treatment followed by open ligament repair. A total of 105 patients (group B) without OCL were followed up as the control. The evaluation parameters included sports recovery, postoperative visual analog scale (VAS) pain score, American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, Tegner score, sprain recurrence, satisfaction, and range of motion. Patients in group A were then subgroup-analyzed according to age, sex, body mass index, injury side, OCL location, and stage (Ferkel and Cheng’s staging system).ResultsThe postoperative exercise level of the two groups recovered to more than 90% of the normal level (91.2% ± 11.2% in group A and 90.9% ± 13.3% in group B, n.s.). The average time of group A and group B to return to preinjury sports activity was respectively 4.4 ± 1.0 months and 4.4 ± 1.2 months with no significant difference (p = 0.716). No significant differences were found in the preoperation VAS pain score, AOFAS score, and Tegner score between the two groups. The postoperative VAS pain score in group A was significantly higher than that in group B (0.8 ± 1.7 vs. 0.3 ± 0.8, p = 0.027), but the difference was not clinically important. The postoperative VAS pain score of patients with stage D–F lesions was significantly higher than that of patients with stage B–C lesions (1.3 ± 2.1 vs. 0.3 ± 0.9, p = 0.038).ConclusionsFor the severe acute ankle sprain combined with OCL, the simultaneous arthroscopic treatment and open lateral ankle ligament repair achieved good mid- to long-term outcomes. Except that the pain was more pronounced than in the control group, there were no differences in other outcomes. Postoperative pain was positively correlated with the grade of OCL.

Distal insertion rupture of lateral ankle ligament as a predictor of weakened and delayed sports recovery after acute ligament repair: mid-term outcomes of 117 cases

BackgroundFor lateral ankle ligament rupture, surgical repair has been considered for patients requiring return to high-demanding sports. However, there is a lack of systematic research regarding arthroscopic treatment followed by ligament repair for severe acute ankle sprain. The purpose of this study was to analyze the mid-term outcomes of arthroscopy followed by open anatomic lateral ankle ligament repair surgery for acute lateral ankle sprain and the impact of ligament rupture site on the outcomes.MethodsProfessional or amateur athletes with clinically- and radiologically-confirmed grade III acute lateral ankle ligament injuries undergoing ankle arthroscopy followed by open anatomic ligament repair between June 2007 and May 2017 were reviewed. Intra-articular lesions and the location of rupture were first examined under arthroscopy. Simple suture repair was performed for mid- substance ligament rupture (middle group), while suture repair with anchors were used for the ruptures near the ligament attachment site on the fibular (proximal group), talar or the calcaneal side (distal group). Outcomes were evaluated at final follow-up, including visual analog scale (VAS) pain score, American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, Tegner score, time to return to sports, resumption of pre-injury sports level, sprain recurrence and range of motion (ROM).ResultsA total of 117 patients were included for analysis, with a mean follow-up duration of 46.4 ± 16.1 months. There were 48 (41%) cases in the proximal group, 41 (35%) cases in the middle group and 28 (24%) cases in the distal group respectively. At final follow-up, all of the VAS score, AOFAS score and the Tegner score were significantly improved from the pre-operative level (p < 0.001). 12 (10%) patients complained of sprain recurrence during follow-up. 14 (12%) patients reported mild ROM restriction and 7 (6%) patients experienced transient skin numbness. The average time to return to pre-injury sports was 4.34 ± 1.11 months. The smallest proportion (86% ± 13%) of resumption of pre-injury sports level was reported from the distal group, compared with 93% ± 12% for the proximal group and 89% ± 14% for the middle group (p = 0.037). Time to return to sports was significantly longer for the distal group, with an average of 4.59 ± 1.27 months compared to 3.99 ± 1.09 months for the proximal group and 4.58 ± 0.90 months for the middle group (p = 0.009).ConclusionsAnkle arthroscopy followed by open anatomic ligament repair is a reliable procedure for patients requiring return to high demanding sports after severe acute ankle sprains. Distal rupture near the talar or calcaneal end was associated with delayed return-to-sport and inferior performance in resuming pre-injury sports level.

Evidence-based treatment choices for acute lateral ankle sprain: a comprehensive systematic review.

Lateral ankle sprains are very common injuries that can be treated with different strategies. The aim of the present systematic review was to provide a comprehensive analysis on the treatment of acute lateral ankle sprains to clarify the possible differences in outcome between surgical and conservative management, different external supports, and different rehabilitation protocols. A literature search on three different topics was carried out on PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science databases on June 25th, 2021. The main objective of the literature search was to identify the randomized trials comparing: (1) surgery to conservative management, (2) different external supports, and (3) different rehabilitation protocols for the treatment of acute lateral ankle sprains. Two investigators extracted independently relevant data from each paper and assessed the quality of the trials using the Cochrane Risk of Bias Assessment. A total of 12 studies for the first topic, 8 for the second one and 4 for the last one were included in this review. 8 out of 12 RCTs demonstrated a superior outcome and better socio-economic impact of conservative treatment compared to surgical management. In the other two comparisons, due to the wide variety of braces used and the different rehabilitation protocols, inconclusive results were obtained. Conservative treatment should be the first choice for severe acute lateral ankle sprains, as it provides satisfactory functional outcomes without the risks and costs of surgery. It was not possible to identify the best external support, but a preference toward flexible braces emerged since they allow an earlier return to daily activities. The paucity of studies comparing different rehabilitation protocols precluded the possibility of defining the ideal one.

Utilizing Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (rTMS) to Relieve Pain Associated with Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS) Type II: A Case Report

Background: Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS) is a poorly understood phenomenon, frequently presenting as pain out of proportion to an underlying injury, and often refractory to treatment. Although CRPS is typically limited to a single limb, it has been reported to spread to other regions of the body. Emerging reports advocate the use of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) in treatment of pain conditions, including neuropathic pain. We report the case of a 33-year-old military member who developed refractory widespread CRPS after a severe ankle sprain.

Superficial peroneal nerve entrapment in ankle sprain in childhood and adolescence

Traumatic injuries of the ankle are the most common injuries in sports. Up to 40% of patients who have undergone inversion ankle sprain report residual symptoms. The primary purpose of the study is to evaluate the incidence of SPN entrapment as consequence of acute severe inversion ankle sprain in children and adolescents; the secondary is to report the diagnostic pathway and the results after surgical treatment. From 2000 to 2015 were reviewed to summarize patients under the age of 15 years treated for a first episode of severe inversion ankle sprain. Cases with persistent symptoms (more than 3 months) indicative for SPN neuropathy were then identified. Instrumental investigations were recovered and a pre-operative assessment of pain (VAS) was recorded. Patients were evaluated at minimum of 1-year post-operative follow-up. 981 acute ankle sprains have been evaluated. 122 were considered severe according to van Dijk criteria. 5 patients were considered affected by neuropathy of the SPN. All patients underwent surgery consisting in neurolysis and capsular retention and ligament reconstruction. At 25 months of follow-up AOFAS moved from 57.6 to 98.6. The study highlights a previously unreported condition of perineural fibrosis of the superficial peroneal nerve at the level of the ankle following first acute severe inversion ankle sprain in children.

Chronic ankle instability has no correlation with the number of ruptured ligaments in severe anterolateral sprain: a systematic review and meta-analysis.

Despite being a significant public health problem, ankle sprains' prognostic factors are largely unknown. This review aimed to systematically analyze the literature on acute ankle sprains to compare the prognosis of a combined anterior talofibular (ATFL) and calcaneofibular (CFL) ligaments rupture with an isolated ATFL rupture in terms of progression to chronic ankle instability and other clinical outcomes. The databases for Pubmed, CENTRAL and Web of Science were searched. Clinical studies reporting the prognostic effect of combined ATFL-CFL rupture versus an isolated ATFL rupture in conservatively treated ankle sprains, with a minimum follow-up of 12months, were eligible for inclusion. Only studies with a reliable diagnostic method for anterolateral ankle ligaments evaluation, namely ultrasonography, magnetic resonance imaging, arthrography or stress tenography, were included. The relative risk (RR), along with the 95% confidence interval (CI), was used to quantitatively analyze the main outcomes. Nine papers were selected for inclusion, of which five were suitable for quantitative analysis. None of them found a statistically significant correlation between ligament injury severity and progression to chronic instability. Concerning other clinical outcomes, three studies found a statistically significant correlation between a combined ligament injury and a worse clinical prognosis. From the quantitative analysis, the relative risk (RR) of chronic ankle instability in a single versus a combined ligament rupture showed no significant difference. A significant statistical correlation between a combined ATFL-CFL rupture and chronic ankle instability, compared to an isolated ATFL rupture, was not found. There is, however, fair evidence showing a worse clinical outcome score in the combined ruptures, as well as a decreased return to full sports activities. The use of reliable and accessible diagnostic methods to determine the number of ruptured ligaments might have a role in managing severe ankle sprains. Level III.

Does the Spraino low-friction shoe patch prevent lateral ankle sprain injury in indoor sports? A pilot randomised controlled trial with 510 participants with previous ankle injuries

BackgroundLateral ankle sprains are common in indoor sports. High shoe–surface friction is considered a risk factor for non-contact lateral ankle sprains. Spraino is a novel low-friction patch that can be...

Sensory changes associated with severe ankle sprain

An intact afferent nervous system is important in providing the feedback necessary for effective motor control. Joint injury may influence afferent feedback and, if the lower limb is involved, lead to a decrease in stability. Accordingly, the association between severe ankle sprain and local sensory deficit was examined. Measurements of vibration perception, two point discrimination and balance in one legged standing were made in subjects who had sustained a previous severe unilateral ankle sprain and in subjects with no history of lower limb injury. Comparisons between the two groups showed that subjects with previous severe ankle sprain had sensory deficits in all measured variables between the injured and non-injured sides. Such differences between sides was not apparent in the non-injured group. This study highlights that local sensory deficits are associated with severe ankle sprain.

Bayesian adaptive designs for multi-arm trials: an orthopaedic case study

BackgroundBayesian adaptive designs can be more efficient than traditional methods for multi-arm randomised controlled trials. The aim of this work was to demonstrate how Bayesian adaptive designs can be constructed for multi-arm phase III clinical trials and assess potential benefits that these designs offer.MethodsWe constructed several alternative Bayesian adaptive designs for the Collaborative Ankle Support Trial (CAST), which was a randomised controlled trial that compared four treatments for severe ankle sprain. These designs incorporated response adaptive randomisation (RAR), arm dropping, and early stopping for efficacy or futility. We studied the operating characteristics of the Bayesian designs via simulation. We then virtually re-executed the trial by implementing the Bayesian adaptive designs using patient data sampled from the CAST study to demonstrate the practical applicability of the designs.ResultsWe constructed five Bayesian adaptive designs, each of which had high power and recruited fewer patients on average than the original designs target sample size. The virtual executions showed that most of the Bayesian designs would have led to trials that declared superiority of one of the interventions over the control. Bayesian adaptive designs with RAR or arm dropping were more likely to allocate patients to better performing arms at each interim analysis. Similar estimates and conclusions were obtained from the Bayesian adaptive designs as from the original trial.ConclusionsUsing CAST as an example, this case study shows how Bayesian adaptive designs can be constructed for phase III multi-arm trials using clinically relevant decision criteria. These designs demonstrated that they can potentially generate earlier results and allocate more patients to better performing arms. We recommend the wider use of Bayesian adaptive approaches in phase III clinical trials.Trial registrationCAST study registration ISRCTN, ISRCTN37807450. Retrospectively registered on 25 April 2003.

A 14-Day Recovery and Physical Activity Levels After an Ankle Sprain in Mice.

Research is needed to find ways of improving physical activity after a lateral ankle sprain. To investigate the effects of a prolonged rest period on lifelong activity after a surgically induced ankle sprain. Controlled laboratory study. Research laboratory. A total of 18 male CBA/J mice (age at surgery = 7 weeks). We transected the anterior talofibular ligament and calcaneofibular ligament of the right hindlimb. Each mouse was placed in a separate cage and randomized into 1 of 3 groups of 6 mice each. A running wheel was placed in each cage at 3 days, 7 days, or 14 days after surgery. Physical activity was measured daily. Daily duration (ie, time spent on the wheel), distance, and running speed were examined using analysis of variance (group × age) with repeated measures at 15-week periods to approximate the first 3 quartiles of the lifespan. From weeks 3 to 15 after surgery, we observed no differences in duration, distance, or running speed among groups (P > .05). From weeks 16 to 30, distance (F2,14 = 0.57, P = .041) and running speed (F2,14 = 0.93, P = .01) were greater in the 14-day group than in the 3- and 7-day groups. From weeks 31 to 45, duration (F2,14 = 0.74, P = .02), distance (F2,14 = 0.95, P = .009), and running speed (F2,14 = 1.05, P = .007) were greater in the 14-day group than in the 3- and 7-day groups. Our findings suggest that the longer recovery period of 14 days can increase activity levels throughout the lifespan after a severe ankle sprain. Rest after an ankle injury is critical to restoring physical activity levels across the lifespan. Rest and time away from exercise after an ankle sprain may be necessary to restore physical activity to normal, uninjured levels.

Surgical Treatment of Subfibular Ossicle in Children: A Retrospective Study of 36 Patients with Functional Instability.

To evaluate the surgical management of a symptomatic subfibular ossicle after severe ankle sprain with functional instability and pain sequelae in children. We analyzed 36 patients complaining of functional instability without laxity, 1 year after an ankle inversion trauma associated with the observation of a subfibular ossicle. We systematically suggested the open excision of the residual ossicles, followed by 6 weeks of immobilization and proprioceptive physiotherapy. Seventeen of them, constituting the "resection" group accepted this surgical approach. The remaining 19 patients, the "control" group, received only rehabilitative care. The American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society ankle pain and function score was evaluated in both groups. The mean latest follow-up was 4 years and 4 months (range, 1 y 8 mo to 14 y 7 mo). A significant improvement of the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society score was observed and was significantly higher in the resection group with a mean gain of 31 points (SD=31.8), versus 7 points (SD=7) in the control group (P<0.001). We conclude that in the absence of objective laxity, excision of the os subfibulare appears as a simple and effective technique in the treatment of posttraumatic functional instability and ankle pain. Level IV-retrospective case-control study.

The Role of the Calcaneofibular Ligament in Chronic Ankle Pain Following Severe Ankle Sprains

Category: Sports Introduction/Purpose: Lateral ankle pain persists in 10%-20% of patients following severe ankle sprains treated non-operatively. The authors hypothesize that the peroneal tendons may become interposed between the ruptured ends of the calcaneofibular ligament (CFL). Though previously visualized and noted in the literature, no studies have evaluated this lesion biomechanically and anatomically. The purpose of this study is to demonstrate that following a severe lateral ankle sprain that the interposition of the peroneal tendons between the ruptured ends of the CFL can occur. Methods: Eight fresh-frozen cadaveric lower extremity specimens (defrosted) were secured by the foot to a wooden board in the method of Lauge-Hansen. A manual inversion force was then applied to the ankle, both with the ankle in plantar flexion and also in a neutral position to approximate a severe ankle sprain. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was then performed on each ankle. Each specimen was then dissected to observe the integrity and relationship of the lateral ankle structures. Results: Four of the eight specimens sustained CFL tears as viewed by MRI and confirmed through anatomic dissection. One of the four specimens with a CFL tear had a mid substance ligament rupture with the proximal half of the ligament positioned superficial to the peroneal tendon complex. This relationship was observed using the MRI. Conclusion: Creating severe lateral ankle sprain produced ruptures of the CFL with interposition of the peroneal tendon complex between the torn ends of the ligament was seen and identified. This phenomenon may prevent primary ligament healing of the CFL and may be a contributing factor in the chronic ankle pain of non-surgically treated lateral ankle sprains. Perhaps surgical intervention should be considered if clinical suspicion exists, such as with a Stener lesion of the hand.

Cost-Utility Analyses in Foot &amp; Ankle Surgery

Category: Other Introduction/Purpose: Orthopedic surgery lies at the forefront of the initiative to deliver value-based care. As a result, cost utility analyses have gained increased importance in the orthopedic literature. While other authors have previously reviewed the quality of US-based cost-utility analyses in orthopedic trauma, spine, sports, and arthroplasty, a similar analysis specific to foot and ankle surgery has not been performed. As such, the practicing foot and ankle surgeon does not yet have a comprehensive analysis of the available cost-utility analyses or the quality of the available evidence. The purpose of this study was to perform a systematic review of cost-utility analyses in foot and ankle surgery. Methods: A systematic review of foot and ankle studies was conducted to identify cost-utility based analyses published between 2000 and 2017. Of 687 studies screened by abstract, eight cost-utility foot and ankle studies were identified that met inclusion criteria and were scored by the Quality of Health Economic Studies instrument for overall quality. Results: Of the eight studies that met inclusion criteria, four were published in the U.S. Regarding topic, three examined end-stage arthritis, two examined diabetic foot ulcers, two examined ankle fractures and one examined ankle sprains. Cost-effective interventions identified by these studies included total ankle arthroplasty over ankle fusion or nonoperative treatment, adjunctive hyperbaric oxygen therapy for diabetic foot ulcers, suture button fixation over syndesmotic screws for unstable supination-external rotation type IV ankle fractures, and below knee cast and fracture boot immobilization over tubular bandages for acute severe ankle sprains respectively. The mean Quality of Health Economic Studies scores for these studies was 81.9 with interquartile range, 25th percentile score of 74.8 to 75th percentile score of 86. Conclusion: Despite the increasing focus on value-based care delivery, there are few foot and ankle cost-utility analyses in the current literature. Nonetheless, the quality of existing analyses is high as rated by the Quality of Health Economic Studies and certain interventions have been identified as cost-effective as highlighted above. The findings of this review can be used to help design future analyses in order to best demonstrate the cost-effectiveness of foot and ankle interventions.

38 A comparison of two interventions in the treatment of severe ankle sprains and distal fibular avulsion fractures: a patient perspective

Stable ankle injuries are highly prevalent in Emergency Departments across the UK. Appropriate management to enable patients to experience a smooth recovery and prevent chronic ankle instability or reoccurrence is...

Is CFL Repair Necessary During Lateral Ankle Ligament Stabilization? A Biomechanical Comparison of Repair Techniques

There was a greater increase in stiffness following combined ATFL and CFL repair compared to ATFL repair alone. The intact stiffness of the ankle is highly predictive of repair stiffness and load to failure. Restoring CFL plays a relevant role in lateral ligament repair, however sufficient time for ligament healing should be allowed before inversion stresses are applied. Lateral ankle sprain is a common athletic injury. At least 20% of patients with severe ankle sprains will develop chronic ankle instability, and possibly require surgical repair. The most common mechanism of injury in ankle sprain is ankle inversion with a plantar flexed foot. The ATFL is injured most frequently, and higher grade injuries result in rupture to the CFL as well. The standard for lateral ligament stabilization is direct repair of the ATFL by open or arthroscopic technique. However, implications and necessity of repairing the CFL are not well understood. The purpose of this study was to assess the impact of repairing the ATFL alone compared to repairing both the ATFL and CFL, in a biomechanical cadaver model. We hypothesized that repairing the CFL will add significant ankle and subtalar joint stability during weight-bearing ankle inversion compared to ATFL repair alone. Ten matched pairs of fresh frozen human cadaveric ankles were dissected to expose intact ATFL and CFL. Ankles were mounted to an Instron at 20° plantar flexion and 15° of internal rotation. Each ankle was loaded to body weight and then inverted from 0 to 20° for three cycles; torque was recorded and stiffness was calculated. Ankles then underwent sectioning of ATFL and CFL and were randomly assigned to ATFL only repair using two arthroscopic Broström all-soft anchors, or combined ATFL and CFL repair. Testing was repeated after repair to 20° of inversion, then load-to-failure (LTF). The predominant mode of failure (17/20) after repair was at the ligament/suture interface – there were no occurrences of anchor pull-out. There was an 11.7% increase in stiffness in combined repairs, and only a 1.6% increase in single repairs, compared to the complete injury condition, although this did not reach statistical significance (p=.158). The CFL failed at lower torque (p=.017) and rotation (p=.01) than the ATFL in combined repairs. However, there was no difference between groups in inversion degrees or torque at failure of the ATFL during LTF. There was a strong correlation (r=.74) with intact stiffness and stiffness after repair, across both groups, and a strong correlation (r=.77) with intact stiffness and ATFL torque in LTF testing, across both groups. In a biomechanical weight-bearing inversion model, we found a greater increase in stiffness following combined ATFL and CFL repair compared to ATFL repair alone, although this did not reach statistical significance. This added stability is likely due to complimentary contributions of the CFL, not augmented strength of the ATFL, since ATFL rotation and torque at LTF were unaffected by CFL repair. Intact specimen stiffness correlated strongly with both stiffness after repair, and LTF torque of ATFL. Thus, a patient’s inherent laxity or stiffness is likely a meaningful contributor to strength after repair. The CFL fails before the ATFL, potentially indicating its vulnerability immediately following repair. Restoring the CFL likely plays a relevant role in lateral ligament repair, however sufficient time for ligament healing should be allowed before inversion stresses are applied.