Procurement Of Services Research Articles

Analysis of the Effect of Using the SIPLah Application on User Satisfaction in Procuring Elementary School Books in Pangkalpinang City

The advancement of information technology has become more widespread across various sectors, particularly in education. The integration of information technology has increasingly simplified many aspects of human life. This study aims to evaluate the impact of the SIPLah (School Procurement Information System) application on user satisfaction in the procurement of books for elementary schools. SIPLah is a government-provided digital platform designed to streamline the procurement of goods and services within schools, promoting greater transparency, efficiency, and accountability. The research data was collected through surveys involving SIPLah users, such as school principals, teachers, and administrative staff engaged in book procurement. The study measured variables including ease of use, system reliability, procurement process speed, and user satisfaction with the procurement outcomes. The analysis revealed that the SIPLah application has a significant impact on user satisfaction. Among the factors studied, ease of use and system reliability had the most positive influence. However, some respondents reported technical challenges, such as delays in data updates and insufficient technical support. To enhance future user satisfaction, the study recommends improvements in technical services and system optimization.

Analisis Sengketa Wanprestasi dan Ganti Rugi dalam Kontrak Pengadaan Jasa Ditinjau dari Kitab Undang-Undang Hukum Perdata

Contract law plays a key role in trade and business. Failure to fulfill obligations in an agreement, known as default, can include non-fulfillment, delays, or performing actions not aligned with the agreement. The aggrieved party is entitled to seek compensation for the default. In a service agreement case resolved through arbitration, the Respondent was found to have defaulted. Despite both parties agreeing to all terms and performing the contract without objection, the Respondent was ordered to pay compensation under Article 1248 of the Civil Code, which includes the concept of "fraud." The author aims to analyze how default in service procurement is resolved through arbitration and whether the arbitral panel’s decision to impose compensation is justified according to the Civil Code and the contract. The research employs a normative legal approach, focusing on literature and statutory regulations. The findings show that both parties committed default, yet the arbitral panel only adjudicated the Respondent, as the Claimant was not counter-sued. Moreover, the Respondent's actions cannot be classified as fraud. The compensation imposed by the arbitral panel based on Article 1248 of the Civil Code should be seen as abuse of circumstances, not fraud..

Social Return on Investment of Musculoskeletal Physiotherapy in the National Health Service.

Social return on investment (SROI) may present a method for demonstrating the social value of healthcare interventions. It has not previously been measured in musculoskeletal (MSK) physiotherapy but is being used in the procurement and performance management of healthcare services. The aim of the study was to measure SROI in one provider of MSK physiotherapy in the United Kingdom's National Health Service (NHS). A retrospective single arm online survey-based service evaluation was carried out to calculate the SROI of an NHS adult MSK physiotherapy service using the Housing Association's Charitable Trust Social Value Calculator. 237 respondents (35.6%) completed the survey and a mean SROI of £4.13 for every £1 invested was demonstrated. There were sub-group variations based on symptom location and discharge location. This is the first time SROI has been calculated in an MSK physiotherapy setting. This service evaluation raises new questions about the variations observed in subgroups and the applicability of this methodology in individuals with MSK conditions who receive physiotherapy. MSK physiotherapy is an intervention which offers a positive SROI across a range of MSK conditions and contributes towards improved wellbeing. This is the first study to use the HACT Social Value Calculator when evaluating a physiotherapy service and further research is required to validate the results.

Enterprise Architecture Business Model Planning Using EAP Framework (Case Study: PT. Gempita Cahaya Makmur)

The advancement of technology in a company has an impact on improving business quality. From this observation, architectural planning is a part that is used to build alignment between business strategy and information technology. Architecture within the business domain illustrates how a company conducts business activities and functions to achieve the company's goals. Therefore, the company's business model architecture depicts the current state of architecture by identifying business needs and activities. From this study, the business role of PT. GEMPITA CAHAYA MAKMUR, a company engaged in the procurement of goods and services, especially in the field of wholesale office stationery, printing, photocopier sales, and photocopier and laptop rentals, which has customers from medium-sized companies, large companies, both private and government. The use of the Enterprise Architecture Planning or EAP framework focuses on business architecture. The purpose of this research is expected to produce a blueprint proposal that will be beneficial for PT. GEMPITA CAHAYA MAKMUR to plan the business model architecture that will become the foundation for the design phase of application architecture.

The operational impact of medicines shortages on pharmacy Procurement and Distribution (P&D) services at a large teaching hospital

Abstract Introduction There has been a nine-fold increase in medicines shortages in the UK over the last 5 years.1 The reasons are multifactorial including shortages in raw materials, as well as financial and geopolitical instability. The adverse impact on clinicians and patients is well documented however studies on the impact to P&D services is sparse. Aim This study aims to quantify the impact of increasing medicines shortages to P&D services who lead on sourcing and distributing alternative medicines to meet patient needs.1 Method The period between January 2021 and January 2024 of the Pharmacy “Drug Shortages Tracker” was reviewed by the P&D Specialist Pharmacist. Each Shortage was assigned at least one of eight potential managing solutions e.g. “Rationalising Usage” and “Sourcing Unlicensed Alternatives”. The time required to complete the tasks for each shortage was calculated using the following formula: [Sum of the Estimated Time to Complete Each Task* (minutes) x Duration of Shortage (weeks)] + Sum of the Estimated Time to Complete all ‘One Time Only’ Activities’* * Standardised times based on time in motion data [collected in June 2023] and feedback from specialist P&D staff. The data was recorded on a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet which had the following headings: Shortage, Method(s) of Resolution, Duration of Shortage and Total Time to Resolve. This study was deemed a service evaluation by the trust’s Research and Audit Group and therefore ethics approval was not required. Results All 332 shortages are included in the results totalling 1,841 hours of staff time. The year by year breakdown is as follows: From 2021 to 2022, 3 shortages accounting for 49 hours. From 2022 to 2023, an increase to 146 shortages accounting for 898 hours (18-fold increase from previous year). From 2023 to 2024, 183 shortages accounting for 894 hours. The number of shortages recorded per month was 0.24 from 2021 to 2022, 11.2 from 2022 to 2023 and 14 from 2023 to 2024. The mean time required to complete the P&D aspects of a single shortage was 332 minutes. With the most time consuming shortage requiring 1640 minutes in 2022. Discussion This increased volume of shortages nationally has put pressure on P&D services to allocate greater resources to support their management and maintain patient safety. P&D teams are assessed nationally on metrics relating to medicine expenditure.2 In practice, the core services that ensure medicines are available for patients’ takes precedent. The rising challenge of shortages poses a risk to the capacity of P&D teams to carry out both critical tasks and those relating to medicines expenditure. Notable limitations to this study include the numerous interpretations and definitions of shortages which produced inconsistent recordings within the trust3. This was exacerbated by changes to documentation procedures internally. As an example, the variable recording process in 2021 does not provide an accurate representation of the actual period. Other internal changes included the uptake of automated dispensing cabinets which added further complexity to shortage management. Conclusion The growing demands of shortages highlights the need for dedicated shortages teams.

Quality of Service in the Preparation of Population and Civil Registration Administration Documents at the Cirebon Regency Population and Civil Registration Office

Public Service Procurement is a task for the government in creating community welfare, for the creation of welfare in the community it is necessary to have quality in the implementation of these services, in this era of digitalization the government is expected to be able to implement technological advances by utilizing digitalization as an effort to improve services with easy access for the community. This study is aimed at finding out how the quality in the implementation of public services at the Cirebon Regency Population and Civil Registration Office, measuring the level of public satisfaction with the Cirebon Regency Population and Civil Registration Office, and finding out how to Improve the Quality of Public Services at the Cirebon Regency Population and Civil Registration Office. The research method used is a Qualitative Research Method with Questionnaire data collection techniques that are disseminated to the community in Cirebon Regency through Google Forms, Interviews with employees of the Cirebon Regency Population and Civil Registration Office, and Location Observation which is a place of service located at the Cirebon Regency Population and Civil Registration Office. Research shows that the quality of administrative document loading services at the Cirebon Regency Population and Civil Registration Office has not been maximized, improvements are needed to improve the quality of service. a) improving Facilities and Infrastructure that are Facilities in the Service process; b) hard skills training is needed in the implementation of E-Governance; c) There is a need for training on excellent service so that they know how to behave well and appropriately to maximize service to the community

PENGARUH PERENCANAAN ANGGARAN, PELAKSANAAN ANGGARAN, PENGADAAN BARANG DAN JASA, SERTA KOMPETENSI SUMBER DAYA MANUSIA TERHADAP PENYERAPAN ANGGARAN (STUDI PADA SATUAN KERJA BALAI JASA KONSTRUKSI WILAYAH V BANJARMASIN)

This research has five main purposes (1) to analyse whether budget planning partially has a significant effect on budget absorption, (2) to analyse whether partial implementation of the budget has a significant effect on absorption of the budget, (3) to analyse whether procurement of goods and services partially has a significant effect on absorption, (4) to analyse whether human resources competencies partially has a significant effect on budget absorption, and (5) to analyse whether budget planning, implementation budget, procurement of goods and services, and competence of human resources simultaneously have a significant effect on budget absorption.This research was carried out by the Work Unit of the Construction Service Center Region V Banjarmasin. Research method was descriptive quantitative. The population of this research was civil servants at Work Unit of Banjarmasin Region V Construction Service Center with the sample of 32 respondents using a purposive sampling technique. Methods of collecting data used surveys and questionnaires. The data analysis technique used the SPSS Version 25 for Window program.The results of research show that (1) budget planning has a partial and significant effect on budget absorption (2) budget execution has a partial significant effect on budget absorption, (3) goods and services have partial and significant effect on budget absorption, (4) human resources competencies have partial and insignificant effect on budget absorption, and (5) budget planning, budget execution, procurement of goods and services, and human resource competencies simultaneously have a significant effect on budget absorption.

Analisis penerapan sistem dan prosedur pengeluaran kas belanja langsung pada Badan Pendapatan Daerah Provinsi Sulawesi Utara

Implementing cash disbursement systems and procedures in accordance with applicable regulations is very important for government institutions in order to assess the effectiveness of the systems and procedures implemented and facilitate the cash disbursement process. The cash disbursement system and procedures are regulated in Minister of Home Affairs Regulation Number 77 of 2020 concerning Technical Guidelines for Regional Financial Management as well as being the main reference in managing regional cash at the Regional Revenue Agency of North Sulawesi Province. This research aims to analyze the implementation of systems and procedures for direct cash expenditure (LS) for the procurement of goods and services at the Regional Revenue Agency of North Sulawesi Province based on Minister of Home Affairs Regulation No. 77 of 2020. The type of research used is descriptive qualitative with data collection techniques through interviews, observation and documentation studies. The research results showed that the system and procedures for disbursing cash directly to the BAPENDA of North Sulawesi Province were running well in accordance with Minister of Home Affairs Regulation No. 77 of 2020.

Onrechmatige Daad and Default on Supreme Court Decision Number: Number: 1120 K / Pdt/2022 Jo. Number: 342 / Pdt / 2021 / PT MDN 342 / Pdt / 2021 / PT MDN.

Procurement agreements have a very important function in the development of the country's economy, the amount of state money involved in this agreement is very large. Failure to fulfill this feat is often the basis for the injured party not to execute the agreement. The existence of parties who do not run the agreement often arise disputes because there are parties who feel disadvantaged as a result of this. The purpose of this research is to: 1). Describe the form of unlawful acts and defaults in the implementation of the procurement of goods and services in the decision of the Supreme Court Number: 1120 K/Pdt/2022 Jo. Decision number: 342/Pdt/2021 / PT MDN, 2). Reviewing legal considerations by judges in Supreme Court decision number: 1120 K/Pdt/2022 Jo. Decision number: 342/Pdt/2021 / PT MDN, 3). Reviewing the legal settlement of disputes over the procurement of goods and services that are not in accordance with the agreement on the Supreme Court decision number: 1120 K/Pdt/2022 Jo. No.342 / Pdt / 2021 / PT MDN. This type of research is normative legal research the data source of this research is secondary data, which includes: primary legal materials, secondary legal materials and tertiary legal materials. The method of data collection using the study of literature and documents. Analysis of research data using normative analysis of research results obtained a conclusion that: 1). Form of tort and tort in the Procurement Agreement of goods and services with number: PJJ.04.04.01/05/07/2019/0104 about the procurement and installation of AC (Air Conditioner) at Garbarata Kualanamu Deli Serdang International Airport in the Supreme Court decision number: 1120 K/Pdt/2022 Jo. No.342/Pdt/2021/PT MDN is the plaintiff/comparator/applicant for Cassation I / respondent to Cassation II (CV. Marendal Mas) is considered to have done what was promised, but it is too late and the defendant/compared/applicant Cassation II / respondent Cassation I (PT. Angkasa Pura II Kualanamu Airport Branch) did not immediately make payment for the work that the plaintiff/comparator plaintiff/comparator/Cassation applicant I/Cassation respondent did, as a result CV. Marendal Mas felt aggrieved because he could not pay the working capital of the bank and declared bad loans and collateral threatened with auction.

Data Classification System for Economic Analysis after the Implementation of Separate Order Construction in the Firefighting System Installation Business

Data on the performance of the firefighting system installation business are scarce compared with other construction projects, such as electricity and information and communication projects, where separate order construction was previously practiced. This study aimed to obtain data on fire facility construction contracts by analyzing the current data, deriving improvement plans, and reviewing empirical studies on separate order construction from various construction projects, both domestically and internationally. An analysis of the data from Statistics Korea and the Public Procurement Service revealed an annual increase in the number and amount of firefighting system installation projects. In addition, the scale of the construction could be identified using separate order construction data. This study highlights cost reduction, shortened construction delay periods, and increased construction speed as the key economic review items. Based on these findings, a data classification system for the construction of firefighting facilities was proposed and categorized according to the project size, ordering organization, contractor, type of construction, construction period, and contract method.

Contingent payments in procurement interactions: Experimental evidence

A primary objective of creating competition among suppliers is the procurement of higher quality goods and services at lower prices. When procuring non-standard goods, it is often difficult to write a complete specification of desired quality in the contract. Thus, payments to suppliers cannot be perfectly conditioned on the quality provided. We develop a simple model to distil several real-world features and illustrate how contract structure within price priority competition jointly affects bid aggression and incentives for the provision of surplus-enhancing quality. We implement the contingent payments as probabilistic. The selected supplier’s payment is, according to a fixed probability, either their bid or a quality contingent amount that depends on the bid and an exogenous norm for allocating social surplus. We use a lab experiment to show that there is a ‘Goldilocks’ region for high quality in which the probability of quality contingent payment is large enough to incentivize provision, but not so large as to induce overly aggressive bidding. This implementation only relies upon preferences for maximizing one’s own profit and the rationality of backward induction. An experimental finding not predicted in our setting is that suppliers earn positive economic profits inside the Goldilocks region, which can be explained by suppliers’ risk aversion. The results have implications for the effective design of contingent payments in contracts.

Tinjauan Kriminologis Terhadap Korupsi Pengadaan Benih Bawang Merah Dikabupaten Malaka

Extraordinary Crime is a label given to the crime of corruption. This is because corruption can hamper the economic life of the nation and state. Therefore, the eradication of corruption cannot be handled in the usual way but through an extraordinary handling. Corruption is a serious problem that can threaten the continuity of the Indonesian nation, coupled with the fact that the perpetrators of corruption are officials of government agencies who have a duty to foster and serve the community for the fulfillment of justice and public welfare. One of the easy targets for people who commit corruption, namely officials of government agencies in launching their actions, is the procurement sector of government goods and services. As happened in the procurement of shallot seeds in Malaka Regency in the 2018 fiscal year involving government agency officials and private parties.The problem formulations in this study are: (1) Factors causing corruption in the procurement of government goods and services, namely the procurement of shallot seeds in Malaka Regency (2) The impact of corruption in the procurement of shallot seeds in Malaka Regency (3) Countermeasures to improve the process of procurement of government goods and services in Malaka Regency.The writing of this thesis uses a type of juridical-empirical research with a case approach method, so that it is based on applicable laws and regulations and data obtained in the field. The case approach taken in this research is related to the corruption case of shallot procurement in Malacca Regency in the 2018 fiscal year.The results of the study show that the factors causing corruption in the procurement of shallot seeds in Malaka Regency are the intention of the defendants, the existence of authority and the opportunity for corruption. The impact of corruption in the procurement of shallot seeds in Malaka Regency is a state loss of Rp. 4,770,725,000.00 (four billion seven hundred seventy million seven hundred twenty-five thousand rupiah), not only limited to state losses but also losses felt by the community and government agencies involved in the corruption case of shallot seed procurement, namely the Government Goods / Services Procurement Section at the Regional Secretariat of Malaka Regency and also the Agriculture and Food Security Office of Malaka Regency. Therefore, efforts to eradicate corruption in the procurement of goods and services of the Malaka district government are not only carried out by the government alone, but also involve the active role of the community in preventing corruption in the government goods/services procurement sector and also countermeasures involving cooperation between the Malaka district government and the Malaka district police.

Primary healthcare services' accessibility and quality under compulsory social health insurance in Kazakhstan.

Between 2020 and 2022, there was a rise in employment and entrepreneurial activity, despite some unemployment growth. In the Compulsory Social Health Insurance (CSHI), insured individuals, especially privileged and wage workers, increased. However, certain contributors, like those exempt from contributions and single social taxpayers, decreased, possibly due to legislative changes or the economic climate. The study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness and accessibility of medical services within the frameworks of Compulsory Social Health Insurance and the state Guaranteed volume of free medical care based on data regarding waiting times and the volume of services provided. This retrospective study analyzed data from 2020 to 2022 on patients receiving care under Kazakhstan's Mandatory Social Medical Insurance System (MSMIS) and Guaranteed Volume of Free Medical Care. Data included insurance status, labor market indicators, and medical service procurement. Descriptive statistics were calculated, and t-tests, with p-values indicating statistical significance (p < 0.05). It has been identified that overall, the execution of the plan for all types of medical care in Kazakhstan, including Almaty, reaches 100.0%, indicating sufficient financial support for the healthcare system. Rehabilitation centers and COVID-19 testing services stand out with shorter waiting times, whereas comprehensive diagnostic and advisory services require significantly longer waiting periods. The Guaranteed Volume of Free Medical Care typically offers a greater number of services with shorter waiting times compared to MSMIS, except for specialized medical care services in diagnosing new formations, where the Guaranteed Volume of Free Medical Care also has shorter waiting times but provides a greater number of services. The study has allowed us to identify differences in the availability and volume of medical services provided between Compulsory Social Health Insurance and the state Guaranteed volume of free medical care.

Tinjauan Hukum terhadap Persekongkolan Tender dalam Pengadaan Barang dan Jasa Pemerintah

Bid rigging, an illegal practice that undermines the principles of fair business competition, is widespread in government procurement of goods and services. The actions of business actors who deliberately control tender winners not only harm the state, but also deprive consumers of their right to obtain quality products and services at competitive prices. This research in-depth analyzes the practice of bid rigging in the perspective of Law Number 5 of 1999 concerning Prohibition of Monopolistic Practices and Unfair Business Competition, especially Article 22. Using a statutory approach, this research reveals the impact, forms and legal sanctions on the practice. bid rigging in the procurement of government goods and services. It is hoped that the results of this research can provide effective policy recommendations to prevent and take firm action against the practice of bid rigging, so as to create a healthy and fair business competition climate.

Financial Management of the Regional Public Service Agency at Puskesmas in Sumbawa District

The Local Public Service Agency is part of the local government unit, with a legal status not separate from the local government, which has a flexible financial management pattern in the form of flexibility to apply fair business practices to improve and develop services, as an exception to the provisions of financial management in general. The flexibility of financial management includes revenue and expenditure management, cash management, debt management, tariff determination, employee procurement, procurement of goods and services, and investment management. The pattern of flexible financial management still refers to the regulations that have been set, namely the Sumbawa Regent Regulation Number 5-year 2020 concerning guidelines for financial management of the regional public service agencies within the Sumbawa government. Regulations or policies that have been established by the Sumbawa Regency government to be implemented and adhered to in implementing BLUD financial management policies at Puskesmas are expected to improve and develop health services with transparency and accountability. Based on the description, the research problem is how far is the financial management of the Regional Public Service Agency (BLUD) at Puskesmas in the Sumbawa Regency region based on the Sumbawa Regent Regulation Number 5 of 2020 concerning guidelines for financial management of regional public service agencies within the scope of the Sumbawa Regency. Researchers used a qualitative descriptive method approach using interview and observation tools to collect data both directly and through document review. The data obtained were analyzed using Likert scale categorization, which consists of Very Good, Good, and Less Good. The findings of the research provided an overview that public policy evaluation is closely related to the level of compliance and readiness of Human Resources in conducting the financial management of the Regional Public Service Agency (BLUD) at Puskesmas in Sumbawa. The results of this study can complement Wiliam Dunn’s opinion or theory on public policy evaluation to emphasize the level of compliance and readiness of Human Resources in conducting public policy evaluations, which not only focus on the values and objectives but also the targets of a policy. Keywords: regional public service agency, policy evaluation, financial management

Модели цепей поставок и их классификация

The article discusses various models of supply chains of goods. The classification and models of supply chains are considered. The basic concepts and elements of supply chain management are revealed. The theoretical basis of the article is research conducted in such fields of knowledge as logistics and supply chain management. Logistics supply chains are an important element in the activities of any company. They include the planning, production and management of goods, services and information from the point of origin to the point of consumption. Supply chains coordinate complex patterns of movement and transportation, shipment and receipt, import and export operations, warehousing, inventory management, procurement, production planning and customer service.

Совершенствование процесса управления государственными закупками в подразделениях системы МВД России

Estimated indicators for three years, the same period is considered when forming a plan of financial and economic activities in autonomous and budgetary institutions. The principle of efficient use of budgetary funds for procurement of goods, works and services is fundamental in the budgetary process when forming expenditures in a public institution. The authors, reflecting the efficiency of using budgetary funds in procurement activities, guided by this principle, investigate the initial maximum contract price, proposed a metho-dology for forming the lowest contract price by introducing a correction factor.

The Internal and External Factors in Prevention of Procurement Fraud in Goods and Services Based on E-Procurement

The process of goods and services procurement within the government environment still has vulnerabilities to fraud, which necessitates proper handling. This study aims to identify the factors that can influence efforts to prevent fraud in the procurement of goods and services using an e-procurement system. The data for this research was obtained through the distribution of questionnaires to employees at the Procurement Services Unit (ULP) and the Regional Financial and Asset Management Agency (BPKAD) Office of Dompu Regency. The sampling method used in this study is purposive sampling. Furthermore, the research data were tested using multiple regression analysis. This study demonstrates that the variables of technology utilization, e-procurement, internal control systems, organizational culture, employee ethics, and religiosity can influence the prevention of fraud in the procurement of goods and services. The research findings can serve as a reference for evaluating the use of information technology through e-procurement and the application of internal control systems for optimal results. Additionally, it is important to consider human resources, specifically employees, in maintaining organizational culture, good ethics, and religious values as a foundation for actions in the workplace to avoid various deviant or unlawful behaviors.

Application of Blockchain in Procurement and Management of Building Services: A Critical and Systematic Review

Building services systems are essential for creating a comfortable and safe living environment in buildings. These are complex systems with high stakeholder involvement, a lengthy lifecycle, and high financial costs. This leads to building services systems having complex procurement and management (P&amp;M) requirements which create a multitude of challenges. Blockchain technology has emerged as a revolutionary digital technology under “Procurement 4.0”. The purpose of this paper is to investigate the applicability of blockchain technology for systematic procurement and management of building services. The science mapping method was used to systematically and quantitatively analyse 102 publications related to bibliographic records retrieved from Scopus and the Web of Science databases. This includes content analysis of the existing issues, current trends of technologies, and applicability of blockchain in the P&amp;M of building services. The results of the bibliometric analysis indicate that publications had grown significantly faster in 2021 related to the P&amp;M of building services with new technologies while there is a minimal collaboration of countries, organisations and authors in publishing research in this area. Further, it is observed that Building Information Modelling (BIM) is the main technology utilised in general P&amp;M. As a result of content analysis, a total of 28 issues that affect the performance of procurement and management of building services are identified. The paper critically evaluates blockchain technology in terms of peer-to-peer networks, hashing algorithms, public key cryptography, consensus mechanisms, smart contracts, and distributed ledger. It indicates that blockchain provides a perfect match for resolving these issues. The findings of the research will open a path to apply blockchain technology in building services. The study offers a readily available point of reference for practitioners, policymakers and research and development bodies.

The aid-corruption paradox in development: An examination of provinces in Indonesia

The relationship between aid and corruption remains ambiguous. On the one hand, aid may benefit a country if the aid management system runs efficiently and transparently. On the other hand, aid tends to create new problems, namely corruption, especially in developing countries. This research examines the aid-corruption paradox in Indonesian provinces from a spatial perspective. The data was obtained from the Indonesian Ministry of Finance, the National Development Planning Agency of Indonesia, the Corruption Eradication Commission of Indonesia, and the Electronic Procurement Service, referring to 34 Indonesian provinces between 2011 and 2019. The research applies the spatial panel method and uses Haversine distance to construct the weighted matrix. The spatial error model (SEM) is the best for Model 1 (Grants) and Model 2 (Loans) and the best corruption model in Model 3 (Gratification). The spatial autoregressive model (SAR) is the best approach for Model 4 (Public Complaints) and Model 5 (Corruption). The findings show that there is no spatial dependence between provinces in Indonesia in terms of grants or loans. However, corruption in Indonesia is widespread.