Self-assembling Protein Cages Research Articles

Design of a symmetry-broken tetrahedral protein cage by a method of internal steric occlusion.

Methods in protein design have made it possible to create large and complex, self-assembling protein cages with diverse applications. These have largely been based on highly symmetric forms exemplified by the Platonic solids. Prospective applications of protein cages would be expanded by strategies for breaking the designed symmetry, for example, so that only one or a few (instead of many) copies of an exterior domain or motif might be displayed on their surfaces. Here we demonstrate a straightforward design approach for creating symmetry-broken protein cages able to display singular copies of outward-facing domains. We modify the subunit of an otherwise symmetric protein cage through fusion to a small inward-facing domain, only one copy of which can be accommodated in the cage interior. Using biochemical methods and native mass spectrometry, we show that co-expression of the original subunit and the modified subunit, which is further fused to an outward-facing anti-GFP DARPin domain, leads to self-assembly of a protein cage presenting just one copy of the DARPin protein on its exterior. This strategy of designed occlusion provides a facile route for creating new types of protein cages with unique properties.

A suite of designed protein cages using machine learning and protein fragment-based protocols

Designed protein cages and related materials provide unique opportunities for applications in biotechnology and medicine, but their creation remains challenging. Here, we apply computational approaches to design a suite of tetrahedrally symmetric, self-assembling protein cages. For the generation of docked conformations, we emphasize a protein fragment-based approach, while for sequence design of the de novo interface, a comparison of knowledge-based and machine learning protocols highlights the power and increased experimental success achieved using ProteinMPNN. An analysis of design outcomes provides insights for improving interface design protocols, including prioritizing fragment-based motifs, balancing interface hydrophobicity and polarity, and identifying preferred polar contact patterns. In all, we report five structures for seven protein cages, along with two structures of intermediate assemblies, with the highest resolution reaching 2.0Å using cryo-EM. This set of designed cages adds substantially to the body of available protein nanoparticles, and to methodologies for their creation.

Protein Cages and Nanostructures Constructed from Protein Nanobuilding Blocks.

Protein cages and nanostructures are promising biocompatible medical materials, such as vaccines and drug carriers. Recent advances in designed protein nanocages and nanostructures have opened up cutting-edge applications in the fields of synthetic biology and biopharmaceuticals. A simple approach for constructing self-assembling protein nanocages and nanostructures is the design of a fusion protein composed of two different proteins forming symmetric oligomers. In this chapter, we describe the design and methods of protein nanobuilding blocks (PN-Blocks) using a dimeric de novo protein WA20 to construct self-assembling protein cages and nanostructures. A protein nanobuilding block (PN-Block), WA20-foldon, was developed by fusing an intermolecularly folded dimeric de novo protein WA20 and a trimeric foldon domain from bacteriophage T4 fibritin. The WA20-foldon self-assembled into several oligomeric nanoarchitectures in multiples of 6-mer. De novo extender protein nanobuilding blocks (ePN-Blocks) were also developed by fusing tandemly two WA20 with various linkers, to construct self-assembling cyclized and extended chain-like nanostructures. These PN-Blocks would be useful for the construction of self-assembling protein cages and nanostructures and their potential applications in the future.

Rapid Assembly and Prototyping of Biocatalytic Virus-like Particle Nanoreactors.

Protein cages are attractive as molecular scaffolds for the fundamental study of enzymes and metabolons and for the creation of biocatalytic nanoreactors for in vitro and in vivo use. Virus-like particles (VLPs) such as those derived from the P22 bacteriophage capsid protein make versatile self-assembling protein cages and can be used to encapsulate a broad range of protein cargos. In vivo encapsulation of enzymes within VLPs requires fusion to the coat protein or a scaffold protein. However, the expression level, stability, and activity of cargo proteins can vary upon fusion. Moreover, it has been shown that molecular crowding of enzymes inside VLPs can affect their catalytic properties. Consequently, testing of numerous parameters is required for production of the most efficient nanoreactor for a given cargo enzyme. Here, we present a set of acceptor vectors that provide a quick and efficient way to build, test, and optimize cargo loading inside P22 VLPs. We prototyped the system using a yellow fluorescent protein and then applied it to mevalonate kinases (MKs), a key enzyme class in the industrially important terpene (isoprenoid) synthesis pathway. Different MKs required considerably different approaches to deliver maximal encapsulation as well as optimal kinetic parameters, demonstrating the value of being able to rapidly access a variety of encapsulation strategies. The vector system described here provides an approach to optimize cargo enzyme behavior in bespoke P22 nanoreactors. This will facilitate industrial applications as well as basic research on nanoreactor-cargo behavior.

Relaxivity properties of magnetoferritin: The iron loading effect

Self-assembling ferritin protein cages have been used as a template for magnetic iron oxide nanoparticle synthesis within its 8nm cavity to be explored as a potential magnetic resonance imaging contrast agent. Here in, magnetic nanocores with various iron content were successfully synthesized using recombinant human H-chain ferritin (HFn) by a controlled mineralization reaction. r1 and r2 relaxivities of the synthesized magnetoferritin nanoparticles were measured and the effect of iron loading factor on the r1 and r2 relaxivity was investigated by using a quite large range of 10 different iron loadings per protein cage (500-5000) at 90MHz and 300MHz. The sample with the highest iron loading of 5329 Fe/cage has r2 value of 165.2mM-1s-1 and r1 value of 1.98mM-1s-1 at 300MHz. This high r2 value together with a very low protein and iron concentrations (0.03-0.2mg/mL and 0.15mM, respectively) renders magnetoferritin very effective T2 contrast agents. However, r1 values were found to be smaller than literature values suggesting that magnetoferritin may not serve as T1 contrast agent in MRI. Moreover, magnetoferritin showed an increase in r2 relaxivity with the iron loadings while r1 values have not been affected by the number of Fe atoms loaded as much as r2 values. This result also sheds light on understanding the formation mechanism of iron oxide core and its contribution on relaxation in MRI.

Design and structure of two new protein cages illustrate successes and ongoing challenges in protein engineering.

In recent years, new protein engineering methods have produced more than a dozen symmetric, self-assembling protein cages whose structures have been validated to match their design models with near-atomic accuracy. However, many protein cage designs that are tested in the lab do not form the desired assembly, and improving the success rate of design has been a point of recent emphasis. Here we present two protein structures solved by X-ray crystallography of designed protein oligomers that form two-component cages with tetrahedral symmetry. To improve on the past tendency toward poorly soluble protein, we used a computational protocol that favors the formation of hydrogen-bonding networks over exclusively hydrophobic interactions to stabilize the designed protein-protein interfaces. Preliminary characterization showed highly soluble expression, and solution studies indicated successful cage formation by both designed proteins. For one of the designs, a crystal structure confirmed at high resolution that the intended tetrahedral cage was formed, though several flipped amino acid side chain rotamers resulted in an interface that deviates from the precise hydrogen-bonding pattern that was intended. A structure of the other designed cage showed that, under the conditions where crystals were obtained, a noncage structure was formed wherein a porous 3D protein network in space group I21 3 is generated by an off-target twofold homomeric interface. These results illustrate some of the ongoing challenges of developing computational methods for polar interface design, and add two potentially valuable new entries to the growing list of engineered protein materials for downstream applications.

Nanoreactor Design Based on Self-Assembling Protein Nanocages.

Self-assembling proteins that form diverse architectures are widely used in material science and nanobiotechnology. One class belongs to protein nanocages, which are compartments with nanosized internal spaces. Because of the precise nanoscale structures, proteinaceous compartments are ideal materials for use as general platforms to create distinct microenvironments within confined cellular environments. This spatial organization strategy brings several advantages including the protection of catalyst cargo, faster turnover rates, and avoiding side reactions. Inspired by diverse molecular machines in nature, bioengineers have developed a variety of self-assembling supramolecular protein cages for use as biosynthetic nanoreactors that mimic natural systems. In this mini-review, we summarize current progress and ongoing efforts creating self-assembling protein based nanoreactors and their use in biocatalysis and synthetic biology. We also highlight the prospects for future research on these versatile nanomaterials.

Diversification of Protein Cage Structure Using Circularly Permuted Subunits.

Self-assembling protein cages are useful as nanoscale molecular containers for diverse applications in biotechnology and medicine. To expand the utility of such systems, there is considerable interest in customizing the structures of natural cage-forming proteins and designing new ones. Here we report that a circularly permuted variant of lumazine synthase, a cage-forming enzyme from Aquifex aeolicus (AaLS) affords versatile building blocks for the construction of nanocompartments that can be easily produced, tailored, and diversified. The topologically altered protein, cpAaLS, self-assembles into spherical and tubular cage structures with morphologies that can be controlled by the length of the linker connecting the native termini. Moreover, cpAaLS proteins integrate into wild-type and other engineered AaLS assemblies by coproduction in Escherichia coli to form patchwork cages. This coassembly strategy enables encapsulation of guest proteins in the lumen, modification of the exterior through genetic fusion, and tuning of the size and electrostatics of the compartments. This addition to the family of AaLS cages broadens the scope of this system for further applications and highlights the utility of circular permutation as a potentially general strategy for tailoring the properties of cage-forming proteins.

The C-terminal peptide of Aquifex aeolicus riboflavin synthase directs encapsulation of native and foreign guests by a cage-forming lumazine synthase

Encapsulation of specific enzymes in self-assembling protein cages is a hallmark of bacterial compartments that function as counterparts to eukaryotic organelles. The cage-forming enzyme lumazine synthase (LS) from Bacillus subtilis (BsLS), for example, encapsulates riboflavin synthase (BsRS), enabling channeling of lumazine from the site of its generation to the site of its conversion to vitamin B2 Elucidating the molecular mechanisms underlying the assembly of these supramolecular complexes could help inform new approaches for metabolic engineering, nanotechnology, and drug delivery. To that end, we investigated a thermostable LS from Aquifex aeolicus (AaLS) and found that it also forms cage complexes with the cognate riboflavin synthase (AaRS) when both proteins are co-produced in the cytosol of Escherichia coli A 12-amino acid-long peptide at the C terminus of AaRS serves as a specific localization sequence responsible for targeting the guest to the protein compartment. Sequence comparisons suggested that analogous peptide segments likely direct RS complexation by LS cages in other bacterial species. Covalent fusion of this peptide tag to heterologous guest molecules led to their internalization into AaLS assemblies both in vivo and in vitro, providing a firm foundation for creating tailored biomimetic nanocompartments for medical and biotechnological applications.

Multivalent Display of Antifreeze Proteins by Fusion to Self-Assembling Protein Cages Enhances Ice-Binding Activities.

Antifreeze proteins (AFPs) are small monomeric proteins that adsorb to the surface of ice to inhibit ice crystal growth and impart freeze resistance to the organisms producing them. Previously, monomeric AFPs have been conjugated to the termini of branched polymers to increase their activity through the simultaneous binding of more than one AFP to ice. Here, we describe a superior approach to increasing AFP activity through oligomerization that eliminates the need for conjugation reactions with varying levels of efficiency. A moderately active AFP from a fish and a hyperactive AFP from an Antarctic bacterium were genetically fused to the C-termini of one component of the 24-subunit protein cage T33-21, resulting in protein nanoparticles that multivalently display exactly 12 AFPs. The resulting nanoparticles exhibited freezing point depression >50-fold greater than that seen with the same concentration of monomeric AFP and a similar increase in the level of ice-recrystallization inhibition. These results support the anchored clathrate mechanism of binding of AFP to ice. The enhanced freezing point depression could be due to the difficulty of overgrowing a larger AFP on the ice surface and the improved ice-recrystallization inhibition to the ability of the nanoparticle to simultaneously bind multiple ice grains. Oligomerization of these proteins using self-assembling protein cages will be useful in a variety of biotechnology and cryobiology applications.

Symmetry and Computational Methods in the Design of Self‐Assembling Protein Materials

Nature is replete with self-assembling molecular structures having diverse cellular functions. Some of the largest and most sophisticated types are built from many copies of the same or similar protein molecules arranged following principles of symmetry. A long-standing engineering goal has been to design novel protein molecules to self-assemble into geometrically specific structures similar to the extraordinary structures that have evolved in Nature. Practical routes to this goal have been developed by using ideas in symmetry to articulate the minimum design requirements for achieving various types of symmetric architectures, including cages, extended two-dimensional layers, and three-dimensional crystalline materials. The key requirement is that two distinct self-associating interfaces, each conferring one element of rotational symmetry, have to be engineered into the protein molecule (or molecules), following particular geometric specifications. The main mathematical principle is that combining two separate symmetry elements into a single molecular entity produces a molecule that necessarily assembles into an architecture dictated by a symmetry group that is the product of the two simpler contributing symmetries. Recent experiments have demonstrated success using a variety of symmetry-based strategies. Strategic variations are emerging that differ from each other with respect to biophysical features such as flexibility vs rigidity in the assembled structures, and with respect to design aspects such as whether the protein interfaces are inherited from natural oligomeric proteins or are designed de novo by advanced computational methods. The success of these strategies has been proven by determining crystal structures of several giant, self-assembling protein cages and clusters (100–230 Å in diameter), created by design. The ability to create sophisticated supramolecular structures from designed protein subunits opens the way to broad applications in synthetic biology and nanotechnology. Design principles and strategies will be discussed, along with new results. Support or Funding Information Supported by NSF grant CHE-1332907. Crystal structure of a designed 24-subunit cubic protein cage, 225 Å in diameter, rendered with an imaginary 130 Å diameter sphere in its interior to emphasize its geometric properties (Lai, et al. 2014. Nat Chem. 6, 1065–71). [Figure composed using PyMol.]

Symmetry-Based Design and Structure of Self-Assembling Protein Cages and Nanomaterials

Nature is replete with self-assembling molecular structures having diverse cellular functions. The largest and most sophisticated types are built from many copies of one protein molecule (or a few distinct protein molecules) arranged following principles of symmetry. Well-studied viral capsids and lesser-known bacterial microcompartments provide examples of natural closed shell architectures. A long-standing engineering goal has been to design novel protein molecules to self-assemble into geometrically specific structures similar to the extraordinary structures evolved in Nature. Practical routes to this goal have been developed by using ideas in symmetry to articulate the minimum design requirements for achieving various types of symmetric architectures, including cages, extended two-dimensional layers, and three-dimensional crystalline materials. The key requirement is generally that two distinct self-associating interfaces have to be built into the designed protein molecule, following specific geometric specifications. Recent experiments have demonstrated success using two alternate strategies, one based on fusing together two simple oligomers (e.g. a dimer and a trimer) in a geometrically specific orientation, and one based on designing one new interface into a natural oligomer (which already bears one interface). The success of these strategies has been proven by determining crystal structures of several giant, self-assembling protein cages (100-200 Å in diameter), created by design. The ability to create sophisticated supramolecular structures from designed protein subunits opens the way to broad applications in synthetic biology. Design principles and strategies will be discussed, along with current successes.

Trimer-Based Design of pH-Responsive Protein Cage Results in Soluble Disassembled Structures

Limited studies have been done on the interactions between subunits of self-assembling protein cages. E2 protein cage from Bacillus stearothermophilus was investigated in this work to impart pH-sensitive disassembly profile. Key amino acids were identified at the intratrimer and intertrimer interfaces, and histidine residues were introduced to these key sites to probe for their influences on the E2 assembly. We found that both the intratrimer- and the intertrimer-modified mutant proteins have the same quaternary structures as the wild type (E2-WT) at physiological pH of 7.4. At pH 5.0, the intratrimer-modified protein maintained its spherical structure. In contrast, the intertrimer modified protein lost its integrity, as observed under the electron microscope, whereas it remained soluble and nondenatured. The identified interactions between the intertrimers are critical in the formation of E2 protein cage. The pH-controlled disassembly of E2 protein cage in soluble and nondenatured form make it promising in nanoscale applications, especially for drug delivery and release in the endosomes.

Iron-based ferritin nanocore as a contrast agent

Self-assembling protein cages have been exploited as templates for nanoparticle synthesis. The ferritin molecule, a protein cage present in most living systems, stores excess soluble ferrous iron in the form of an insoluble ferric complex within its cavity. Magnetic nanocores formed by loading excess iron within an engineered ferritin from Archaeoglobus fulgidus (AfFtn-AA) were studied as a potential magnetic resonance (MR) imaging contrast agent. The self-assembly characteristics of the AfFtn-AA were investigated using dynamic light scattering technique and size exclusion chromatography. Homogeneous size distribution of the assembled nanoparticles was observed using transmission electron microscopy. The magnetic properties of iron-loaded AfFtn-AA were studied using vibrating sample magnetometry. Images obtained from a 3.0 T whole-body MRI scanner showed significant brightening of T(1) images and signal loss of T(2) images with increased concentrations of iron-loaded AfFtn-AA. The analysis of the MR image intensities showed extremely high R(2) values (5300 mM(-1) s(-1)) for the iron-loaded AfFtn-AA confirming its potential as a T(2) contrast agent.

Role of surface charge density in nanoparticle-templated assembly of bromovirus protein cages.

Self-assembling icosahedral protein cages have potentially useful physical and chemical characteristics for a variety of nanotechnology applications, ranging from therapeutic or diagnostic vectors to building blocks for hierarchical materials. For application-specific functional control of protein cage assemblies, a deeper understanding of the interaction between the protein cage and its payload is necessary. Protein-cage encapsulated nanoparticles, with their well-defined surface chemistry, allow for systematic control over key parameters of encapsulation such as the surface charge, hydrophobicity, and size. Independent control over these variables allows experimental testing of different assembly mechanism models. Previous studies done with Brome mosaic virus capsids and negatively charged gold nanoparticles indicated that the result of the self-assembly process depends on the diameter of the particle. However, in these experiments, the surface-ligand density was maintained at saturation levels, while the total charge and the radius of curvature remained coupled variables, making the interpretation of the observed dependence on the core size difficult. The current work furnishes evidence of a critical surface charge density for assembly through an analysis aimed at decoupling the surface charge and the core size.

Design of a pH-Dependent Molecular Switch in a Caged Protein Platform

Self-assembling protein cages provide a wide range of possible applications in nanotechnology. We report the first example of an engineered pH-dependent molecular switch in a virus-like particle. By genetically manipulating the subunit-subunit interface of the E2 subunit of pyruvate dehydrogenase, we introduce pH-responsive assembly into a scaffold that is natively stable at both pH 5.0 and 7.4. The redesigned protein module yields an intact, stable particle at pH 7.4 that dissociates at pH 5.0. This triggered behavior is especially relevant for applications in therapeutic delivery.

Bioprospecting in high temperature environments; application of thermostable protein cages.

The first researchers to discover life in high temperature environments could not have anticipated the impact of their findings on the biotechnology industry. Today biotech companies benefit from multimillion dollar sales of enzymes originating from microorganisms that thrive in diverse high temperature environments. In this review we highlight significant advances made towards the development of self-assembling oligomeric protein cages from hyperthermophilic organisms as amenable platforms for diverse applications in biotechnology, electronics and medicine.