Selective CO2 Electroreduction Research Articles

Selective electroreduction of CO2 to value-added C1 and C2 products using MOF and COF-based catalysts

Selective electroreduction of CO2 to value-added C1 and C2 products using MOF and COF-based catalysts

Controllable Regulation of CO2 Adsorption Behavior via Precise Charge Donation Modulation for Highly Selective CO2 Electroreduction to Formic Acid.

The synthesis of value-added products via CO2 electroreduction (CO2ER) is of great significance, but the development of efficient and versatile strategies for the controllable selectivity tuning is extremely challenging. Herein, the tuning of CO2ER selectivity through the modulation of CO2 adsorption behavior is proposed. Using the constructed zeolitic MOF (SNNU-339), CO2 adsorption behavior is controllably changed from *CO2 to CO2* via the precise ligand-to-metal charge donation (LTMCD) regulation. It is confirmed that the high electronegativity of the coordinate ligand directly restricts the LTMCD, reduces the charge density on the metal sites, lowers the Gibbs free energy for CO2* adsorption, and leads to the transformation of CO2 adsorption mode from *CO2 to CO2*. Owing to the modulated CO2 adsorption behavior and regulated kinetics, SNNU-339 exhibits superior HCOOH selectivity (≈330% promotion, 85.6% Faradaic efficiency) and high CO2ER activity. The wide applicability of the proposed approach sheds light on the efficient CO2ER. This study provides a competitive strategy for rational catalyst design and underscores the significance of adsorption behavior tuning in electrocatalysis.

Delocalization State-Stabilized Znδ+ Active Sites for Highly Selective and Durable CO2 Electroreduction.

Zinc (Zn)-based materials are cost-effective and promising single-metal catalysts for CO2 electroreduction to CO but is still challenged by low selectivity and long-term stability. Undercoordinated Zn (Znδ+) sites have been demonstrated to be powerful active centers with appropriate *COOH affinity for efficient CO production However, electrochemical reduction conditions generally cause the inevitable reduction of Znδ+, resulting in the decline of CO efficiency over prolonged operation. Herein, a Zn cyanamide (ZnNCN) catalyst is constructed for highly selective and durable CO2 electroreduction, wherein the delocalized Zn d-electrons and resonant structure of cyanamide ligand prevent the self-reduction of ZnNCN and maintain Znδ+ sites under cathodic conditions. The mechanism studies based on density functional theory and operando spectroscopies indicate that delocalized Znδ+ site can stabilize the key *COOH intermediate through hard-soft acid-base theory, therefore thermodynamically promoting CO2-to-CO conversion. Consequently, ZnNCN delivers a CO Faradaic efficiency (FE) of up to 93.9% and further exhibits a remarkable stability lifespan of 96h, representing a significant advancement in developing robust Zn-based electrocatalysts. Beyond expanding the variety of CO2 reduction catalysts, this work also offers insights into understanding the structure-function sensitivity and controlling dynamic active sites.

Operando Spectroelectrochemistry Unravels the Mechanism of CO2 Electrocatalytic Reduction by an Fe Porphyrin.

Iron porphyrins are molecular catalysts recognized for their ability to electrochemically and photochemically reduce carbon dioxide (CO2). The main reduction product is carbon monoxide (CO). CO holds significant industrial importance as it serves as a precursor for various valuable chemical products containing either a single carbon atom (C1), like methanol or methane, or multiple carbon atoms (Cn), such as ethanol or ethylene. Despite the long-established efficiency of these catalysts, optimizing their catalytic activity and stability and comprehending the intricate reaction mechanisms remain a significant challenge. This article presents a comprehensive investigation of the mechanistic aspects of the selective electroreduction of CO2 to CO using an iron porphyrin substituted with four trimethylammonium groups in the para position [(pTMA)FeIII-Cl]4+. By employing infrared and UV/Visible spectroelectrochemistry, changes in the electronic structure and coordination environment of the iron center can be observed in real-time as the electrochemical potential is adjusted, offering new insights into the reaction mechanisms. Catalytic species were identified, and evidence of a secondary reaction pathway was uncovered, potentially prompting a re-evaluation of the nature of the catalytically active species.

Prompting CO2 Electroreduction to Ethanolby Iron Group Metal Ion Dopants Induced Multi-sites at the Interface of SnSe/SnSe2 p-n Heterojunction.

The development of non-copper-based materials for CO2 electroreduction to ethanol with high selectivity at large current density is highly desirable, but still a great challenge. Herein, we report iron group metal ions of M2+ (M = Fe, Co, or Ni)-doped amorphous/crystalline SnSe/SnSe2nanorod/nanosheet hierarchical structures (a/c-SnSe/SnSe2) for selective CO2 electroreduction to ethanol. Iron group metal ions doping induces multiple active sites at the interface of M2+-doped SnSe/SnSe2 p-n heterojunction, which strengthens *CO intermediate binding for further C-C coupling to eventual ethanol generation. As a representative, Fe9.0%-a/c-SnSe/SnSe2 exhibits an ethanol Faradaic efficiency of 62.7% and a partial current density of 239.0 mA cm-2 at -0.6 V in a flow cell. Moreover, it can output an ethanol Faradaic efficiency of 63.5% and a partial current density of 201.2 mA cm-2 with a full-cell energy efficiency of 24.1% at 3.0 V in a membrane electrode assembly (MEA) electrolyzer. This work provides insight into non-Cu based catalyst design for stabilizing the key intermediates for selective ethanol production from CO2 electroreduction.

Radiation-Synthesized Metal-Organic Frameworks with Ligand-Induced Lewis Pairs for Selective CO2 Electroreduction.

The electrochemical activation of inert CO2 molecules through C─C coupling reactions under ambient conditions remains a significant challenge but holds great promise for sustainable development and the reduction of CO2 emission. Lewis pairs can capture and react with CO2, offering a novel strategy for the electrosynthesis of high-value-added C2 products. Herein, an electron-beam irradiation strategy is presented for rapidly synthesizing a metal-organic framework (MOF) with well-defined Lewis pairs (i.e., Cu- Npyridinic). The synthesized MOFs exhibit a total C2 product faradic efficiency of 70.0% at -0.88V versus RHE. In situ attenuated total reflection Fourier transform infrared and Raman spectra reveal that the electron-deficient Lewis acidic Cu sites and electron-rich Lewis basic pyridinic N sites in the ligand facilitate the targeted chemisorption, activation, and conversion of CO2 molecules. DFT calculations further elucidate the electronic interactions of key intermediates in the CO2 reduction reaction. The work not only advances Lewis pair-site MOFs as a new platform for CO2 electrochemical conversion, but also provides pioneering insights into the underlying mechanisms of electron-beam irradiated synthesis of advanced nanomaterials.

Asymmetrically Coordinated Cu Dual-Atom-Sites Enables Selective CO2 Electroreduction to Ethanol.

Electrochemical reduction of CO2 (CO2RR) to value-added liquid fuels is a highly attractive solution for carbon-neutral recycling, especially for C2+ products. However, the selectivity control to preferable products is a great challenge due to the complex multi-electron proton transfer process. In this work, a series of Cu atomic dispersed catalysts are synthesized by regulating the coordination structures to optimize the CO2RR selectivity. Cu2-SNC catalyst with a uniquely asymmetrical coordinated CuN2-CuNS site shows high ethanol selective with the FE of 62.6% at -0.8V versus RHE and 60.2% at 0.9V versus RHE in H-Cell and Flow-Cell test, respectively. Besides, the nest-like structure of Cu2-SNC is beneficial to the mass transfer process and the selection of catalytic products. In situ experiments and theory calculations reveal the reaction mechanisms of such high selectivity of ethanol. The S atoms weaken the bonding ability of the adjacent Cu to the carbon atom, which accelerates the selection from *CHCOH to generate *CHCHOH, resulting in the high selectivity of ethanol. This work indicates a promising strategy in the rational design of asymmetrically coordinated single, dual, or tri-atom catalysts and provides a candidate material for CO2RR to produce ethanol.

Near-Electrode Concentration Gradients of Bicarbonate and pH within Porous Gas Diffusion Electrode for Optimized Selective CO2 Electroreduction to C2+ Products.

With high current density, the intense near-electrode CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) will cause the concentration gradients of bicarbonate (HCO3-) and hydroxyl (OH-) ions, which affect the selectivity of high-value C2+ products of the CO2RR. In this work, we simulated the near-electrode concentration gradients of electrolyte species with different porous Cu-based CLs (catalyst layers) of GDE (gas diffusion electrode) by COMSOL Multiphysics. The higher porosity CL exhibits a better buffer ability of local alkalinity while ensuring a sufficient supply of H+ and local CO2 concentration. Subsequently, the different porosity CLs were prepared by vacuum-thermal evaporation with different evaporation rate. Structural characterizations and liquid permeability tests confirm the role of the porous CL structure in optimizing concentration gradients. As a result, the high-porosity CL (Cu-HP) exhibits a higher C2+ Faraday efficiency (FE) of ∼79.61% at 500 mA cm-2 under 1 M KHCO3, far more than the FEC2+ ≈ 38.20% with the low-porosity sample (Cu-LP).

Stabilized Cu0 -Cu1+ dual sites in a cyanamide framework for selective CO2 electroreduction to ethylene

Electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide to produce high-value ethylene is often limited by poor selectivity and yield of multi-carbon products. To address this, we propose a cyanamide-coordinated isolated copper framework with both metallic copper (Cu0) and charged copper (Cu1+) sites as an efficient electrocatalyst for the reduction of carbon dioxide to ethylene. Our operando electrochemical characterizations and theoretical calculations reveal that copper atoms in the Cuδ+NCN complex enhance carbon dioxide activation by improving surface carbon monoxide adsorption, while delocalized electrons around copper sites facilitate carbon-carbon coupling by reducing the Gibbs free energy for *CHC formation. This leads to high selectivity for ethylene production. The Cuδ+NCN catalyst achieves 77.7% selectivity for carbon dioxide to ethylene conversion at a partial current density of 400 milliamperes per square centimeter and demonstrates long-term stability over 80 hours in membrane electrode assembly-based electrolysers. This study provides a strategic approach for designing catalysts for the electrosynthesis of value-added chemicals from carbon dioxide.

Mesostructure-Specific Configuration of *CO Adsorption for Selective CO2 Electroreduction to C2+ Products.

The multi-carbon (C2+) alcohols produced by electrochemical CO2 reduction, such as ethanol and n-propanol, are considered as indispensable liquid energy carriers. In most C-C coupling cases, however, the concomitant gaseous C2H4 product results in the low selectivity of C2+ alcohols. Here, we report rational construction of mesostructured CuO electrocatalysts, specifically mesoporous CuO (m-CuO) and cylindrical CuO (c-CuO), enables selective distribution of C2+ products. The m-CuO and c-CuO showed similar selectivity towards total C2+ products (≥76%), but the corresponding predominant products were C2+ alcohols (55%) and C2H4 (52%), respectively. The ordered mesostructure not only induced the surface hydrophobicity, but selectively tailored the adsorption configuration of *CO intermediate: m-CuO preferred bridged adsorption, whereas c-CuO favored top adsorption as revealed by in situ spectroscopies. Computational calculations unraveled that bridged *CO adsorbate is prone to deep protonation into *OCH3 intermediate, thus accelerating the coupling of *CO and *OCH3 intermediates to generate C2+ alcohols; by contrast, top *CO adsorbate is apt to undergo the favorable conventional C-C coupling process to produce C2H4. This work illustrates selective C2+ products distribution via mesostructure manipulation, and paves new path into the design of efficient electrocatalysts with tunable adsorption configuration of key intermediates for targeted products.

Rational Designing Microenvironment of Gas-Diffusion Electrodes via Microgel-Augmented CO2 Availability for High-Rate and Selective CO2 Electroreduction to Ethylene.

Efficient electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) requires advanced gas-diffusion electrodes (GDEs) with tunned microenvironment to overcome low CO2 availability in the vicinity of catalyst layer. Herein, for the first time, pyridine-containing microgels-augmented CO2 availability is presented in Cu2O-based GDE for high-rate CO2 reduction to ethylene, owing to the presence of CO2-phil microgels with amine moieties. Microgels as three-dimensional polymer networks act as CO2 micro-reservoirs to engineer the GDE microenvironment and boost local CO2 availability. The superior ethylene production performance of the GDE modified by 4-vinyl pyridine microgels, as compared with the GDE with diethylaminoethyl methacrylate microgels, indicates the bifunctional effect of pyridine-based microgels to enhance CO2 availability, and electrocatalytic CO2 reduction. While the Faradaic efficiency (FE) of ethylene without microgels was capped at 43% at 300mAcm-2, GDE with the pyridine microgels showed 56% FE of ethylene at 700mAcm-2. A similar trend was observed in zero-gap design, and GDEs showed 58% FE of ethylene at -4.0 cell voltage (>350mAcm-2 current density), resulting in over 2-fold improvement in ethylene production. This study showcases the use of CO2-phil microgels for a higher rate of CO2RR-to-C2+, opening an avenue for several other microgels for more selective and efficient CO2 electrolysis.

Copper Atom Pairs Stabilize *OCCO Dipole Toward Highly Selective CO2 Electroreduction to C2H4.

Deeply electrolytic reduction of carbon dioxide (CO2) to high-value ethylene (C2H4) is very attractive. However, the sluggish kinetics of C-C coupling seriously results in the low selectivity of CO2 electroreduction to C2H4. Herein, we report a copper-based polyhedron (Cu2) that features uniformly distributed and atomically precise bi-Cu units, which can stabilize *OCCO dipole to facilitate the C-C coupling for high selective C2H4 production. The C2H4 faradaic efficiency (FE) reaches 51% with a current density of 469.4 mA cm-2, much superior to the Cu single site catalyst (Cu SAC) (~0%). Moreover, the Cu2 catalyst has a higher turnover frequency (TOF, ~520 h-1) compared to Cu nanoparticles (~9.42 h-1) and Cu SAC (~0.87 h-1). In situ characterizations and theoretical calculations revealed that the unique Cu2 structural configuration could optimize the dipole moments and stabilize the *OCCO adsorbate to promote the generation of C2H4.

Anchoring Cs+ Ions on Carbon Vacancies for Selective CO2 Electroreduction to CO at High Current Densities in Membrane Electrode Assembly Electrolyzers.

Electrolyte cations have been demonstrated to effectively enhance the rate and selectivity of the electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR), yet their implementation in electrolyte-free membrane electrode assembly (MEA) electrolyzer presents significant challenges. Herein, an anchored cation strategy that immobilizes Cs+ on carbon vacancies was designed and innovatively implemented in MEA electrolyzer, enabling highly efficient CO2 electroreduction over commercial silver catalyst. Our approach achieves a CO partial current density of approximately 500 mA cm-2 in the MEA electrolyzer, three-fold enhancement compared to pure Ag. In situ Raman and theoretical analyses, combined with machine learning potentials, reveal anchored Cs induces an electric field that significantly promotes the adsorption of *CO2 - intermediates through performing muti-point energy calculations on each structure. Furthermore, reduced adsorption of *OH intermediates effectively hampers competing hydrogen evolution reaction, as clarified by disk electrode experiments and density functional theory studies. Additionally, coupling our system with commercial polysilicon solar cells yields a notable solar-to-CO energy conversion efficiency of 8.3 %. This study opens a new avenue for developing effective cation-promoting strategy in MEA reactors for efficient CO2RR.

(Invited) Multimodal Operando Studies of Dynamic Cu Nanocatalysts for CO2 Electroreduction

In an era of shifting the energy paradigm from fossil fuels to renewable energy, CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) emerges as a promising approach to covert greenhouse gas into valuable chemical fuels and close the carbon cycle for a sustainable energy supply. Since Cu remains the sole element for CO2RR to multicarbon products (C2+), significant efforts have been devoted to developing Cu electrocatalysts with higher selectivity and activity. However, the complex nature of active sites and the intrinsic structures under reaction conditions have remained largely elusive due to the lack of operando/in situ methods.1-3 In our previous studies, we reported that small Cu nanoparticles (sub-10 nm NPs) showed superior C2+ superior C2+ selectivity, relative to the larger sized Cu NPs, especially at low overpotentials.4,5 In this work, we present a comprehensive operando correlative study of dynamic evolution during the life cycle of a family of monodisperse Cu NP ensemble electrocatalysts under CO2RR.1 Operando electrochemical liquid-cell scanning transmission electron microscopy (EC-STEM) and 4D-STEM resolves microscopic dynamic morphological and structural evolution at the nm scale. Correlated operando high-energy-resolution fluorescence-detector (HERFD) X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS)6 reveals dynamic macroscopic changes in valence states and coordination environment. Statistical analysis of interparticle dynamics was probed by operando resonant soft X-ray-based small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS).2 The operando correlative strategies, described herein, elucidates the longstanding enigmatic nature of Cu active sites as metallic Cu nanograins for selective CO2 electroreduction (Fig. 1). The strategy described herein can serve as a general platform to resolve the electrocatalytic interface of nanoparticle catalysts under real-time operating conditions across multiple time and length scales, thus serving the fundamental understanding necessary to development of many other electrochemical reactions for renewable energy technologies.

Selective CO2 Electroreduction to Multi-Carbon Products on Organic-Functionalized CuO Nanoparticles by Local Micro-Environment Modulation

HighlightsDeveloping surface-functionalized catalysts with exceptional activity and selectivity for the electrocatalytic CO2RR to C2+ products under neutral electrolyte.A remarkable C2+ FE of nearly 90% at an unprecedented current density of 300 mA cm−2 and maintain high FE (> 80%) at the wide current density performance (100–600 mA cm−2) in neutral environments using a flow cell as well as MEA electrolyzer.Mechanical study reveals that reducing the coverage of coordinated K·H2O water increased the probability of intermediate reactants (CO) interacting with the surface, thereby promoting efficient C–C coupling and enhancing the yield of C2+ products.

Anionic Metal-Organic Framework Derived Cu Catalyst for Selective CO2 Electroreduction to Hydrocarbons.

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs)-related Cu materials are promising candidates for promoting electrochemical CO2 reduction to produce valuable chemical feedstocks. However, many MOF materials inevitable undergo reconstruction under reduction conditions; therefore, exploiting the restructuring of MOF materials is of importance for the rational design of high-performance catalyst targeting multi-carbon products (C2). Herein, a facile solvent process is choosed to fabricate HKUST-1 with an anionic framework (a-HKUST-1) and utilize it as a pre-catalyst for alkaline CO2RR. The a-HKUST-1 catalyst can be electrochemically reduced into Cu with significant structural reconstruction under operating reaction conditions. The anionic HKUST-1 derived Cu catalyst (aHD-Cu) delivers a FEC2H4 of 56% and FEC2 of ≈80% at -150mAcm-2 in alkaline electrolyte. The resulting aHD-Cu catalyst has a high electrochemically active surface area and low coordinated sites. In situ Raman spectroscopy indicates that the aHD-Cu surface displays higher coverage of *CO intermediates, which favors the production of hydrocarbons.

Hierachical Aerogel-Supported Cu-Sn-Ox Solid Solutions for Highly Selective CO2 Electroreduction and Zn-CO2 Batteries.

The electrochemical CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) into high-value carbon compounds such as CO and HCOOH is a promising strategy for the utilization and conversion of emitted CO2. However, the selectivity of the CO2RR for HCOOH is typically less than 90% and operates within a narrow voltage range, which limits its practical application. Herein, we propose a novel heterostructural aerogel as a highly efficient electrocatalyst for CO2RR to HCOOH. This catalyst consists of Cu-Sn-Ox solid solutions embedded in a reduced graphene oxide matrix (Cu-Sn-Ox/rGO). The incorporation of Cu2+ into the SnO2 matrix enhances HCOOH production by improving the adsorption of the *OCHO intermediate and inhibiting H2 evolution, as confirmed by in situ measurements and computational studies. As a result, Cu-Sn-Ox/rGO achieves a remarkable Faradaic efficiency (FE) of up to 91.4% for HCOOH and maintains high selectivity over a broad operating voltage range (-0.8 to -1.1 V). Additionally, the assembled Zn-CO2 batteries demonstrated an excellent power density of 1.14 mW/cm2 and exceptional stability for over 25 h.

Highly Selective CO2 Electroreduction to C2H4 Using a Dual-Sites Cu(II) Porphyrin Framework Coupled with Cu2O Nanoparticles via a Synergetic-Tandem Strategy.

Low *CO coverage on the active sites is a major hurdle in the tandem electrocatalysis, resulting in unsatisfied C2H4 production efficiencies. In this work, we developed a synergetic-tandem strategy to construct a copper-based composite catalyst for the electroreduction of CO2 to C2H4, which was constructed via the template-directed polymerization of ultrathin Cu(II) porphyrin organic framework incorporating atomically isolated Cu(II) porphyrin and Cu(II) bipyridine sites on a carbon nanotube (CNT) scaffold, and then Cu2O nanoparticles were uniformly dispersed on the CNT scaffold. The presence of dual active sites within the Cu(II) porphyrin organic framework create a synergetic effect, leading to an increase in local *CO availability to enhance the C-C coupling step implemented on the adjacent Cu2O nanoparticles for further C2H4 production. Accordingly, the resultant catalyst affords an exceptional CO2-to-C2H4 Faradaic efficiency (FEC2H4) of 71.0 % at -1.1 V vs reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE), making it one of the most effective copper-based tandem catalysts reported to date. The superior performance of the catalyst is further confirmed through operando infrared spectroscopy and theoretic calculations.

Selective and stable CO2 electroreduction at high rates via control of local H2O/CO2 ratio

Controlling the concentrations of H2O and CO2 at the reaction interface is crucial for achieving efficient electrochemical CO2 reduction. However, precise control of these variables during catalysis remains challenging, and the underlying mechanisms are not fully understood. Herein, guided by a multi-physics model, we demonstrate that tuning the local H2O/CO2 concentrations is achievable by thin polymer coatings on the catalyst surface. Beyond the often-explored hydrophobicity, polymer properties of gas permeability and water-uptake ability are even more critical for this purpose. With these insights, we achieve CO2 reduction on copper with Faradaic efficiency exceeding 87% towards multi-carbon products at a high current density of −2 A cm−2. Encouraging cathodic energy efficiency (>50%) is also observed at this high current density due to the substantially reduced cathodic potential. Additionally, we demonstrate stable CO2 reduction for over 150 h at practically relevant current densities owning to the robust reaction interface. Moreover, this strategy has been extended to membrane electrode assemblies and other catalysts for CO2 reduction. Our findings underscore the significance of fine-tuning the local H2O/CO2 balance for future CO2 reduction applications.

Modulating the Active Sites of VS2 by Mn Doping for Highly Selective CO2 Electroreduction to Methanol in a Flow Cell.

Methanol is a valuable liquid C1 product in CO2 electroreduction (CO2ER); however, it is hard to achieve high selectivity and a large current density simultaneously. In this work, we construct Mn2+-doped VS2 multilayer nanowafers applied in a flow cell to yield methanol as a single liquid product to tackle this challenge. Mn doping adjusts the electronic structure of VS2 and concurrently introduces sulfur vacancies, forming a critical *COB intermediate and facilitating its sequential hydrogenation to methanol. The optimal Mn4.8%-VS2 exhibits methanol Faradic efficiencies of more than 60% over a wide potential range of -0.4 to -0.8 V in a flow cell, of which the maximal value is 72.5 ± 1.1% at -0.6 V along with a partial current density of 74.3 ± 1.1 mA cm-2. This work opens an avenue to rationally design catalysts for engineering C1 intermediates toward CO2ER to a single liquid methanol in a flow cell.