Successful establishment of desired species during restoration is challenging in drylands. Much research has focused on the importance of the critical life stages such as germination and emergence, but factors influencing survival through the seedling stages of perennial grasses may be equally important. We asked whether seedling defoliation by insects and/or mammals could cause restoration failure. We quantified the degree of defoliation on seedlings of common perennial grass species at 46 restoration sites throughout Oregon, Idaho, and Nevada, and calculated survival probabilities during the first growing season after planting. At each site, we excluded small mammals and insects for 6 weeks and compared defoliation and survival probabilities with seedlings in controls without exclusions. Seedlings were classified as either: large perennial grasses (LPG), primarily from the Triticeae tribe, or Bluegrasses (Poa spp.). Defoliation of LPG reduced seedling survival, but the effect was small compared to the influence of meteorological variables, such as precipitation and temperature. Based on bite patterns, most defoliation resulted from insects. Only a small percentage of vegetation was removed (36% of individuals were defoliated, mean = 13.2% vegetation removal). Defoliation of bluegrasses was less common than that of LPG seedlings, with only 16% experiencing defoliation, primarily from insects (mean = 4.3% vegetation removal). Some defoliation did occur within the exclusion treatments, but the effect of defoliation on seedling survival did not appear to interact with treatment. Based on the results of this study, seedling herbivory is unlikely to be a major factor in restoration failure in the Northern Great Basin.