Bacterial cellulose (BC) is a cellulosic biopolymer produced by specific acetic acid bacteria during kombucha fermentation. In this study, bacterial cellulose-producing strains were isolated from four different global kombucha SCOBY samples obtained from markets in the Netherlands, America, China, and Iran. The strains were identified using biochemical and molecular techniques. The ability of species to produce BC was evaluated under both static and stirred fermentation conditions. Seven dominant strains from the Acetobacteraceae family and the genus of Komagataeibacter and Gluconacetobacter were identified and submitted to NCBI gene bank archives: K. xylinus CH1, K. sucrofermentans IR2, K. intermedius IR3, K. cocois AM2, K. sucrofermentans NE4, K. cocois NE6, and G. liquefaciens NE7. Among these, K. intermedius IR3, isolated from local Iranian SCOBY, exhibited the highest BC production yield at 5.733 ± 0.170 gL−1 under static fermentation conditions. On the other hand, K. xylinus CH1, from Chinese SCOBY, had the highest yield under stirred conditions, producing 12.689 ± 0.808 gL−1 of BC. The BC production yield of both K. xylinus CH1 and K. intermedius IR3 under stirred conditions was 3 and 1.3 times more than static conditions, respectively. Despite the yield differences, static fermentation demonstrated superior physicochemical characteristics; such as moisture content, water holding capacity, and crystallinity degree, compared to stirred. Therefore, depending on the intended application in industry and specific criteria, both products could serve as functional substitutes in food and medicine sectors.