Superconducting rf surface resistance measurements were made on oxidized Nb cavities that had been warmed for a few minutes to temperatures between 250 and 300° C. Warmed oxide layers were further studied using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, Auger electron spectroscopy and secondary electron emission yield measurements. Warming usually reduced the temperature-dependent (BCS) part of the surface resistance by 10–20% while, for warming temperatures near 300° C, the low-temperature residual surface resistance increased by as much as 70 nΩ. Surface spectroscopy measurements showed that, at temperatures between 200 and 250° C, the oxide layer was chemically altered but remained surface-segregated; between 250 and 300° C, however, surface oxygen dissolved into the Nb bulk. Changes in the BCS resistance were consistent with a model based on a shortening of the electron mean free path by oxygen that had diffused into the Nb metal and based on the theoretical dependence of BCS resistance on electron mean free path. No specific cause for the increased residual resistance could be positively identified, although oxygen-induced surface roughening is a possibility.
Read full abstract