Predatory Sea Stars Research Articles

Abalone recruitment patterns before and after sea urchin barrens formation in northern California: incorporating climate change

ABSTRACT Understanding the recruitment dynamics of invertebrates in kelp forests is critical to informing climate-ready restoration. Here we examine abalone and sea urchin recruitment (3–20 mm in size) patterns in northern California across a period of drastic change. Annual surveys were conducted before, during and after the MHW (2014–2016), the loss of a major predatory sea star (2012–2016) and the collapse of a bull kelp forest in 2014. Divers surveyed artificial reef recruitment modules (n = 12) over 20 years in an area that once supported dense bull kelp, Nereocystis leutkeana, forests and the world's largest recreational abalone fishery. From 2016 to 2022, we tracked the decline of red abalone, Haliotis rufescens, recruitment and the rise of purple sea urchin, Strongylocentrotus purpuratus, recruitment. Adult densities of purple sea urchins increased as did newly settled sea urchins (<3 mm), while adult and newly settled red abalone declined. Eight years after the kelp forest collapse, red abalone recruitment remained low and sea urchin recruitment continued to increase. Recruitment patterns can inform both abalone restoration targets and sea urchin dynamics as part of a more holistic kelp forest recovery plan that is responsive to climate change drivers.

The temperate marine Peruvian Province: How history accounts for its unusual biota.

The Peruvian Province, from 6° S in Peru to 42° S in Chile, is a highly productive coastal marine region whose biology and fossil record have long been studied separately but never integrated. To understand how past events and conditions affected today's species composition and interactions, we examined the role of extinction, colonization, geologic changes to explain previously unrecognized peculiar features of the biota and to compare the Peruvian Province's history to that of other climatically similar temperate coasts. We synthesized all available data on the benthic (or benthically feeding) biota, with emphasis on fossilizable taxa, for the interval from the Miocene (23-5.4 Ma) and Pliocene (5.4-2.5 Ma) to the present. We outline the history of ecological guilds including primary producers, herbivores, predators, and suspension-feeders and document patterns of extinction, colonization, and geographic restriction. We identify twelve unusual attributes of the biota, most of which are the result of repeated episodes of extinction. Several guilds present during the Miocene and Pliocene are not represented in the province today, while groups such as kelps and perhaps intertidal predatory sea stars are relative newcomers. Guilds on soft bottoms and in sheltered habitats were severely affected by extinction, whereas those on hard bottoms were most affected by colonists and held their own in diversity. The Peruvian Province has not served as a biogeographic refuge, in contrast to the coasts of Australasia and Argentina, where lineages no longer present in the Peruvian Province survive. The loss of sheltered habitats since the Pliocene explains many of the present-day peculiarities of the biota. The history of the province's biota explains its unique attributes. High productivity, a rich Southern Hemisphere heritage, and colonization from the north account for the present-day composition and unusual characteristics of the biota.

Juvenile waiting stage crown-of-thorns sea stars are resilient in heatwave conditions that bleach and kill corals.

The juveniles of predatory sea stars can remain in their recruitment-nursery habitat for some time before their ontogenetic shift to the adult habitat and diet. These small juveniles are vulnerable to a range of factors with their sensitivity amplified by climate change-driven ocean warming. We investigate the thermal tolerance of the waiting stage herbivorous juveniles of the keystone coral predator, the crown-of-thorns sea star (COTS, Acanthaster sp.), in context with the degree heating weeks (DHW) model that predicts coral bleaching and mass mortality. In temperature treatments ranging from +1 to 3°C in prolonged heatwave acclimation conditions, the juveniles exhibited ~100% survival in DHW scenarios that trigger coral bleaching (4 DHW), resulting in mass mortality of corals (8 DHW) and extreme conditions well beyond those that kill corals (12 DHW). This indicates that herbivorous juvenile COTS are far more resistant to heatwave conditions than the coral prey of the adults. The juveniles exhibited higher activity (righting) and metabolic rate after weeks in increased temperature. In separate acute temperature experiments, the upper thermal limit of the juveniles was 34-36°C. In a warming world, juvenile COTS residing in their coral rubble nursery habitat will benefit from an increase in the extent of this habitat due to coral mortality. The juveniles have potential for long-term persistence as herbivores as they wait for live coral to recover before becoming coral predators, thereby serving as a proximate source of COTS outbreaks on reefs already in a tenuous state due to climate change.

Nearshore subtidal community response during and after sediment disturbance associated with dam removal

Dam removal is used increasingly to restore aquatic ecosystems and remove unnecessary or high-risk infrastructure. As the number of removals increases, there is a growing understanding about the hydrologic, geomorphic, and ecological responses to these removals. Most dam removal studies, however, focus on river and watershed responses to dam removal. The removal of two dams on the Elwha River provided a unique opportunity to characterize the response of nearshore (coastal) ecosystems. We conducted SCUBA surveys between 2011 and 2022 to quantify trajectories of change in a nearshore ecosystem during and after dam removal. We focused on the degree to which the abundances of kelp, benthic invertebrates, and fish changed in response to patterns of sediment fluxes during and after dam removal. Our findings point to two pathways of response depending on the disturbance mechanism and species type. Sites with persistent sediment deposition were characterized by wholesale community changes that did not recover to a before dam removal condition. Instead, the sites were colonized by new species that were largely absent prior to dam removal. Sites that experienced high turbidity but lacked persistent seafloor deposition were primarily characterized by a reduction in the abundance of kelp and other algae during dam removal and a rapid recovery after sediment flux to the nearshore declined. Dam removal influences on invertebrates and fish at these sites were more variable, benefiting some species and disadvantaging others. In addition to dam removal, sea star wasting syndrome and a marine heatwave exerted distinct controls on subtidal communities during the same period. The loss of the predatory sea star Pycnopodia helianthoides was associated with gains in some of its prey species, and kelp community changes reflected regional trends in ocean temperature and kelp abundance. The results presented here have important implications for understanding the response of marine ecosystems to future dam removals and similar sediment perturbation events.

Community-managed coral reef restoration in southern Kenya initiates reef recovery using various artificial reef designs

Monitoring of reef restoration efforts and artificial reefs (ARs) has typically been limited to coral fragment survival, hampering evaluation of broader objectives such as ecosystem recovery. This study aimed to determine to what extent AR design influences the ecological recovery of restored reefs by monitoring outplanted coral fragments, benthic cover, coral recruitment and fish and invertebrate communities for two years. Four AR designs (16 m2), unrestored controls and natural reef patches as reference (n = 10) were established in Mkwiro, Kenya. ARs consisted either of concrete disks with bottles, layered concrete disks, metal cages or a combination thereof. A mixture of 18 branching coral species (mainly Acropora spp.) was outplanted on ARs at a density of 7 corals m-2. After two years, 60% of all outplanted fragments had survived, already resulting in coral cover on most ARs comparable (though Acropora-dominated) to reference patches. Coral survival differed between ARs, with highest survival on cages due to the absence of crown-of-thorns sea star predation on this design. In total, 32 coral genera recruited on ARs and recruit densities were highest on reference patches, moderate on concrete ARs and low on cages. ARs and reference patches featured nearly twice the fish species richness and around an order of magnitude higher fish abundance and biomass compared to control patches. Fish abundance and biomass strongly correlated with coral cover on ARs. AR, reference and control patches all had distinct fish species compositions, but AR and reference patches were similar in terms of trophic structure of their fish communities. Motile invertebrates including gastropods, sea urchins, sea cucumbers and sea stars were present at ARs, but generally more abundant and diverse at natural reference patches. Taken together, all studied ecological parameters progressed towards reef ecosystem recovery, with varying influences of AR design and material. We recommend a combination of metal cages and layered concrete ARs to promote high fragment survival as well as natural coral recruitment. Ultimately, a longer period of monitoring is needed to fully determine the effectiveness reef restoration as conservation tool to support coral reef ecosystem recovery.

Predators regulate the taxonomic structure of mixed Mytilus edulis L. and M.trossulus Gould settlements in the shallow waters of the White Sea

Cryptic mussel species Mytilus edulis (Me) and M.trossulus (Mt) form mixed settlements in shallow waters of the White Sea. The proportion of Mt and Me in local settlements varies in broad limits but the factors regulating taxonomic composition of mixed populations are poorly understood. Present study focuses on the assessment of the sea star (Asterias rubens) predation influence on the Mt-Me ratio in natural habitats. For this purpose, we’ve conducted a series of field experiments. For mussels placed on experimental units (ceramic plates submerged in starfish-infested habitats), we’ve estimated a probability of being eaten by starfish. We’ve constructed a linear model that includes several predictors which may influence the probability of being eaten (starfish biomass, mussel size, mussel species, prey abundance, Mt-Me ratio on experimental units and abundance of conspecifics). The analysis has revealed that the probability of being eaten expectedly increases with sea stars’ biomass increasing, but it is higher for Mt in comparison with Me. This indicates Mt as a preferable prey. Negative correlations between the probability of being eaten and shell size, number of conspecifics and mussel abundance were also revealed. No significant dependence on Mt-Me ratio was found. Additionally, we’ve taken field samples which revealed a significant decrease in the proportion of Mt in mussel patches after a massive starfish attack. This indicates that starfish ate out Mt as its preferable prey. These results show that predators can contribute to the regulation of taxonomic composition of mixed Mt-Me settlements in the White Sea.

Sunflower sea star predation on urchins can facilitate kelp forest recovery.

The recent collapse of predatory sunflower sea stars (Pycnopodia helianthoides) owing to sea star wasting disease (SSWD) is hypothesized to have contributed to proliferation of sea urchin barrens and losses of kelp forests on the North American west coast. We used experiments and a model to test whether restored Pycnopodia populations may help recover kelp forests through their consumption of nutritionally poor purple sea urchins (Strongylocentrotus purpuratus) typical of barrens. Pycnopodia consumed 0.68 S. purpuratus d-1, and our model and sensitivity analysis shows that the magnitude of recent Pycnopodia declines is consistent with urchin proliferation after modest sea urchin recruitment, and even small Pycnopodia recoveries could generally lead to lower densities of sea urchins that are consistent with kelp-urchin coexistence. Pycnopodia seem unable to chemically distinguish starved from fed urchins and indeed have higher predation rates on starved urchins owing to shorter handling times. These results highlight the importance of Pycnopodia in regulating purple sea urchin populations and maintaining healthy kelp forests through top-down control. The recovery of this important predator to densities commonly found prior to SSWD, whether through natural means or human-assisted reintroductions, may therefore be a key step in kelp forest restoration at ecologically significant scales.

Steller’s Sea Cow and Kelp Forest Regeneration in the North Pacific

Modern ecosystems are almost universally degraded relative to their past counterparts, from the Pleistocene to the present day. Thus, modern ecosystems may serve as poor guides to conservation actions. Conservation paleobiology is well-suited to address this challenge through enhanced understanding of systems dynamics during past periods of greater species and functional diversity, abundances, and resilience. However, past and present ecosystem dynamics must be integrated to model the future impacts of conservation actions. Here we propose a three-step, Past-Present-Future (PPF) methodology rooted in mathematical modeling. First, construct a model of primary species and interactions of the present-day ecosystem, including biotic and abiotic components. Second, integrate historical and/or paleontological data into the model to investigate past states and processes of the ecosystem, with an emphasis on critical elements (e.g., ecological engineer species) that are no longer present. Third, integrate analyses from the first two steps to predict putative future dynamics and states, and use these to make testable predictions regarding specific conservation interventions. We illustrate this approach with a study investigating impacts of the now-extinct Steller’s sea cow on north Pacific giant kelp forests. The model indicates that the historical system was distinct from the modern, with differing abundances of giant kelp and understory algae. Furthermore, the familiar kelp-dominated state is metastable, capable of rapid transitions to an urchin-dominated state if perturbed by extreme hydrodynamic events, disease-driven reductions of seastar predation, or disease coupled to extreme warming events. We explore the possibility of increasing the resilience of modern forests by artificially recreating at least some of the ecological impacts of sea cows, accounting for metabolic requirements, estimates of abundance based on recent analyses of ancient DNA, and trophic impact.

Testing habitat suitability for shellfish restoration with small‐scale pilot experiments

AbstractThe global loss in ecosystem engineers has initiated calls for restoration, which includes the UN declaration of 2021–2030 as the decade of ecosystem restoration. As researchers dive into this decade it is important to consider the current state of an ecosystem to ensure restoration success. Pilot‐scale restoration has been recommended by global guidelines and standards as an effective starting point for restoration to provide valuable initial information to increase efficiency and success of subsequent larger‐scale restoration. To test habitat suitability, 4 t of green‐lipped mussels were placed onto three 2.25 m2plots at five locations with differing benthic environments and assessed over 2 years. This study had a mean of 85% mussel survival at four of the five locations, while the restored shellfish in one location were completely extirpated, most likely by sea star predation. This pilot‐scale restoration revealed location‐specific differences that have implications for ensuring larger‐scale restoration success, including mussel survival, density, and health, and recommends a timeframe of at least 18 months to properly assess habitat suitability. Overall, the results validated the efficacy of using small‐scale pilot experiments to test habitat suitability and optimize location selection to maximize success and efficiency of larger‐scale restoration efforts.

Quantitative biogeography: Decreasing and more variable dynamics of critical species in an iconic meta‐ecosystem

AbstractEcosystem stability has intrigued ecologists for decades, and the realization that the global climate was changing has sharpened and focused this interest. One possible early warning signal of decreasing stability is increasing variability in ecosystems over time with increasing climate variability. Determining climate change effects on community stability, however, requires long‐term studies of structure and underlying dynamics, including bottom‐up and top‐down effects in natural ecosystems. Although relevant datasets were rare in the early years of community ecology, such information has increased in recent decades. We investigated spatiotemporal changes in mean and variability of ecological subsidies (nutrients, phytoplankton, prey colonization), performance metrics of a dominant space occupier (mussels) and its primary predator (sea stars), and sea star predation rates on mussels in relation to climatic oscillations, temperature, and disease on rocky shores. The research involved annually repeated multiyear (~1999–2018), multisite (13 sites nested within five regions along ~260 km of the Oregon coast) observations, measurements, and experiments. We analyzed associations between environmental variables and ecological performance of key elements of the sea star‐mussel‐dominated mid intertidal system. We found that upwelling declined in some regions, but became more variable across all study regions. Air and water temperatures oscillated, but their mean and variation increased through time, with peak values coinciding with the 2014–2016 combined El Niño and Marine Heat Wave. Ecological subsidies generally declined during the study period but increased in variability. Excepting growth rate, mussel (Mytilus californianus) performance (condition index, reproductive output) generally decreased and became more variable. Primarily due to a sea star wasting epidemic, reproductive output of the top predator Pisaster ochraceus decreased and became more variable, and predation rate on mussels decreased. Analyses indicated that the primary drivers of these changes were temperature‐related environmental factors. As declining means and increasing variability of ecological performances can typify destabilizing ecosystems, and environmental trends are toward ever more stressful conditions, the outlook for this iconic ecosystem is discouraging. Immediate and rapid action to mitigate and ultimately reverse climate change likely is the only option available to prevent an irreversible shift in the future of this, and most other ecosystems.

Effects of ocean acidification and ocean warming on the behavior and physiology of a subarctic, intertidal grazer

The global ocean is expected to both acidify and warm concurrently; thus, multiple-stressor manipulative experimentation is an emergent area of study that ultimately aims to examine the individual and interactive effects of these factors on marine organisms. We characterized the physiological responses to acidification and warming of the intertidal grazer Lottia scutum, and examined how these ocean change variables influenced predator-prey dynamics with Evasterias troschelii, a key sea star predator. Specifically, we conducted a laboratory experiment where we exposed limpets to factorial combinations of temperature (11 and 15°C) and pH (7.6 and 8.0), and measured effects on thermal tolerance, metabolic rate, cortisol concentrations, and behavioral responses to the predator. We found that ocean warming (OW) decreased the critical thermal maxima (CTmax) and increased cortisol levels in L. scutum, whereas ocean acidification (OA) increased the mass-specific metabolic rate in this species. Additionally, we found that there was no significant effect of OA or OW on the anti-predator behavior of L. scutum when exposed to E. troschelii. These results highlight the need for future studies to integrate multidisciplinary experimental designs (i.e. behavior and physiology) that span multiple levels of biological organization to make ecologically relevant predictions for how marine organisms will respond to ocean change.

Impact of the extinct megaherbivore Steller's sea cow (Hydrodamalis gigas) on kelp forest resilience

Giant kelp forests off the west coast of North America are maintained primarily by sea otter (Enhydra lutris) and sunflower sea star (Pycnopodia helianthoides) predation of sea urchins. Human hunting of sea otters in historical times, together with a marine heat wave and sea star wasting disease epidemic in the past decade, devastated these predators, leading to widespread occurrences of urchin barrens. Since the late Neogene, species of the megaherbivorous sirenian Hydrodamalis ranged throughout North Pacific giant kelp forests. The last species, H. gigas, was driven to extinction by human hunting in the mid-eighteen century. H. gigas was an obligate kelp canopy browser, and its body size implies that it would have had a significant impact on the system. Here, we hypothesize that sea cow browsing may have enhanced forest resilience. We tested this hypothesis with a mathematical model, comparing historical and modern community responses to marine heat waves and sea star wasting disease. Results indicate that forest communities were highly resistant to marine heat waves, yet susceptible to sea star wasting disease, and to disease in combination with warming. Resistance was greatest among systems with both sea cows and sea otters present. The model additionally predicts that historical communities may have exhibited delayed transitions after perturbation and faster recovery times. Sea cow browsing may therefore have enhanced resilience against modern perturbations. We propose that operationalizing these findings by mimicking sea cow herbivory could enhance kelp forest resilience.

Evidence of increased mussel abundance related to the Pacific marine heatwave and sea star wasting

AbstractMussels occupy a key middle trophic position in nearshore food webs linking primary producers to predators. Climate‐related environmental changes may synergistically combine with changes in predator abundance to affect intertidal ecosystems. We examined the influence of two major events on mussel (Mytilus trossulus) abundance in the northern Gulf of Alaska: the recent Pacific marine heatwave (PMH, 2014–2016) and an outbreak of sea star wasting (SSW). We investigated how mussel abundance changed since the onset of SSW and whether the density of predatory sea stars or PMH‐related temperature metrics explain variation in mussel abundance. Sea stars and mussels were surveyed since 2005 approximately annually in four regions of the northern Gulf of Alaska: Katmai (KATM), Kachemak Bay (KBAY), Kenai Fjords (KEFJ) and western Prince William Sound (WPWS). Mussel percent cover in the mid‐intertidal increased 1–3 years after declines in sea stars at all regions and in the low‐intertidal at KATM, KBAY, and KEFJ, but not at WPWS. After the onset of SSW, large (≥20 mm length) mussel density and mussel bed width increased at KATM but not the other regions. Total mussel densities, including recruits, did not differ before and after the onset of SSW. The total number of sea stars significantly explained variation in mussel metrics, but the proportions of the three sea star species examined did not. We did not find strong evidence for direct effects of temperature on mussels. The effects of the PMH and the SSW outbreak appear to have combined, with increased temperatures indirectly benefiting mussels in concert with relaxed top‐down pressure from sea stars, allowing for increased mussel abundance. Changing mussel abundance may affect intertidal local productivity and the abundance or performance of other nearshore consumers of mussels.

The effect of ocean acidification on the escape behaviour of the sea star Parvulastra exigua to its sea star predator Meridiastra calcar

Ocean acidification (OA) driven by sea water uptake of anthropogenic atmospheric CO2 has broad deleterious effects on marine species including modified behavioural interactions such as between predators and prey. Predatory sea stars are key species in many marine ecosystems and often elicit defensive responses in their prey. This study investigated the effect of elevated CO2 on the escape response of the sea star Parvulastra exigua to its sea star predator Meridiastra calcar. In response to touch by M. calcar, P. exigua exhibits a distinct fleeing response. The escape response of P. exigua with respect to velocity and escape trajectory was investigated after both species were acclimated in OA conditions. At pHT 7.6 and 7.8 velocity and escape trajectory of the fleeing response of P. exigua did not differ from that seen in the ambient treatment. However, there was a delay in the time that P. exigua started to flee with the initiation time being 2.8 times slower (10 vs 28 s) at pHT 7.6. This delay may increase the vulnerability of P. exigua to predation by M. calcar and have ecological effects with respect to the role of this species as an algal grazer on rocky shores of southeast Australia where these sea star species co-occur.

Low-pH seawater alters indirect interactions in rocky-shore tidepools.

Ocean acidification is expected to degrade marine ecosystems, yet most studies focus on organismal‐level impacts rather than ecological perturbations. Field studies are especially sparse, particularly ones examining shifts in direct and indirect consumer interactions. Here we address such connections within tidepool communities of rocky shores, focusing on a three‐level food web involving the keystone sea star predator, Pisaster ochraceus, a common herbivorous snail, Tegula funebralis, and a macroalgal basal resource, Macrocystis pyrifera. We demonstrate that during nighttime low tides, experimentally manipulated declines in seawater pH suppress the anti‐predator behavior of snails, bolstering their grazing, and diminishing the top‐down influence of predators on basal resources. This attenuation of top‐down control is absent in pools maintained experimentally at higher pH. These findings suggest that as ocean acidification proceeds, shifts of behaviorally mediated links in food webs could change how cascading effects of predators manifest within marine communities.

Assessment of Exploitation Intensity of Commercial Species and Associated Benthic Communities, in Chilean Marine Management Areas of North Patagonia

The Aysén region of Chile (North Patagonia), has had limited studies on the effectiveness of management and exploitation areas of benthic resources, and performance relative to open access areas in this region has never been evaluated. We evaluated seven management areas (MAs) and five open access areas (OAAs) between 43.9°S and 45.2°S for exploitation intensity of three commercial species (Concholepas concholepas, Loxechinus albus, and Ameghinomya antiqua) together with characterization of the benthic community. Indicators based on size, density and weight were used to evaluate exploitation intensity of commercial species. Associated benthic communities were evaluated considering density, species composition, and community structure. We found a high species richness and a community structure with low variability between MAs and OAAs. Low densities and small sizes classes of C. concholepas in most of the areas indicated high exploitation intensity in both MAs and OAAs. In this context, a permanent ban to harvest C. concholepas within OAAs may need to be reevaluated since with no enforcement and monitoring, the exploitation status of this species remains unclear in these areas. L. albus in most areas were absent in the harvestable sizes, which could be indicating high exploitation intensity in both regimes. High densities and small sizes of C. concholepas and L. albus in some MAs, indicated a potential recruitment zones which bears further investigation. A. antiqua, showed better conditions than other commercial species evaluated, with no significant differences in densities and size-based indicators when comparing OAAs and MAs. Benthic communities were dominated numerically by the Echinoidea class in both MAs and OAAs, with L. albus, Arbacia dufresnii and Pseudechinus magellanicus being the dominant species. High densities of sea urchins co-occurring with low coverage of macroalgae found in MAs-Gala could indicate that a sea urchin barren was dominant during the study period. On the other hand, high densities of Cosmasterias lurida, a predatory sea star, in conjunction with low densities of C. concholepas in most of the studied areas suggested that a shift in predator roles is occurring. No differences were estimated in terms of fisheries indicators and benthic community structure across the two management regimes, suggesting the poor performance of MAs in Aysén region. Our data also support the need to improve monitoring of MAs especially with respect to associated benthic community incorporating a broader spatial scale.

Variation in the behavioral tolerance of congeneric marine snails to low-pH exposure

The ocean is acidifying, with multiple consequences for coastal organisms. However, species may differ in their sensitivities. Some taxa may find future conditions mildly stressful or even advantageous, while others will persist only through acclimatization or genetic adaptation. An open question is whether such variation in the sensitivity of species to ocean acidification relates to their evolutionary histories of exposure to reduced pH. Here, we explored this unknown through an investigation of differences in pH tolerance of 2 shoreline gastropods, the black turban snail Tegula funebralis and its congener, the brown turban snail T. brunnea. These species occupy distinct vertical distributions on rocky shores, each subject to different extremes in low pH. We assayed the extent to which low pH degrades the flight behavior of each species in response to the predatory sea star Pisaster ochraceus. Across a range of pH, the tidepool-inhabiting T. funebralis exhibited less behavioral disruption than T. brunnea at any given pH value but also experienced impairment at a pH characteristic of the present-day minimum in its habitat (7.1 pH). The latter pattern suggests T. funebralis operates near what may be a fixed tolerance limit to low pH. T. funebralis also exhibited hints of elevated intraspecific variation in its behaviors, which could imply scope for selection to act. Deeper-dwelling T. brunnea, in contrast, showed little sensitivity to present-day pH minima found where it lives (7.6 pH) and displayed less variation upon which selection might operate. These results provide a initial framework for investigations into the capacity of species of differing evolutionary histories to cope with future ocean acidification.

Ecological implications of variable energy storage in the keystone predator, Pisaster ochraceus

AbstractWe considered how environmental variation and adaption together constrain energy acquisition of a keystone predator and how the constraints might influence its ecological function. We tested the proposition that changing energy availability, occurring as shifts in shore level and size composition of the lower vertical boundary of intertidal mussel beds (Mytilus spp.), affects energy storage and growth of predatory sea stars, Pisaster ochraceus. Energy storage of Pisaster (mass of the pyloric caeca, PC) increased when highly variable inter‐annual mussel recruitment temporarily shifted the lower boundary of the mussel bed down‐shore; energy storage decreased when the lower boundary receded up‐shore. Greatest storage occurred during massive recruitment of juvenile mussels, which caused the largest downward extensions of the boundary. To test the causal basis of the storage–boundary correlation, sea stars collected from sites with natural episodes of massive mussel recruitment were tagged and translocated to sites with experimentally shifted boundaries. On mussel beds with lower boundaries artificially expanded downward, the sea stars sustained high energy storage over most of the range of initial sizes. On mussel beds left unaltered or experimentally recessed, they lost PC mass. The amounts of loss were similar between unaltered and recessed treatments. We suggest an explanation for this unexpected similarity. Pisaster aggregate and disperse in response to the inter‐annual variation in mussel recruitment, and this numerical response is integral to mechanisms holding stationary the lower boundary, imposing stability on the local mussel population. Inter‐annual episodes of massive mussel recruitment, which have the potential to abruptly destabilize the lower boundaries, (1) elicit the strongest numerical response and (2) incur the greatest energy storage. The amount of energy storage in the season of active foraging is approximately proportional to the reproductive output in the subsequent reproductive season. Therefore, we propose that the system property of prey population stability originates in energy constraints underpinning Darwinian fitness of a keystone predator. Study limitations and further tests of the hypothesis are described.

The Waiting Stage, Prolonged Residency in Nursery Habitats by Juveniles of the Predatory Sea Star Marthasterias glacialis.

AbstractGrowth and recruitment of the sea star Marthasterias glacialis was followed over six years in Lough Hyne, southwest Ireland. Juveniles from a 2-mm radius were found on algae at <1-2-m depth following what appeared to be gregarious larval settlement. Data from Lough Hyne and Mulroy Bay (northwest Ireland) indicated that algal habitat serves as a nursery area for juveniles of M. glacialis. Successive size frequency modes of the juveniles at Lough Hyne indicated slow growth over 6 years, to a mean radius of 20 mm. The absence of additional recruitment allowed monitoring of a discrete population. Recruits in the nursery habitat over the six years remained as waiting stage juveniles, a Peter Pan group with delayed maturity subsisting on a diet of epibionts. An initial sharp decline in numbers indicated post-settlement mortality, with subsequent decline likely due to migration to the adjacent shelly habitat, where subadult M. glacialis (30-70-mm radius) lives. In this habitat, M. glacialis preys on small bivalves and eventually joins the adult (maximum radius = 280 mm) population on open sediment, where it feeds on large bivalves. Size frequency distributions of the juveniles and adults showed growth over the six years, with the waiting stage sea stars slowly merging in size with the adult population. It appears that the supply of new individuals into the adult population may take place six or more years following settlement. Strong connectivity between life stage habitats and prolonged recruitment into the adult population may contribute to balanced exploitation of infaunal prey.

The stars are out: Predicting the effect of seawater freshening on the ecological impact of a sea star keystone predator

Predicting the myriad effects of climate change on ecological communities is a major challenge for scientists, and to date relatively few studies have focused on the effects of sea freshening on species interactions. In particular, changes in keystone species predatory effects could be pervasive. Here, we assess the consequences of decreasing salinity on the ecological impact exerted by a keystone predatory sea star, Asterias rubens. We quantified sea star functional responses (FRs; per capita predation as a function of prey density) under decreasing salinity treatments aligned with climate change projections (18ppt, 15ppt, 12ppt). Furthermore, we combined FRs with larval recruitment estimates, i.e. ecological “Impact Potential”, to act as an ecological indicator of predator population-level responses under this environmental change. Attack and maximum feeding rates of sea stars were reduced by decreasing salinities, with no instances of predation found at 12ppt. Given that decreasing salinities also reduced larval sea star recruitment, the overall Impact Potential of this keystone predator species was lessened by decreased salinity. Sea freshening projections by the end of this century could thus drive significant decreases in the effects of this keystone predator, with serious implications for the structuring and functioning of ecological communities.