Super-absorbents are expected to amend soils as they are capable of retaining water, which turns dry loose powdery substances (also capsule) into hydrogel. These were applied to prevent an artificial regeneration failure due to drought events. Four commercially-available products were mixed with soil from planting holes (the capsule was put to the soil) in order to support bare-root Scots pine and European beech seedlings after a spring planting on eleven clear-cut sites in 2020–2021. The plantations were designed as rows with 4 × 150 plants treated with four hydrogels plus 150 plants without hydrogel as a control. The performance evaluation of new plantations was based on attributes such as mortality/survival and relative height and root-collar diameter increments. The plants, which lost their initial size, due to pine weevil damage, dry tops and damage by game, were excluded from the evaluation. Besides the plant response to the applied super-absorbents, the planting operations were evaluated from economic point of view. The 2020 plantations showed higher mortality than 2021 ones; both years showed an excessive loss. The hydrogels did not help the plants to survive better compared to control and growth data also showed ambiguous results. Therefore, from commercial perspective, the application of all tested super-absorbents just increased the renewal costs.