Schroeder-phase Complexes Research Articles

Frequency shifts in distortion-product otoacoustic emissions evoked by swept tones.

When distortion-product otoacoustic emissions (DPOAEs) are evoked using stimuli whose instantaneous frequencies change rapidly and continuously with time (swept tones), the oscillatory interference pattern known as distortion-product fine structure shifts slightly along the frequency axis in the same direction as the sweep. By analogy with the temporal mechanisms thought to underlie the differing efficacies of up- and down-swept stimuli as perceptual maskers (e.g., Schroeder-phase complexes), fine-structure shifts have been ascribed to the phase distortion associated with dispersive wave propagation in the cochlea. This paper tests an alternative hypothesis and finds that the observed shifts arise predominantly as a methodological side effect of the analysis procedures commonly used to extract delayed emissions from the measured time waveform. Approximate expressions for the frequency shifts of DPOAE distortion and reflection components are derived, validated with computer simulations, and applied to account for DPOAE fine-structure shifts measured in human subjects. Component magnitudes are shown to shift twice as much as component phases. Procedures for compensating swept-tone measurements to obtain estimates of the total DPOAE and its components measured at other sweep rates or in the sinusoidal steady state are presented.

Exploring the role of feedback-based auditory reflexes in forward masking by schroeder-phase complexes.

Several studies have postulated that psychoacoustic measures of auditory perception are influenced by efferent-induced changes in cochlear responses, but these postulations have generally remained untested. This study measured the effect of stimulus phase curvature and temporal envelope modulation on the medial olivocochlear reflex (MOCR) and on the middle-ear muscle reflex (MEMR). The role of the MOCR was tested by measuring changes in the ear-canal pressure at 6 kHz in the presence and absence of a band-limited harmonic complex tone with various phase curvatures, centered either at (on-frequency) or well below (off-frequency) the 6-kHz probe frequency. The influence of possible MEMR effects was examined by measuring phase-gradient functions for the elicitor effects and by measuring changes in the ear-canal pressure with a continuous suppressor of the 6-kHz probe. Both on- and off-frequency complex tone elicitors produced significant changes in ear canal sound pressure. However, the pattern of results was not consistent with the earlier hypotheses postulating that efferent effects produce the psychoacoustic dependence of forward-masked thresholds on masker phase curvature. The results also reveal unexpectedly long time constants associated with some efferent effects, the source of which remains unknown.

Challenges in exploring the role of medial olivocochlear efferents in auditory tasks via otoacoustic emissions

A number of recent psychophysical studies have hypothesized that the activation of medial olivocochlear (MOC) efferents plays a significant role in forward masking. These hypotheses are based on general similarities between spectral and temporal characteristics exhibited by some psychophysical forward-masking results and by effects of efferent activation measured using physiological methods. In humans, noninvasive physiological measurements of otoacoustic emissions have been used to probe changes in cochlear responses due to MOC efferent activation. The aim of this study was to verify our earlier efferent-based hypothesis regarding the dependence of psychophysical forward masking of a 6-kHz probe on the phase curvature of harmonic-complex maskers. The ear-canal pressure for a continuous 6-kHz probe was measured in the presence and absence of Schroeder-phase complexes used as forward maskers in our previous psychophysical study. Changes in the ear-canal pressure were analyzed using methods for estimating the effects of efferent activation on stimulus frequency otoacoustic emissions under the assumption that changes in cochlear gain due to efferent activation will be reflected in changes in the magnitude and phase of the emission. Limitations and challenges in relating effects of feedback-based reflexes to psychophysical effects will be discussed. [Work supported by NIH grant R01DC010374.]

Phase effects in masking by harmonic complexes: Speech recognition

Harmonic complexes that generate highly modulated temporal envelopes on the basilar membrane (BM) mask a tone less effectively than complexes that generate relatively flat temporal envelopes, because the non-linear active gain of the BM selectively amplifies a low-level tone in the dips of a modulated masker envelope. The present study examines a similar effect in speech recognition. Speech reception thresholds (SRTs) were measured for a voice masked by harmonic complexes with partials in sine phase (SP) or in random phase (RP). The masker's fundamental frequency (F0) was 50, 100 or 200 Hz. SRTs were considerably lower for SP than for RP maskers at 50-Hz F0, but the two converged at 100-Hz F0, while at 200-Hz F0, SRTs were a little higher for SP than RP maskers. The results were similar whether the target voice was male or female and whether the masker's spectral profile was flat or speech-shaped. Although listening in the masker dips has been shown to play a large role for artificial stimuli such as Schroeder-phase complexes at high levels, it contributes weakly to speech recognition in the presence of harmonic maskers with different crest factors at more moderate sound levels (65 dB SPL).

Detection of acoustic temporal fine structure by cochlear implant listeners: Behavioral results and computational modeling

A test of within-channel detection of acoustic temporal fine structure (aTFS) cues is presented. Eight cochlear implant listeners (CI) were asked to discriminate between two Schroeder-phase (SP) complexes using a two-alternative, forced-choice task. Because differences between the acoustic stimuli are primarily constrained to their aTFS, successful discrimination reflects a combination of the subjects' perception of and the strategy's ability to deliver aTFS cues.Subjects were mapped with single-channel Continuous Interleaved Sampling (CIS) and Simultaneous Analog Stimulation (SAS) strategies. To compare within- and across- channel delivery of aTFS cues, a 16-channel clinical HiRes strategy was also fitted. Throughout testing, SAS consistently outperformed the CIS strategy (p ≤ 0.002). For SP stimuli with F0 = 50 Hz, the highest discrimination scores were achieved with the HiRes encoding, followed by scores with the SAS and the CIS strategies, respectively. At 200 Hz, single-channel SAS performed better than HiRes (p = 0.022), demonstrating that under a more challenging testing condition, discrimination performance with a single-channel analog encoding can exceed that of a 16-channel pulsatile strategy.To better understand the intermediate steps of discrimination, a biophysical model was used to examine the neural discharges evoked by the SP stimuli. Discrimination estimates calculated from simulated neural responses successfully tracked the behavioral performance trends of single-channel CI listeners.

On- and Off-Frequency Forward Masking by Schroeder-Phase Complexes

Forward masking by harmonic tone complexes was measured for on- and off-frequency maskers as a function of masker phase curvature for two masker durations (30 and 200 ms). For the lowest signal frequency (1 kHz), the results matched predictions based on the expected interactions between the phase curvature and amplitude compression of peripheral auditory filtering. For the higher signal frequencies (2 and 6 kHz), the data increasingly departed from predictions in two respects. First, the effects of the masker phase curvature became stronger with increasing masker duration, inconsistent with the expected effects of the fast-acting compression and time-invariant phase response of basilar membrane filtering. Second, significant effects of masker phase curvature were observed for the off-frequency masker using a 6-kHz signal, inconsistent with predictions based on linear processing of stimuli well below the signal frequency. New predictions were generated assuming an additional effect with a longer time constant, consistent with the influence of medial olivocochlear efferent activation on otoacoustic emissions in humans. Reasonable agreement between the predicted and the measured effects suggests that efferent activation is a potential candidate mechanism to explain certain spectro-temporal masking effects in human hearing.

Auditory temporal resolution in the Zebra Finch (Taeniopygia guttata): A model of enhanced temporal acuity

ABSTRACT We review recent studies that examine the temporal resolution of the avian auditory system as measured behaviorally in a small songbird, the Zebra Finch (Taeniopygia guttata). These birds naturally learn and produce complex harmonic vocalizations. Here we created complex harmonic stimuli that simulate the fine temporal properties of these natural calls in order to probe the possible parallels between productive precision and perceptual acuity. The studies we review show that these birds are exquisitely sensitive to changes in temporal fine structure in complex sounds, 3–5 times more sensitive than humans, and probably other mammals. This sensitivity also was obtained with several types of synthetic harmonic stimuli that mimicked particular properties of natural signals, including harmonic sounds with individually altered components, Schroeder-phase complexes that control for envelope cues, and synthetic signals constructed from repeated single periods of natural calls. These last studies confirm ...

Acoustic reflexes to Schroeder-phase harmonic complexes in normal-hearing and hearing-impaired individuals

Harmonic complexes generated with positive or negative Schroeder-phases may result in differences in cochlear excitation, even though their long-term spectra and amplitudes are equal. As a measure of possible differences in cochlear excitation resulting from these harmonic complexes, thresholds and growth of the acoustic reflex were assessed in normal-hearing and hearing-impaired subjects. Harmonic complexes with fundamental frequencies of 50, 100, and 200 Hz were constructed with positive and negative-Schroeder phases. In normal-hearing subjects, acoustic reflex thresholds for the 50- and 100-Hz fundamental waveforms were typically lower for negative Schroeder-phase complexes than for positive Schroeder phase stimuli. At the highest fundamental frequency of 200 Hz, there were no significant threshold differences due to phase. Hearing-impaired subjects showed a similar pattern for thresholds between the two phase selections, but with smaller differences than those observed in normal-hearing subjects. At levels above reflex threshold, the magnitude of the acoustic reflex was greater for the negative-phase than the positive-phase stimuli for the lowest fundamental frequency, but no significant differences were observed at fundamental frequencies of 100 and 200 Hz. These results are consistent with generally greater cochlear excitation in response to negative than to positive Schroeder-phase stimuli when the fundamental frequency is sufficiently low. Increased excitation may reflect a synchronization of response across a wide band of frequencies in the cochlea when the rate of frequency sweep within periods of these harmonic complexes is appropriately matched to timing characteristics of the traveling wave.

Reconciling frequency selectivity and phase effects in masking.

The effects of auditory frequency selectivity and phase response on masking were studied using harmonic tone complex maskers with a 100-Hz fundamental frequency. Positive and negative Schroeder-phase complexes (m+ and m-), were used as maskers and the signal was a long-duration sinusoid. In the first experiment, thresholds for signal frequencies of 1 and 4 kHz were measured as a function of masker bandwidth and number of components. A large difference in thresholds between the m+ and m- complexes was found only when masker components were presented ipsilateral to the signal over a frequency range wider than the traditional critical band, regardless of the absolute number of components. In the second experiment, frequency selectivity was measured in harmonic tone complexes with fixed or random phases as well as in noise, using a variant of the notched-noise method with a fixed masker level. The data showed that frequency selectivity is not affected by masker type, indicating that the wide listening bandwidth suggested by the first experiment cannot be ascribed to broader effective filters in complex-tone maskers than in noise maskers. The third experiment employed a novel method of measuring frequency selectivity, which has the advantage that the overall level at the input and the output of the auditory filter remains roughly constant across all conditions. The auditory filter bandwidth measured using this method was wider than that measured in the second experiment, but may still be an underestimate, due to the effects of off-frequency listening. The data were modeled using a single-channel model with various initial filters. The main findings from the simulations were: (1) the magnitude response of the Gammatone filter is too narrow to account for the phase effects observed in the data; (2) none of the other filters currently used in auditory models can account for both frequency selectivity and phase effects in masking; (3) the Gammachirp filter can be made to provide a good account of the data by altering its phase response. The final conclusion suggests that masker phase effects can be accounted for with a single-channel model, while still remaining consistent with measures of frequency selectivity: effects that appear to involve broadband processing do not necessarily require across-channel mechanisms.

An auditory model that explains masking by Schroeder-phase complexes.

An auditory model that explains masking by Schroeder-phase complexes.

Basilar membrane responses to broadband stimuli.

Basilar membrane (BM) responses to two types of broadband stimuli-clicks and Schroeder-phase complexes--were recorded at several sites at the base of the chinchilla cochlea. Recording sites (characteristic frequency, CF, in the range of 5.5-18 kHz) span the 1-4-mm basal region of the basilar membrane. BM responses to clicks consisted of undamped oscillations with instantaneous frequency that increased over time until it reached a value around CF. The time constant of this glide is CF dependent. Throughout the entire region under study, BM vibration exceeded umbo motion by up to 60 dB. Nonlinear properties of BM responses to clicks resemble those found in the more studied 8-10-kHz region. Amplitude spectra of Schroeder-phase complex stimuli, which consist of a series of sinusoidal components summed in negative (-SCHR) and positive Schroeder phase (+SCHR), are flat. The envelope of BM responses to +SCHR stimuli contains valleys, or dips, that are wider than those found in responses to the -SCHR stimuli. Hence, BM responses to the former stimuli are "peakier" than responses to the latter. Differences in response waveforms are less obvious in linear cochleae. Suppression of a near-CF tone by -SCHR stimuli was larger than that evoked by +SCHR stimuli.

Effects of hearing impairment and presentation level on masking period patterns for Schroeder-phase harmonic complexes.

Masking period patterns (MPPs) for Schroeder-phase harmonic complexes containing equal-amplitude harmonics of a 100-Hz fundamental were determined for 5-ms tonal probes at 4,000 and 1,000 Hz. Maskers consisted of harmonics 2-50 (200-5,000 Hz bandwidth) for 4,000-Hz probes and harmonics 2-20 (200-2,000 Hz) for 1,000-Hz signals. Masked thresholds were determined for probe onsets 153, 155.5, 158, 160.5, and 163 ms following masker onset (masker duration=460 ms). Overall, results were similar for both probe frequencies. For listeners with normal hearing, MPPs for positive Schroeder-phase complexes masking 60 dB SPL probes were highly modulated and became flatter when probe level was increased to 80 dB SPL. MPPs were less modulated for listeners with sensorineural hearing loss than for normally hearing listeners at both 60 and 80 dB SPL probe levels. Thresholds in negative Schroeder-phase maskers were more similar across the two groups of listeners and across differences in probe position and probe level. The findings support an interpretation involving differences in the shape of the basilar-membrane waveform generated by each masker and possible influences of nonlinear cochlear processing on these internal responses. For normally hearing listeners, 60 dB SPL probes were most difficult to detect when temporally positioned so that probe frequency and masker instantaneous frequency were closely matched. For 80 dB SPL probes and for hearing-impaired listeners, probes presented at these same positions were often more easily detected than probes at other positions. The latter result appears to involve benefit associated with in-phase addition of the probe to a portion of the masker similar to the probe in both frequency and phase. This benefit was reduced or entirely eliminated when probe phase was altered so that this in-phase addition did not occur.

Contralateral suppression of transiently evoked otoacoustic emissions by harmonic complex tones in humans.

Variations in the amplitude of transiently evoked otoacoustic emissions (TEOAEs) produced by a contralateral complex tone were measured in 26 normal-hearing human subjects. TEOAEs were evoked using a 1-kHz tone pip at 60 dB SPL. The contralateral complex consisted of harmonic components with frequencies between 400 and 2000 Hz; it was presented at levels ranging from 40 to 50 dB SL and its fundamental frequency (F0) was varied. In experiment 1, the dependence of TEOAE amplitude variations on the F0 of the contralateral complex was measured by varying the F0 from 50 to 400 Hz in octave steps. The results revealed a nonmonotonic dependence of TEOAE amplitude variations on contralateral F0, with significantly larger TEOAE suppression for F0's of 100 and 200 Hz than for F0's of 50 and 400 Hz. Experiment 2, in which the harmonics were summed in alternating sine-cosine phase instead of constant sine phase, showed a shift of the function relating TEOAE attenuation to F0 towards lower F0's, indicating that the waveform repetition rate, rather than harmonic spacing, was the actual factor of the dependence of contralateral TEOAE attenuation on F0. Furthermore, significantly smaller suppression was observed with the alternating-phase complexes than with the sine-phase complexes, suggesting an influence of the waveform crest factor. Experiment 3 showed no difference between the contralateral TEOAE attenuation effects produced by positive and negative Schroeder-phase complexes. Overall, these results bring further arguments for the notion that contralaterally induced medial olivocochlear bundle (MOCB) activity, as measured through the contralateral suppression of TEOAEs in humans, is sensitive to the rate of temporal envelope fluctuations of the contralateral stimulus, with preferential rates around 100-200 Hz.

Masking of tones and speech by Schroeder-phase harmonic complexes in normally hearing and hearing-impaired listeners

Tone detection and sentence recognition were measured for normally hearing and hearing-impaired listeners using maskers consisting of harmonic series with components summed in positive or negative Schroeder phase. Each task was carried out with the signal set at 60, 70, or 80 dB SPL. For listeners with normal hearing, positive Schroeder-phase complexes masked tones and sentences less than negative Schroeder-phase maskers. In the two experimental tasks, to achieve the same amount of masking, positive Schroeder-phase complexes had to be set as much as 12–15 dB higher than negative Schroeder-phase complexes. Large phase effects were observed on both tasks at all three test levels. The two maskers were more nearly equal in effectiveness in the presence of cochlear damage. The findings support an interpretation that involves differences in the shape of the basilar-membrane waveform generated by each masker and active cochlear processing which enhances the internal signal-to-masker ratio for signals presented in the positive Schroeder masker. This spectral enhancement appears to require nonlinear active gain that is characteristic of normal auditory processing at moderate presentation levels. The results of the sentence recognition task suggest that group differences observed in tone detection transfer fairly directly to speech perception under masking.

Excitation produced by Schroeder-phase complexes: evidence for fast-acting compression in the auditory system.

A series of experiments compared the excitation produced in an auditory filter centered on 1100 Hz by two complexes, both of which consisted of harmonics 2-20 of a 100-Hz fundamental. When the components had a level of 69 dB SPL each, summing them in positive Schroeder phase produced substantially less forward masking of an 1100-Hz signal than when the components were summed in negative Schroeder phase. This difference decreased with decreases in overall masker level. Listeners also reported that the components of the positive-phase masker close to 1100 Hz were quieter than the corresponding components in the negative-phase masker. The data are explained using Kohlrausch and Sander's [J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 97, 1817-1829 (1995)] finding that the response of an 1100-Hz auditory filter to the positive-phase complex shows marked peaks and dips, whereas that to the negative-phase complex does not. It is argued that the peaks in the response to the positive-phase masker are attenuated by fast-acting compression in the auditory system, thereby reducing the excitation produced by that sound. It is also argued that, compared to the power functions commonly used to model "excess masking" and the growth of loudness, the present data reflect greater compression at high levels but less compression at low levels.

Masking period patterns of Schroeder-phase complexes: effects of level, number of components, and phase of flanking components.

Masking period patterns (MPPs) were obtained for maskers consisting of harmonics 2-20 of a 100-Hz fundamental. The signal was always a 5-ms 1100-Hz sinusoid presented 152, 154, 156, 158, or 160 ms after the start of a 400-ms masker. Experiment 1 replicated the finding that, for a masker level of 69 dB component, the shape of the MPP depended strongly on the phases of the components: Summing them in positive Schroeder phase led to a threshold variation of about 18 dB across the MPP, but summing them in negative Schroeder phase produced a flat MPP [A. Kohlrausch and A. Sander, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 97, 1817-1829 (1995)]. Reducing the level of the positive-phase masker resulted in a systematic flattening of the MPP, whereas the negative-phase MPPs were flat both at high and at low levels. Experiment 2 showed that removing all components of a positive-phase masker except those close to the signal raised thresholds at the minimum of the MPP. In contrast, a similar manipulation applied to the negative-phase masker produced a uniform elevation of the MPP. Experiment 3 showed that an analogous effect could be obtained by manipulating the phases of masker components remote from the signal. It is shown that several features of the data can be simulated using a nonlinear model of the auditory periphery [C. Giguère and P.C. Woodland, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 95, 331-342 (1994)].