Abstract The sub-harmonic resonance in closed cracks is caused by resonant properties of the system and the contact of crack surfaces. Local defect resonance is considered a potential resonant phenomenon near cracks. This study compares local resonance and sub-harmonic resonance in a surface-breaking crack using numerical simulations. The authors previously simulated nonlinear sub-harmonic resonance using the harmonic balance-boundary element method. The investigation of local defect resonance utilizes both the boundary element method and the Sakurai-Sugiura method. The numerical results indicate a strong relation between the vibration fields of sub-harmonic frequency components and local defect resonance.