Rut Site Research Articles

Rho-dependent transcriptional switches regulate the bacterial response to cold shock

Binding of the bacterial Rho helicase to nascent transcripts triggers Rho-dependent transcription termination (RDTT) in response to cellular signals that modulate mRNA structure and accessibility of Rho utilization (Rut) sites. Despite the impact of temperature on RNA structure, RDTT was never linked to the bacterial response to temperature shifts. We show that Rho is a central player in the cold-shock response (CSR), challenging the current view that CSR is primarily a posttranscriptional program. We identify Rut sites in 5'-untranslated regions of key CSR genes/operons (cspA, cspB, cspG, and nsrR-rnr-yjfHI) that trigger premature RDTT at 37°C but not at 15°C. High concentrations of RNA chaperone CspA or nucleotide changes in the cspA mRNA leader reduce RDTT efficiency, revealing how RNA restructuring directs Rho to activate CSR genes during the cold shock and to silence them during cold acclimation. These findings establish a paradigm for how RNA thermosensors can modulate gene expression.

Three kinetically distinct but compatible routes of Rho-dependent termination uncovered by single-molecule transcription imaging.

When gene transcription for RNA synthesis terminates in a factor-dependent manner, Rho is a general termination factor in bacteria, but its mechanism has been elusive in many aspects. Various models have been proposed for the pre-terminational interaction of Rho with RNA polymerase (RNAP), for the terminational release of RNA transcript, and for the post-terminational outcome. We developed several single-molecule fluorescence assays in order to monitor those three steps of termination mediated by Escherichia coli Rho. We find that the different mechanisms previously proposed for each step co-exist compatibly together in any single terminator but three kinetically distinct routes take place with each terminator. Rho mostly binds nascent RNA first at a rut site, translocates on RNA and catches up with the paused RNAP at the termination site. The fastest route is that this catch-up Rho first mediates RNA shearing for RNA-only release and consequently one-dimensional recycling of the DNA-bound RNAP. The catch-up Rho later mediates RNAP displacement in the next but the most frequent route to decompose RNAP·DNA·RNA complexes in a step for three-dimensional recycling of the dissociated RNAP. Contrastingly, a minor fraction of Rho pre-binds RNAP prior to the terminational pausing site and stands by for an incipient RNA rut site. This stand-by Rho lastly mediates only RNAP displacement for the decomposing outcome in the slowest route, despite interacting with RNAP earlier than the catch-up Rho. Furthermore, we uncover that transcriptional pause extension benefits only the stand-by Rho's termination, and the essential pause does not need to be long for the catch-up Rho's terminations The riboswitch-associated termination is controlled mainly by modulation of the stand-by. Thus, the three compatible routes of Rho-dependent termination not only operate on distinct timescales but also play different regulatory roles.

A scalable framework for the discovery of functional helicase substrates and helicase-driven regulatory switches

Helicases are ubiquitous motor enzymes that remodel nucleic acids (NA) and NA-protein complexes in key cellular processes. To explore the functional repertoire and specificity landscape of helicases, we devised a screening scheme-Helicase-SELEX (Systematic Evolution of Ligands by EXponential enrichment)-that enzymatically probes substrate and cofactor requirements at global scale. Using the transcription termination Rho helicase of Escherichia coli as a prototype for Helicase-SELEX, we generated a genome-wide map of Rho utilization (Rut) sites. The map reveals many features, including promoter- and intrinsic terminator-associated Rut sites, bidirectional Rut tandems, and cofactor-dependent Rut sites with inverted G > C skewed compositions. We also implemented an H-SELEX variant where we used a model ligand, serotonin, to evolve synthetic Rut sites operating invitro and invivo in a ligand-dependent manner. Altogether, our data illustrate the power and flexibility of Helicase-SELEX to seek constitutive or conditional helicase substrates in natural or synthetic NA libraries for fundamental or synthetic biology discovery.

In vivo regulation of bacterial Rho-dependent transcription termination by the nascent RNA

Bacterial Rho is a RNA-dependent ATPase that functions in the termination of transcription. The in vivo nature of the bacterial Rho-dependent terminators, as well as the mechanism of the Rho-dependent termination process, are not fully understood. Here, we measured the in vivo termination efficiencies of 72 Rho-dependent terminators in Escherichia coli by systematically performing qRT-PCR analyses of cDNA prepared from mid-log phase bacterial cultures. We found that these terminators exhibited a wide range of efficiencies, and many behaved differently in vivo compared to the predicted or experimentally determined efficiencies in vitro. Rho-utilization sites (rut sites) present in the RNA terminator sequences are characterized by the presence of C-rich/G-poor sequences or C > G bubbles. We found that weaker terminators exhibited a robust correlation with the properties (size, length, density, etc.) of these C > G bubbles of their respective rut sites, while stronger terminators lack this correlation, suggesting a limited role of rut sequences in controlling in vivo termination efficiencies. We also found that in vivo termination efficiencies are dependent on the rates of ATP hydrolysis as well as Rho-translocation on the nascent RNA. We demonstrate that weaker terminators, in addition to having rut sites with diminished C > G bubble sizes, are dependent on the Rho-auxiliary factor, NusG, in vivo. From these results, we concluded that in vivo Rho-dependent termination follows a nascent RNA-dependent pathway, where Rho-translocation along the RNA is essential and rut sequences may recruit Rho in vivo, but Rho-rut binding strengths do not regulate termination efficiencies.

NusG prevents transcriptional invasion of H-NS-silenced genes.

Evolutionarily conserved NusG protein enhances bacterial RNA polymerase processivity but can also promote transcription termination by binding to, and stimulating the activity of, Rho factor. Rho terminates transcription upon anchoring to cytidine-rich motifs, the so-called Rho utilization sites (Rut) in nascent RNA. Both NusG and Rho have been implicated in the silencing of horizontally-acquired A/T-rich DNA by nucleoid structuring protein H-NS. However, the relative roles of the two proteins in H-NS-mediated gene silencing remain incompletely defined. In the present study, a Salmonella strain carrying the nusG gene under the control of an arabinose-inducible repressor was used to assess the genome-wide response to NusG depletion. Results from two complementary approaches, i) screening lacZ protein fusions generated by random transposition and ii) transcriptomic analysis, converged to show that loss of NusG causes massive upregulation of Salmonella pathogenicity islands (SPIs) and other H-NS-silenced loci. A similar, although not identical, SPI-upregulated profile was observed in a strain with a mutation in the rho gene, Rho K130Q. Surprisingly, Rho mutation Y80C, which affects Rho’s primary RNA binding domain, had either no effect or made H-NS-mediated silencing of SPIs even tighter. Thus, while corroborating the notion that bound H-NS can trigger Rho-dependent transcription termination in vivo, these data suggest that H-NS-elicited termination occurs entirely through a NusG-dependent pathway and is less dependent on Rut site binding by Rho. We provide evidence that through Rho recruitment, and possibly through other still unidentified mechanisms, NusG prevents pervasive transcripts from elongating into H-NS-silenced regions. Failure to perform this function causes the feedforward activation of the entire Salmonella virulence program. These findings provide further insight into NusG/Rho contribution in H-NS-mediated gene silencing and underscore the importance of this contribution for the proper functioning of a global regulatory response in growing bacteria. The complete set of transcriptomic data is freely available for viewing through a user-friendly genome browser interface.

RhoTermPredict: an algorithm for predicting Rho-dependent transcription terminators based on Escherichia coli, Bacillus subtilis and Salmonella enterica databases.

BackgroundIn bacterial genomes, there are two mechanisms to terminate the DNA transcription: the “intrinsic” or Rho-independent termination and the Rho-dependent termination. Intrinsic terminators are characterized by a RNA hairpin followed by a run of 6–8 U residues relatively easy to identify using one of the numerous available prediction programs. In contrast, Rho-dependent termination is mediated by the Rho protein factor that, firstly, binds to ribosome-free mRNA in a site characterized by a C > G content and then reaches the RNA polymerase to induce its release. Conversely on intrinsic terminators, the computational prediction of Rho-dependent terminators in prokaryotes is a very difficult problem because the sequence features required for the function of Rho are complex and poorly defined. This is the reason why it still does not exist an exhaustive Rho-dependent terminators prediction program.ResultsIn this study we introduce RhoTermPredict, the first published algorithm for an exhaustive Rho-dependent terminators prediction in bacterial genomes. RhoTermPredict identifies these elements based on a previously proposed consensus motif common to all Rho-dependent transcription terminators. It essentially searches for a 78 nt long RUT site characterized by a C > G content and with regularly spaced C residues, followed by a putative pause site for the RNA polymerase. We tested RhoTermPredict performances by using available genomic and transcriptomic data of the microorganism Escherichia coli K-12, both in limited-length sequences and in the whole-genome, and available genomic sequences from Bacillus subtilis 168 and Salmonella enterica LT2 genomes. We also estimated the overlap between the predictions of RhoTermPredict and those obtained by the predictor of intrinsic terminators ARNold webtool. Our results demonstrated that RhoTermPredict is a very performing algorithm both for limited-length sequences (F1-score obtained about 0.7) and for a genome-wide analysis. Furthermore the degree of overlap with ARNold predictions was very low.ConclusionsOur analysis shows that RhoTermPredict is a powerful tool for Rho-dependent terminators search in the three analyzed genomes and could fill this gap in computational genomics. We conclude that RhoTermPredict could be used in combination with an intrinsic terminators predictor in order to predict all the transcription terminators in bacterial genomes.

RNA secondary structures regulate three steps of Rho-dependent transcription termination within a bacterial mRNA leader.

Transcription termination events in bacteria often require the RNA helicase Rho. Typically, Rho promotes termination at the end of coding sequences, but it can also terminate transcription within leader regions to implement regulatory decisions. Rho-dependent termination requires initial recognition of a Rho utilization (rut) site on a nascent RNA by Rho's primary binding surface. However, it is presently unclear what factors determine the location of transcription termination, how RNA secondary structures influence this process and whether mechanistic differences distinguish constitutive from regulated Rho-dependent terminators. We previously demonstrated that the 5′ leader mRNA of the Salmonella corA gene can adopt two mutually exclusive conformations that dictate accessibility of a rut site to Rho. We now report that the corA leader also controls two subsequent steps of Rho-dependent termination. First, the RNA conformation that presents an accessible rut site promotes pausing of RNA polymerase (RNAP) at a single Rho-dependent termination site over 100 nt downstream. Second, an additional RNA stem-loop promotes Rho activity and controls the location at which Rho-dependent termination occurs, despite having no effect on initial Rho binding to the corA leader. Thus, the multi-step nature of Rho-dependent termination may facilitate regulation of a given coding region by multiple cytoplasmic signals.

Molecular Basis of NusG-mediated Regulation of Rho-dependent Transcription Termination in Bacteria

The bacterial transcription elongation factor NusG stimulates the Rho-dependent transcription termination through a direct interaction with Rho. The mechanistic basis of NusG dependence of the Rho function is not known. Here, we describe Rho* mutants I168V, R221C/A, and P235H that do not require NusG for their termination function. These Rho* mutants have acquired new properties, which otherwise would have been imparted by NusG. A detailed analyses revealed that they have more stable interactions at the secondary RNA binding sites of Rho, which reduced the lag in initiating its ATPase as well as the translocase activities. These more stable interactions arose from the significant spatial re-orientations of the P, Q, and R structural loops of the Rho central channel. We propose that NusG imparts similar conformational changes in the central channel of Rho, yielding faster isomerization of the open to the closed hexameric states of the latter during its RNA-loading step. This acceleration stabilizes the Rho-RNA interactions at many terminators having suboptimal rut sites, thus making Rho-NusG interactions so essential in vivo. Finally, identification of the NusG binding sites on the Rho hexamer led us to conclude that the former exerts its effect allosterically.

Redundancy of primary RNA-binding functions of the bacterial transcription terminator Rho.

The bacterial transcription terminator, Rho, terminates transcription at half of the operons. According to the classical model derived from in vitro assays on a few terminators, Rho is recruited to the transcription elongation complex (EC) by recognizing specific sites (rut) on the nascent RNA. Here, we explored the mode of in vivo recruitment process of Rho. We show that sequence specific recognition of the rut site, in majority of the Rho-dependent terminators, can be compromised to a great extent without seriously affecting the genome-wide termination function as well as the viability of Escherichia coli. These terminators function optimally only through a NusG-assisted recruitment and activation of Rho. Our data also indicate that at these terminators, Rho-EC-bound NusG interaction facilitates the isomerization of Rho into a translocase-competent form by stabilizing the interactions of mRNA with the secondary RNA binding site, thereby overcoming the defects of the primary RNA binding functions.

Interaction with the Nascent RNA Is a Prerequisite for the Recruitment of Rho to the Transcription Elongation Complex In Vitro

In the conventional model of the Rho-dependent transcription termination, the terminator Rho binds to the rut (Rho utilization) site and translocates along the nascent RNA prior to making possible interactions with the elongating RNA polymerase (RNAP). Even though the interaction between Rho and isolated RNAs was studied in great detail, the same has never been shown with the nascent RNA emerging from the transcription elongation complex (EC). Direct demonstration and requirement of the Rho–nascent RNA binding become even more important because of the recently proposed alternative model where Rho loads onto the RNAP prior to the formation of the nascent RNA. Here, we have measured the direct association of Rho in vitro with the free RNAP, RNAP–promoter binary complex and stalled ECs with varied length of RNA. We observed the association of Rho only with the ECs having the rut-site-containing long nascent RNA. This association was significantly reduced when either a Rho mutant, Y80C, defective for RNA binding or an antisense oligo to the rut site was used or when the rut site was eliminated by RNase digestion or replacement with a random RNA sequence. The presence of EC-bound NusG, the binding partner of Rho, did not facilitate this association. RNase footprinting of the Rho–EC complex revealed a clear Rho-mediated protection of the rut sites on the nascent RNA. We concluded that the nascent RNA loading of Rho and its interaction with the rut site are mandatory and prerequisites for its recruitment to the EC under in vitro experimental conditions.

Mutagenesis-Based Evidence for an Asymmetric Configuration of the Ring-Shaped Transcription Termination Factor Rho

Transcription termination factor Rho is an ATP-dependent ring-shaped molecular motor that tracks along RNA to dissociate RNA–DNA duplexes and transcription complexes in its path. The Rho hexamer contains two distinct sites for interaction with RNA. The primary binding site is composed of pyrimidine-specific binding clefts that are located in the N-terminal domains and anchor Rho to transcripts at C-rich Rut (Rho utilization) sites. Components of the secondary binding site (SBS) in the C-terminal domains directly couple RNA binding to ATP hydrolysis in order to translocate RNA through the Rho ring. Published crystal structures of RNA-bound Rho display distinct architectures (‘trimer-of-dimers’ or asymmetric hexamer) and SBS–RNA interaction networks that suggested conflicting models of RNA “handoff” or “escort” by the Rho subunits. To probe the mechanism of mechanochemical transduction in Rho, we have mutated into alanines (or glycines) the residues that make SBS contacts with RNA in the ‘trimer-of-dimers’ structure supporting the “handoff” model. We find that the resulting single-point mutants have similar RNA binding affinities but exhibit significantly different ATP hydrolysis, transcription termination, and RNA–DNA unwinding activities that are more compatible with the asymmetric Rho structure than with the ‘trimer-of-dimers’ structure and the resulting “handoff” model. We discuss our findings in connection with specific features of the asymmetric Rho structure yet argue that a simple RNA “escort” model is insufficient to account for all experimental evidence.

Transcription Termination Factor Rho Prefers Catalytically Active Elongation Complexes for Releasing RNA

RNA polymerase pauses at different DNA sequences during transcription elongation, and this pausing is associated with distinct conformational state(s) of the elongation complex (EC). Transcription termination by the termination factor Rho, an RNA-dependent molecular motor, requires pausing of the EC in the termination zone of Rho-dependent terminators. We hypothesized that the conformational state(s) of the EC associated with this pausing would influence the action of Rho. Analyses of the pausing behavior of the EC at the termination points of two well known Rho-dependent terminators revealed that Rho prefers actively transcribing complexes for termination. RNA release kinetics from stalled ECs showed that the rate of RNA release by Rho was reduced if the EC was irreversibly backtracked, if its RNA exit channel was modified by an RNA hairpin, or the bridge helix/trigger loop movement in its active site was perturbed. These defects were overcome significantly by enhancing the rate of ATP hydrolysis either by increasing the concentration of ATP or by using a Rho mutant with higher ATPase activity. We propose that the force generated from ATP hydrolysis of Rho is the key factor in dislodging the EC through its molecular motor action, and this process is facilitated when the EC is in a catalytically competent state, undergoing rapid "Brownian ratchet" motion.

Sequence-specific Rho-RNA interactions in transcription termination.

The bacteriophage lambda tR1 terminator encodes a region of the nascent cro transcript containing RNA residues recognized by termination factor Rho. To identify ribonucleotide-protein interactions contributing to termination, a library of reporter gene plasmids was constructed containing predominantly single-nucleotide substitutions in a 24 nt region previously shown to be critical for efficient termination. Screening 16 822 bacterial transformants identified 110 terminator mutants, most of which contained two or more nucleotide substitutions. Although the vast majority of single base changes did not reduce tR1 function, 11 specific single-nucleotide substitutions at eight positions interspersed in the upstream part of the target region (5'-ATAACCCCGCTCTT ACACATTCCA-3') did reduce termination. About half of these substitutions also reduced Rho-dependent termination on cro gene templates transcribed by purified RNA polymerase, indicating specific residues critical for optimal terminator function. Other termination defects were not reproduced in these in vitro assays, and likely resulted from indirect effects of altering interactions between tR1 and additional cellular factors capable of attenuating Rho function. Our results indicate that while Rho is able to recognize a wide variety of similar rut site sequences by interacting with alternate nucleotides at critical positions, interactions with specific individual ribonucleotides of the tR1 transcript provide highly efficient Rho-dependent termination.

Analysis of Tryptophanase Operon Expression in Vitro: ACCUMULATION OF TnaC-PEPTIDYL-tRNA IN A RELEASE FACTOR 2-DEPLETED S-30 EXTRACT PREVENTS Rho FACTOR ACTION, SIMULATING INDUCTION

Expression of the tryptophanase (tna) operon in Escherichia coli is regulated by catabolite repression and tryptophan-induced transcription antitermination. The key feature of this antitermination mechanism has been shown to be the retention of uncleaved TnaC-peptidyl-tRNA in the translating ribosome. This ribosome remains stalled at the tna stop codon and blocks the access of Rho factor to the tna transcript, thereby preventing transcription termination. In normal S-30 preparations, synthesis of a TnaC peptide containing arginine instead of tryptophan at position 12 (Arg(12)-TnaC) was shown to be insensitive to added tryptophan, i.e. Arg(12)-TnaC-peptidyl-tRNA was cleaved, and there was normal Rho-dependent transcription termination. When the S-30 extract used was depleted of release factor 2, Arg(12)-TnaC-tRNA(Pro) was accumulated in the absence or presence of added tryptophan. Under these conditions the accumulation of Arg(12)-TnaC-tRNA(Pro) prevented Rho-dependent transcription termination, mimicking normal induction. Using a minimal in vitro transcription system consisting of a tna template, RNA polymerase, and Rho, it was shown that RNA sequences immediately adjacent to the tnaC stop codon, the presumed boxA and rut sites, contributed most significantly to Rho-dependent termination. The tna boxA-like sequence appeared to serve as a segment of the Rho "entry" site, despite its likeness to the boxA element.

RNA Passes through the Hole of the Protein Hexamer in the Complex with the Escherichia coli Rho Factor

Escherichia coli transcription termination factor Rho is a ring-shaped hexameric protein that uses the energy derived from ATP hydrolysis to dissociate RNA transcripts from the ternary elongation complex. To test a current model for the interaction of Rho with RNA, three derivatives of Rho were made containing single cysteine residues and modified with a photo-activable cross-linker. The positions for the cysteines were: 1) in part of the primary RNA-binding site in the N terminus (Cys-82 Rho); 2) in a connecting polypeptide proposed to be on the outside of the hexamer (Cys-153 Rho); and 3) near the proposed secondary RNA-binding site in the ATP-binding domain (Cys-325 Rho). Results from the cross-linking of the modified Rho proteins to a series of lambda cro RNA derivatives showed that Cys-82 Rho formed cross-links with all transcripts containing the Rho utilization (rut) site, that Cys-325 Rho formed cross-links to transcripts that had the rut site and 10 or more residues 3' of the rut site, and that Cys-153 did not form cross-links with any of the transcripts. From a model of the quaternary structure of Rho, which is largely based on homology to the F(1)-ATPase, amino acid 82 is located near the top of the hexamer, and amino acid 325 is located on a solvent-accessible loop in the center of the hexamer. These data are consistent with binding of the rut region of RNA around the crown, with its 3'-segment passing through the center of the Rho hexamer.

Reproducing tna Operon Regulation in Vitro in an S-30 System: TRYPTOPHAN INDUCTION INHIBITS CLEAVAGE OF TnaC PEPTIDYL-tRNA

Expression of the tryptophanase (tna) operon of Escherichia coli is regulated by catabolite repression and tryptophan-induced transcription antitermination. Catabolite repression regulates transcription initiation, whereas excess tryptophan induces antitermination at Rho factor-dependent termination sites in the leader region of the operon. Synthesis of the leader peptide, TnaC, is essential for antitermination. BoxA and rut sites in the immediate vicinity of the tnaC stop codon are required for termination. In this paper we use an in vitro S-30 cell-free system to analyze the features of tna operon regulation. We show that transcription initiation is cyclic AMP (cAMP)-dependent and is not influenced by tryptophan. Continuation of transcription beyond the leader region requires the presence of inducing levels of tryptophan and synthesis of the TnaC leader peptide. Using a tnaA'-'trpE fusion, we demonstrate that induction results in a 15-20-fold increase in synthesis of the tryptophan-free TnaA-TrpE fusion protein. Replacing Trp codon 12 of tnaC by an Arg codon, or changing the tnaC start codon to a stop codon, eliminates induction. Addition of bicyclomycin, a specific inhibitor of Rho factor action, substantially increases basal level expression. Analyses of tna mRNA synthesis in vitro demonstrate that, in the absence of inducer transcription is terminated and the terminated transcripts are degraded. In the presence of inducer, antitermination increases the synthesis of the read-through transcript. TnaC synthesis is observed in the cell-free system. However, in the presence of tryptophan, a peptidyl-tRNA also appears, TnaC-tRNA(Pro). Our findings suggest that inducer acts by preventing cleavage of TnaC peptidyl-tRNA. The ribosome associated with this newly synthesized peptidyl-tRNA presumably stalls at the tnaC stop codon, blocking Rho's access to the BoxA and rut sites, thereby preventing termination. 1-Methyltryptophan also is an effective inducer in vitro. This tryptophan analog is not incorporated into TnaC.

Rut Sites in the Nascent Transcript Mediate Rho-dependent Transcription Termination in Vivo

The in vitro function of the coliphage lambda tR1 Rho-dependent terminator is governed primarily by a tripartite upstream sequence element designated rut. To determine the contribution of the different components of the rut site to terminator function in the normal context of coupled translation of the nascent cro message, tR1 variants lacking different rut site sequences were tested for terminator function in vivo. Intact rutA and rutB sequences were both necessary for efficient termination. However, deletion of the upstream rutA was far more detrimental than deletion of rutB. The intervening boxB, which encodes a short RNA stem and loop, could be deleted without reducing termination or detectably altering Rho's interaction with the corresponding cro transcript. The relative importance of these sequence elements was also the same in a minimal in vitro termination assay system. Rut sequences are therefore essential for terminator function in vivo and rutA contributes substantially more to tR1 function than does rutB. The relative contribution of these elements can be ascribed to differences in Rho's binding affinity for the encoded transcripts. If other cellular factors also bind the rut element RNA, they do not alter the relative contribution of its two regions to Rho-dependent transcription termination in vivo.

N-Independent leftward transcription in coliphage lambda: Deletions, insertions and new promoters bypassing termination functions

Lambda mutants capable of N-independent red-gam gene expression were isolated by selecting Fec+ plaque-forming derivatives of lambda N+ nutL- (Fec-) strains. In addition to true nutL+ reversions, three classes of second-site mutations were identified: (1) ninL deletions that remove a region containing either tL1 or both tL1 and tL2 termination signals, or only a small region (defining the rut site) just upstream from tL1, (2) new constitutive promoters that map just upstream from the tL2 termination site and which are created either by point mutations (hip) or by short insertion sequences (isp), (3) small internal deletions in gene cro. The positions and individual effects of these mutations, some of which only partially abolish termination function, provide evidence for a complex multipartite structure of the termination signals.