Background: To date, in breast cancer (BC) treatment, adjuvant chemotherapy (A-CT) has preceded adjuvant radiotherapy (A-RT). In the last twenty years, the adjuvant treatment of BC has quickly evolved due to better knowledge of its molecular biology, genetic profile, and α/β ratio of 3/4 Gy for tumor and normal tissue radiosensitivity. Thus, new schedules with hypofractionated radiotherapy have been tested, and a third generation of A-CT has been introduced, raising the question of whether it is time to rethink the sequencing between these two approaches. Methods: In the last 20 years, many attempts have been made worldwide to optimize the best sequencing strategy between these two approaches in terms of sequential CT-RT and RT-CT and concomitant and sandwich modalities using drugs and schedules. This paper presents a comprehensive review of the state of the art, analyzing all the available studies to assess the sequencing between A-CT and A-RT with different generations of chemotherapy schedules. Results: More than 8000 patients from 30 studies treated with adjuvant chemotherapy and whole breast radiotherapy who were enrolled in randomized, retrospective, and prospective studies were analyzed. Sequential, concomitant, and sandwich modalities of chemotherapy with conventional or hypofractionated RT schedules from the most important studies were included. The most used sequence was adjuvant chemotherapy followed by conventional or hypofractionated radiotherapy. In the concomitant approach, i.v. CMF has been the most important adopted schedule, while the concomitant use of anthracyclines and taxanes with conventional or hypofractionated radiotherapy has been found to be more toxic. One study analyzed the benefit in terms of reducing adjuvant treatment time with upfront hypofractionated radiotherapy and third-generation chemotherapy. Conclusions: At present, the best sequencing strategy has not yet been defined. This comprehensive review is a journey among the most important randomized, retrospective, and prospective studies that highlights the past, current, and novel time sequencing proposals between A-CT and A-RT to assess the state of the art and provide useful information for future adjuvant approaches in breast cancer treatment.
Read full abstract