ABSTRACT The root phosphorus (P) uptake efficiency (RE), defined as plant P uptake per unit root mass or root area, may contribute to the P efficiency of upland rice grown in acid, P-deficient soils. The identification of root traits conferring RE of rice has been compromised by the lack of attention given to P speciation when evaluating P-mining mechanisms. Here we disentangled the effect of soluble organic P (PO) from that of total soluble P (PT) on the RE in rice seedlings in acid soil. Six rice genotypes were grown for 21 days in P-deficient substrates, i.e. a sample of an acid mineral soil, an acid peat and a mixture thereof. Each of the three substrates were amended with different P doses, partially limed and incubated, yielding substrates with significant differences in total soluble P (0.005–0.41 mg P/L) and in the percentage of organic P in that pool (PO/PT, 0–55%). Plants showed a large growth response to the P addition. There was a significant genotypic variation in P uptake (0.9–1.5mg P/plant) and RE (4.4–8.3 mg P/g root mass) under moderate P deficiency but these traits were unaffected by the PO/PT in the soluble fraction of the substrates. Along the same lines, phosphatase activity in the rhizosphere soil was unaffected by genotypes and did not explain the RE among all data (R2 = 0.17, ns). A multiple regression model showed that the RE of rice seedlings was mainly affected by the inherent genotypic effects, the PO/PT and the total soluble P concentration in soil (R2 = 0.73), while the genotype-PO/PT interaction only marginally improved the RE model (R2 = 0.78). This suggests limited genotypic effects due to the better use of organic P. A root elongation test in the acid mineral soil that was either or not limed suggests that the differences in acid soil tolerance may play a larger role in the genotypic performance of RE than organic P utilization potential.
Read full abstract