A Moral Reckoning: The Role of Catholic Church in Holocaust and Its Unfulfilled Duty of Repair. By Daniel Jonah Goldhagen. (New York: Alfred A. Knopf. 2002. Pp. 352. $25.00.) A Moral Reckoning: The Role of Catholic Church in Holocaust and its Unfulfilled Duty of Repair is yet another attack on Catholic Church, focusing on World War II and Holocaust. This book, however, is noteworthy both for breathtaking scope of its claims and air of righteous indignation that infuses it. Not content to argue that Pope Pius XII did less to save than he should have, author goes much farther-to attack Pius as an anti-Semite and Church as an institution thoroughly permeated by anti-Semitism. In fact, he argues that the main responsibility for producing this alltime leading Western hatred lies with Christianity. More specifically, with Catholic Church. Goldhagen claims that Catholic Church provided Nazis with a motive for murder and should be held to a moral reckoning for its sinful behavior. He argues that authors of New Testament inserted anti-Semitic passages into text decades after crucifixion in order to serve their own political needs and that these passages should be expunged. As such, Goldhagen's book is simply an attack on papacy or Catholic Church, but on Christianity itself, especially New Testament, which Goldhagen says is fictitious and not a reliable rendition of facts and events, but legend. Goldhagen's focus is on those passages of New Testament that long have been recognized as containing language that can be misunderstood. For in-stance, he cites John, chapter 8. Here Jesus is instructing people on need to follow him. Jesus tells them to reject Satan and follow him to Father. If you remain in my word, you will truly be my disciples, and you will know truth, and truth will set you free. He continues: You belong to your father devil and you willingly carry out your father's desires. He was a murderer from beginning and does stand in truth, because there is no truth in him. When he tells a lie, he speaks in character, because he is a liar and father of lies. But because I speak truth, you do believe me. Goldhagen argues that these words are anti-Semitic because Jesus is calling Jews children of devil. The Gospel does say that Jesus was talking to a group of but that-in context-is like saying he was talking to any group of people who were his followers. In John, chapter 8, he was trying to convince a group of those people to follow him. He was talking to Jews, and his words, as recorded in scripture, were anti-Semitic! Goldhagen is also outraged by Matthew 27:24-25, where Jesus is handed over to Roman authorities, ultimately to face crucifixion. Pontius Pilate offered to free one of criminals, and crowd called for Barabbas. As Matthew reports: So when Pilate saw that he was gaining nothing, but rather that a riot was beginning, he took water and washed his hands before crowd, saying,! am innocent of this man's blood; see to it yourselves. And all people answered,His blood be on us and on our children! Goldhagen argues that Matthew here falsely attributes blame for crucifixion to all for all times, that this instilled a hatred of into European psyche, and that Hitler merely had to exploit this pre-existing attitude to his own perverted ends. The remedy that Goldhagen proposes includes having Christians agree that Christ is only way to salvation and having them (with help from non-Christians) re-write Gospels to purge offensive, anti-Semitic passages. He goes on to demand that Catholic Church make reparations to Jews. He says that money reparations are deserved; political reparations are useful; but above all he stresses need for Church to admit its moral failings. …
Read full abstract