Risk Of Motor Vehicle Crashes Research Articles

Non-benzodiazepine Hypnotics and Police-Reported Motor Vehicle Crash Risk among Older Adults: A Sequential Target Trial Emulation.

Non-benzodiazepine hypnotics ( "Z-drugs") are prescribed for insomnia, but might increase risk of motor vehicle crash (MVC) among older adults through prolonged drowsiness and delayed reaction times. We estimated the effect of initiating Z-drug treatment on the 12-week risk of MVC in a sequential target trial emulation. After linking New Jersey driver licensing and police-reported MVC data to Medicare claims, we emulated a new target trial each week (July 1, 2007 - October 7, 2017) in which Medicare fee-for-service beneficiaries were classified as Z-drug-treated or untreated at baseline and followed for an MVC. We used inverse probability of treatment and censoring weighted pooled logistic regression models to estimate risk ratios (RR) and risk differences with 95% bootstrap confidence limits (CLs). There were 257,554 person-trials, of which 103,371 were Z-drug-treated and 154,183 untreated, giving rise to 976 and 1,249 MVCs, respectively. The intention-to-treat RR was 1.06 (95%CLs 0.95, 1.16). For the per-protocol estimand, there were 800 MVCs and 1,241 MVCs among treated and untreated person-trials, respectively, suggesting a reduced MVC risk (RR 0.83 [95%CLs 0.74, 0.92]) with sustained Z-drug treatment. Z-drugs should be prescribed to older patients judiciously but not withheld entirely over concerns about MVC risk.

Cognitive workload classification of law enforcement officers using physiological responses

Motor vehicle crashes (MVCs) are a leading cause of death for law enforcement officers (LEOs) in the U.S. LEOs and more specifically novice LEOs (nLEOs) are susceptible to high cognitive workload while driving which can lead to fatal MVCs. The objective of this study was to develop a machine learning algorithm (MLA) that can estimate cognitive workload of LEOs while performing secondary tasks in a patrol vehicle. A ride-along study was conducted with 24 nLEOs. Participants performed their normal patrol operations while their physiological responses such as heartrate, eye movement, and galvanic skin response were recorded using unobtrusive devices. Findings suggested that the random forest algorithm could predict cognitive workload with relatively high accuracy (>70%) given that it was entirely reliant on physiological signals. The developed MLA can be used to develop adaptive in-vehicle technology based on real-time estimation of cognitive workload, which can reduce the risk of MVCs in police operations.

Accuracy and replicability of identifying eyelid tremor as an indicator of recent cannabis smoking

Introduction Cannabis intoxication may increase the risk of motor vehicle crashes. However, reliable methods of assessing cannabis intoxication are limited. The presence of eyelid tremors is among the signs of cannabis use identified under the Drug Evaluation and Classification Program of the International Association of Chiefs of Police. Our objectives were to assess the accuracy and replicability of identifying eyelid tremor as an indicator of recent cannabis smoking using a blinded, controlled study design. Methods Adult subjects (N = 103) were recruited into three groups based on their cannabis use history: daily, occasional, and no current cannabis use. Participants’ closed eyelids were video recorded for 30 seconds by infrared videography goggles before and at a mean ± standard deviation time of 71.4 ± 4.6 minutes after the onset of a 15-minute interval of ad libitum cannabis flower smoking or vaping. Three observers with expertise in neuro-ophthalmology and medical toxicology were trained on exemplar videos of eyelids to reach a consensus on how to grade eyelid tremor. Without knowledge of subjects’ cannabis use history or time point (pre- or post-smoking), observers reviewed each video for eyelid tremor graded as absent, slight, moderate, or severe. During subsequent data analysis, this score was further dichotomized as a consensus score of absent (absent/slight) or present (moderate/severe). Results Kappa and intraclass correlation coefficient statistics demonstrated moderate agreement among the coders, which ranged from 0.44–0.45 and 0.58–0.61, respectively. There was no significant association between recent cannabis use and the observers’ consensus assessment that eyelid tremor was present, and cannabis users were less likely to have tremors (odds ratio: 0.75; 95 percent confidence interval: 0.25, 2.40). The assessment of eyelid tremor as an indicator of recent cannabis smoking had a sensitivity of 0.86, specificity of 0.18, and accuracy of 0.64. Discussion Eyelid tremor has fair sensitivity but poor specificity and accuracy for identification of recent cannabis use. Inter-rater reliability for assessment of eyelid tremor was moderate for the presence and degree of tremor. The weak association between recent cannabis use and eyelid tremor does not support its utility in identifying recent cannabis use. Limitations Videos were recorded at only one time point after cannabis use. Adherence to abstinence could not be strictly supervised. Due to regulatory restrictions, we were unable to control the cannabis product used or administer a fixed Δ9-tetrahydrocannabinol dose. Participants were predominately non-Hispanic and White. Conclusions In a cohort of participants with a range of cannabis use histories, acute cannabis smoking was not associated with the presence of eyelid tremor, regardless of cannabis use history, at 70 minutes post-smoking. Additional research is needed to identify the presence of eyelid tremor accurately, determine the relationship between cannabis dose and timeline in relation to last cannabis use to eyelid tremor, and determine how it should be, if at all, utilized for cannabis Drug Recognition Evaluator examinations.

Syncope While Driving and the Risk of a Subsequent Motor Vehicle Crash

Syncope that occurs while driving can result in a motor vehicle crash. Whether individuals with a prior syncope-related crash exhibit an exceptional risk of subsequent crash remains uncertain. We performed a population-based retrospective observational study of patients diagnosed with 'syncope and collapse' at any of 6 emergency departments in British Columbia, Canada (2010 to 2015). Data were obtained from chart abstraction, administrative health records, insurance claims and police crash reports. We compared crash-free survival among individuals with crash-associated syncope (a crash and an emergency visit for syncope on the same date) to that among controls with syncope alone (no crash on date of emergency visit for syncope). In the year following their index emergency visit, 13 of 63 drivers with crash-associated syncope and 852 of 9,160 controls with syncope alone experienced a subsequent crash as a driver (crash risk 21% versus 9%). After accounting for censoring and potential confounders, crash-associated syncope was not associated with a significant increase in the risk of subsequent crash (adjusted hazard ratio [aHR] 1.38, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.78 to 2.47). Individuals with crash-associated syncope were 31-fold more likely to have physician driving advice documented during their index visit (prevalence ratio 31.0, 95% CI, 21.3 to 45.1). In the subgroup without documented driving advice, crash-associated syncope was associated with a significant increase in subsequent crash risk (aHR 1.88, 95% CI 1.06 to 3.36). Crash risk after crash-associated syncope appears similar to crash risk after syncope alone.

Risks of motor vehicle crash before and during pregnancy: A population-based controlled study in Taiwan

BackgroundChanges in risk of motor vehicle crashes (MVCs) during pregnancy are less known, and very few studies have assessed this issue by using unselected population-based datasets and adopting a before-and-during design. The study aimed to address the risk of MVC events in association with pregnancy using a national pregnant women cohort in Taiwan. MethodsWe conducted a self-matched design in which each woman served as a driver before and during pregnancy. A total of 1,372,664 pregnant women with live birth(s) at 18–50 years of age between 2008 and 2017 were identified from the Birth Notification dataset. MVC events as a driver were ascertained from the Police-reported Traffic Accident Registry dataset. We calculated the rate ratio (RR) with a 95 % confidence interval (CI) using the conditional Poisson regression model to compare the MVC event rates between pre-pregnancy and pregnancy periods. ResultsThe overall rate of MVC events was significantly reduced during pregnancy (RR = 0.69, 95 % confidence interval (CI) = 0.68–0.71). Mothers with alcoholism during pregnancy were associated with an increased RR at 2.00 but with a very wide CI. Reduction in RR was primarily attributed to the reduced MVC event rate involving scooter crashes (0.60, 95 % CI = 0.58–0.62). ConclusionAlthough MVC event rates decreased during women became pregnant, many women drivers were still involved in MVCs during pregnancy. Their potential maternal and perinatal conditions along with their offspring's health outcomes need further investigations.

Motor Vehicle Crash Risk in Older Adult Drivers With Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder

Symptoms of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), such as inattentiveness and impulsivity, could affect daily functioning and driving performance throughout the life span. Previous research on ADHD and driving safety is largely limited to adolescents and young adults. To examine the prevalence of ADHD and the association between ADHD and crash risk among older adult drivers. This prospective cohort study collected data from primary care clinics and residential communities in 5 US sites (Ann Arbor, Michigan; Baltimore, Maryland; Cooperstown, New York; Denver, Colorado; and San Diego, California) between July 6, 2015, and March 31, 2019. Participants were active drivers aged 65 to 79 years at baseline enrolled in the Longitudinal Research on Aging Drivers project who were studied for up to 44 months through in-vehicle data recording devices and annual assessments. The data analysis was performed between July 15, 2022, and August 14, 2023. Lifetime ADHD based on an affirmative response to the question of whether the participant had ever had ADHD or had ever been told by a physician or other health professional that he or she had ADHD. The main outcomes were hard-braking events defined as maneuvers with deceleration rates of 0.4g or greater, self-reported traffic ticket events, and self-reported vehicular crashes. Multivariable negative binomial modeling was used to estimate adjusted incidence rate ratios (aIRRs) and 95% CIs of outcomes according to exposure status. Of the 2832 drivers studied, 1500 (53.0%) were women and 1332 (47.0%) were men with a mean (SD) age of 71 (4) years. The lifetime prevalence of ADHD in the study sample was 2.6%. Older adult drivers with ADHD had significantly higher incidence rates of hard-braking events per 1000 miles than those without ADHD (1.35 [95% CI, 1.30-1.41] vs 1.15 [95% CI, 1.14-1.16]), as well as self-reported traffic ticket events per 1 million miles (22.47 [95% CI, 16.06-31.45] vs 9.74 [95% CI, 8.99-10.55]) and self-reported vehicular crashes per 1 million miles (27.10 [95% CI, 19.95-36.80] vs 13.50 [95% CI, 12.61-14.46]). With adjustment for baseline characteristics, ADHD was associated with a significant 7% increased risk of hard-braking events (aIRR, 1.07; 95% CI, 1.02-1.12), a 102% increased risk of self-reported traffic ticket events (aIRR, 2.02; 95% CI, 1.42-2.88), and a 74% increased risk of self-reported vehicular crashes (aIRR, 1.74; 95% CI, 1.26-2.40). As observed in this prospective cohort study, older adult drivers with ADHD may be at a significantly elevated crash risk compared with their counterparts without ADHD. These findings suggest that effective interventions to improve the diagnosis and clinical management of ADHD among older adults are warranted to promote safe mobility and healthy aging.

Conditional Poisson Regression with Random Effects for the Analysis of Multi-site Time Series Studies.

The analysis of time series studies linking daily counts of a health indicator with environmental variables (e.g., mortality or hospital admissions with air pollution concentrations or temperature; or motor vehicle crashes with temperature) is usually conducted with Poisson regression models controlling for long-term and seasonal trends using temporal strata. When the study includes multiple zones, analysts usually apply a two-stage approach: first, each zone is analyzed separately, and the resulting zone-specific estimates are then combined using meta-analysis. This approach allows zone-specific control for trends. A one-stage approach uses spatio-temporal strata and could be seen as a particular case of the case-time series framework recently proposed. However, the number of strata can escalate very rapidly in a long time series with many zones. A computationally efficient alternative is to fit a conditional Poisson regression model, avoiding the estimation of the nuisance strata. To allow for zone-specific effects, we propose a conditional Poisson regression model with a random slope, although available frequentist software does not implement this model. Here, we implement our approach in the Bayesian paradigm, which also facilitates the inclusion of spatial patterns in the effect of interest. We also provide a possible extension to deal with overdispersed data. We first introduce the equations of the framework and then illustrate their application to data from a previously published study on the effects of temperature on the risk of motor vehicle crashes. We provide R code and a semi-synthetic dataset to reproduce all analyses presented.

Associations between vision impairment and vision-related interventions on crash risk and driving cessation: systematic review and meta-analysis

ObjectivesTo systematically investigate the associations between vision impairment and risk of motor vehicle crash (MVC) involvement, and evaluate vision-related interventions to reduce MVCs.DesignMedline (Ovid), EMBASE and Global Health electronic databases...

Rates and predictors of teen driver crash culpability

Background: Motor-vehicle crash risk is highest among teen drivers. Despite a wealth of research on the topic, there are still many contributors to these crashes that are not well understood. The current study sought to examine the contribution of graduated driver licensing (GDL) restrictions, sex, age, roadway circumstances, and citation history to teen drivers’ crash culpability. Method: Crash system data from the Iowa Department of Transportation were linked with traffic-related charges from the Iowa Court Information System. Crashes involving teens aged 14 to 17 years between 2016 and 2019 were analyzed (N = 19,847). Culpability was determined using the driver contributing circumstances from the crash report. Moving and non-moving traffic citations issued prior to the date of each crash were considered. A multivariable logistic regression model was constructed to examine predictors of crash culpability. Results: Teen drivers were determined to be culpable for more than two thirds of crashes (N = 13,604, 68.54%). Culpability was more prevalent among males, younger teens, in rural areas, in the presence of reported roadway contributing circumstances, during hours of restricted nighttime driving, and among teens with citation histories that included both moving and non-moving citations. Similarly, multivariable model results indicated that the likelihood of culpability was higher among males, in rural areas, and at each stage of GDL compared to teen drivers with unrestricted licenses. While drivers with a history of both moving and non-moving violations were more likely to be culpable, those with a history of only moving or only non-moving violations were less likely to be culpable compared to those with no violation history. Conclusion: Sex, crash location, and GDL stage were associated with teen driver crash culpability. A singular prior moving or non-moving violation may play a protective role in teen crash culpability.

Motor Vehicle Crash Risk among Adults Undergoing General Surgery: A Retrospective Case-crossover Study.

Surgery causes transient impairment in cognition and function, which may impact driving safety. The authors hypothesized that the risk of a motor vehicle crash would increase after compared to before surgery. The authors performed a nested case-crossover study within population-based observational data from the New Jersey Safety Health Outcomes Data Warehouse. The study included adults 18 yr or older with a valid driver's license who underwent general surgery in an acute care hospital in New Jersey between January 1, 2016, and November 30, 2017, and were discharged home. Individuals served as their own controls within a presurgery interval (56 days to 28 days before surgery) and postsurgery interval (discharge through 28 days after surgery). General surgery was defined by Common Procedural Terminology Codes. The primary outcome was a police-reported motor vehicle crash. In a cohort of 70,722 drivers, the number of crashes after surgery was 263 (0.37%) compared to 279 (0.39%) before surgery. Surgery was not associated with a change in crash incidence greater than 28 days using a case-crossover design (adjusted incidence rate ratio, 0.92; 95% CI, 0.78 to 1.09; P = 0.340). Statistical interaction was present for sex and hospital length of stay. Younger versus older adults (adjusted risk ratio, 1.87; 95% CI, 1.10 to 3.18; P = 0.021) and non-Hispanic Black individuals (adjusted risk ratio, 1.96; 95% CI, 1.33 to 2.88; P = 0.001) and Hispanic individuals (adjusted risk ratio, 1.38; 95% CI, 1.00 to 1.91; P = 0.047) versus non-Hispanic White individuals had a greater risk of a crash after surgery. Using population-based crash and hospital discharge data, the incidence of motor vehicle crashes over a 28-day period did not change on average before compared to after surgery. The authors provide data on crash risk after surgery and highlight specific populations at risk.

Self-harm in adolescence and risk of crash: a 13-year cohort study of novice drivers in New South Wales, Australia

IntroductionSelf-harm and suicide are leading causes of morbidity and death for young people, worldwide. Previous research has identified self-harm is a risk factor for vehicle crashes, however, there is a...

Special Report from the CDC Healthcare provider influence on driving behavior after a mild traumatic brain injury: Findings from the 2021 SummerStyles survey

Introduction: Research shows that a mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) impairs a person's ability to identify driving hazards 24 h post injury and increases the risk for motor vehicle crash. This study examined the percentage of people who reported driving after their most serious mTBI and whether healthcare provider education influenced this behavior. Methods: Self-reported data were collected from 4,082 adult respondents in the summer wave of Porter Novelli’s 2021 ConsumerStyles survey. Respondents with a driver’s license were asked whether they drove right after their most serious mTBI, how safe they felt driving, and whether a doctor or nurse talked to them about when it was ok to drive after their injury. Results: About one in five (18.8 %) respondents reported sustaining an mTBI in their lifetime. Twenty-two percent (22.3 %) of those with a driver’s license at the time of their most serious mTBI drove within 24 h, and 20 % felt very or somewhat unsafe doing so. About 19 % of drivers reported that a doctor or nurse talked to them about when it was safe to return to driving. Those who had a healthcare provider talk to them about driving were 66 % less likely to drive a car within 24 h of their most serious mTBI (APR = 0.34, 95 % CI: 0.20, 0.60) compared to those who did not speak to a healthcare provider about driving. Conclusions: Increasing the number of healthcare providers who discuss safe driving practices after a mTBI may reduce acute post-mTBI driving. Practical Applications: Inclusion of information in patient discharge instructions and prompts for healthcare providers in electronic medical records may help encourage conversations about post-mTBI driving.

Associations of cannabis use with motor vehicle crashes and traffic stops among older drivers: AAA LongROAD study

Background Acute cannabis use is associated with a higher risk of motor vehicle crashes (MVC). This study aimed to determine if self-reported past-year cannabis use is associated with MVC or traffic stops among older drivers. Methods This cross-sectional analysis used data from a multi-center study enrolling active drivers aged 65-79 years. Data regarding cannabis use, MVC, and traffic stops (i.e., being pulled over by police, whether ticketed or not) within the previous 12 months were collected through participant interviews. Log-binomial regression models examined associations of past-year cannabis use with MVC and traffic stops, adjusting for site and sociodemographic and mental health characteristics. Results Of 2,095 participating older drivers, 186 (8.88%) used cannabis in the past year but only 10 (<0.5%) within an hour before driving in the last 30 days; 11.41% reported an MVC and 9.45% reported a traffic stop. Past-year cannabis users had a higher prevalence of MVC (adjusted prevalence ratio [aPR] = 1.38; 95%CI: 0.96, 2.00; p = 0.086) and traffic stops (aPR = 1.58; 1.06, 2.35; p = 0.024). Conclusions Past-year cannabis use was associated with increased traffic stops, which are correlated modestly with increased MVC in past studies and may indicate impaired driving performance. We did not find a statistically significant association of past-year cannabis use with MVC, which may indicate limited sustained effects on driving performance from periodic use among older adults, who report rarely driving immediately after use.

Healthcare Access Disparities &amp; Motor Vehicle Crashes (Web of Science Core Collection).

Abstract Scoping review on health care access and quality and crash predictors and outcomes in the US. This review will help define the state of the field in terms of how the Social determinants of health (SDoH) indicator of healthcare access and quality is being examined in relation to behavioral motor vehicle crashrisk factors and outcomes. This search was conducted by a health sciences librarian in conjunction with two members of the research team.

Healthcare Access Disparities &amp; Motor Vehicle Crashes (TRID &amp; ITRD).

Abstract Scoping review on health care access and quality and crash predictors and outcomes in the US. This review will help define the state of the field in terms of how the Social determinants of health (SDoH) indicator of healthcare access and quality is being examined in relation to behavioral motor vehicle crashrisk factors and outcomes. This search was conducted by a health sciences librarian in conjunction with two members of the research team.

Healthcare Access Disparities &amp; Motor Vehicle Crashes (Embase).

Abstract Scoping review on health care access and quality and crash predictors and outcomes in the US. This review will help define the state of the field in terms of how the Social determinants of health (SDoH) indicator of healthcare access and quality is being examined in relation to behavioral motor vehicle crashrisk factors and outcomes. This search was conducted by a health sciences librarian in conjunction with two members of the research team.

Healthcare Access Disparities &amp; Motor Vehicle Crashes (CINAHL Complete).

Abstract Scoping review on health care access and quality and crash predictors and outcomes in the US. This review will help define the state of the field in terms of how the Social determinants of health (SDoH) indicator of healthcare access and quality is being examined in relation to behavioral motor vehicle crashrisk factors and outcomes. This search was conducted by a health sciences librarian in conjunction with two members of the research team.

Healthcare Access Disparities &amp; Motor Vehicle Crashes (Medline, PubMed).

Abstract Scoping review on health care access and quality and crash predictors and outcomes in the US. This review will help define the state of the field in terms of how the Social determinants of health (SDoH) indicator of healthcare access and quality is being examined in relation to behavioral motor vehicle crashrisk factors and outcomes. This search was conducted by a health sciences librarian in conjunction with two members of the research team.

O066 The Impact of Work Break Characteristics on Sleep Duration in Heavy Vehicle Drivers

Abstract Introduction Heavy vehicle drivers (HVDs) frequently experience reduced sleep due to travelling long distances under non-standard work hours. Short sleep in HVDs can increase risk of motor vehicle crashes and falling asleep while driving. This study sought to examine the influence of break duration between shifts, break onset time, and prior shift duration on HVDs’ total sleep time (TST) between consecutive work shifts, and the interaction between break duration and break onset time. Methods Twenty-seven HVDs’ sleep and shift work were monitored for up to nine weeks through actigraphy, sleep diaries, and work diaries. Differences in TST between consecutive shifts and days off were assessed. Linear mixed models and pairwise comparisons evaluated the impact of break duration, break onset time, and prior shift duration on TST between shifts. Results TST was significantly lower between consecutive shifts (M=6.38-hours) compared to days off (M=7.63-hours), p&amp;lt;.001. Longer break durations were associated with more TST, p&amp;lt;.001. Break durations up to 7-, 9-, and 11-hours resulted in, on average, 4.76-, 5.66-, and 6.41-hours of sleep, respectively. Breaks starting between 00:01-08:00h led to shorter TST compared to breaks starting between 16:01-20:00h, p&amp;lt;.05. Prior shift duration and the interaction between break duration and break onset time were not associated with TST. Discussion HVDs’ TST between workdays are independently impacted by break duration and break onset time. Break durations between 7-11-hours, reflecting Australian and European break guidelines, result in insufficient sleep. Work regulations must evaluate appropriate break durations and break onset times to allow adequate sleep in HVDs.

Ambient temperature and risk of motor vehicle crashes: A countrywide analysis in Spain

BackgroundSome studies have documented that cold or hot ambient temperatures increase the risk of motor vehicle crashes. However, the number of existing studies is still limited, especially for the effects of cold. ObjectivesTo estimate the relationship between ambient temperatures and risk of motor vehicle crashes in Spain, and to estimate the same association when restricting to those crashes with driver performance–associated factors (namely distraction, fatigue, sleepiness or disease). MethodsWe used data for the period 1993–2013. We conducted a time series analysis controlling for seasonality and trends and using the distributed lag nonlinear model framework to estimate nonlinear and delayed effects of up to 7 days. Analyses were conducted at the province level and combined using multivariate meta-analysis. ResultsThe study included 1,908,460 motor vehicle crashes, 37% of them with associated driver performance factors. The overall analysis showed that the risk of crashes increased almost linearly with temperature. The estimates of the cumulative effect of lags 0–7 when comparing the 99th percentile and the first percentile of temperature produced a relative risk (RR) of 1.15 (95% confidence interval (CI): 1.11, 1.20). The estimates were slightly higher when analyses were restricted to crashes with driver performance–associated factors (RR: 1.23, 95% CI: 1.17, 1.30). In some provinces that reached temperatures below 0 °C, an increased risk with cold temperatures was also observed. An added effect of both cold spell and heat wave periods was found only in the analysis of crashes with driver performance–associated factors (cold spells, RR: 1.029, 95% CI: 1.005, 1.053; heat waves, RR: 1.020, 95% CI: 1.002, 1.039). ConclusionsThe increase of temperature increased the risk of motor vehicle crashes in Spain. Measures aimed at reducing the influence of heat on the risk of motor vehicle crashes can have important benefits for public health.