Risk Assessment Guidance For Superfund Research Articles

Pollution characteristics and human health risks of PM2.5-bound heavy metals: a 3-year observation in Suzhou, China.

This study aimed to analyze the temporal trends, pollution levels, and health risks associated with eleven PM2.5-bound heavy metals (Sb, Al, As, Hg, Cd, Cr, Mn, Ni, Pb, Se and Tl). A total of 504 PM2.5 samples were collected in Suzhou from January 2019 to December 2021. The pollution levels were estimated based on enrichment factors (EFs) which can be used to calculate the enrichment of heavy metals in PM2.5 and determine whether the concentrations of PM2.5-bound heavy metals are influenced by the crustal or anthropogenic sources, and the health risk of PM2.5-bound heavy metals via inhalation was assessed following US EPA's Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS). The annual average concentration of PM2.5 was 46.76μgm-3, which was higher than the WHO recommended limit of 5μgm-3. The average of the sum of eleven PM2.5-bound heavy metals was 180.61ngm-3, dominated by Al, Mn, and Pb. The concentration of PM2.5 in 2020 was significantly lower than that in 2019 and 2021. The PM2.5 and PM2.5-bound heavy metal concentrations in winter and spring were significantly higher than those in autumn and summer. The EF of As, Cr, Cd, Hg, Ni, Pb, Sb, Mn, Se, and Tl was higher than 10, indicating they were mainly from anthropogenic sources. Exposure to a single non-carcinogenic heavy metal via inhalation was unlikely to cause non-carcinogenic effects (HQ < 1), but the integrated non-carcinogenic risks should be taken seriously (HI > 1). The cumulative carcinogenic risks from the carcinogenic elements were exceeding the lower limit (1 × 10-6) of the acceptable risk range. The carcinogenic risks of As and Cr(VI) contributed 60.98% and 26.77%, respectively, which were regarded as two key carcinogenic risk factors. Overall, the government policies and countermeasures for the PM2.5 pollution control should be performed not only based on the PM2.5 concentration but also based on the PM2.5-bound heavy metals and their health risks for the local residents.

Distribution, Sources, and Health Risk Assessment of PAHs in Water Supply Source Regions of Guangzhou

Trace polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in drinking water sources have significant harmful effects on human health. Water and sediment samples from water source regions of three water treatment plants in Guangzhou were collected and the distributions of 16 kinds of PAHs were analyzed. The human risk of PAHs in the water samples was also evaluated using the Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS) of the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). The results showed that PAHs in the samples from the three water source regions did not exceed the corresponding standard limit for water quality, and the content of ΣPAHs in suspended solids and sediments was below the medium level. The non-carcinogenic risks (HQ and HI) of PAHs in the water samples were less than 1, and the non-carcinogenic risk was negligible. In addition, Riskingest, Riskdermal, and RiskT for the waters were all in range of 5.53×10-7 to 5.34×10-6, indicating that a carcinogen risk was possible but acceptable. The results of the isomer ratio method indicated that the PAHs in the water sources of the three water plants had a mixed input of pollution, including petroleum discharge, petroleum combustion, and incomplete combustion of wood, coal, and biomass. The total organic carbon (TOC) content of the water and sediment samples was positively correlated with the accumulation and enrichment of low-ring PAHs, and there was a significant positive correlation between PAHs and similar molecules in the sediments. The ΣPAHs in the water and sediment samples were also strongly correlated.

Municipal solid waste management health risk assessment from air emissions for China by applying life cycle analysis.

This study is to quantify and objectively evaluate the extent of environmental health risks from three waste treatment options suggested by the national municipal solid waste management enhancing strategy (No [2011] 9 of the State Council, promulgated on 19 April 2011), which includes sanitary landfill, waste-to-energy incineration and compost, together with the material recovery facility through a case study in Zhangqiu City of China. It addresses potential chronic health risks from air emissions to residential receptors in the impacted area. It combines field survey, analogue survey, design documents and life cycle inventory methods in defining the source strength of chemicals of potential concern. The modelling of life cycle inventory and air dispersion is via integrated waste management(IWM)-2 and Screening Air Dispersion Model (Version 3.0) (SCREEN3). The health risk assessment is in accordance with United States Environmental Protection Agency guidance Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS), Volume I: Human Health Evaluation Manual (Part F, Supplemental Guidance for Inhalation Risk Assessment). The exposure concentration is based on long-term exposure to the maximum ground level contaminant in air under the 'reasonable worst situation' emissions and then directly compared with reference for concentration and unit risk factor/cancer slope factor derived from the national air quality standard (for a conventional pollutant) and toxicological studies (for a specific pollutant). Results from this study suggest that the option of compost with material recovery facility treatment may pose less negative health impacts than other options; the sensitivity analysis shows that the landfill integrated waste management collection rate has a great influence on the impact results. Further investigation is needed to validate or challenge the findings of this study.

Heavy metal pollution and health risk assessment in the Wei River in China.

From data collected monthly at 26 monitoring cross sections in the Wei River in the Shaanxi Region of China during the period 2008-2012, the temporal pollution characteristics of heavy metals (Hg, Cd, Cr(VI), Pb, and As) were analyzed based on a heavy metal pollution index (HPI). The monthly HPI values of the five heavy metals in the river fluctuated greatly in 2008 and then declined gradually with time. This general trend of reduction in HPI appears not to have a seasonal variation and most likely resulted from the continued improvement in heavy metal pollution control strategies implemented by local environmental agencies combined with a significant improvement in wastewater treatment capacities. Among the five heavy metals, Cd and Pb were below 0.1 and 3μgL(-1), respectively, at all the sampling points in the studied areas in the year 2012. The detection rates of As, Hg, and Cr(VI) were in the order of Hg > Cr(VI) > As. Hg, Cr(VI), and As exceeded, in a month of the dry season in 2012, the standard limits for category III surface waters according to the China Environment Quality Standards for Surface Water (CEQSSW). Based on the assessment using the HPI method, the pollution status of these heavy metals in water of the Wei River in the Shaanxi Region was generally at an acceptable level, but exhibited distinctive characteristics between the main stream river and tributaries. Most of the tributaries were more seriously polluted than the main river. A health risk assessment was conducted based on the Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) method recommended by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA). Apart from As, the health risk for the five heavy metals in the region were at acceptable levels for drinking water sources (hazard quotient (HQ) < 1, carcinogenic risk (CR) ranged from 10(-4)-10(-6)) according to the Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS), USEPA. Arsenic was identified as the most important pollutant of concern among the five heavy metals; both its values of the HQ and CR indicated potentially adverse health risks for the local population.

Persistent organic pollutants (POPs) in the topsoil of typical urban renewal area in Beijing, China: Status, sources and potential risk

In order to assess the health risk of persistent organic pollutants (POPs) in the topsoil of a typical urban renewal area, a comprehensive study was conducted to determine their spatial distribution, possible sources and potential carcinogenic risk. Topsoil samples were collected from former chemical industrial areas in south-east Beijing and tested for concentrations of POPs, including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), organochlorine pesticides (OCPs) and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs). The concentration of PAHs ranged from 126.68 to 365926.17ng/g, OCPs ranged from 2.38 to 933.12ng/g, and PCBs ranged from 47.04 to 3883.77ng/g. The spatial distribution of POPs was mapped using a geographic information system (GIS) to identify hotspots. Although PAHs, OCPs and PCBs varied in terms of their concentration and spatial distribution, the sources of each type of POPs were identified using multivariate statistical analysis and the diagnostic ratios method. Total lifetime carcinogenic risk (TLCR) for PAHs, OCPs and PCBs exposure was evaluated quantitatively for each sampling site using the Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS) methodology, and a risk distribution map was created. The TLCR values of 76% sites for the PAHs were higher than the target level for individual excess lifetime cancer risk (10−6) and with 12% sites were higher than the acceptable levels (10−4) for residential cancer risk. There are 28% sites that have TLCR above 10−6 for recreational exposure to PAHs.

Personal exposure of primary school children to BTEX, NO2 and ozone in Eskişehir, Turkey: Relationship with indoor/outdoor concentrations and risk assessment

Personal exposures of 65 primary school children to benzene, toluene, ethyl benzene, xylenes (BTEX), nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and ozone (O3) were measured during 24h by using organic vapor monitors and tailor-made passive samplers. Two schools were selected to represent students living in more polluted (urban) and less polluted (sub-urban) areas in the city of Eskişehir, Turkey. The pollutant concentrations were also measured in indoor and outdoor environments during the personal sampling to investigate the contribution of each micro-environment on measured personal concentrations. Socio-demographic and personal time–activity data were collected by means of questionnaires and half-hour-time resolution activity diaries. Personal exposure concentrations were found to be correlated with indoor home concentrations. Personal, indoor and outdoor concentrations of all studied pollutants except for ozone were found to be higher for the students living at the urban traffic site. Ozone, on the other hand, had higher concentrations at the sub-urban site for all three types of measurements (personal, indoor and outdoor). Analysis of the questionnaire data pointed out to environmental tobacco smoke, use of solvent based products, and petrol station nearby as factors that affect personal exposure concentrations. Cancer and non-cancer risks were estimated using the personal exposure concentrations. The mean cancer risk for the urban school children (1.7×10−5) was found to be higher than the sub-urban school children (0.88×10−5). Children living with smoking parents had higher risk levels (1.7×10−5) than children living with non-smoking parents (1.08×10−5). Overall, the risk levels were <1×10−4. All hazard quotient values for BTEX for the non-cancer health effects were <1 based on the calculations EPA's Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS) part F.

Characterization of Heavy Metals in the Surrounding of Municipal Solid Waste Incinerator (MSWI) and Health Risks Assessment via Inhalation in Shenzhen Nanshan, China

Take the Shenzhen Nanshan Municipal solid waste incinerator (MSWI) as the object, in total 18 ambient air samples were got. The study analyzed the distribution characteristics of ambient air heavy metals (Cu, Cd, Pb, Cr) and As in the surroundings of the MSWI. The EPA Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS) was used to assess the exposure risk. The results demonstrated that the Pb and Cd value in the surroundings of the MSWI were in the accept level according to the Ambient Air Quality Standards (GB3095-2012); The risk assessment showed that the carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic risks via inhalation exposure in the sorrounding of the MSWI were in the accessible levels.

Dermal absorption of environmental contaminants from soil and sediment: a critical review

Risk assessment of hazardous wastes sites may require characterization of the dermal availability of chemical contaminants in soil and/or sediment. Current U.S. Environmental Protection Agency guidance for assessment of dermal exposures to contaminants in water and soil was finalized in 2004 as a supplement (Part E) to the Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS). The soil protocol presented in RAGS Part E is less sophisticated than the water protocol and is supported by less empirical data. Investigations of dermal absorption of soil and sediment-borne contaminants that have been conducted to date include in vitro and in vivo experiments using both human and surrogate skin. A review of that literature was conducted with attention to relevant criteria including consideration of layering effects, degree of chemical saturation of soil, appropriateness of particle size distribution employed, soil-chemical contact time, and continuity of soil-skin contact (in in vivo studies). Most studies published to date are deficient by virtue of execution or reporting on one or more of the selected criteria. In addition the lack of methodological standardization evident in the literature hinders systematic evaluation of results. Since additional experimental work is needed, general agreement on acceptable approaches would be useful. Recommendations for good practice are presented.

Risk of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) exposure from ingested food: The Azerbaijan case study

Risks due to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) exposure from food consumption for the population of Azerbaijan were determined using deterministic and probabilistic methods. The guidelines and methods described and presented in the United States Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS) Part A was used in performing the risk assessments. The current study utilized concentration data from different sources representing international studies performed over the past decade to determine those food products that contribute the most exposure to PAHs through ingestion for the Azeri population. Due to lack of concentration data from middle-Eastern countries, only European countries were considered and used for this analysis. Using the benzo[a]pyrene (BaP) toxicity equivalency factors (TEFs) to adjust the concentrations of the individual PAH compounds to BaP equivalent concentrations, risk analyses were performed. Deterministic risk estimates fell within probabilistic risk estimates. Child risks were consistently four to seven times higher in magnitude than adult risks. Risk potentials determined for the food exposure pathway were also determined to be up to ten times higher in magnitude than risks determined from exposures due to other pathways such as soil contamination. It was observed that three major factors contributed to the variability in the assessment results, which were child and adult body weights, consumption rates of the different food groups, and the variances of the input data. The most prevalent pathways of PAH exposure from the dietary patterns of the Azerbaijani population were determined to be from bread and bakery products, milk and dairy products, and egg products.*

Comparison of Standard Radiological Risk Models and Using RESRAD to Derive Generic Risk‐Based Area Factors for Final Status Surveys

The RESidual RADioactivity (RESRAD) computer code has been used for years to calculate carcinogenic risk and radiological dose from exposure to radionuclides. The basic ingestion, inhalation, and direct gamma intake equations used by RESRAD, Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS), and the Soil Screening Guidance for Radionuclides (SSG) are similar and can produce similar results, but there are some notable differences. Of particular interest is the fact that RESRAD incorporates sophisticated environmental transport models. Associated environmental parameters allow risk assessors to consider, among other variables, the size (i.e., surface area) of the contaminated zone, a variable not typically addressed quantitatively under the RAGS/SSG paradigm. Considering the similarities between basic RESRAD, RAGS, and SSG intake equations and given the broad acceptance of RESRAD, it stands to reason that RESRAD-derived area factors may be used to supplement RAGS/SSG human health risk calculations. This would allow risk assessors to retrofit existing results or otherwise modify standard RAGS/SSG equations for use in site closeout planning under the Multi-Agency Radiation Survey and Site Investigation Manual (MARSSIM), given a key component of the MARSSIM method is the consideration of small areas of elevated activity or "hot spots" through the use of area factors.

Habitat and exposure modelling for ecological risk assessment: A case study for the raccoon on the Savannah River Site

Contamination has a dramatic impact on the health of ecosystem and habitat suitability for the inhabited flora and fauna. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) mandates an ecological risk assessment (ERA) that evaluates the potential adverse impact of any anthropogenic activities on the ecosystem (US Environmental Protection Agency, 1997. Ecological Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund: Process for Designing and Conducting Ecological Risk Assessment. EPA/630/R-021011, Washington, DC). This study provides a general framework and specific procedures to predict the contaminant exposure of mid-sized mammals using a geographical information system (GIS)-based Monte Carlo simulation model. The model was applied to the raccoons ( Procyon lotor) on the Savannah River Site (SRS), a former nuclear production and current research facility. Habitat behavioral data of 13 radiocollared male raccoons were used to determine home range and core areas. Combined with other geographic data layers, such as distance to water, number of wetlands, and class landscape metrics, a logistic regression model was used to inductively derive the resource selection functions that define the occurrence of raccoon. The cross validation consistently revealed a high accuracy. A Monte Carlo simulation was then performed to estimate the likelihood of exposure and contaminant uptake of the species weighted by the resource selection probability. This model adopted conservative assumptions and spatial parameters. The proposed model served the purpose of assessing ecological risk and supporting decision-making. Implementation issues for a GIS-based ecological risk assessment model are discussed.

Case study of a potency‐weighted emission screen

AbstractAccording to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) document entitled Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS) (EPA/540/1–89/002, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Emergency and Remedial Response, Washington, DC, 1989), a concentration‐toxicity screen is one of the chemicals of potential concern (COPCs) selection processes that may be employed to reduce the number of chemicals carried through a human health risk assessment. COPCs are those constituents for which carcinogenic risks and noncarcinogenic hazards are estimated. This paper describes the results of an analogous approach to rank chemicals at a facility according to their emission rates and potency. The objective of our proposed COPC selection methodology was to consider the comprehensive list of chemicals used in normal operations at a facility with a large chemical inventory and to identify those chemicals that have the potential to contribute at least 90 to 95% of the estimated risk for the facility (i.e., the main risk drivers). By focusing our efforts on this shorter list of chemicals, we increased the accuracy of information obtained from facility personnel and improved the level of confidence in the emission estimation, air dispersion modeling, and risk assessment results. While this approach does not consider constituent transport from multiple facility sources or proximity of receptors to those sources, these effects were evaluated in the subsequent air dispersion modeling and risk assessment of facility emissions. An evaluation of the subsequent risk assessment analyses demonstrated that the potency‐weighted emissions screen was successful in determining the list of chemicals responsible for 90 to 95% of the estimated carcinogenic risks and noncarcinogenic hazards. © 2004 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Environ Prog, 23: 168–177, 2004

Ecological Risk Assessment Guidance and Procedural Documents: An Annotated Compilation and Evaluation of Reference Materials

The scientific approach toward ecological risk assessment (ERA) has advanced greatly during the 1990s. This growth has been accompanied by the development of ERA guidance by USEPA Headquarters, individual USEPA Regions, state environmental agencies, as well as international agencies. This compilation of ERA guidance and procedural documents identifies many of the existing ERA reference materials from the regulatory and/or governmental agency arena. In addition, this compilation provides annotations pertaining to the focus of each reviewed document, and compares/contrasts the approaches presented in the documents. As such, the evaluation provides insight into some of the qualities and levels of detail provided by each document. Examples of documents which are highlighted include recently published USEPA's “Guidelines for Ecological Risk Assessment;” USEPA's “Ecological Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund;” the U.S. Army's “Procedural Guidelines for Ecological Risk Assessments;” and Environment Canada's “Ecological Risk Assessments Under the Canadian Environmental Protection Act.”

A Native American exposure scenario.

EPA's Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS) and later documents provide guidance for estimating exposures received from suburban and agricultural activity patterns and lifestyles. However, these methods are not suitable for typical tribal communities whose members pursue, at least in part, traditional lifestyles. These lifestyles are derived from a long association with all of the resources in a particular region. We interviewed 35 members of a Columbia River Basin tribe to develop a lifestyle-based subsistence exposure scenario that represents a midrange exposure that a traditional tribal member would receive. This scenario provides a way to partially satisfy Executive Order 12,898 on environmental justice, which requires a specific evaluation of impacts from federal actions to peoples with subsistence diets. Because a subsistence diet is only a portion of what is important to a traditional lifestyle, we also used information obtained from the interviews to identify parameters for evaluating impacts to environmental and sociocultural quality of life.

Assessing Health Risks Associated with DDT Residues in Soils in California: A Proposition 65 Case Study

Population growth in California has increased the pressure to convert agricultural land to commercial, industrial, or residential uses. In the ensuing property transactions, buyers and sellers must address the presence of toxic materials in soils such as pesticides, several of which are known to the State of California to cause cancer under Proposition 65. While this statute does not specifically address soil contaminants, the potential scope of its enforcement is sufficiently broad that owners of former agricultural properties may be obliged to provide warning of exposure to potential buyers, occupants, or construction workers about exposure to residues in soil from pesticide applications. However, Proposition 65 provides no guidance on how to assess exposures to chemicals in soil. The U.S. EPA Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS) provides a method for assessing soil-related exposure pathways that is consistent with the intent of Proposition 65. Using this approach, we have calculated the lifetime average concentrations of DDT in soil corresponding to the no-significant-risk level stipulated under Proposition 65 (1 x 10(-5)) for a hypothetical residential exposure scenario. The concentration of DDT in soil corresponding to a no-significant-risk ranges from 7.9-18.8 mg/kg, depending upon which exposure pathways are deemed to be complete for residential land use. It is argued that Proposition 65 forces the assessment and possible cleanup of such a situation through the threat of creating a health risk perception that could affect the market value of a property.

Comparing the Results of a Monte Carlo Analysis with EPA′s Reasonable Maximum Exposed Individual (RMEI): A Case Study of a Former Wood Treatment Site

In the United States, there are about 250 former sites that treated wood with preservatives that are now in need of some degree of remediation. The soil at many of these sites is contaminated with creosote, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), polychlorinated dibenzo- p-dioxins (PCDDs), and polychlorinated dibenzofurans (PCDFs). This paper compares the results of the current USEPA point estimate (deterministic) approach for predicting the health risks associated with exposure to PCDDs/PCDFs in soil with the results of a probabilistic approach which uses a Monte Carlo analysis. At many of these wood treatment sites the hazard posed by the PAHs, and especially pentachlorophenol, can be much greater than that due to PCDD and PCDFs; however, because at this site the health risk associated with PAHs was deemed negligible by ATSDR, only PCDDs/PCDFs were evaluated. Octachlorodibenzo- p-dioxin (OCDD) and octachlorodibenzofuran (OCDF) congeners were evaluated independently from the other congeners due to their prevalence in the environment and the availability of congener-specific data. The results of the reevaluation of the rodent bioassay data for 2,3,7,8-TCDD were considered in the probability distribution for the cancer potency factor. The authors′ analyses indicate that when assessing exposure to soil via inhalation, ingestion, and dermal contact, the current regulatory approach used to estimate the reasonable maximally exposed individual (RMEI) (USEPA, Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund, Vol. 1, Part A, 1989) can predict risks which are 10- to 100-fold greater than the 95th percentile risk predicted by a Monte Carlo analysis.