Those drawn to the calling of molecular biology will inevitably be touched when a universal step in the flow of genetic information is clarified. That clarification is underway for the interaction of tRNAs and aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (AARS) in vivo and in vitro. These new data also apply to the more general topic of RNA-protein association and may illuminate other little-understood, though ubiquitous, ribonucleoprotein interactions. The Data, Old and New Distinction among tRNAs by AARS is sometimes simple. From work begun almost two decades ago, we know that a single additional genetic mutation in the CCA arm of amber (UAG) suppressor tRNATyrcun (the subscript shows a changed anticodon) alters this tRNA so that it inserts glutamine (Ghysen and Celis, JMB 83, 333-351, 1974). A single C-U mutation in the middle position of the anticodon of tRNATrp simultaneously converts it to an amber suppressor and makes it a glutaminyl-tRNA (Yaniv et al., JMB 86,245260,1974). Thus GlnRS depends heavily on one or two nucleotides to determine acceptance or rejection of some tRNAs. The anticodon plainly contains sufficient information to uniquely determine a tRNA’s associated amino acid, and can be the predominant determinant of amino acid specificity. The importance of the anticodon to E. coli MetRS in vitro was shown by work begun shortly after the early genetic experiments. Schulman and Pelka (PNAS 80, 6755-6759, 1983) ligated anticodon oligoribonucleotides into RNAase-gapped tRNAMet to demonstrate that MetRS depends heavily on the three nucleotides of the anticodon (34,35, and 36 in the figure, marked M). These same workers (Schulman and Pelka, Science, in press, 1988) have now transformed tRNAVarI into tRNAVa$,cAu, which accepts methionine at the same rate as bona fide tRNAMet. This represents an increase of 600,000-fold in acylation rate (V,,/K,) as a result of the substitution of two anticodon nucleotides. Similarly, tRNATrPCAu is acylated by MetRS only tenfold more slowly than tRNAMet. Other experiments of Schulman and Pelka show that ValRS displays the same type of dependence on the anticodon (sites marked V in the figure): tRNAMet,,unc accepts valine at a rate only tenfold lower than that of tRNAV$. Much recent work takes its inspiration from Normanly et al. (Nature 327, 213-219, 1986) whose experiments initially suggested that tRNA discrimination could be studied by changing a relatively small part of the tRNA sequence. These workers introduced a now widely used approach for determining the “identity set” of a tRNA and AARS (identity set is defined as the minimal set of nucleotide substitutions that changes the amino acid inserted into cellular Minireview
Read full abstract