Connections are made between two valence bond studies of hydrogen atom abstraction reactions: (a) J. Phys. Chem. A 2001, 105, 8226 and (b) J. Phys. Chem. 1993, 97, 12210; corrections 1994, 98, 3226. At each stage along the reaction coordinate, the variational-best valence bond formulation for the reacting system of (b) can be described in terms of resonance between valence bond structures for a reactantlike complex and a productlike complex. It is demonstrated that the (a) and (b) descriptions of the transition states are equivalent. Further development for (b) is presented, to compare expressions for the promotion gap (G) and the resonance energy at the avoided crossing (B) with those that arise in (a). By use of a triple-ζ 1s atomic orbital (AO) basis set to formulate the wave functions for the reactantlike and productlike complexes, it is demonstrated how these wave functions are constructed as linear combinations of localized molecular orbital (MO) configurations, each of which involves one AO per atomic center. Similar procedures that include 2p AOs as polarization functions in the treatment are also described. The results of valence bond calculations that use these two types of AO basis sets provide illustrative examples of how the formulation of (b) provides a compact valence bond representation for the electronic reorganization that is involved in the conversion of reactants into products.