Coral Reef Restoration Research Articles

Oceanographic‐informed coral out‐planting density for coral reef restoration activities

Out‐planting corals onto coral reefs as a mechanism to increase coral cover on degraded reef systems is an increasing global activity. Current practices typically focus on asexual out‐planting of coral fragments (coral gardening). Newer sexual reproductive approaches are being developed to out‐plant younger corals produced in aquaculture facilities or sea‐based rearing pools to enable assisted evolution or assisted gene flow conservation genetics approaches. Designing out‐planting deployment operations requires decisions to be made on planting density and location in order to maximize future recruitment on both the out‐planted reefs, and on nearby reefs that are connected through oceanographic transport processes. The thinking presented here seeks to unpack how out‐planting density may be influenced, especially by local oceanographic conditions, in order to guide practitioners undertaking restoration projects.

Boater’s Preference for Coral Reef Restoration and Sustainable Resource Management in Florida

The Florida Reef is under intense pressure from excessive human disturbance and climate change. A group of Florida residents including boaters and fishers was surveyed about their concerns and willingness to pay (WTP) for restorative services. A discrete choice valuation experiment was conducted, involving nearly 1,300 respondents, to estimate WTP for coral reef restoration, wide beaches, and clean water. The boaters demonstrated a somewhat higher WTP for a more extensive beach size and coral restoration. The analysis allowed quantification of maritime transportation passengers’ preferences for sustainable resource management. The findings provide useful insights for maritime transportation and coastal management agencies wishing to finance conservation initiatives. Furthermore, the study offers valuable methodological contributions and policy relevant information to incorporate ecosystem service valuations into the decision-making process beyond the study areas.

Advancing the coral propagation toolkit via hypersalinity induced coral micropropagates

In the face of escalating threats posed by human-induced climate change, urgent attention to coral reef restoration is imperative due to ongoing reef degradation. Here, we explored the potential of generating coral micropropagates as a tool to rapidly generate coral tissue for reef restoration and reef engineering. We developed a hypersalinity-induced polyp bailout protocol and a simple attachment device to support the growth of micropropagates on commonly used restoration substrates. We found that hypersalinity induction, at a rate of < 1 ppt hr-1, produced healthy micropropagates of the coral Stylophora pistillata. The highest attachment success (~74%) was achieved in CaCO3 substrate devices, which outperformed PVC (~48%) and Portland cement (~5%). Settled micropropagates displayed rapid growth rates on both CaCO3 (0.037 mm²/day ± 0.002 SE) and PVC (0.057 mm²/day ± 0.008 SE) substrates, while Portland cement induced tissue degradation. Our study provides a detailed methodology for reliably generating, attaching, and growing coral micropropagates and underscores the potential of polyp bailout as a viable technique supporting coral propagation efforts.

Impacts of “Reef Star” coral restoration on multiple metrics of habitat complexity

Coral reefs face threats from climate change and local pressures that lead to reductions in their physical structure, impacting biodiversity by limiting habitat availability. Despite many efforts to actively restore damaged reefs, few projects provide thorough evaluations of their success. This study measured the success of the “Reef Star” method at the Mars Coral Reef Restoration Project in Indonesia in reestablishing the physical structure of reef habitats that were destroyed by blast fishing. We used photogrammetry surveys to measure the physical habitat structure of 17 large sites (1000 m2 each), calculating three complementary measures of small‐ and large‐scale habitat complexity across degraded, restored, and naturally healthy coral reefs. We demonstrate that the restoration efforts have successfully restored small‐scale habitat complexity, as described by surface complexity metrics (3.22 ± 0.27 on restored reefs; 2.85 ± 0.26 on healthy reefs) and fractal dimension (2.27 ± 0.02 on restored reefs; 2.24 ± 0.02 on healthy reefs). This demonstrates the capacity for restored reefs to recover important ecosystem functions that are lost in degradation. However, while restoration has delivered some increases in large‐scale habitat complexity compared to degraded reefs, restored reefs still exhibit lower values of maximum vertical relief than healthy reefs, due to a lack of large physical structures. This lack of available large‐scale habitat might impact fish populations, meaning that restored reefs with limited large‐scale complexity may only support a restricted range of ecosystem functions. Effective reef restoration strategies must use a mixture of different methods that target the recovery of structural complexity at multiple scales.

A transcriptome-wide analysis provides novel insights into how Metabacillus indicus promotes coral larvae metamorphosis and settlement

BackgroundCoral reefs experience frequent and severe disturbances that can overwhelm their natural resilience. In such cases, ecological restoration is essential for coral reef recovery. Sexual reproduction has been reported to present the simplest and most cost-effective means for coral reef restoration. However, larval settlement and post-settlement survival represent bottlenecks for coral recruitment in sexual reproduction. While bacteria play a significant role in triggering coral metamorphosis and settlement in many coral species, the underlying molecular mechanisms remain largely unknown. In this study, we employed a transcriptome-level analysis to elucidate the intricate interactions between bacteria and coral larvae that are crucial for the settlement process.ResultsHigh Metabacillus indicus strain cB07 inoculation densities resulted in the successful induction of metamorphosis and settlement of coral Pocillopora damicoris larvae. Compared with controls, inoculated coral larvae exhibited a pronounced increase in the abundance of strain cB07 during metamorphosis and settlement, followed by a significant decrease in total lipid contents during the settled stage. The differentially expressed genes (DEGs) during metamorphosis were significantly enriched in amino acid, protein, fatty acid, and glucose related metabolic pathways. In settled coral larvae induced by strain cB07, there was a significant enrichment of DEGs with essential roles in the establishment of a symbiotic relationship between coral larvae and their symbiotic partners. The photosynthetic efficiency of strain cB07 induced primary polyp holobionts was improved compared to those of the negative controls. In addition, coral primary polyps induced by strain cB07 showed significant improvements in energy storage and survival.ConclusionsOur findings revealed that strain cB07 can promote coral larval settlement and enhance post-settlement survival and fitness. Manipulating coral sexual reproduction with strain cB07 can overcome the current recruitment bottleneck. This innovative approach holds promise for future coral reef restoration efforts.

Shifting sands: The influence of coral reefs on shoreline erosion from short-term storm protection to long-term disequilibrium

Climate change is exacerbating shoreline erosion and flooding, posing significant risks to coastal communities. Although traditional coastal defenses such as seawalls, dykes, and breakwaters offer protection from these hazards, their high environmental and economic costs are driving interest in cost-competitive nature-based solutions. Coral reef restoration is a nature-based solution that may be particularly apt to mitigate tropical coastal flooding and shoreline erosion while providing benefits to local tourism, fisheries, and nature. However, the novelty of this field requires studies demonstrating the benefits of reefs for coastal protection. While the flood protection benefits of reefs have been well-documented, their effects on shoreline erosion are comparatively less understood. Here, we investigate the effects of coral reefs on shoreline erosion by comparing tropical beach responses at short and long timescales, as well as identifying important reef structural features influencing coastal erosion rates. Our analyses leveraged two key datasets created in this study: the first derived from a literature review on short-term shoreline erosion due to storm events, and another compiling >80 years of long-term erosion rates, bathymetry, habitat, and wave energy for the Hawaiian Islands of Kauaʻi, Oʻahu, and Maui. Our analyses reveal three key findings regarding the effects of reefs on shoreline erosion. Firstly, we find evidence for the role of reefs in mitigating shoreline erosion during storm events, with coral reef-protected beaches experiencing 97 % less beach volume loss than unprotected beaches. Secondly, a linear regression analysis demonstrates that coral reef structure and wave energy are important predictors of long-term shoreline erosion rates, explaining 34 % of the variation across the Hawaiian Islands. Consistent with prior research, we find beaches protected by coral reefs with shallow reef crests, wide reef flats, calmer offshore conditions, and positioned farther from the shore exhibit lower erosion rates than others. Finally, when comparing historical erosion rates of protected and unprotected beaches in Hawai'i, we find a seemingly incongruous pattern where coral reef-protected beaches eroded up to 2x faster than beaches without reefs. While the cause of the enhanced erosion is yet to be fully understood, a combination of coral reef structural degradation and sea-level rise is likely shifting the equilibrium profiles of reef-protected beaches inshore. These results emphasize the role of coral reefs in reducing coastal erosion during storm events while revealing contrasting erosion patterns over long timescales. Future studies would ideally broaden the scope to include various regions, utilize advanced sediment transport models, and undertake field experiments to deepen our understanding of coral reef-coupled shoreline dynamics.

Ten golden rules for restoration to secure resilient and just seagrass social‐ecological systems

Societal Impact StatementSeagrass meadows are a globally important habitat subject to significant loss. As efforts to restore these sensitive habitats are hampered by their high cost and low levels of reliability, rigorous guidance is required to improve effectiveness and ensure they are cost‐effective. Here, we define 10 golden rules for how we can undertake seagrass restoration. We do this by considering that for seagrass restoration to be successful, it needs to take place with people and not against people. The framework we present aims to direct efforts for seagrass restoration that are holistic and achieve broad goals for people, biodiversity and the planet.SummaryThe world has lost a significant proportion of its seagrass, and although glimmers of hope for its recovery exist, losses and degradations continue. First and foremost, evidence highlights the need to put the world on a global pathway to seagrass net gain. Achieving this outcome requires that conservation of what remains is a priority, but reaching net gain requires seagrass coverage to increase at rates unlikely to be achieved naturally; large‐scale active restoration is required to fill this gap. Novel finance mechanisms aligned to the climate emergency and biodiversity crises are increasingly leading to larger scale restoration projects. However, no clear framework exists for developing or prioritising approaches. With seagrass restoration expensive and unreliable, rigorous guidance is required to improve effectiveness and ensure it is cost‐effective. Building on evidence from terrestrial and marine sources, here, we apply the ‘10 golden rules’ concept, first outlined for reforestation and later applied to coral reefs, to seagrass restoration. In doing so, we follow international standards for ecological restoration and view seagrass restoration in a broad context, whereby regeneration can be achieved either by planting or by enhancing and facilitating natural recovery. These rules somewhat differ from those on reforestation and coral reef restoration, principally due to the relative immaturity of seagrass restoration science. These 10 golden rules for seagrass restoration are placed within a coupled social‐ecological systems context, and we present a framework for conservation more broadly, to achieve multiple goals pertaining to people, biodiversity and the planet.

Speeding up the recovery of coastal habitats through management interventions that address constraints on dispersal and recruitment.

Plans for habitat restoration will benefit from predictions of timescales for recovery. Theoretical models have been a powerful tool for informing practical guidelines in planning marine protected areas, suggesting restoration planning could also benefit from a theoretical framework. We developed a model that can predict recovery times following restoration action, under dispersal, recruitment and connectivity constraints. We apply the model to a case study of seagrass restoration and find recovery times following restoration action can vary greatly, from <1 to >20 years. The model also shows how recovery can be accelerated when restoration actions are matched to the constraints on recovery. For example, spreading of propagules can be used when connectivity is the critical restriction. The recovery constraints we articulated mathematically also apply to the restoration of coral reefs, mangroves, saltmarsh, shellfish reefs and macroalgal forests, so our model provides a general framework for choosing restoration actions that accelerate coastal habitat recovery.

Cognatishimia coralii sp. nov., a marine bacterium isolated from seawater surrounding corals.

Coral reefs are declining due to the rising seawater temperature. Bacteria within and surrounding corals play key roles in maintaining the homeostasis of the coral holobiont. Research on coral-related bacteria could provide benefits for coral reef restoration. During the isolation of coral-associated bacteria, a Gram-stain-negative, motile bacterium (D5M38T) was isolated from seawater surrounding corals in Daya Bay, Shenzhen, PR China. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that strain D5M38T represents a novel species in the genus Cognatishimia. The temperature range for strain D5M38T growth was 10-40 °C, and the optimum temperature was 37 °C. The salinity range for the growth of this isolate was from 0 to 4.0 %, with an optimal salinity level of 0.5 %. The pH range necessary for strain D5M38T growth was between pH 5.0 and 9.0, with an optimal pH being 7.5. The predominant fatty acid was summed feature 8 (65.0 %). The major respiratory quinone was Q-10. The DNA G+C content was 56.8 %. The genome size was 3.88 Mb. The average nucleotide identity (ANI), average amino acid identity (AAI) and digital DNA-DNA hybridization (dDDH) values between strain D5M38T and its two closest neighbours, Cognatishimia activa LMG 29900T and Cognatishimia maritima KCTC 23347T, were 73.2/73.6%, 73.2/73.6% and 19.7/19.5%, respectively. Strain D5M38T was clearly distinct from its closest neighbours C. activa LMG 29900T and C. maritima KCTC 23347T, with 16S rRNA gene sequence similarity values of 97.5 and 97.3 %, respectively. The phylogenetic analysis, along with the ANI, AAI, and dDDH values, demonstrated that strain D5M38T is a member of the genus Cognatishimia, and is distinct from the other two recognized species within this genus. The physiological, biochemical and chemotaxonomic characteristics also supported the species novelty of strain D5M38T. Thus, strain D5M38T is considered to be classified as representing a novel species in the genus Cognatishimia, for which the name Cognatishimia coralii sp. nov. is proposed. The type strain is D5M38T (=MCCC 1K08692T=KCTC 8160T).

The interplay of temperature, light, and substrate type in driving growth and reproduction of an important tropical crustose coralline alga

Crustose coralline algae (CCA) from the genus Titanoderma are reported to induce high levels of coral larval settlement across a wide diversity of species. Consequently, Titanoderma is a promising taxon to cultivate in aquaculture facilities for application in coral reef restoration projects. However, knowledge on the optimum conditions to promote growth and reproduction in Titanoderma is limited. To investigate this, we cultured adult fragments of Titanoderma sp. at two temperatures (27.5 or 30 °C) and two light levels (mean maximum midday irradiance of 10 or 40 µmol photons m−2 s−1) on three different tile materials (CaCO3, concrete, or PVC). We found that the combination of 27.5 °C and 40 µmol photons m−2 s−1 were best for adult fragment growth. Greater number of conceptacles were formed under higher light intensities, while temperature did not have an influence. Sporeling settlement and subsequent growth into juveniles were only evident at 40 µmol photons m−2 s−1, with substantially higher recruitment on substrates made of concrete. These results provide important insights for developing optimal conditions to cultivate Titanoderma sp. in aquaculture facilities to support reef restoration projects using sexually produced corals.

Optimizing initial stocking densities of wild coral spawn slicks for mass production of larvae and settled corals for restoration

Mass culturing coral larvae collected from spawn slicks during spawning events and rearing them directly on reefs is an important method for coral reef restoration as it utilizes high genetic diversity and is readily upscaled. Understanding optimal initial stocking densities in mass cultures is, therefore, central to optimizing larval production efficiency. Yet, no studies have focused on optimizing initial stocking densities while coral embryos are still floating, despite the influence of density‐dependent effects during larval culturing. This study aimed to (1) explore initial stocking densities based on slick coverage and (2) determine the effects of initial densities on embryo development to coral settlement and early post‐settlement survival. Wild coral spawn slicks were collected at Lizard Island and reared at different combinations of slick coverage and density based on tank volume. Immediate density‐dependent effects were observed in treatments with 45% slick coverage, which had lower abundances of embryos 12 hours post‐spawning. The 12‐hour embryo densities ranged from 1.7 to 10.7 mL−1 and continued to display a negative relationship between density and survival of developing larvae. Overall, a density of approximately 5.1 embryos mL‐1 was the optimal stocking density for larval survival to competency (16.5%). The proportion of settlement and early post‐settlement survival was negatively correlated with higher initial densities, while a positive relationship was observed between the abundance of competent larvae and those settled, including initial settlers and 2‐month‐old recruits. These results highlight the importance of both larval quality and supply, and opportunities for site and system‐specific optimization of larval production in future work.

Coral reef restoration in Indonesia: lessons learnt from the world’s largest coral restoration nation

Coral reef restoration in Indonesia: lessons learnt from the world’s largest coral restoration nation

Population genetics assessment of two pocilloporid coral species from the northern red sea: Implications for urbanized reef sustainability

Understanding the genetic makeup of key coral species is vital for effective coral reef management, as heightened genetic diversity directly influences long-term survival and resilience against environmental changes. This study focused on two widespread Indo-Pacific branching corals, Pocillopora damicornis (referred as Pocillopora cf. damicornis (as identified only morphologically) and Seriatopora hystrix, by genotyping 222 and 195 colonies, respectively, from 10 sites in the northern Gulf of Eilat, Red Sea, using six and five microsatellite markers, respectively. Both species exhibited low observed heterozygosity (0.47 for P. cf. damicornis, 0.32 for S. hystrix) and similar expected heterozygosity (0.576 for P. cf. damicornis, 0.578 for S. hystrix). Pocillopora cf. damicornis showed minimal deviations from Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium (HWE) and low but positive F values, indicating high gene flow, while S. hystrix exhibited higher diversion from HWE and positive F values, suggesting isolation by distance and possible non-random mating or genetic drift. As the Gulf of Eilat undergoes rapid urbanization, this study highlights the anthropogenic impacts on the population genetics of key ecosystem engineering species and emphasizes the importance of managing genetics of Marine Protected Areas while implementing active coral reef restoration. The differences in reproductive traits between the two species (S. hystrix being a brooder, while P. cf. damicornis a broadcast spawner), underscore the need for sustainable population genetics management of the coral reefs for the future and resilience of the coral reef ecosystem of the northern Red Sea region.

Developing a sustainable resin for 3D printing in coral restoration

Coral reefs boast one of the planet&amp;rsquo;s most diversified ecosystems, serving as an essential source of food and revenue for millions of people while providing shelter to a wide variety of marine creatures. However, overfishing, pollution, climate change, and other factors collectively pose an escalating danger to coral reefs. Therefore, coral reef restoration efforts are urgently needed to save corals. In this study, we exploited 3D printing technology based on vat polymerization to fabricate artificial coral plugs, expediting the reef restoration process while minimizing labor costs. We have developed a scalable model through the photoinitiated polymerization of an eco-friendly resin composed of modified soybean oil and calcium carbonate which has the potential to significantly enhance global restoration efforts. Material characterization demonstrated that the printed scaffold was highly cross-linked. Based on cytotoxicity analysis, the printed scaffold exhibited excellent cell adhesion and proliferation characteristics. The coral microfragmentation experiment showed initial signs of coral settlement on the printed coral plugs. This work demonstrates that plant-based material and vat-polymerization-based 3D printing techniques hold promise for coral restoration.

Short-term thermal acclimation improved the thermal tolerance of three species of scleractinian corals in the South China Sea

Investigating the potential and mechanisms of thermal adaptability in scleractinian corals is critical for aiding corals in dealing with global warming and improving the efficiency of coral reef restoration efforts. Although thermal acclimation facilitates the resistance of branching corals to thermal stress, little is known about the physiological processes of massive and platy corals in the South China Sea or their ability to adapt to heat stress. In this study, we conducted indoor short-term thermal acclimation simulation experiments on three types of corals: massive Porites lutea, platy Pavona decussata, and branching Pocillopora damicornis. Subsequently, we studied the responses and adaptive mechanisms of the three corals to heat stress and explored the effects of short-term thermal acclimation using physiological and biochemical markers. The results showed that the three corals exhibited comparable phenotypic and physiological responses to heat stress, including tentacle retraction and decreases in zooxanthellae density, maximum quantum efficiency of photosystem II, and glutathione content, along with increases in antioxidant activity (catalase and superoxide dismutase), ammonium assimilation (glutamine synthetase), and apoptosis (lipid peroxide and caspase-3). Additionally, heat tolerance differed among the different species of coral. Furthermore, the physiological markers performed better in all three coral types after acclimation, and the effects of short-term acclimation decreased from P. lutea to P. damicornis to P. decussata. We propose that short-term thermal acclimation enhances the heat tolerance of corals by affecting their metabolism and antioxidant capacity. Leveraging short-term thermal acclimation in coral reef restoration efforts could help corals adapt to the threats posed by global warming and enhance restoration efficiency.

Experimental Observations And Prediction Of Wave Attenuation Using A Coral Reef Restoration Approach

The large bottom roughness typical of coral reefs can be effective at reducing wave energy incident to coastlines through the dissipation induced by how wave-driven oscillatory flows interact with the roughness to determine hydrodynamic forces (i.e., drag and inertial). A physical understanding of these fluid-structure interaction processes is essential in designing coral reef restoration projects that can enhance coastal protection as well as deliver other beneficial ecosystem services, as a more sustainable alternative over conventional engineered structures (e.g. breakwaters and seawalls). In this study we quantify both wave attenuation and hydrodynamic forces across progressive stages of a coral reef restoration solution developed by Mars Sustainable Solutions. The Mars Assisted Reef Restoration System (MARRS) involves propagating coral fragments onto hexagonal steel structures called Reef Stars, which are connected in tessellating patterns over degraded reef flats (Figure 1).

Optimizing Infragravity Wave Attenuation to Improve Coral Reef Restoration Design for Coastal Defense

Coral reefs are effective natural flood barriers that protect adjacent coastal communities. As the need to adapt to rising sea levels, storms, and environmental changes increases, reef restoration may be one of the best tools available to mitigate coastal flooding along tropical coastlines, now and in the future. Reefs act as a barrier to incoming short-wave energy but can amplify low-frequency infragravity waves that, in turn, drive coastal flooding along low-lying tropical coastlines. Here, we investigate whether the spacing of reef restoration elements can be optimized to maximize infragravity wave energy dissipation while minimizing the number of elements—a key factor in the cost of a restoration project. With this goal, we model the hydrodynamics of infragravity wave dissipation over a coral restoration or artificial reef, represented by a canopy of idealized hemispherical roughness elements, using a three-dimensional Navier–Stokes equations solver (OpenFOAM). The results demonstrate that denser canopies of restoration elements produce greater wave dissipation under larger waves with longer periods. Wave dissipation is also frequency-dependent: dense canopies remove wave energy at the predominant wave frequency, whereas sparse canopies remove energy at higher frequencies, and hence are less efficient. We also identify an inflection point in the canopy density–energy dissipation curve that balances optimal energy losses with a minimum number of canopy elements. Through this work, we show that there are an ideal number of restoration elements per across-shore meter of coral reef flat that can be installed to dissipate infragravity wave energy for given incident heights and periods. These results have implications for designing coral reef restoration projects on reef flats that are effective both from a coastal defense and costing standpoint.

Composite substrates for coral larval settlement and reef restoration based on natural hydraulic lime and inorganic strontium and magnesium compounds

Coral reefs face unprecedented threats from climate change and human activities, making reef restoration increasingly important for the preservation of marine biodiversity and the sustainability of coastal communities. One promising restoration method relies on coral breeding and larval settlement, but this approach requires further innovation to achieve high rates of settlement and survival. In this study, we built on our previous work engineering lime mortar-based coral settlement substrates by investigating three different compositions of a natural hydraulic lime (NHL) base material as well as composite NHL substrates containing alkaline earth metals. These materials were tested with larvae of three reef-building Caribbean coral species: Orbicella faveolata (Mountainous star coral), Diploria labyrinthiformis (Grooved brain coral), and Colpophyllia natans (Boulder brain coral). We found that the base material composition, including its silicate and calcium carbonate (CaCO3) content, as well as the addition of the inorganic additives strontium carbonate (SrCO3), magnesium carbonate (MgCO3), and magnesium sulfate (MgSO4), all influenced coral larval settlement rates. Overall, NHL formulations with lower concentrations of silicate and higher concentrations of calcium, strontium, and magnesium carbonates significantly increased coral settlement. Further, when dissolved ions of magnesium and strontium were added to seawater, both had a significant effect on larval motility, with magnesium promoting settlement and metamorphosis in C. natans larvae, supporting the observation that these additives are also bioactive when incorporated into substrates. Our results demonstrate the potential benefits of incorporating specific inorganic ion additives such as Mg2+ and Sr2+ into substrates to facilitate early coral life history processes including settlement and metamorphosis. Further, our results highlight the importance of optimizing multiple aspects of coral substrate design, including material composition, to promote settlement and survival in coral propagation and reef restoration.

Restoration success limited by poor long‐term survival after 9 years of Acropora cervicornis outplanting in the upper Florida Keys, United States

The degradation of coral reefs has resulted in the expansion of coral reef restoration projects worldwide. In the tropical western Atlantic, most restoration efforts focus on outplanting Acropora cervicornis, once a dominant reef‐building branching coral, now found predominantly in spatially isolated populations. Hundreds of thousands of A. cervicornis colonies are outplanted onto degraded reefs every year; however, long‐term growth and survival data of outplanted corals is limited. In this study, we assessed the long‐term restoration of A. cervicornis by determining the relationship between surviving outplant populations and restoration effort. We surveyed coral populations at 11 sites in the upper Florida Keys that represented a gradient of restoration effort, defined by the total number of outplants, number of outplanting years, and time since last outplanting. We found a negative relationship between the amount of A. cervicornis live tissue and time since last outplanting, suggesting that outplants are not surviving longer than 2 years. In addition to restoration effort, we investigated how past and present benthic community metrics such as coral density and diversity may influence long‐term outplant survival. We found a positive relationship between the amount of live A. cervicornis tissue and pre‐restoration coral density, suggesting that areas that previously supported dense populations of corals may facilitate restoration success. Ultimately, this study finds that restored A. cervicornis populations decline over time, and continued outplanting effort is needed for the persistence of the species in certain areas. This study also highlights the need for more long‐term monitoring to inform adaptive management and restoration strategies.

Including environmental and climatic considerations for sustainable coral reef restoration.

Coral reefs provide ecosystem benefits to millions of people but are threatened by rapid environmental change and ever-increasing human pressures. Restoration is becoming a priority strategy for coral reef conservation, yet implementation remains challenging and it is becoming increasingly apparent that indirect conservation and restoration approaches will not ensure the long-term sustainability of coral reefs. The important role of environmental conditions in restoration practice are currently undervalued, carrying substantial implications for restoration success. Giving paramount importance to environmental conditions, particularly during the pre-restoration planning phase, has the potential to bring about considerable improvements in coral reef restoration and innovation. This Essay argues that restoration risk may be reduced by adopting an environmentally aware perspective that gives historical, contemporary, and future context to restoration decisions. Such an approach will open up new restoration opportunities with improved sustainability that have the capacity to dynamically respond to environmental trajectories.