Histoplasmosis is an endemic mycosis that often presents as a respiratory infection in immunocompromised patients. Hundreds of thousands of new infections are reported annually around the world. The etiological agent of the disease, Histoplasma, is a dimorphic fungus commonly found in the soil where it grows as mycelia. Humans can become infected by Histoplasma through inhalation of its spores (conidia) or mycelial particles. The fungi transition into the yeast phase in the lungs at 37°C. Once in the lungs, yeast cells reside and proliferate inside alveolar macrophages. Genomic work has revealed that Histoplasma is composed of at least five cryptic phylogenetic species that differ genetically. Three of those lineages have received new names. Here, we evaluated multiple phenotypic characteristics (colony morphology, secreted proteolytic activity, yeast size, and growth rate) of strains from five of the phylogenetic species of Histoplasma to identify phenotypic traits that differentiate between these species: Histoplasma capsulatum sensu stricto, Histoplasma ohiense, Histoplasma mississippiense, Histoplasma suramericanum, and an African lineage. We report diagnostic traits for three species. The other two species can be identified by a combination of traits. Our results suggest that (i) there are significant phenotypic differences among the cryptic species of Histoplasma and (ii) those differences can be used to positively distinguish those species in a clinical setting and for further study of the evolution of this fungal pathogen.IMPORTANCEIdentifying species boundaries is a critical component of evolutionary biology. Genome sequencing and the use of molecular markers have advanced our understanding of the evolutionary history of fungal pathogens, including Histoplasma, and have allowed for the identification of new species. This is especially important in organisms where morphological characteristics have not been detected. In this study, we revised the taxonomic status of the four named species of the genus Histoplasma, H. capsulatum sensu stricto (ss), H. ohiense, H. mississippiense, and H. suramericanum, and propose the use of species-specific phenotypic traits to aid their identification when genome sequencing is not available. These results have implications not only for evolutionary study of Histoplasma but also for clinicians, as the Histoplasma species could determine the outcome of disease and treatment needed.