Resistance To Thyroid Hormone Patients Research Articles

Variable Clinical Characteristics and Molecular Spectrum of Patients with Syndromes of Reduced Sensitivity to Thyroid Hormone: Genetic Defects in the THRB and SLC16A2 Genes

Background/Aims: Syndromes of reduced sensitivity to thyroid hormone can be caused by innate resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH), thyroid hormone cell transporter defects, or thyroid hormone metabolism defects. This study was performed to describe clinical, endocrinological, and molecular characteristics of patients with disorders associated with impaired sensitivity to thyroid hormone due to THRB or SLC16A2 mutations. Methods: This study included 5 probands (1 male and 4 females) with RTH and 6 patients with Allan-Herndon-Dudley syndrome (AHDS). Clinical features and endocrine findings were reviewed retrospectively. Molecular analysis of two candidate genes, THRB or SLC16A2, confirmed the diagnosis. Results: Among RTH patients, median age at diagnosis was 5.6 years. Three patients were classified as having generalized RTH, whereas the other 2 patients were regarded as having isolated pituitary RTH. Three novel heterozygous mutations and 2 known mutations in THRB were identified from 5 independent pedigrees. All mutations were located in the major ligand-binding domain. In AHDS patients, delayed development was apparent between 3 and 6 months of age. Direct sequencing of SLC16A2 identified 6 hemizygous missense mutations in each patient: p.I188N, p.G221R, p.A224V, p.G276R, p.W398R, and p.G401R. Conclusions: This study identified 3 novel mutations in THRB in RTH patients and 1 novel mutation in SLC16A2 in AHDS patients. Routine neonatal screening based on the TSH assay has a limited role in detecting RTH or AHDS. Therefore, genetic testing of the candidate genes THRB and SLC16A2 should be performed for diagnosis of RTH and AHDS in patients with the suggestive clinical phenotype.

The Hypercoagulable state in Hyperthyroidism is mediated via the Thyroid Hormone β Receptor pathway.

Hyperthyroidism is associated with a hypercoagulable state, but the underlying mechanism is unknown. Patients with resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) due to defective thyroid hormone receptor β (TRβ) exhibit elevated circulating thyroid hormones (TH) with refractoriness to TH action in TRβ-expressing tissues. We tested the hypothesis that the hypercoagulable state in hyperthyroidism is mediated via the TRβ. We conducted a cross-sectional study from November 2013 to January 2015 in 3 hospitals in the Netherlands and the United Kingdom. Patients with RTH due to defective TRβ (n=18), patients with hyperthyroidism (n=16) and euthyroid subjects (n=18) were included. TH concentrations and markers of coagulation and fibrinolysis were measured. Data are expressed as median [interquartile range]. Free thyroxine (FT4) levels were slightly higher in hyperthyroid patients than in RTH patients (53.9 [30.5-70.0] and 34.9 [28.4-42.2]pmol/l, respectively, P=0.042). Both groups had raised FT4 levels compared to euthyroid subjects (14.0 [13.0-15.8] pmol/l, P≤0.001). Levels of von Willebrand factor (VWF), factor (F) VIII, fibrinogen, and D-dimer were significantly higher in hyperthyroid patients than in RTH patients (VWF 231 [195-296] vs. 111 [82-140]%, FVIII 215 [192-228] vs. 145 [97-158]%, fibrinogen 3.6 [3.0-4.4] vs. 2.8 [2.5-3.2]g/L, D-dimer 0.41 [0.31-0.88] vs. 0.20 [0.17-0.26]mg/L, respectively, P≤0.001), while there were no differences between RTH patients and euthyroid controls. Parameters of coagulation and fibrinolysis were elevated in hyperthyroid patients compared to patients with RTH due to defective TRβ, whereas these parameters were not different between euthyroid controls and RTH patients, despite elevated FT4 concentrations in RTH patients. This indicates that the procoagulant effects observed in hyperthyroidism are mediated via the TRβ.

Syndrome of inappropriate secretion of TSH: Differential diagnosis in 61 patients

Objective To analyze the diagnostic approaches to differentiate thyrotropin(TSH)-secreting pituitary adenomas(TSHoma)and resistance to thyroid hormone(RTH). Methods This was a retrospective single center study. All patients with insuppressible TSH despite elevated free-T4 and free-T3 levels from 2004 to 2014 were enrolled. Results Twenty-seven patients were diagnosed as TSHoma, 20 as RTH, and 14 remained undetermined. Palpitation was observed in 54% patients as the main symptom. There was no significant difference in gender, serum levels of sex hormone-binding globulin, and free thyroid hormones between patients with TSHoma and RTH. The ages of patients at diagnosis and disease onset were older in TSHoma patients than RTH patients[(45.59±11.32 vs 31.80±11.32)years, P=0.012; (42.16±12.53 vs 23.30±15.77)years, P<0.01]. The course of disease was shorter in TSHoma patients than RTH patients[(3.44±4.55 vs 8.50±9.95)years, P=0.049]. Five RTH patients showed pituitary adenoma by MRI. TSHoma patients showed blunt TSH response to thyrotropin hormone releasing hormone(TRH)stimulation while RTH patients showed normal TRH stimulation[(2.35±1.61 vs 9.48±2.94)fold, P<0.01]. TSHoma patients showed significantly suppressed serum TSH by somatostatin analogs as compared with RTH patients[(77.02±13.43)%vs(52.33±15.02)%, P<0.01]. Twelve RTH patients had thyroid hormone receptor beta (TRβ) mutation. Conclusion A later age of disease onset and shorter disease course suggested TSHoma other than RTH. TRH stimulating test was the most accurate test to distinguish RTH and TSHoma as compared with pituitary MRI, somatostatin suppression test, and TRβ mutation analysis. (Chin J Endocrinol Metab, 2015, 31: 925-931) Key words: Thyrotropin-secreting pituitary adenoma; Resistance to thyroid hormones

A Rare Mutation in Patients With Resistance to Thyroid Hormone and Review of Therapeutic Strategies

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) is a rare syndrome characterized by elevated thyroid hormone (TH) along with nonsuppressed thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH). The clinical symptoms can vary considerably, and no definite treatment has been established thus far. A family with RTH harboring a TH receptor (THR)-β gene mutation (A234T) is described, the therapeutic strategies for RTH are reviewed, and optimization of the treatment strategies was attempted. Gene sequencing revealed a point mutation (A234T) in the THR-β gene of the proposita, her elder brother and her mother. During the 20-month follow-up period, it was found that the proposita experienced apparently higher TSH level and normal TH level on taking antithyroid medication. However, on discontinuing the medication, her thyroid function returned to the baseline of elevated FT3, FT4 level along with inappropriately normal TSH. Thus far, there is no guideline regarding the treatment strategies for the RTH. Antithyroid drugs are effective for patients with thyrotoxic symptoms but pose an increased risk of thyrotroph hyperplasia. The efficacy and safety of D-T4 and bromocriptine still remains debatable, TRIAC may be the most promising drug, as it is effective and can reduce both TH and TSH level. However, L-T3 or L-T4 may be necessary for some RTH patients who exhibit massive goiter or hypothyroid symptoms. It is demonstrated in this article that the A234T mutation in the THR-β gene can cause the RTH. Treatment of this condition is challenging, and individualized therapy is required because of the variable clinical features.

Characteristics of patients with late manifestation of resistance thyroid hormone syndrome: a single-center experience

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) is a rare genetic disease caused by reduced tissue sensitivity to thyroid hormone. The hallmark of RTH is elevated serum levels of thyroid hormone with unsuppressed thyrotropin (TSH). However, the most common form of RTH results from minor defects in the ligand-binding domain or hinge domain of the TRβ gene, resulting in impaired T3-induced transcriptional activity, often showing mild presentation. Early diagnosis can be challenging. The objective of the current study was to characterize this specific group of RTH patients. This was a retrospective study. Patients diagnosed as RTH with TRβ mutations were enrolled in a single institute between 2004 and 2014. A total of 14 patients were diagnosed as RTH with mutation in THβ gene. The median age at diagnosis was 22.5 (IQR: 13.25-32.75). Goiter was the most common clinical finding. TSH was significantly elevated after TRH injection (median peak was 21.83 μIU/l, IQR: 13.59-31.48), 9.2-fold compared to the basal level. We found 10 mutations in TRβ gene, all located in the last four exons, and including one novel mutation, H271D. In vitro study found that H271D mutation reduced TR affinity to T3. Four patients with intact thyroid were diagnosed after 16 years old, defined as late manifestation. Compared to those diagnosed before 10 years old, patients with late manifestation presented with normal growth and mental development. Interestingly, three of them carried R438H mutation. We identified a novel p.H271D mutation in TRβ associated with RTH. Endocrinologists should be alert that RTH is frequently found in euthyroid patients with mild symptoms and often leads to misleading diagnosis as well as inappropriate treatment.

Differentiated thyroid cancer in patients with resistance to thyroid hormone syndrome. A novel case and a review of the literature.

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) represents a syndrome in which patients present elevated circulating thyroid hormones in the presence of non-suppressed TSH. We report a novel case where a patient with RTH presented a differentiated thyroid cancer. A19 year-old female had been referred due to thyroid disease that disclosed features characteristic of a RTH. During the follow up it was detected a follicular tumor that led to the recommendation for thyroid surgical ablation, where an incidental papillary thyroid microcarcinoma (mPTC) was found. The increase of thyroglobulin (TG) levels following thyroid removal referred the patient for radioiodine treatment. Post-treatment, it was detected jugular adenopathies and the patient was subjected to cervical lymph node drainage where metastases of the mPTC were found. RTH syndrome was confirmed by the detection of a THRB germline mutation. A BRAF mutation was also found in the mPTC but not detected in the follicular adenoma or normal adjacent tissue. The young age of the patient, the rarity of BRAF mutations in childhood and the high dissemination of the malignancy, lead us to the speculation that increased TSH stimulation in a RTH background and oncogenic activation of BRAF could have served as (co) drivers and might have triggered an advanced stage of the neoplastic disease. These findings together with a review of published cases add novel information to the management of RTH patients with differentiated thyroid cancer.

Role of TSH in the spontaneous development of asymmetrical thyroid carcinoma in mice with a targeted mutation in a single allele of the thyroid hormone-β receptor.

Mutations of the thyroid hormone receptor-β gene (THRB) cause resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH). A mouse model of RTH harboring a homozygous thyroid hormone receptor (TR)-β mutation known as PV (Thrb(PV/PV) mouse) spontaneously develops follicular thyroid cancer (FTC). Similar to RTH patients with mutations of two alleles of the THRB gene, the Thrb(PV/PV) mouse exhibits elevated thyroid hormones accompanied by highly nonsuppressible TSH. However, the heterozygous Thrb(PV/+) mouse with mildly elevated TSH (~2-fold) does not develop FTC. The present study examined whether the mutation of a single allele of the Thrb gene is sufficient to induce FTC in Thrb(PV/+) mice under stimulation by high TSH. Thrb(PV/+) mice and wild-type siblings were treated with propylthiouracil (PTU) to elevate serum TSH. Thrb(PV/+)mice treated with PTU (Thrb(PV/+)-PTU) spontaneously developed FTC similar to human thyroid cancer, but wild-type siblings treated with PTU did not. Interestingly, approximately 33% of Thrb(PV/+)-PTU mice developed asymmetrical thyroid tumors, as is frequently observed in human thyroid cancer. Molecular analyses showed activation of the cyclin 1-cyclin-dependent kinase-4-transcription factor E2F1 pathway to increase thyroid tumor cell proliferation of Thrb(PV/+)-PTU mice. Moreover, via extranuclear signaling, the PV also activated the integrin-Src-focal adhesion kinase-AKT-metalloproteinase pathway to increase migration and invasion of tumor cells. Therefore, mutation of a single allele of the Thrb gene is sufficient to drive the TSH-simulated hyperplastic thyroid follicular cells to undergo carcinogenesis. The present study suggests that the Thrb(PV/+)-PTU mouse model potentially could be used to gain insights into the molecular basis underlying the association between thyroid cancer and RTH seen in some affected patients.

Variable clinical presentation and outcome in pediatric patients with resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH)

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) is characterized by elevated levels of thyroid hormones, normal or slightly increased TSH levels respondent to TRH, resistance to thyroid hormone administration, and variable clinical expression. To describe the diverse clinical and biochemical findings of six children from five unrelated families with molecular diagnosis of RTH (0.5-12.7 years) and their follow-up (3-20 years). All RTH patients and 4 affected parents' harbored mutations in exons 9 or 10 of the thyroid receptor β gene: p.M313T (de novo), pN331D, p.L341P, p.L346F, and p.P453L. At consultation 5/6 had goiter, 4/6 tachycardia, and 3/5 learning disabilities. Median hormone levels were: T(4) 257.4 nmol/l (NR: 77.2-180.2); FreeT(4) 39.9 pmol/(NR:10.3-28.3); T(3) 4.28 nmol/l (NR:1.23-3.39) TSH 2.8 mUI/l (NR: 0.5-5) always responsive to TRH. TSH levels remained detectable after supraphysiologic T(3) administration while SHBG levels showed a paradoxical decrease in 4/6. Thyroid antibodies, initially present in two subjects, became positive in other two during follow-up. All patients grew normally and presented variable symptoms that were treated according to need. Two patients developed psychiatric disorders. Only one of the four affected parents exhibited clinical signs of RTH (tachycardia and depression). Parent's thyroid profile showed similar TSH and T(3) levels but lower T(4) and FT(4) than their children. RTH has a distinctive biochemical profile with highly variable clinical manifestations and outcomes. Its recognition and molecular characterization avoid misleading diagnosis. Treatment has to be instituted according to each subject's own clinical requirements.

Approach to the Patient with Resistance to Thyroid Hormone and Pregnancy

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH), a syndrome of reduced end-organ responsiveness to thyroid hormone (TH), is mostly caused by mutations in the TH receptor (TR) beta gene. Diagnosis is based on persistent elevations of serum free T(4) and often T(3) levels in the absence of TSH suppression, and confirmation in most cases is by way of genetic testing. The mainstay in the management of RTH patients who are asymptomatic is to recognize the correct diagnosis and avoid antithyroid treatment. Deciding whether to manage these patients with TH replacement is made even more challenging when an affected individual is pregnant. How one approaches such a patient with pregnancy and RTH would depend on the genotype of the fetus. This requires obtaining prenatal information on the genotype of the fetus and a thorough history of the outcome of previous pregnancies as well as a history of the course and outcome of other family members with RTH. If the TRbeta mutation is known in the mother, the fetus can be rapidly genotyped from DNA from amniocentesis for the same mutation, and then management decisions could be made regarding thyroid or antithyroid hormone treatment.

Resistance to thyroid hormone is associated with raised energy expenditure, muscle mitochondrial uncoupling, and hyperphagia.

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH), a dominantly inherited disorder usually associated with mutations in thyroid hormone receptor beta (THRB), is characterized by elevated levels of circulating thyroid hormones (including thyroxine), failure of feedback suppression of thyrotropin, and variable tissue refractoriness to thyroid hormone action. Raised energy expenditure and hyperphagia are recognized features of hyperthyroidism, but the effects of comparable hyperthyroxinemia in RTH patients are unknown. Here, we show that resting energy expenditure (REE) was substantially increased in adults and children with THRB mutations. Energy intake in RTH subjects was increased by 40%, with marked hyperphagia particularly evident in children. Rates of muscle TCA cycle flux were increased by 75% in adults with RTH, whereas rates of ATP synthesis were unchanged, as determined by 13C/31P magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Mitochondrial coupling index between ATP synthesis and mitochondrial rates of oxidation (as estimated by the ratio of ATP synthesis to TCA cycle flux) was significantly decreased in RTH patients. These data demonstrate that basal mitochondrial substrate oxidation is increased and energy production in the form of ATP synthesis is decreased in the muscle of RTH patients and that resting oxidative phosphorylation is uncoupled in this disorder. Furthermore, these observations suggest that mitochondrial uncoupling in skeletal muscle is a major contributor to increased REE in patients with RTH, due to tissue selective retention of thyroid hormone receptor alpha sensitivity to elevated thyroid hormone levels.

Impact of Resistance to Thyroid Hormone on the Cardiovascular System in Adults

The clinical manifestations of resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) are highly variable, and the impact of RTH on the cardiovascular system has been poorly investigated. The objective of the study was to evaluate the cardiovascular characteristics of 16 untreated and asymptomatic patients with RTH compared with 16 euthyroid healthy controls to define the cardiovascular involvement in RTH syndrome. Sixteen untreated and asymptomatic RTH patients (eight males; aged 33 +/- 12 yr, range 21-45 yr) and 16 controls (nine males; aged 33 +/- 5 yr, range 24-42 yr) were enrolled. Clinical data, thyroid status, and echocardiographic results were recorded. Heart rate was comparable with that of controls, whereas arterial pressure was higher than controls. Mean interventricular septum diastolic thickness and mean left ventricular (LV) posterior wall diastolic thickness were significantly lower in RTH patients than controls with a consequent significant decrease of the mean LV mass and LV mass indexed by body surface area. Patients also had abnormalities of myocardial relaxation as indicated by a significant increase of peak A and consequent reduction of the early to late ratio. Finally, systemic vascular resistance was significantly higher in RTH patients than controls. Our results suggest the presence of cardiovascular alterations in asymptomatic and untreated RTH patients similar to those reported in hypothyroid patients. Our strict selection likely created a bias in the inclusion of a particular type of RTH patients, who could represent a minority of patients with RTH. However, no correlation was found between the type of mutation and cardiovascular characteristics of RTH patients.

Impact of Resistance to Thyroid Hormone on the Cardiovascular System in Adults

ABSTRACT Background The clinical manifestations of resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) are highly variable, and the impact of RTH on the cardiovascular system has been poorly investigated. Aim The objective of the study was to evaluate the cardiovascular characteristics of 16 untreated and asymptomatic patients with RTH compared with 16 euthyroid healthy controls to define the cardiovascular involvement in RTH syndrome. Patients and Methods Sixteen untreated and asymptomatic RTH patients (eight males; aged 33 ± 12 yr, range 21–45 yr) and 16 controls (nine males; aged 33 ± 5 yr, range 24–42 yr) were enrolled. Clinical data, thyroid status, and echocardiographic results were recorded. Results Heart rate was comparable with that of controls, whereas arterial pressure was higher than controls. Mean interventricular septum diastolic thickness and mean left ventricular (LV) posterior wall diastolic thickness were significantly lower in RTH patients than controls with a consequent significant decrease of the mean LV mass and LV mass indexed by body surface area. Patients also had abnormalities of myocardial relaxation as indicated by a significant increase of peak A and consequent reduction of the early to late ratio. Finally, systemic vascular resistance was significantly higher in RTH patients than controls. Conclusions Our results suggest the presence of cardiovascular alterations in asymptomatic and untreated RTH patients similar to those reported in hypothyroid patients. Our strict selection likely created a bias in the inclusion of a particular type of RTH patients, who could represent a minority of patients with RTH. However, no correlation was found between the type of mutation and cardiovascular characteristics of RTH patients.

Augmentation index in resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH)

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) is associated with a varied clinical presentation. The cardiac effects of RTH have been described but vascular function has yet to be fully evaluated in this condition. We have measured the arterial function of those with RTH to assess any vascular changes. An observational study. Twelve RTH patients were recruited from the thyroid clinic (mean value +/- SD), age 40.8 +/- 18.7 years; BMI 27.2 +/- 4.2 kg/m(2) and compared with 12 healthy, euthyroid, age-matched controls (age 41.4 +/- 19.3; BMI 24.8 +/- 4.4 kg/m(2)) with no history of cardiovascular disease. No interventional measures were instituted. Arterial stiffness was measured using pulse wave analysis at the radial artery. Thyroid function, fasting lipids and glucose were also measured on the same occasion in both patients and controls. Results The corrected augmentation index, a surrogate marker of arterial stiffness was significantly higher in patients compared with controls (21.0% +/- 14.1%vs. 5.4% +/- 18.2%, P < 0.03). Low density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-cholesterol) levels were also significantly elevated in patients compared with controls (3.0 +/- 0.6 vs. 2.1 +/- 0.5 mmol/l; P < 0.002). RTH patients show evidence in this study of increased augmentation index consistent with an increase in arterial stiffness compared with euthyroid controls. They also demonstrate elevated LDL-cholesterol levels. Both these measures may lead to increased cardiovascular risk.

Thyroid Color Flow Doppler Sonography: An Adjunctive Tool for Differentiating Patients with Inappropriate Thyrotropin (TSH) Secretion Due to TSH-Secreting Pituitary Adenoma or Resistance to Thyroid Hormone

Thyrotropin (TSH)-secreting pituitary adenoma (TSHoma) and resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) are two forms of inappropriate TSH secretion. Thyroid blood flow is largely TSH dependent. To assess whether thyroid blood flow may help to differentiate TSHoma and RTH. Intrathyroidal color flow Doppler sonography (CFDS) pattern and peak systolic velocity (PSV) were assessed at baseline and during T(3) suppression test on eight consecutive patients with TSHoma and 10 with RTH. All controls had CFDS pattern 0. Three RTH patients had pattern I and seven had pattern II. Two TSHoma patients had pattern I, five had pattern II, and one had pattern III. PSV at baseline was 3.8 +/- 1.3 cm/s in controls, 8.8 +/- 2.5 cm/s in RTH, 11.1 +/- 2.7 cm/s in TSHoma (p < 0.0003 vs. controls, p = 0.087 RTH vs. TSHoma). After T3 suppression test, PSV values were lower in RTH than in TSHoma (4.6 +/- 1.8 vs. 7.7 +/- 2.6 cm/s, p = 0.008). PSV values and CFDS pattern normalized in nine and eight RTH patients, respectively, after T(3) suppression test; conversely, only one TSHoma patient had a normalization of PSV values, and none had a normalization of CFDS pattern (p < 0.003 vs. RTH). Both RTH and TSHoma have increased CFDS pattern and PSV values; however, after T(3) both parameters normalized in most patients with RTH but not in those with TSHoma. Accordingly, CFDS pattern and PSV are adjunctive tools to differentiate these two forms of inappropriate TSH secretion.

Tissue responses to thyroid hormone in a kindred with resistance to thyroid hormone harboring a commonly occurring mutation in the thyroid hormone receptor β gene (P453T)

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) is a dominantly inherited syndrome of reduced tissue responsiveness to thyroid hormone (TH) usually due to mutations in the TH receptor beta gene (TRbeta). We studied pituitary and peripheral tissue responses to graded doses of liothyronine (L-T3) in 5 affected members (2 children and 3 adults) of a family with RTH due to the common TRbeta mutation P453T. Overall, the 5 subjects studied exhibited suppressed thyrotropin response to thyrotropin-releasing hormone of 51% +/- 8%, 12.1% +/- 1.5%, and 6.3% +/- 3% of the 100% baseline on 50, 100, and 200 microg/dL L-T3, respectively. This degree of suppression was greater than that observed in subjects with RTH due to other TRbeta mutations, indicating less resistance. Compared with normal subjects, however, the family described here demonstrated less suppression by L-T3, compatible with their RTH, although of a mild magnitude. The 2 children with RTH demonstrated less L-T3-mediated suppression of prolactin and cholesterol than the adults. Patients often receive thyroid ablative therapy before the diagnosis of RTH and are left with variable degrees of hypothyroidism. Our results demonstrate that graded doses of L-T3 can be used to evaluate RTH patients, even under the condition of limited thyroid reserve, when results are compared with their baseline. We demonstrate that RTH patients can be evaluated either on or off thyroid hormone and still be distinguished from hypothyroid subjects without RTH.

Síndrome de resistência ao hormônio tireoidiano

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) is a syndrome characterized by elevated serum thyroid hormone (TH) levels and elevated or inappropriately normal thyrotropin levels. In general, patients exhibit TH resistance in the pituitary and peripheral tissues. The phenotype of RTH is variable; the affected individuals are clinically euthyroid or even hypothyroid depending on the severity of the mutation, the variable hyposensitivity to TH among individuals as well as in different tissues. In almost all cases the genetic basis of RTH lies in mutation of the carboxyl-terminus of the ss-thyroid hormone receptor. RTH is a dominant disorder, except in one family; most individuals are heterozygous for the mutant allele. New standard techniques and genetically engineered mouse model systems have increased our understanding on TH receptor action, in particular, how mutant thyroid receptors from RTH patients can block wild-type thyroid receptor function (dominant negative activity), and how the mutant receptors can differently affect various tissues and individuals.

Compensatory role of thyroid hormone receptor (TR) alpha 1 in resistance to thyroid hormone: study in mice with a targeted mutation in the TR beta gene and deficient in TR alpha 1.

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) is caused by mutations of the thyroid hormone receptor beta (TR beta) gene. Almost all RTH patients are heterozygous with an autosomal dominant pattern of inheritance. That most are clinically euthyroid suggests a compensatory role of the TR alpha1 isoform in maintaining the normal functions of thyroid hormone (T3) in these patients. To understand the role of TR alpha1 in the manifestation of RTH, we compared the phenotypes of mice with a targeted dominantly negative mutant TR beta (TR betaPV) with or without TR alpha1. TR betaPV mice faithfully recapitulate RTH in humans in that these mice demonstrate abnormalities in the pituitary-thyroid axis and impairment in growth. Here we show that the dysregulation of the pituitary-thyroid axis was worsened by the lack of TR alpha1 in TR betaPV mice, and severe impairment of postnatal growth was manifested in TR betaPV mice deficient in TR alpha1. Furthermore, abnormal expression patterns of T3-target genes in TR betaPV mice were altered by the lack of TR alpha1. These results demonstrate that the lack of TR alpha1 exacerbates the manifestation of RTH in TR betaPV mice. Therefore, TR alpha1 could play a compensatory role in mediating the functions of T3 in heterozygous patients with RTH. This compensatory role may be especially crucial for postnatal growth.

Embryonic lethal effect of expressing a dominant negative mutant human thyroid hormone receptor alpha1 in mice.

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) is caused mainly by mutations of the thyroid hormone receptor (TR) beta gene. Although, in vitro, TRalpha1 and TRbeta1 mutants exhibit similar dominant negative effects against wild-type TR, no TRalpha mutants have ever been identified in RTH patients. It has been postulated that mutations in TRalpha gene may be lethal, compensated completely by intact TRbeta or associated with phenotypic manifestations different from RTH. To investigate the consequences of mutant TRalpha1 expression in vivo, we tried to generate two different lines of transgenic mice which express a strong or a weak dominant negative mutant TR alpha1, respectively. First, we expressed betaF451X identified in a patient with severe RTH and alphaF397X, which has an identical C-terminal truncation and a similarly strong dominant negative potency to betaF451X, under the control of human polypeptide chain elongation factor 1alpha promoter. Six betaF451X-transgenic mice were born from 223 transferred embryos, giving a transgenic frequency of 2.7%. By contrast, expression of alphaF397X resulted in quite a low transgenic frequency with 0.39% of the transferred embryos bearing the transgene. Only three transgenic mice were born with no apparently overt abnormalities, of which one male produced F1 offspring. The transgenic progeny expressed alphaF397X in the testis but we did not succeed in generating transgenic mice expressing alphaF397X in multiple organs. To avoid toxic effects mediated by a strong dominant negative activity of mutant TRalpha1, we exchanged alphaF397X for alphaK389E, which has an identical missense mutation and a relatively weak transdominant potency as betaK443E identified in a patient with mild RTH. When expressed by cytomegalovirus immediate early enhancer-chicken beta-actin promoter, we did not succeed in creating alphaK389E-transgenic mice despite three independent transgene-injections. These findings define crucial in vivo functions of mutant TRalpha1s during mouse fetal development and suggest the possibility that the expression of a dominant negative mutant TRalpha1 in extensive tissues from the early embryonal stages might be lethal.

In vitro effect of Triac on resistance to thyroid hormone receptor mutants: potential basis for therapy

Resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH) is a syndrome caused by a mutation in the carboxyl-terminal domain of the thyroid hormone receptor β (TRβ) gene. 3,5,3′-triiodothyroacetic acid (Triac) has been used on an empirical basis to treat RTH but its efficacy is still controversial. In previous studies, we demonstrated that Triac has TR isoform- and TRE-specific effects. In this report, we used five natural RTH mutations of the ligand-binding domain in both TRβ1 and TRβ2 isoforms for the evaluation of the effect of T 3 and Triac on regulation of transcription and binding affinity. We show that Triac has superior activity on negatively and positively regulated promoters and higher binding affinity than T 3 for a majority of TRβ1 and TRβ2 mutants. However, the difference of transcriptional activity and binding affinity between both ligands is less for RTH mutants than for wild type receptors. These results suggest that Triac could be a potential treatment for RTH patients.

Mice with a targeted mutation in the thyroid hormone beta receptor gene exhibit impaired growth and resistance to thyroid hormone.

Patients with mutations in the thyroid hormone receptor beta (TRbeta) gene manifest resistance to thyroid hormone (RTH), resulting in a constellation of variable phenotypic abnormalities. To understand the molecular basis underlying the action of mutant TRbeta in vivo, we generated mice with a targeted mutation in the TRbeta gene (TRbetaPV; PV, mutant thyroid hormone receptor kindred PV) by using homologous recombination and the Cre/loxP system. Mice expressing a single PV allele showed the typical abnormalities of thyroid function found in heterozygous humans with RTH. Homozygous PV mice exhibit severe dysfunction of the pituitary-thyroid axis, impaired weight gains, and abnormal bone development. This phenotype is distinct from that seen in mice with a null mutation in the TRbeta gene. Importantly, we identified abnormal expression patterns of several genes in tissues of TRbetaPV mice, demonstrating the interference of the mutant TR with the gene regulatory functions of the wild-type TR in vivo. These results show that the actions of mutant and wild-type TRbeta in vivo are distinct. This model allows further study of the molecular action of mutant TR in vivo, which could lead to better treatment for RTH patients.