A relaxin-like gonad-stimulating peptide (RGP), Aso-RGP, featuring six cysteine residues, was identified in the Crown-of-Thorns Starfish (COTS, Acanthaster cf. solaris) and initially produced through recombinant yeast expression. This method yielded a single-chain peptide with an uncleaved C-peptide (His Tag) and suboptimal purity. Our objective was to chemically synthesize Aso-RGP in its mature form, comprising two chains (A and B) and three disulfide bridges, omitting the C-peptide. Furthermore, we aimed to synthesize a newly identified relaxin-like peptide, Aso-RLP2, from COTS, which had not been previously synthesized. This paper reports the first total chemical synthesis of Aso-RGP and Aso-RLP2. Aso-RGP synthesis proceeded without major issues, whereas the A-chain of Aso-RLP2, in its reduced and unfolded state with two free thiols, presented considerable challenges. These were initially marked by "messy" RP-HPLC profiles, typically indicative of synthesis failure. Surprisingly, oxidizing the A-chain significantly improved the RP-HPLC profile, revealing the main issue was not synthesis failure but the peptide's aggregation tendency, which initially obscured analysis. This discovery highlights the critical need to account for aggregation in peptide synthesis and analysis. Ultimately, our efforts led to the successful synthesis of both peptides with purities exceeding 95 %.