Reinforced Concrete Frame Buildings Research Articles

Evaluating and strengthening low-rise reinforced concrete buildings constructed in Nepal

In Nepal, the reinforced concrete (RC) frame system is commonly used to construct low-rise buildings. In last three decades, a significant number of such buildings were proportioned and constructed in accordance with Nepal National Building Code NBC 205:1994 and NBC 205:2012—also known as the Mandatory Rule of Thumb (MRT). In the aftermath of 2015 Gorkha Earthquake (Mw 7.8) which resulted in large scale social and economic losses, the efforts to formulate improved seismic design provisions led to the development of NBC 105:2020. Considering that MRT-designed low-rise RC frame buildings still constitute a significant part of existing building stock, this study is aimed to conduct a comparative seismic performance evaluation of several case study structures under a comprehensive set of ground motions. Using the nonlinear analysis and seismic fragility assessment of four low-rise RC frame buildings (designed using all three code versions), it is shown that the structural performance and seismic losses can be significantly reduced by following NBC 105:2020 provisions. Several retrofitting solutions are also explored to improve the seismic performance of buildings designed using MRT. It is shown that the concrete or steel jacketing of RC columns can significantly increase the lateral strength and energy dissipation, and reduce the damage probability of such buildings. Lastly, based on the developed results, a machine learning approach is employed to correlate the peak ground acceleration with structural drifts for convenient practical applications.

Probabilistic risk assessment for reinforced concrete frame structures subject to mainshock‐aftershock sequences

AbstractRecent earthquakes have highlighted that aftershocks can considerably increase the structural demand and seismic risk of engineering structures. This study presents a probabilistic approach to assess the seismic risk of reinforced concrete (RC) frame structures subjected to mainshock‐aftershock sequences. In this approach, a predictive fragility method is used to evaluate the probabilities of structural damage under sequential excitations. The Bayes theorem is employed to generate posterior distributions of unknown model parameters. Then, a practical seismic hazard assessment method is used to conduct mainshock‐aftershock hazard analysis. The Copula technique is employed to develop a joint distribution model of the mainshock and aftershock intensity measures. Finally, the seismic risk is evaluated using the classical risk integration equation with the mainshock‐aftershock fragilities and hazard surfaces. Confidence bounds for fragilities and seismic risks are also obtained to account for the uncertainties of model parameters caused by aftershocks. The proposed approach is demonstrated by considering a seismic‐designed RC frame building. It can be concluded that aftershocks can significantly increase the seismic risk throughout the entire structural service life. The additional uncertainties caused by aftershocks result in wider confidence bounds for seismic risk.

SEISMIC ANALYSIS OF MULTISTORIED OPEN GROUND STORY BUILDING WITH DIAGONAL STRUT AND SHEAR WALLS

The Open Ground Story (OGS) building is a functional need of all urban areas so cannot be eliminated. According to studies from previous earthquakes, when there is severe earthquake shaking, Reinforced Concrete (RC) frame buildings with open ground levels function badly. In this work, four models of G+14 RC frame buildings with and without a shear wall, coupled sheal wall, and diagonal strut were modeled and analyzed using ETABS-2018 software's static and dynamic response spectrum method. Model 1 open ground story RC building without strut and the shear wall was compared to the other three models that included a shear wall, coupled shear wall, and diagonal strut. As a result of the findings, it has been determined that shear wall, coupled shear wall, and diagonal strut not only increased the stiffness but also reduced displacement. A model with a combination of shear wall and coupled shear wall showed a minimum base shear and overturning moment than all other models.

Retrofitting Solution for Soft Story Mitigation in Reinforced Concrete Frame Buildings: A Socio-technical Approach Using Numerical Optimization

This research provides a practical and feasible retrofitting solution for soft story in reinforced concrete (RC) buildings with masonry infill walls for example in Nepal through numerical analysis. It is well understood that stiffness and strength of the soft story floor can be increased significantly by adding RC shear wall in the frame opening of the ground floor, making lateral deformation of that floor negligible. With this consideration, the authors have developed a numerical optimization framework for optimizing the RC shear wall in the open floor of soft story building incorporating socio-technical aspects from their previous publication [Timsina, K., Gadagamma, C. K., Numada, M. and Meguro, K. [2019b] “Development of a numerical optimization framework for solving soft-story problem in reinforced concrete frame buildings,” Seisan-Kenkyu]. The objective function for numerical optimization is cost minimization with the constraints of usability, performance, and complexity from a detailed field study. In this paper, the numerical optimization framework is developed and solved using the sequential quadratic programing (SQP). The whole scheme has been incorporated inside the 2D-Applied Element Method (AEM). The retrofitting solution thus obtained from the numerical optimization has been analyzed using the incremental dynamic analysis to know the capacity of the frame structure in earthquake ground motion. It shows that the retrofitting method can significantly enhance the soft story frame’s capacity and ensure the dwellers’ interests are not compromised.

Seismic assessment and strengthening of a RC building using pushover analysis

Many existing Reinforced Concrete (RC) buildings in moderate to high seismic hazard zones (including old RC buildings and historical structures in Palestine) have inadequate capacity to resist earthquake loads, most of the existing and old buildings were designed and constructed according to earlier codes, which did not satisfy modern seismic design requirements and current engineering standards, as well as other reasons which may also lead to failure such as the faulty structural design and improper construction, alteration of building functions, changes of seismic load characteristics in the area, etc. Procedures of performance-based analysis using nonlinear static analysis (pushover) were used here to study the performance of a proposed RC frame building in different seismic zones in Palestine, the seismic response and performance of these cases were discussed. The results and analyses of the studied cases showed that the proposed steel jacking system managed to avoid the collapse plastic hinges and to reduce displacements and drifts, it was found that the building fulfilled its seismic design criteria after the application of the strengthening strategy.

Effect of Infills on the Response Modification Factor for Infilled Reinforced Concrete Frame Buildings

RC frames with unreinforced masonry infill walls are the most common type of building. Unreinforced masonry walls are often not considered by engineers in the design process, although walls and frames interact during strong ground motion, leading to structural responses deviating radically from what is expected in the design. Under lateral load, reinforced concrete confining members (frames) act in tension or compression, depending on the direction of the lateral seismic pressures. Meanwhile, masonry walls act as diagonal struts prone to compression. This research aims to develop the effect of masonry infills and their distribution on the value of the resulting response modification factor. For this purpose, a parametric study was performed on five, seven, and ten-story' buildings modeled as bare and infilled frames. Infill ratio, panel aspect ratio, unidirectional eccentricity, and bidirectional eccentricities were the parameters investigated. Each proposed model's resulting response modification factor was compared to the value cited in different international codes. It was concluded that this value differs depending on several parameters and cannot be constant for a certain structural system. The novelty of this research is the deduction of a general equation to calculate the response modification factor as a function of the percentage of infills and the eccentricity, while presenting two different methods to calculate it. Doi: 10.28991/CEJ-2023-09-12-09 Full Text: PDF

A modal-based method for blast-induced damage assessment of reinforced concrete columns: Numerical and experimental validation

Reinforced concrete (RC) columns play a crucial role in the overall performance of modern RC frame buildings under blast loading. The RC columns under blast loads might experience various irreversible consequences such as concrete cracks, crushing and spalling, changing the status of both modal properties and load-carrying capacity. In this paper, the blast-induced damage assessment of the RC columns involving the measurement of modal parameters was introduced and validated. Firstly, a modal-based method for blast-induced damage assessment of RC columns was proposed, in which the damage is characterized as the reduction of axial bearing capacity and further expressed as the explicit function of the vibration frequencies and the mass-normalized displacement mode shapes. Then, the finite-element analysis program LS-DYNA was employed to establish the numerical model of RC columns under axial compression loads and lateral blast loads. The residual load-bearing capacities and modal properties of the RC columns were illustrated. By using the numerical results collected in the present study, the validity of the proposed damage assessment method was discussed and proved numerically. Further, field explosion tests and experimental modal tests were conducted, and the results showed that the modal-based damage assessment method exhibited remarkable agreement with the blast damage determined by residual bearing capacities. Based on the numerical and experimental results, the proposed modal-based damage assessment method is applicable for the non-destructive evaluation of blast-induced damage of RC columns.

Seismic Response of RC Frame Buildings: Theoretical Formulation and Modeling with Soil-Structure Interaction Analysis

"Seismic Response of RC Frame Buildings: Theoretical Formulation and Modeling with Soil- Structure Interaction Analysis," offers a comprehensive exploration of the seismic response of reinforced concrete (RC) framed structures, with particular emphasis on soil flexibility. Through a meticulous response spectrum analysis, the study delves into the influence of soil flexibility on buildings of varying heights, ranging from five to nine storeys, considering both fixed and flexible support conditions across diverse soil types. The research draws the following significant conclusions: Significance of Soil-Structure Interaction (SSI): Incorporating soil-structure interaction (SSI) into the analysis leads to a noteworthy extension of the natural time period of the structure. This parameter stands as a linchpin in grasping the lateral response of framed structures, underlining its pivotal role in the precision of seismic design calculations. Soil Flexibility and Amplified Base Shear: Enhanced soil flexibility is found to correlate with a proportional increase in base shear. This phenomenon is most pronounced in soft soil conditions, where base shear experiences substantial escalation, particularly in taller buildings. Roof Displacement as a Performance Indicator: Roof displacement, a crucial indicator of structural performance, exhibits an upward trajectory owing to the cumulative effects of SSI. Notably, soft soils manifest higher roof displacements, with these variations becoming more pronounced as the building's height increases. The insights garnered from this analysis underscore the profound influence of SSI on a building's seismic response. Furthermore, the study highlights that advancements in finite element methods (FEM) and computer technology have significantly facilitated the integration of SSI into structural analysis. Therefore, it is imperative to harness these advancements fully to enhance our comprehension of structural behavior and to promote the adoption of secure construction practices in seismic-prone regions.

Influence of corrosion on failure modes and lifetime seismic vulnerability assessment of low‐ductility RC frames

AbstractCorrosion of reinforced concrete (RC) structures constitutes a critical form of environmental deterioration and may significantly increase the vulnerability of old non‐seismically designed buildings during earthquake events. This study proposes a probabilistic framework to evaluate the influence of corrosion deterioration on the lifetime seismic fragility of low‐ductility RC frame buildings. In contrast to limited past literature on this topic, the proposed framework offers novel contributions. This is one of the first study to consider potential alteration in failure modes of building components (from flexure to flexure‐shear) due to the time‐dependent aging process. Numerical models validated with past experimental test results are utilized to capture these failure modes, which are particularly relevant for low ductility RC frames designed prior to the introduction of modern seismic codes. Secondly, given the gamut of uncertainties associated with the corrosion process, this study develops condition‐dependent seismic fragility functions independent from an assumed exposure scenario, as often done in literature. These functions can be easily adopted by design engineers and stakeholders for prompt fragility assessment, and subsequent decision‐making without the need for computationally expensive finite element (FE) model runs. The proposed framework is demonstrated on a benchmark three‐story RC frame that considers time‐varying seismic demand models and damage state thresholds while accounting for the uncertain corrosion deterioration process and ground motion record‐to‐record variability.

An Overview of Performance-Based Seismic Design Framework for Reinforced Concrete Frame Buildings

An Overview of Performance-Based Seismic Design Framework for Reinforced Concrete Frame Buildings

Fire scenario-based damage assessment of ductile reinforced concrete buildings using computational fluid dynamics models

This study aims to develop a computational fluid dynamics (CFD)-based framework to assess the thermal behavior of reinforced concrete (RC) structures with non-uniformly distributed fire damage. To achieve this, a CFD model that can predict fire-induced temperature was validated using experimental data of an RC column specimen obtained from an existing study. It was then extended to develop the CFD model of an RC building frame to investigate the extent and pattern of damage to its columns and beams under various fire scenarios, combinations of fire intensity, ventilation coefficient, and fire source locations. The non-uniform temperature distributions of the columns and beams were used to modify the stress–strain curve of concrete and rebar and to perform a moment–curvature analysis to evaluate their residual flexural strength. The computed flexural strengths were compared with those obtained from existing design guidelines. The guidelines were determined to be extremely cautious compared to the results of the proposed method.

The Effect of Soil Liquefaction and Lateral Spreading to the Seismic Vulnerability of RC Frame Buildings Considering SSI

ABSTRACT Evidence of past earthquakes highlighted the seismic vulnerability to buildings due to soil liquefaction and lateral spreading phenomena. Damage to buildings on a liquefiable site, especially on a gently sloping site, can be severe. The liquefied soil can undergo permanent lateral ground displacements as large as several meters in some cases, which can be severely disastrous to buildings. Recent physical tests and effective stress analyses of nonlinear dynamic soil-structure interaction (SSI) proved that simplified empirical processes are often improper for evaluating liquefaction-induced building settlements. A better understanding of the SSI effects is also essential in cases where the underlying soil is susceptible to liquefaction. In this respect, the interaction of the earthquake excitation and ground failure (i.e. soil liquefaction and lateral spreading) for buildings considering SSI is investigated herein. Typical low-code reinforced concrete (RC) frame buildings of different heights with shallow spread footings on liquefiable level-ground or sloping soils subjected to ground shaking are considered. The direct SSI approach is implemented. Predictive relationships are established between the maximum normalized differential displacements (horizontal or settlement) and the permanent ground displacement (PGD) vector at the level of foundation for low-code RC frame buildings with shallow spread footings on soils with high liquefaction potential subjected to ground shaking. Finally, vulnerability is expressed in terms of fragility and vulnerability curves as well as in terms of fragility surfaces as a function of two intensity measures.

Framework to assess the seismic performance of non-engineered masonry infilled RC frame buildings accounting for material uncertainty

Non-engineered construction accounts for more than half of the building stock in low and middle-income countries. A significant portion of these buildings is constructed using masonry infilled reinforced concrete (RC) frames with inadequate seismic detailing. This type of construction is prone to high levels of variability in the material properties, posing a significant challenge in their seismic performance evaluation. This research proposes a framework to assess the seismic performance of non-engineered constructed masonry infilled RC frame buildings, which considers the material uncertainty. A four-stage procedure based on Monte Carlo simulations is introduced, wherein engineering demand parameters and seismic performance are expressed in terms of probability distributions. The framework is demonstrated using a non-engineered housing archetype located in Sincelejo, Colombia. The results showed that the framework allows capturing the uncertainty in the materials construction variability of non-engineered houses. The results also showed that mean values of material properties may lead to significant errors in the seismic performance assessment of non-engineered constructed masonry infilled RC frames. The differences between the predicted minimum and maximum exceedance probabilities of a damage state can be greater than 80%.

Predicting the Influence of Soil–Structure Interaction on Seismic Responses of Reinforced Concrete Frame Buildings Using Convolutional Neural Network

Most regional seismic damage assessment (RSDA) methods are based on the rigid-base assumption to ensure evaluating efficiency, while these practices introduce factual errors due to neglecting the soil–structure interaction (SSI). Predicting the influence of the SSI on seismic responses of regionwide structure portfolios remains a challenging undertaking, as it requires developing numerous high-fidelity, integrated models to capture the dynamic interplay and uncertainties in structures, foundations, and supporting soils. This study develops a one-dimensional convolutional neural network (1D-CNN) model to efficiently predict to what degree considering the SSI would change the inter-story drifts and base shear forces of RC frame buildings. An experimentally validated finite element model is developed to simulate the nonlinear seismic behavior of the building-foundation–soil system. Subsequently, a database comprising input data (i.e., structural and soil parameters, ground motions) and output predictors (i.e., changes in story drift and base shear) is constructed by simulating 1380 pairs of fixed-base versus soil-supported structures under earthquake loading. This large-scale dataset is used to train, test, and identify the optimal hyperparameters for the 1D-CNN model to quantify the demand differences in inter-story drifts and base shears due to the SSI. Results indicate the 1D-CNN model has a superior performance, and the absolute prediction errors of the SSI influence coefficients for the maximum base shear and inter-story drift are within 9.3% and 11.7% for 80% of cases in the testing set. The deep learning model can be conveniently applied to enhance the accuracy of the RSDA of RC buildings by updating their seismic responses where no SSI is considered.

The influence of earthquake characteristics on the seismic performance of reinforced concrete buildings in Australia with varying heights

In Australia, most of the existing buildings were designed before the release of the Australian standard for earthquake actions in 2007. Therefore, many existing buildings in Australia lack adequate seismic design, and their seismic performance must be assessed. The recent earthquake that struck Mansfield, Victoria near Melbourne elevated the need to produce fragility curves for existing reinforced concrete (RC) buildings in Australia. Fragility curves are frequently utilized to assess buildings’ seismic performance and it is defined as the demand probability surpassing capacity at a given intensity level. Numerous factors can influence the results of the fragility assessment of RC buildings. Among the most important factors that can affect the performance-based seismic assessment of buildings are the building height and the characteristics of the earthquake. Despite this, very few studies accounted for the earthquake characteristics and the influence of height on the vulnerability of buildings in Australia. Consequently, the combined effect of building height and the characteristics of the earthquake were investigated in this study. This was achieved through numerical modeling and time-history analyses of three typical two-, four-, and nine-story RC frame buildings in Australia. Moreover, these buildings were subjected to three different types of ground motions which were: short- and long-duration, and near-fault earthquakes. Fragility analysis was then conducted for the three buildings under all the selected earthquake suites. It was noted from the median values of the fragility curves that the four-story and the nine-story RC buildings were 17% and 18% more susceptible to damage in comparison with the two-story building under short-duration earthquakes. Moreover, it was also noted that the median value of the vulnerability increased by 33%, 40%, and 50% for the two-, four-, and nine-story buildings, sequentially, when subjected to near-fault compared to short-duration earthquakes.

Seismic Capacity Estimation for Composite Multi-storeyed RC buildings

Seismic hazard happens to be one of the most devastative natural hazards to be faced by mankind. In view of urbanization and knowledge gained from past natural hazards, several urban cities have seen a transformation in building their habitats. These range from regular, irregular multistoried Reinforced Concrete (RC) buildings to several composite multi storeyed RC buildings due to certain inherent functional benefits (viz., ventilation, parking space, ease of construction etc.,). The existing seismic code regulations provided by BIS (Bureau of Indian Standards) do not specify any approach to arrive at appropriate design seismic forces and capacity for composite multi storeyed buildings. Therefore, it is imminent to assess the structural behaviour of these multistoried composite RC buildings under earthquake forces at the site location to provide a safe and functional configuration. Hence an attempt has been made in this study to analytically compare regular and composite RC building models having similar Plan and Height. The multistoried RC building configurations considered in this study comprises of regular RC building as well as RC building frame coupled with steel joists at certain locations to represent a composite structural system. These models are further analyzed to arrive at inherent nonlinear seismic capacity, ductility and design seismic forces necessary to be considered during design of RC building structure. Hence, a typical hypothetical G+5 regular and composite multistoried buildings were modelled and analysed using the nonlinear static (pushover analysis) approach. The outcomes of these analyses clearly portrays the variation in dynamic characteristics of the building frames represented in terms of its time period, inelastic capacity and response reduction factor (R). Moreover, the present study emphasizes to analytically evaluate the design seismic forces necessary for earthquake resistant design of composite buildings in any urban environment albeit the changes in structural configurations.

Seismic Vulnerability of Code Compliant RC Frame Building with Unreinforced Masonry Infill Walls

Unreinforced masonry (URM) infill walls in Reinforced concrete (RC) buildings are normally designed as non-structural elements. However, in the past, the post-earthquake response of the RC frame building showed that URM infill walls increase the strength and stiffness of the RC frame buildings. Further, it is also observed that URM helped to prevent the disastrous destruction by acting as a structural member in RC frame. In the present study, the performance assessment of a four-storey URM infill RC frame with different infill configurations, namely bare and Open Ground Storey (OGS) is done using fragility analyses. Nonlinear masonry material is modelled as the equitant three strut model in ETABS. Nonlinear static pushover analysis is applied for the analysis of the configured RC frames. The probability of damage states is determined by firstly converting pushover curves into capacity curves and accordingly, performance-point values of Spectral acceleration and Spectral displacement for seismic demand Zone-V (Elastic Response Spectra as per IS 1893:2016) using the capacity-spectrum method (ATC-40) are determined. The fragility function used is an approximation of the continuous to discrete distribution. Fragility curves and mean damage matrix are derived to compare performance with each other. From the vulnerability analyses, it is observed that the OGS framed RC building performs better as compared to the bare frame.

Influence of Structural Parameters on the Buckling of Longitudinal Steel Bar in RC Structural Wall

Reinforced Concrete (RC) structural wall is widely used in multistoried RC frame buildings to enhance lateral stiffness and lateral strength for earthquake resistance. One of the possible failure modes, observed during strong earthquake shaking, is the buckling of longitudinal steel reinforcement in the boundary elements of the wall. This also assumes importance in establishing damage states for seismic fragility analysis of RC wall. Although a few past studies have focussed on longitudinal bar buckling in RC members, detailed parametric study is absent particularly for such instability of bars in the boundary elements of the wall. In the present study, displacement-controlled nonlinear static analysis of several wall specimens is carried out using fibre-discretization of cross-section and distributed plasticity modelling in OpenSEES. Here, 27 different models of the isolated slender wall are created considering variations in six structural parameters, namely (a) length ratio of the boundary element to the wall, (b) axial force ratio, ratios of (c) longitudinal steel in web, and (d) transverse steel and (e) longitudinal steel in the boundary elements. The effect of wall thickness is accounted for through variation in axial force ratio. Using the analytical results from the nonlinear analysis of the wall models, the trends in drift ratio at the onset of longitudinal bar buckling damage states as functions of various key structural wall properties, has been investigated.

Accuracy of Seismic Response Evaluation of Two-Dimensional Analysis Model with Rigid Joints for RC Frame Buildings.

Three- or two-dimensional (2D) numerical models are used for the evaluation of the seismic performance of reinforced concrete (RC) buildings. This study examines a 2D numerical model for a specimen used in a full-scale four-story RC shaking-table test and evaluates the accuracy of the seismic response of the 2D numerical model, which is composed of a square fiber section model for the columns, a T-shape fiber section model for the beam and slab, and a rigid joint model for the beam-column joint. A parametric analysis of the effective slab width is performed to analyze its effects on the modal shape and natural period. The results suggest that the primary natural period of the considered model is almost identical to that associated with the experimental results. The applicability of the 2D numerical model for estimating the seismic response of the structure is established. By comparing the results of the seismic analysis and the experiment in the 50% amplitude of the JMA-Kobe wave, which corresponds to slightly exceeding VII on the modified Mercalli intensity scale, the root-mean-square percentage error of the 2D numerical model is 1.03% for the floor acceleration and 4.7% for the inter-story drift. Thus, the analytical model used in this study has sufficient accuracy in evaluating the seismic performance of buildings constructed in regions with a maximum seismic intensity of VII.

Dynamic behavior and retrofitting of RC frame building under vehicular bomb explosion

Although the terrorist explosion attacks on critical buildings caused by the Vehicle-Borne Improvised Explosive Device (VBIED) are low-probability events, the blast-induced progressive collapse of buildings generally lead to the catastrophic consequences of the events. Through the high-fidelity hybrid finite element (FE) model and numerical simulations, this work aims to get a deep insight into the progressive collapse behavior of high-rise reinforced concrete (RC) frame buildings under blast loadings induced by VBIED, as well as the feasibility of two blast-resistant external retrofitting measures, i.e., fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) and steel plate (SP). Firstly, the applicability of the hybrid FE modelling approach, element types and size, material models and parameters, as well as numerical algorithms, i.e., multi-material Arbitrary Lagrangian-Eulerian (MM-ALE) and Fluid-Structure Interaction (FSI), are fully validated by comparing with the explosion tests on 1/4-scale bare and prototype FRP/SP-retrofitted RC frame structures, respectively. Then, a twelve-story RC frame building is designed following the Chinese regulations, and the corresponding hybrid FE model is established. The failure modes and progressive collapse process of building under the explosions of cargo vans bomb (equivalent TNT of 1814 kg) specified by Federal Emergency Management Agency are numerically examined. Furthermore, the effectiveness of FRP/SP-retrofitted frame columns is assessed quantitatively. It derives that, the SP-retrofitted building is not collapsed for both the scaled distance of 1.0 and 0.55 m/kg1/3; by retrofitting FRP warps, the collapse of entire buildings can be prevented with the scaled distance of 1.0 m/kg1/3, while the progressive collapse of the retrofitted building occurs with a scaled distance of 0.55 m/kg1/3. The present work could provide helpful references for the blast-resistant evaluation, design and retrofitting of the as- and newly-built RC building structures.