The function of proteins involved in electron transfer is dependent on cofactors attaining the necessary reduction potentials. We establish a mode of cluster redox tuning through steric pressure on a synthetic model related to Photosystem II. Resembling the cuboidal [CaMn3O4] subsite of the biological oxygen evolving complex (OEC), [Mn4O4] and [YMn3O4] complexes featuring ligands of different basicity and chelating properties were characterized by cyclic voltammetry. In the absence of ligand-induced distortions, increasing the basicity of the ligands results in a decrease of cluster reduction potential. Contraction of Y-oxo/Y–Mn distances by 0.1/0.15 Å enforced by a chelating ligand results in an increase of cluster reduction potential even in the presence of strongly basic donors. Related protein-induced changes in Ca-oxo/Ca–Mn distances may have similar effects in tuning the redox potential of the OEC through entatic states and may explain the cation size dependence on the progression of the S-state cycle.