In prior studies, HIV-1 BF recombinants with subtype F integrases failed to develop resistance to raltegravir through the Q148H mutational pathway. We aimed to determine the role of subtype-specific polymorphisms in integrase on drug susceptibility, viral replication and integration. Integrase sequences were retrieved from the Los Alamos Database or obtained from the Garrahan HIV cohort. HIV-1 infectious molecular clones with or without Q148H (+ G140S) resistance mutations were constructed using integrases of subtype B (NL4-3) or F1(BF) ARMA159 and URTR23. Integrase chimeras were generated by reciprocal exchanges of a 200 bp fragment spanning amino acids 85-150 of the catalytic core domain (CCD) of NL4-3-Q148H and either ARMA159-Q148H or URTR23-Q148H. Viral infections were quantified by p24 ELISA and Alu-gag integration PCR assay. At least 18 different polymorphisms distinguish subtype B from F1(BF) recombinant integrases. In phenotypic experiments, p24 at Day 15 post-infection was high (105-106 pg/mL) for WT and NL4-3-Q148H; by contrast, it was low (102-104 pg/mL) for both F1(BF)-Q148H + G140S viruses, and undetectable for the Q148H mutants. Compared with WT viruses, integrated DNA was reduced by 5-fold for NL4-3-Q148H (P = 0.05), 9-fold for URTR23-Q148H (P = 0.01) and 16000-fold for ARMA159-Q148H (P = 0.01). Reciprocal exchange between B and F1(BF) of an integrase CCD region failed to rescue the replicative defect of F1(BF) integrase mutants. The functional impairment of Q148H in the context of subtype F integrases from BF recombinants explains the lack of selection of this pathway in vivo. Non-B polymorphisms external to the integrase CCD may influence the pathway to integrase strand transfer inhibitor resistance.