Real-time Heuristic Search Methods Research Articles

Anytime versus Real-Time Heuristic Search for On-Line Planning

Many AI systems, such as robots, must plan under time constraints. The most popular search approach applied in robotics so far is anytime search, in which the algorithm quickly finds a suboptimal plan, and then continues to find better and better plans as time passes, until eventually converging on an optimal plan. However, the time until the first plan is returned is not controllable, so such methods inherently involve idling the system's operation before `real' execution can begin. Real-time search methods provide hard real-time bounds on action selection time, yet to our knowledge, they have not yet been demonstrated for robotic systems. In this work, we compare anytime and real-time heuristic search methods in their ability to allow agents to achieve goals quickly.Our results suggest that real-time search is more broadly applicable and often achieves goals faster than anytime search, while anytime search finds shorter plans and does not suffer from dead-ends.

Real-Time Planning as Decision-Making under Uncertainty

In real-time planning, an agent must select the next action to take within a fixed time bound. Many popular real-time heuristic search methods approach this by expanding nodes using time-limited A* and selecting the action leading toward the frontier node with the lowest f value. In this paper, we reconsider real-time planning as a problem of decision-making under uncertainty. We propose treating heuristic values as uncertain evidence and we explore several backup methods for aggregating this evidence. We then propose a novel lookahead strategy that expands nodes to minimize risk, the expected regret in case a non-optimal action is chosen. We evaluate these methods in a simple synthetic benchmark and the sliding tile puzzle and find that they outperform previous methods. This work illustrates how uncertainty can arise even when solving deterministic planning problems, due to the inherent ignorance of time-limited search algorithms about those portions of the state space that they have not computed, and how an agent can benefit from explicitly metareasoning about this uncertainty.

Avoiding Dead Ends in Real-Time Heuristic Search

Many systems, such as mobile robots, need to be controlled in real time. Real-time heuristic search is a popular on-line planning paradigm that supports concurrent planning and execution. However,existing methods do not incorporate a notion of safety and we show that they can perform poorly in domains that contain dead-end states from which a goal cannot be reached. We introduce new real-time heuristic search methods that can guarantee safety if the domain obeys certain properties. We test these new methods on two different simulated domains that contain dead ends, one that obeys the properties and one that does not. We find that empirically the new methods provide good performance. We hope this work encourages further efforts to widen the applicability of real-time planning.

Comparing real-time and incremental heuristic search for real-time situated agents

Real-time situated agents, such as characters in real-time computer games, often do not know the terrain in advance but automatically observe it within a certain range around themselves. They have to interleave searches with action executions to make the searches tractable when moving autonomously to user-specified coordinates. The searches face real-time requirements since it is important that the agents be responsive to the commands of the users and move smoothly. In this article, we compare two classes of fast heuristic search methods for these navigation tasks that speed up A* searches in different ways, namely real-time heuristic search and incremental heuristic search, to understand their advantages and disadvantages and make recommendations about when each one should be used. We first develop a competitive real-time heuristic search method. LSS-LRTA* is a version of Learning Real-Time A* that uses A* to determine its local search spaces and learns quickly. We analyze the properties of LSS-LRTA* and then compare it experimentally against the state-of-the-art incremental heuristic search method D* Lite on our navigation tasks, for which D* Lite was specifically developed, resulting in the first comparison of real-time and incremental heuristic search in the literature. We characterize when to choose each one of the two heuristic search methods, depending on the search objective and the kind of terrain. Our experimental results show that LSS-LRTA* can outperform D* Lite under the right conditions, namely when there is time pressure or the user-supplied h-values are generally not misleading.

Graph Abstraction in Real-time Heuristic Search

Real-time heuristic search methods are used by situated agents in applications that require the amount of planning per move to be independent of the problem size. Such agents plan only a few actions at a time in a local search space and avoid getting trapped in local minima by improving their heuristic function over time. We extend a wide class of real-time search algorithms with automatically-built state abstraction and prove completeness and convergence of the resulting family of algorithms. We then analyze the impact of abstraction in an extensive empirical study in real-time pathfinding. Abstraction is found to improve efficiency by providing better trading offs between planning time, learning speed and other negatively correlated performance measures.

Graph abstraction in real-time heuristic search

Real-time heuristic search methods are used by situated agents in applications that require the amount of planning per move to be independent of the problem size. Such agents plan only a few action...

SEARCHING SOLITAIRE IN REAL TIME

This article presents a new real-time heuristic search method for planning problems with distinct stages. Our multistage nested rollout algorithm allows the user to apply separate heuristics at each stage of the search process and tune the search mag

Minimax real-time heuristic search

Real-time heuristic search methods interleave planning and plan executions and plan only in the part of the domain around the current state of the agents. So far, real-time heuristic search methods have mostly been applied to deterministic planning tasks. In this article, we argue that real-time heuristic search methods can efficiently solve nondeterministic planning tasks. We introduce Min-Max Learning Real-Time A∗ (Min-Max LRTA∗), a real-time heuristic search method that generalizes Korf's LRTA∗ to nondeterministic domains, and apply it to robot-navigation tasks in mazes, where the robots know the maze but do not know their initial position and orientation (pose). These planning tasks can be modeled as planning tasks in nondeterministic domains whose states are sets of poses. We show that Min-Max LRTA∗ solves the robot-navigation tasks fast, converges quickly, and requires only a small amount of memory.