Rat Laryngeal Transplant Research Articles

Ten-Month Laryngeal Allograft Survival with Use of Pulsed Everolimus and Anti—αβ T-Cell Receptor Antibody Immunosuppression

The risks of daily immunosuppression limit the use of laryngeal transplantation as a reconstructive option. Pulsed immunosuppressive dosing can lessen these risks. The study objective was to develop a long-term pulsing regimen that minimizes exposure to immunosuppressive agents. Rat laryngeal transplantation was performed. Everolimus (1 mg/kg per day) and anti-c41 T-cell receptor (TCR) antibodies (250 microg) were given for 7 days beginning 1 day before transplantation and for 5 days beginning on day 90 after transplantation. On day 180, group 1 (n = 5) received the initial regimen for 3 days, and group 2 (n = 5) received everolimus (1 mg/kg per day) until euthanization, which occurred when parathyroid hormone (PTH) levels dropped to less than 11 pg/mL or at 300 days. Four of the 5 rats in group 1 had normal PTH levels at 300 days. The PTH level for 1 rat was less than 11 pg/ mL at 270 days. In group 2, none of the 5 rats had normal PTH levels at 300 days. Two had PTH levels below 11 pg/mL at 270 days, and 3 had PTH levels below 11 pg/mL at 300 days. The allografts that survived beyond 300 days had an essentially normal histologic appearance. Pulsed immunosuppression prevented allograft rejection for 10 months and was more effective than daily everolimus. Short-term perioperative therapy followed by pulsed, tapered dosing is a viable alternative to traditional regimens and may decrease associated risks.

A new mouse laryngeal transplantation rejection grading system

Development of a rat laryngeal transplantation model allowed for the first total human laryngeal transplantation by the senior author in 1998. In an effort to further our knowledge of the immune system's role in laryngeal rejection, a change to the mouse model was required. Prior to initiating immunosuppressive research protocols, a reliable mouse larynx rejection classification had to be established. Animal study. Thirty-one mouse laryngeal transplants (C57 BL/6 donors to C3H recipients) were performed and allowed to reject. Six time points were evaluated histologically: 1, 3, 5, 7, 9, and 15 days post-transplant. Eight anatomic sites were evaluated and assigned a point value. A linear regression model was constructed using the group number as the response and the scores from the eight histological criteria as predictors. Severity classifications were determined by observing patterns in the sum of scores of variables found to be significant contributors. Group 1 was normal; group 2, minimal rejection; groups 3, 4, and 5, moderate rejection; and group 6, severe rejection. All mice survived the transplants. Of the observed histological changes, cartilage, fat, muscle, and magnitude of lymphocytic infiltration significantly correlated with rejection severity. The rejection model created demonstrated 100% accuracy in predicting the severity classification for the 31 specimens in the study. The model established provides an accurate and reliable way to classify rejection severity in mice receiving laryngeal allografts. This sets the stage for future advanced study of manipulating the immune system as a mechanism for establishing allograft tolerance.

Induction with T-cell receptor antibody leads to long-term laryngeal allograft function

Purpose The use of induction therapy with αβ T-cell receptor ( αβTCR) monoclonal antibody in association with tacrolimus in an allogeneic rat laryngeal transplant model permits rigorous long-term evaluation of potential short-term synergism offered by these agents. Materials and methods The allogeneic model consisted of 19 Brown Norway larynges transplanted to Lewis recipients. Treatment consisted of tacrolimus (1.2 mg/kg per day) alone and in combination with 7 days of αβTCR (0.5 mL/d). Control groups consisted of untreated animals, as well as a semiallogeneic model with Lewis-Brown Norway larynges transplanted to Lewis recipients and treated with tacrolimus monotherapy. Each group consisted of 6 to 11 rats. The median duration of engraftment was 44 days (range, 14–106 days). Graft histopathology was graded according to an established 31-point scale in a blinded fashion. Long-term grafts (>75 days) were followed with serum parathyroid hormone levels. Results Untreated controls experienced almost complete rejection (mean score, 27; SD, 0). Allogeneic transplants treated with tacrolimus monotherapy experienced near-complete rejection (mean score, 25.2; SD, 2.1). Allogeneic transplants treated with combination therapy and followed for a median duration of 100 days demonstrated significantly better rejection scores than controls (mean score, 11.1; SD, 1.7; P = .003). Combination therapy was also significantly more effective in preventing acute rejection than monotherapy with tacrolimus in a semiallogeneic model (mean score, 22.1; SD, 4.6; P < .04). Conclusions Induction therapy with tacrolimus and αβTCR prevents rejection in an allogeneic model for up to 100 days. This regimen was associated with significantly better histopathologic rejection scores than untreated controls, or monotherapy with tacrolimus in allogeneic or semiallogeneic models.

Donor bone marrow in laryngeal transplantation: results of a rat study

Introduction The concept of donor bone marrow transplantation has been successfully used in human solid organ transplantation to increase recipient chimerism. The development of recipient chimerism is associated with a decreased need for immunosuppression and even donor-specific tolerance. In this study, we attempted to augment recipient chimerism by the transfer of donor bone marrow at the time of rat laryngeal transplant. Study design Experimental study in rats. Methods The study used a well-established semiallogeneic rat laryngeal transplant model with partial major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-mismatched Lewis-Brown-Norway donors and Lewis recipients. Donor bone marrow was introduced at transplantation via (1) intravascular injection and (2) transfer of a vascularized femoral bone graft. Recipients were treated with an established immunosuppressive regimen consisting of everolimus and anti- αβTCR monoclonal antibody for a 7-day perioperative course. Animals received a 5-day boost of the same regimen at 90 days posttransplantation. Parathyroid hormone levels and histological examination were used for rejection surveillance and scoring. Results Animals treated with intravenous bone marrow injection followed by perioperative and pulsed immunosuppression commonly demonstrated early rejection (90%). Animals receiving transfer of vascularized donor femur had an average rejection score of 2.9 (scale, 1-6) at 180 days posttransplantation. Mixed-lymphocyte reaction did not demonstrate donor-specific tolerance in the latter group, and chimerism was less than 1%. Conclusions In the rat laryngeal transplant model, donor bone marrow does not consistently lead to augmentation of peripheral chimerism using our established pulsed immunosuppression protocol. In many cases, rejection occurred earlier than animals not receiving bone marrow. This may be due to several different factors including (1) an element of graft-vs-host disease, (2) inability to establish bone marrow engraftment due to our short-term perioperative immunosuppression regimen, or (3) preferential rejection of donor bone marrow cells.

Postallograft Donor and Recipient Dendritic Cell Trafficking in the Rat Larynx

Dendritic cells (DC) are potent antigen-presenting cells that instigate allograft rejection. Their migration kinetics vary depending on the type of organ transplanted. The timing of donor and recipient DC trafficking in laryngeal transplants is unknown. Prospective animal model. Lewis to Brown Norway (BN) rat laryngeal allografts and BN to BN isografts were performed without immunosuppression. Recipient animals were sacrificed at seven posttransplant time points. Total DC, as well as recipient and donor DC (in allograft recipients), were enumerated in situ in the airway epithelium and subepithelium using monoclonal antibodies, immunofluorescence, confocal microscopy, and image analysis software. Total DC densities in both laryngeal allografts and isografts decreased to approximately 10% of their initial values in the first 3 days and then rose beyond their starting values. In allografts, there was a net efflux of donor DC, reaching a nadir by 3 to 5 days; they were identified in recipient cervical lymph nodes from 12 hours to 5 days. Recipient DC infiltrated the laryngeal allograft, reaching a maximal density by day 7. The paradigm of donor DC efflux and recipient DC influx has been confirmed in a rat laryngeal transplant model, and the allograft-specific timing of these events has been elucidated. Similarities in total DC migration between allografts and isografts suggest that this phenomenon may not be driven entirely by major histocompatibility mismatch. Further understanding of trafficking may help with the goal of manipulating DC to induce allograft tolerance in the absence of generalized immunosuppression.

Quantitative Analysis of OX62-Positive Dendritic Cell Distribution in the Rat Laryngeal Complex

Dendritic cells (DCs) are key instigators of rejection after transplantation. Their distribution has not been systematically characterized in all locations of the larynx and its surrounding tissues. Rat larynges were stained with monoclonal antibodies identifying DCs. These cells were then enumerated by a new combination of techniques including immunofluorescence, confocal microscopy, and imaging software. The vast majority of DCs were located in the epithelium and subepithelium of the airway; the mean DC density ranged from 9 cells per square millimeter (0.2% of cells) to 645 cells per square millimeter (10.3% of cells). Their density in the epithelium was 3 to 11 times higher than that in the subepithelium. Non-airway sites (thyroid, parathyroid, muscle, fat) had mean DC densities varying from 3 cells per square millimeter (0.2%) to 57 cells per square millimeter (0.8%). No DCs were detected in cartilage. Dendritic cells are concentrated in the laryngotracheal epithelium and subepithelium and represent a much smaller proportion in the other sites studied. A baseline for laryngeal DC population studies has been established, and a computerized model for consistent quantitation using confocal microscopy has been developed. This unique method will serve as a foundation for investigating DC trafficking after rat laryngeal transplantation.

Pulsed Immunosuppression with Everolimus and Anti-αβ T-Cell Receptor: Laryngeal Allograft Preservation at Six Months

Laryngeal transplantation can restore the voice in patients who have undergone laryngectomy. However, the prospect of lifelong immunosuppression is a drawback to this procedure. We present data from a study aimed at minimizing the need for immunosuppression while maintaining graft viability through a novel pulsed-dosing protocol. Larynges were transplanted from Lewis-brown Norway (RT1(l+n, F1) rats to Lewis (RT1(l)) recipients. All recipients received 7 days of treatment with everolimus and mouse anti-rat alphabeta T-cell receptor (anti-TCR) monoclonal antibodies beginning the day before transplantation. At 90 days after transplantation, all recipients received a pulse of the same treatment combination for 5 days. From 90 to 180 days after transplantation, the rats received no treatment (group 1, n = 5), 2.5 mg/kg everolimus per day (group 2, n = 5), or 1.0 mg/kg everolimus per day (group 3, n = 5). Histologic analysis of rats that received everolimus as pulse therapy evidenced no signs of rejection, whereas animals that were untreated after 90 days had normal to mild chronic rejection. T-cell reconstitution occurred 65 days after perioperative immunosuppressive treatment, but less rapidly after pulse therapy. Also, peripheral chimerism was generated in all 3 groups. In the rat laryngeal transplantation model, short-term perioperative therapy with everolimus and anti-TCR followed by pulsing is a viable alternative to the concerns associated with continuous, lifelong immunosuppression.

The effect of donor-specific transfusion upon rejection in a rat model of laryngeal transplantation

Lifelong immunosuppression carries significant morbidity, and techniques to reduce or eliminate such immunosuppression might expand laryngeal transplantation. This study investigates the ability of donor-specific transfusion to establish tolerance in a rat model of laryngeal transplantation. A total of 289 transplants were performed from Lewis-Brown-Norway donors to Lewis recipients. Donor-specific transfusion was provided as single intravenous injections of donor splenocytes 1 hour before transplantation. Different combinations of in vitro irradiation of donor larynges and postoperative cyclosporine doses provided additional immunomodulation. Allograft rejection was scored histologically at sacrifice 15 or 30 days posttransplant. Multivariate analysis was performed across all groups, and paired analyses compared groups with and without donor-specific transfusion. Donor-specific transfusion did not improve rejection score, although increased cyclosporine dose did ( P < .001). Donor splenocyte injection on the day of transplantation does not establish tolerance to laryngeal allografts or permit reduction of other immunosuppression. Other immunomodulatory strategies to establish tolerance in rat laryngeal transplantation require further investigation.

Rat laryngeal transplant model: technical advancements and a redefined rejection grading system.

The rat laryngeal transplant model, introduced in 1992, laid the basic science foundation that contributed to the first successful human larynx transplant in 1998. Over 1,500 rat transplants later, numerous modifications have improved the model, increasing the initially reported evaluability rate of 50% to almost 100%. The observed histologic rejection process has been altered, as well. We report the technique modifications, as well as the results of a new study using nonimmunosuppressed, allogenic transplantations, in order to define a new rejection grading system. Using the updated model, we performed 50 transplantations between LBN(f1) donor rats and Lewis recipients. Larynges from 8 groups of 5 to 10 animals were harvested at intervals between 1 and 20 days after transplantation. The larynges were examined grossly and microscopically in a blinded manner for evidence of rejection. A multivariable linear regression model was used to define a new rejection grading scale. All 50 animals survived their assigned posttransplantation period. No animals exhibited vascular thromboses, for an evaluability rate of 100%. Histologic criteria in 7 categories and gross criteria in 5 categories demonstrated increased rejection proportional to the amount of time after transplantation. The equation [Group = -2.209 + 0.465 x (Size) + 0.901 x (VA Flow) + 0.613 x (Muscle) + 1.040 x (Thyroid)] reproducibly grades rejection on the basis of gross and histologic findings. New modifications to the rat laryngeal transplant model have conferred greatly improved animal survival rates and anastomotic patency rates. Additionally, the observed rates of rejection have been reduced in comparison to those of initial studies. This updated rejection staging system will be used to compare immunosuppressive regimens in future rat laryngeal transplant studies.

Effect of in vitro irradiation of donor larynges on cyclosporine requirements and rejection rates in rat laryngeal transplantation.

Total lymphoid irradiation is an acknowledged adjunctive immunosuppressant in whole organ transplantation in humans and animals. Local irradiation administered for a similar purpose is at best controversial. We evaluated in vitro donor larynx irradiation immediately preceding laryngeal transplantation as an immunomodulator. Each donor larynx was pretreated with 7.34 Gy of radiation in vitro. After transplantation, cyclosporine was administered in doses of 5 mg/kg per day, 2.5 mg/kg per day, and 1 mg/kg per day for trial lengths of 15 days and 30 days. Each of these 6 groups consisted of 10 rats per group. Earlier data have shown cyclosporine dosed at 5 mg/kg per day, without irradiation, administered for 1 month to have varied efficacy. Established histologic criteria were used to determine rejection patterns. All recipient rats survived the 15-day and 30-day trials. In all 10 rats receiving 5 mg/kg per day of cyclosporine for 15 days, the harvested transplanted larynges were viable without evidence of meaningful rejection (mild rejection). In 9 of the 10 rats receiving 5 mg/kg per day of cyclosporine for 30 days, the transplanted larynges displayed no meaningful rejection (mild rejection). In 9 of the 10 rats receiving 2.5 mg/kg per day of cyclosporine for 15 days, the transplanted larynges displayed no meaningful rejection (mild rejection). One rat receiving 2.5 mg/kg per day of cyclosporine for 15 days had a transplanted larynx that displayed moderate rejection. In all 10 rats receiving 2.5 mg/kg per day of cyclosporine for 30 days, the transplanted larynges displayed no meaningful rejection (mild rejection). At 15 days, 5 rats treated with 1 mg/kg per day of cyclosporine displayed mild rejection, 2 displayed moderate rejection, 2 displayed advanced to moderate rejection, and 1 displayed severe rejection. At 30 days, 4 rats treated with 1 mg/kg per day of cyclosporine displayed moderate rejection, 2 displayed advanced to moderate rejection, and 4 displayed severe rejection. We conclude that pretransplantation in vitro irradiation of donor larynges has immunomodulatory effects, allowing reduced cyclosporine immunosuppression with less rejection.

A Comparison of preservation techniques in a vascularized rat laryngeal transplant model

In earlier laryngeal transplantation studies by Takenouchi, et al., the longest ischemic interval tolerated was 45 minutes. A new animal model and enhanced preservative solutions made reassessment timely. This study evaluated two determinants of graft viability: 1. the duration of ischemia and 2. the composition of the preservative media. Three groups of viable transplants were assessed. Groups I and II were preserved with iced heparinized saline with respective ischemic intervals of 3 and 6 hours. Group III was preserved with the Wisconsin solution during a 20-hour ischemic interval. All animals were sacrificed at 24 hours. Representative sections of group I confirmed viability whereas group II exhibited both clinical and histologic evidence of irreversible vascular change. In contrast, most representative sections in group III had little demonstrable change. These data suggest that laryngeal allografts can endure prolonged ischemic intervals if properly maintained.