Raman Optical Activity Spectra Research Articles

Why Does One Measure Resonance Raman Optical Activity? A Unique Case of Measurements under Strong Resonance versus Far-from-Resonance Conditions.

Raman optical activity (ROA) spectroscopy exhibits significant potential in the study of (bio)molecules as it encodes information on their molecular structure, chirality, and conformations. Furthermore, the method reveals details on excited electronic states when applied under resonance conditions. Here, we present a combined study of the far from resonance (FFR)-ROA and resonance ROA (RROA) of a single relatively small molecular system. Notably, this study is the first to employ the density functional theory (DFT) analysis of both FFR-ROA and RROA spectra. This is illustrated for cobalamin derivatives using near-infrared and visible light excitation. Although the commonly observed monosignate RROA spectra lose additional information visible in bisignate nonresonance ROA spectra, the RROA technique acts as a complement to nonresonance ROA spectroscopy. In particular, the combination of these methods integrated with DFT calculations can reveal a complete spectral picture of the structural and conformational differences between tested compounds.

Chiral Spectroscopy of Bulk Systems with Propagated Localized Orbitals.

We present approaches for the simulation of electronic circular dichroism, Raman, and Raman optical activity (ROA) spectra for isolated and periodic systems as well as subsystem analysis thereof. The method is based on the use of time-dependent maximally localized Wannier functions in the CP2K package and accounts for origin dependencies inherent to the Gaussian and plane wave with pseudopotentials approach as well as the origin dependence of the magnetic dipole and electric quadrupole operators. Tests on the H-bonded enantiomers of alanine by harmonic normal-mode analysis and on an aqueous solution of l-alanine by ab initio molecular dynamics obeying periodic boundary conditions (PBCs) are presented as total and subsystem-resolved spectra. To our knowledge, this is the first instance of an ROA spectrum derived from real-time propagation obeying PBCs and the first ROA simulation considering off-, pre-, and on-resonance effects within PBCs.

Induced Chirality in Canthaxanthin Aggregates Reveals Multiple Levels of Supramolecular Organization

AbstractCarotenoids tend to form supramolecular aggregates via non‐covalent interactions where the chirality of individual molecules is amplified to the macroscopic level. We show that this can also be achieved for non‐chiral carotenoid monomers interacting with polysaccharides. The chirality induction in canthaxanthin (CAX), caused by heparin (HP) and hyaluronic acid (HA), was monitored by chiroptical spectroscopy. Electronic circular dichroism (ECD) and Raman optical activity (ROA) spectra indicated the presence of multiple carotenoid formations, such as H‐ and J‐type aggregates. This is consistent with molecular dynamics (MD) and density functional theory (DFT) simulations of the supramolecular structures and their spectroscopic response.

Induced Chirality in Canthaxanthin Aggregates Reveals Multiple Levels of Supramolecular Organization.

Carotenoids tend to form supramolecular aggregates via non-covalent interactions where the chirality of individual molecules is amplified to the macroscopic level. We show that this can also be achieved for non-chiral carotenoid monomers interacting with polysaccharides. The chirality induction in canthaxanthin (CAX), caused by heparin (HP) and hyaluronic acid (HA), was monitored by chiroptical spectroscopy. Electronic circular dichroism (ECD) and Raman optical activity (ROA) spectra indicated the presence of multiple carotenoid formations, such as H- and J-type aggregates. This is consistent with molecular dynamics (MD) and density functional theory (DFT) simulations of the supramolecular structures and their spectroscopic response.

(Resonance) Raman optical activity among chiroptical spectroscopies: Quo vadis?

AbstractAlthough the potential of Raman Optical Activity (ROA) spectroscopy in the field of organic and inorganic materials research has been well demonstrated, its practical application is still limited. This work shows historical background, current state of the art and challenges of ROA spectroscopy facing scientists today. Expectations and development prospects for the coming years are also discussed. Efforts have already been made to improve but also to properly interpret the ROA signal when the ROA technique is combined with other spectroscopies (i.e., ROA/Electronic Circular Dichroism and ROA/Circularly Polarized Luminescence). The paper shows how to intensify the ROA effect to shorten the spectrum accumulation time, control possible artefacts and support the analysis of ROA spectra with actual and new theoretical approaches. However, the challenge is to increase the interest in this technique among the academic community, develop reliable protocols and adapt them for practical use. National and international research networks can significantly contribute to the growth of methodologies and standardization in areas in which the ROA has so far been little used. This paper presents a perspective vision for the future progress of ROA alongside other chiroptical methods.

On the use of property-oriented basis sets for the simulation of vibrational chiroptical spectroscopies

We computed vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) and Raman optical activity (ROA) spectra for a test set of six chiral compounds using two standard density-functionals and an array of basis sets. We analysed the performance of property-oriented basis sets using a quadruple-zeta basis as a reference against four key metrics. We find little qualitative difference between the spectra produced by the larger basis sets (ORP, LPolX, aug-cc-pVTZ, and aug-cc-pVQZ), though their quantitative metrics exhibit wide variations. The smaller basis sets (rDPS, augD-3-21G, augT3-3-21G, Sadlej-pVTZ, and aug-cc-pVDZ) performed better for VCD rotatory strengths than for the corresponding ROA circular intensity differences (CIDs). However, this trend diminishes as the basis-set size is increased, lending validity to the conclusion that more robust property-oriented basis sets are required for ROA spectral generation than that of VCD. We observed improved performance in the mid-infrared region compared to the high-frequency regime, as well as overestimation of VCD rotatory strengths in the latter region as compared to the reference. We conclude that the ORP and LPol-ds basis sets are the most efficient and effective choices of basis set for the prediction of VCD and ROA spectra, as they provide both highly accurate results at reduced computational expense.

Molecular Vibrations in Chiral Europium Complexes Revealed by Near-Infrared Raman Optical Activity.

Raman optical activity (ROA) is commonly measured with green light (532nm) excitation. At this wavelength, however, Raman scattering of europium complexes is masked by circularly polarized luminescence (CPL). This can be avoided using near-infrared (near-IR, 785nm) laser excitation, as demonstrated here by Raman and ROA spectra of three chiral europium complexes derived from camphor. Since luminescence is strongly suppressed, many vibrational bands can be detected. They carry a wealth of structural information about the ligand and the metal core, and can be interpreted based on density functional theory (DFT) simulations of the spectra. For example, jointly with ROA experimental data, the simulations make it possible to determine absolute configuration of chiral lanthanide compounds in solution.

Effective fully polarizable QM/MM approaches to compute Raman and Raman Optical Activity spectra in aqueous solution

Raman and Raman Optical Activity (ROA) signals are amply affected by solvent effects, especially in the presence of strongly solute–solvent interactions such as Hydrogen Bonding (HB). In this work, we extend the fully atomistic polarizable Quantum Mechanics/Molecular Mechanics approach, based on the Fluctuating Charges and Fluctuating Dipoles force field to the calculation of Raman and ROA spectra. Such an approach is able to accurately describe specific HB interactions, by also accounting for anisotropic contributions due to the inclusion of fluctuating dipoles. To highlight the potentiality of the novel approach, Raman and ROA spectra of L-Serine and L-Cysteine dissolved in aqueous solution are computed and compared both with alternative theoretical approaches and experimental measurements.

Understanding the surrounding effects on Raman optical activity signatures of a chiral cage system: Cryptophane-PP-111

Cryptophane molecules are cage-like structures consisting in two hemispheres, each made of three benzene rings. These hemispheres are bound together with three O(CH2)nOlinkers of various lengths giving rise to a plethora of cryptophane derivatives. Moreover, they are able to encapsulate neutral guests: CH2Cl2, CHCl3, …; and charged species: Cs+, Tl+, …. Finally, they exhibit chiroptical properties thanks to the anti arrangement of the linkers between the hemispheres.This work focuses on the Raman optical activity (ROA) signatures of Cryptophane-111 (n=1 for each linker). More specifically, we aim at simulating accurately its ROA spectra with and without a xenon atom inside its cavity. Experimental data (Buffeteau et al., 2017) have already demonstrated the effect of the encapsulation in the low-wavenumbers region. To generate the initial structures, we rely on the novel Conformer–Rotamer Ensemble Sampling Tool (CREST) program, developed by S. Grimme and co-workers. This is required due to the flexibility provided by the linkers. The CREST algorithm seems promising and has already been used to sample the potential energy surface (PES) of target systems before the simulation of their vibrational spectroscopies (Eikås et al., 2022).We observe large similarities between the two sets of conformers (one with and one without Xe encapsulated), demonstrating the robustness of the CREST algorithm. For corresponding structures, the presence of xenon pushed the two hemispheres slightly further apart. After optimization at the DFT level, only one unique conformer has a Boltzmann population ratio greater than 1%, pointing out the relative rigidity of the cage. Based on this unique conformer, our simulations are in good agreement with the experimental data. Regarding xenon encapsulation, the (experimental and theoretical) ROA signatures at low wavenumbers are impacted: slight shifts in wavenumbers are observed as well as a decrease in relative ROA intensity for bands around 150 cm−1. The wavenumber shifts were very well reproduced by our simulations, but the experimental decrease in the ROA intensity was unfortunately not reproduced.

Combination of Resonance and Non‐Resonance Chiral Raman Scattering in a Cobalt(III) Complex

AbstractResonance Raman optical activity (RROA) spectra with high sensitivity reveal details on molecular structure, chirality, and excited electronic properties. Despite the difficulty of the measurements, the recorded data for the Co(III) complex with S,S‐N,N‐ethylenediaminedisuccinic acid are of exceptional quality and, coupled with the theory, spectacularly document the molecular behavior in resonance. This includes a huge enhancement of the chiral scattering, contribution of the antisymmetric polarizabilities to the signal, and the Herzberg‐Teller effect significantly shaping the spectra. The chiral component is by about one order of magnitude bigger than for an analogous aluminum complex. The band assignment and intensity profile were confirmed by simulations based on density functional and vibronic theories. The resonance was attributed to the S0→S3 transition, with the strongest signal enhancement of Raman and ROA spectral bands below about 800 cm−1. For higher wavenumbers, other excited electronic states contribute to the scattering in a less resonant way. RROA spectroscopy thus appears as a unique tool to study the structure and electronic states of absorbing molecules in analytical chemistry, biology, and material science.

Combination of resonance and non-resonance chiral Raman scattering in a cobalt(III) complex.

Resonance Raman optical activity (RROA) spectra with high sensitivity reveal details on molecular structure, chirality, and excited electronic properties. Despite the difficulty of the measurements, the recorded data for the Co(III) complex with S,S-N,N-ethylenediaminedisuccinic acid are of exceptional quality and, coupled with the theory, spectacularly document the molecular behavior in resonance. This includes a huge enhancement of the chiral scattering, contribution of the antisymmetric polarizabilities to the signal, and the Herzberg-Teller effect significantly shaping the spectra. The chiral component is by about one order of magnitude bigger than for an analogous aluminum complex. The band assignment and intensity profile were confirmed by simulations based on density functional and vibronic theories. The resonance was attributed to the S0®S3 transition, with the strongest signal enhancement of Raman and ROA spectral bands below about 800 cm-1. For higher wavenumbers, other excited electronic states contribute to the scattering in a less resonant way. RROA spectroscopy thus appears as a unique tool to study the structure and electronic states of absorbing molecules in analytical chemistry, biology, and material science.

Molecular Properties of 3d and 4f Coordination Compounds Deciphered by Raman Optical Activity Spectroscopy.

Molecular properties of coordination compounds can be efficiently studied by vibrational spectroscopy. The scope of Raman spectroscopy has been greatly enhanced by the introduction of Raman optical activity (ROA) sensitive to chirality. The present review describes some of its recent applications to study the coordination compounds. 3d and 4f metal complexes often absorb the excitation light, or exhibit luminescence. Therefore, effects caused in ROA spectra by electronic circular dichroism (ECD) and circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) must be taken into consideration.In 3d metal complexes ECD and circularly-polarized Raman scattering compete with the resonance ROA (RROA) signal. Pure RROA spectrum can thus be obtained by subtracting the so-called ECD-Raman component. CPL is frequently encountered in 4f systems. While it can mask the ROA spectra, it is useful to study molecular structure. These electronic effects can be reduced by using near-infrared excitation although vibrational ROA signal is much weaker compared to the usual green laser excitation scenario. The ROA methodology is thus complex, but capable of providing unique information about the molecules of interests and their interaction with light.

Raman Optical Activity of Retinal Chromophore in Sensory Rhodopsin II.

Raman optical activity (ROA) spectroscopy was used to study the conformation of the retinal chromophore in sensory rhodopsin II (SRII), which is a blue-green light sensor of microbes. The ROA spectrum consisted of the negative vibrational bands of the chromophore, whose relative intensities are similar to those of the parent Raman spectrum. This spectral feature was explained by the left-handed helical twist of the retinal chromophore on the basis of quantum chemical calculations. On the other hand, we found that the chromophore conformation based on the crystal structures of SRII has a right-handed helical twist, which does not agree with the observation. This specific result suggests that the consistency with chiro-optical properties can be a key criterion for the accurate prediction and/or evaluation of chromophore conformation in retinal-binding proteins.

A Reactive Force Field for Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Glucose in Aqueous Solution.

To expand the capabilities of reactive force field (ReaxFF) in simulations of biological processes involving glucose, in this work, using Metropolis Monte Carlo algorithm, new ReaxFF parameters for glucose have been developed to better describe the properties of glucose in water during molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. With the newly trained ReaxFF, the mutarotation of glucose in water can be better described, as suggested by our metadynamics simulations. In addition, the newly trained ReaxFF can better describe the distributions of the three stable conformers along the key dihedral angle of α-anomer and β-anomer. With better descriptions of hydration around glucose, the Raman and Raman optical activity spectra can be more accurately calculated. In addition, the infrared spectra obtained from simulations with the new glucose ReaxFF are more accurate than those obtained with the original ReaxFF. We note that although our trained ReaxFF performs better than the original ReaxFF, it is not generally applicable to all carbohydrates, which require further parametrization. We also find that the absence of explicit water molecules in the training sets may lead to inaccurate descriptions of water-water interactions around the glucose, implicating that it is necessary to optimize the water ReaxFF parameters together with the target molecule. The improved ReaxFF makes it possible to explore interesting biological processes involving glucose more accurately and efficiently.

Synthesis and Chiroptical Properties of a Chiral Isotopologue of syn-Cryptophane-B.

We report the synthesis and absolute configuration (AC) of a chiral isotopologue of syn-cryptophane-B. Low chiral signatures were measured by polarimetry and electronic circular dichroism, whereas most significant chiroptical effects were observed by vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) and Raman optical activity (ROA). The comparison of experimental VCD and ROA spectra with those predicted by DFT calculations allows the determination of the AC of the two enantiomers as (-)589-MP-syn-2 and (+)589-PM-syn-2.

Molecular dynamics and Raman optical activity spectra reveal nucleotide conformation ratios in solution.

Nucleotide conformational flexibility affects their biological functions. Although the spectroscopy of Raman optical activity (ROA) is well suited to structural analyses in aqueous solutions, the link between the spectral shape and the nucleotide geometry is not fully understood. We recorded the Raman and ROA spectra of model nucleotides (rAMP, rGMP, rCMP, and dTMP) and interpreted them on the basis of molecular dynamics (MD) combined with density functional theory (DFT). The relation between the sugar puckering, base conformation and spectral intensities is discussed. Hydrogen bonds between the sugar's C3' hydroxyl and the phosphate groups were found to be important for the sugar puckering. The simulated spectra correlated well with the experimental data and provided an understanding of the dependence of the spectral shapes on conformational dynamics. Most of the strongest spectral bands could be assigned to vibrational molecular motions. Decomposition of the experimental spectra into calculated subspectra based on arbitrary maps of free energies provided experimental conformer populations, which could be used to verify and improve the MD predictions. The analyses indicate some flaws of common MD force fields, such as being unable to describe the fine conformer distribution. Also the accuracy of conformer populations obtained from the spectroscopic data depends on the simulations, improvement of which is desirable for gaining a more detailed insight in the future. Improvement of the spectroscopic and computational methodology for nucleotides also provides opportunities for its application to larger nucleic acids.

Exceptionally enhanced Raman optical activity (ROA) of amyloid fibrils and their prefibrillar states.

Amyloid fibrils form remarkable, multi-layered chiral supramolecular architectures. The proximity of interacting oscillators in the chiral fibril supramolecules is responsible for the unusual sensitivity of vibrational circular dichroism (VCD) for fibril formation. Surprisingly, up to now, such characteristics have not been shown for ROA, although it displays the same vibrational markers of fibrils as VCD, including the amide I band. Here, we report an exceptionally large enhancement of the ROA signal detected for mature amyloid fibrils and their prefibrillar states. Remarkably, the same ROA signal has been obtained for fibrils of homologous lysozymes and the dissimilar protein, insulin, indicating a possible common enhanced ROA spectrum, analogous to that for VCD for all amyloid fibrils investigated to date. The ROA signal is observed at earlier stages of fibril formation than VCD and provides access to a considerably broader range of vibrations. Further studies are necessary to verify the applicability of ROA for the analysis of amyloid fibrils.

Chirality transfer observed in Raman optical activity spectra

Chirality transfer (also called induced chirality) is a phenomenon present in chiroptical spectra that manifests itself as a new band or bands of an achiral molecule interacting with a chiral one. In the Raman optical activity (ROA) spectroscopy, the bands of achiral solvents have been recently observed, but the latest papers have shown that they corresponded to the new ECD-Raman (eCP-Raman) effect. Here, we show an unambiguous example of chirality transfer observed in the ROA spectra. The spectra registered for the (1:1) mixtures of achiral benzonitrile with the enantiomers of 2,2,2-trifluoro-1-phenylethanol, 1-phenylethanol, and 1-phenylethylamine exhibited the v(CN) vibration band at about 2230 cm−1. The ROA measurements were repeated several times to ensure the reliability of the phenomenon. Calculations revealed the CN···HO or CN···HNH hydrogen bond formation accompanied by the π···π or CH···π interactions. The interaction strength was shown to be an important factor for the pronouncement of the ROA chirality transfer effect.

Accurate Determination of Enantiomeric Excess Using Raman Optical Activity

The optical purity of a chiral sample is of particular importance to the analytical chemistry and pharmaceutical industries. In recent years, the vibrational optical activity (VOA) has become established as a sensitive and nondestructive technique for the analysis of chiral molecules in solution. However, the relatively limited accuracy in the range of about 1–2% reported in published papers and the relatively small spread of experimental facilities to date have meant that vibrational spectroscopy has not been considered a common method for determining enantiomeric excess. In this paper, we attempt to describe, in detail, a methodology for the determination of enantiomeric excess using Raman optical activity (ROA). This method achieved an accuracy of 0.05% for neat α-pinene and 0.22% for alanine aqueous solution, after less than 6 h of signal accumulation for each enantiomeric mixture, which we believe is the best result achieved to date using vibrational optical activity techniques. An algorithm for the elimination of systematic errors (polarization artifacts) is proposed, and the importance of normalizing ROA spectra to correct for fluctuations in excitation power is established. Results comparable to those obtained with routinely used chemometric analysis by the partial least squares (PLS) method were obtained. These findings show the great potential of ROA spectroscopy for the quantitative analysis of enantiomeric mixtures.

Raman Optical Activity of N-Acetyl-L-Cysteine in Water and in Methanol: The "Clusters-in-a-Liquid" Model and ab Initio Molecular Dynamics Simulations.

Raman and Raman Optical Activity (ROA) spectra of N-acetyl-L-cysteine (NALC), a flexible chiral molecule, were measured in water and in methanol to evaluate the solvent effects. Two different solvation approaches, that is, the DFT based "clusters-in-a-liquid" solvent model and the ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations, were applied to simulate the Raman and ROA spectra. Systematic conformational searches were carried out using a recently developed conformational searching tool, CREST, with the inclusion of polarizable continuum model of water and of methanol. The CREST candidates of NALC and the NALC-solvent complexes were re-optimized and their Raman and ROA simulations were done at the B3LYP-D3BJ/def2-TZVP and the B3LYP-aug-cc-pVDZ//cc-pVTZ levels. Also, AIMD simulations, which includes some anharmonic effects and all intermolecular interactions in solution, were performed. By empirically weighting the computed Raman and ROA spectra of each conformer, good agreements with the experimental data were achieved with both approaches, while AIMD offered some improvements in the carbonyl and in the low wavenumber regions over the static DFT approach. The pros and cons of these two different approaches for accounting the solvent effects on Raman and ROA of this flexible chiral system will also be discussed.