The practice of forensic psychology and psychiatry has made tremendous advances in the past 20 years. We have moved from a field based solely on vague, subjective opinion, devoid of any support in objective research, to a plethora of well-established research instruments and a vast body of well-founded research studies. Recently, however, some of our colleagues have begun to question whether we have possibly embraced our research findings with too much confidence and enthusiasm (Rogers, 2000; Zonana, 2000). Our field has become almost exclusively devoted to assessment, offering little help to those of us who are charged with the treatment of forensic clients in settings such as prisons, forensic state hospitals, parole outpatient clinics, and conditional release programs.Many clinicians in such settings feel that they cannot really be expected to provide meaningful or effective therapy for their clients. During the same 20 years, there has been a veritable explosion in the field of child abuse research and treatment. With few exceptions (e.g., Gilligan, 1996; Lisak, 1997), there seems to be little communication between these two fields. This is surprising in light of studies on the prevalence of child abuse histories among various populations. Based on the findings of a number of studies (Briere, 1992), about 15% of the general population is thought to have experienced childhood physical abuse. The prevalence rates for childhood sexual abuse are somewhat higher, estimated at 20% to 30% for females (Finkelhor, Hotaling, Lewis, & Smith, 1989; Russell, 1986) and 10% to 15% for males (Finkelhor et al., 1989). These rates have been found to be somewhat higher among psychiatric outpatients and psychiatric emergency roompatients, and are even higher among forensic populations. Noting that most people who have been abused do not become violent, Pincus (2001) observes, “Yet a large number of formerly abused people do become violent and dangerous to society, and there is an undeniable direct link between the experience of abuse and later violence” (p.28). During his tenure as Los Angeles County District Attorney, I heard Gil Garcetti state in a radio interview that 95% of those on death row in California were abused as children. James
Read full abstract