Recognizing the critical need to elucidate the molecular determinants of this selectivity offers a pathway to engineer enzymes with broader and more versatile catalytic capabilities. Through integrated methods including phylogenetic analysis, molecular docking, and structural analysis, we identified a pivotal amino acid residue, αTrp116, linking the substrate binding pocket and the active site of a NHase from Pseudonocardia thermophila JCM 3095 (PtNHase). This residue acts as a crucial determinant of substrate specificity within the NHase enzyme. The mutant αW116R modified the substrate specificity of PtNHase, significantly enhancing its catalytic efficiency towards aromatic substrates. The catalytic activity for aromatic compounds such as 3-Cyanopyridine was 14-fold that of the wild-type, whereas its activity for aliphatic substrates diminished to one-sixth. MD simulations revealed that replacing αTrp116 with Arg allowed aromatic nitrile substrates to achieve more favorable conformations within the active site. Based on the mutant αW116R, we further constructed a combinatorial variant Pt-4, tailored for aromatic substrates, which exhibited an enzyme activity 50 times that of the wild-type. These results highlight the critical influence of amino acid residues in the enzyme's active site on substrate specificity and offer fresh perspectives and approaches for the evolution of enzymes.